Breaking Barriers in Sports Performance: Technology, Analytics, and the Race for a Sub-4-Minute Mile
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE James Smoliga, professor in the Department of Rehabilitation Sciences and director of research for the Doctor of Physical Therapy Program at Tufts University School of Medicine, joins Cade Massey, Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, and Adi Wyner to discuss the quest for a women’s sub-four-minute mile, the influence of super shoes and other technologies, and how marketing, science, and athletic performance intersect on the world stage. Cade, Eric, Shane, and Adi also dive into the evolving playoff structures in Major League Baseball, the statistical weight of home-field advantage, and current storylines in the NFL and college football, blending analytics with real-time sports narratives. Plus, in an overtime interview, Cade and Eric speak with Joseph LaMagna, analyst at Fried Egg Golf, about the Ryder Cup, including the role of pairings, course setup, crowd behavior, and the contrasting approaches of Team USA and Team Europe in leveraging data and preparation.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#MLBPlayoffs #BaseballAnalytics #RyderCup #GolfAnalytics #SportsTechnology #SportsScience ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on
- the Wharton podcast network. This is Kade Massie hosting today with the whole crew. It feels like it's been a while
- and rare lately that we have everybody in here, but today we do. Shane Jensen is in wearing his Phillies red. Audi
- Winer is in wearing his Yankees blue, I'm assuming. Eric Bradlo is in wearing something baseball related. Hall of
- Fame. Hall of Fame. And I'm in here wearing a just a normal button-down shirt because, you know, it's not
- college football day yet. It's only Tuesday. This is Tuesday afternoon. We're going to we're going to record as
- we usually do this afternoon here at the very end of the Cleveland Guardians Detroit Tigers first wild card game
- kicking off the playoffs this afternoon in the ninth inning. We'll probably have
- an update here in the next few minutes as that game wraps up or not or goes into extra innings. But otherwise, we're
- going to run um a regular show in that we'll have a guest here in the first half hour. We'll have open topics in the
- second half hour. And then we are going to have an overtime guest in a third half hour. If you want to stick around,
- if you want a little more conversation, we're going to have uh uh talking a little writer cup in the last in the
- last overtime segment. You want to stick around. We got analytics. We have a a wonderful conversation lined up. We'd
- like to welcome back to Wharton Moneyball, Jamie Smoliga. Jamie has even more letters than we have after our
- names, guys. He's got a DVM name. That's Oh, I don't even know. Is that Well, he's going to tell us what I can imagine
- what it might be. He's got PhD out of his name. We know that he has FACSM after his name. Um but his title which
- is a cool one professor department of rehabilitation sciences and director of research doctor of physical therapy
- program in Seattle Washington at the tus university school of medicine. So Jamie
- uh welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. >> Thanks so much for having me again. I really appreciate it. So it's clear, you
- know, from reviewing your academic work, you do work, let's call it, broadly in translational medicine, athletic
- performance, injuries. Um, you also write about these topics. Um, I did not know, but uh I will be the abstract and
- you're a lifelong Olympic sports fan. We could ask you about so many things, but
- I think one of the topics you've been working on lately is I'll probably mispronounce her name, but Faith
- Kipiggon um and her attempt to break the 4-minute mile. So, could you please give us a
- status? Maybe this would be good for our listeners. Obviously, Dr. Roger Banister
- broke the 4-minute mile for men years and years ago. You'll probably even know the date. probably sometime I don't even
- know the 60s 50s I don't know >> 50s I think it was 19 late 50s right >> y >> and so just you're gonna give us uh
- Jamie the history like how close are women to breaking the 4-minute mile will it actually happen you know we'd love to
- start there and there's lots of stuff we want to talk to you about >> sure that sounds great
- yeah I mean as far as uh you know track and field you know it's it's definitely a passion of mine um I got into it in
- high school and have been hooked ever since. So, yeah, Faith Kipon, she is a three-time gold medalist uh in uh in
- track and field uh from Kenya and she is the she's gotten the closest uh as to breaking the sub4minute barrier as any
- female has right now. She is the current world record holder in the mile and that
- is uh her time is 407.64. So, she's about 7 and a half seconds away from a sub4-minute mile. And let's
- just stop by saying that's really fast. I mean that's that's really really really fast. And I think that's that's
- one of the first things I really want to acknowledge is whether you're a man, whether you're a woman, it's a fast
- time. Now if if you are an NCAA Division One men's track and field competitor, then you're surrounded by a bunch of
- other fast people. 407 doesn't seem fast, but trust me, it's really fast whether you're a man or a woman. And so
- she's about seven and a half seconds away. But the thing is seven and a half seconds away from a mile world record in
- the grand scheme or sorry seven and a half seconds away from a sub4minute mile. There's a lot of ground there. I
- mean that's you know it it could be um despite what Nike told us in the breaking four attempt it could be
- decades before we see somebody go under four or maybe it could happen in the next few years but but there's still a
- lot of round to go uh before somebody breaks four. >> Let me ask you a question. I've always
- thought about this. Okay. One of my former colleagues when I worked at ETSS, AI and Shane know him well. His name's
- Howard Wner, studied this issue a lot, which is trajectories of records. And there's lots of neat graphics.
- How far back would we have to go in time? Like when was the women's record roughly 4:15 and how long has it taken?
- And I imagine whatever number you give me, let's say you tell me 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30 years, I don't know
- what it was. I guess your point is it's going to take potentially longer to get the next seven
- and a half seconds than it took to get the last seven and a half. But that I could be wrong, but yeah, you know, that
- that's what I would say. I I I think all these we we get to this point where there's you know uh we start getting to
- this threshold where you know we've got diminishing returns where people start just chipping away at the world record
- and it's measured in ten of seconds you know or maybe even seconds. Now, Faith Kipon, you know, to her credit, she took
- the world record down from uh I believe it was 412 to 407, you know, which is which is, you know, really uh you know,
- impressive, you know, in itself that translation. So, it's possible somebody could come
- up, you know, somebody could have a really breakthrough performance, but a breakthrough performance would be two or
- three seconds. Seven and a half seconds is going to be is going to be a lot >> quickly. Yeah, I'm looking at the record
- charts. Uh so it stayed very for over 20 years pretty much right around that time
- 412 or so and then Faith did drop but uh anything any of that drop have to do with technology shoes or something? I
- mean how I mean because that's always the wild card in all these things, >> right? And I I would say definitely
- pretty much all the world records in track and field have something to do with shoes. Again, anytime we talk about
- any of these world records, I think we need to start off by saying that number one's the athlete is putting in the hard
- work. You know, if we we go to some random person on the street or even a really good runner and we give them a
- pair of shoes that are spectacular, they're not going to become a world record holder because the shoes. Faith
- Cape Bon, it's a combination of incredible hard work, incredible coaching, you know, just motivation,
- drive, and then you add a pair of super shoes onto that. And these super shoes that have been around since 2017, those
- are going to improve in performance by maybe up to five five percent, which is gigantic. And this is why we've seen
- since 2017, we've seen all these distance running world records fall and the entire field has gotten fast. And so
- the shoes are definitely a big part of her world record and everybody's world record.
- >> Just if you took the the world record from 1995 and put them in the shoes, they'd be running 4072 is roughly.
- >> Yeah. I mean, I I think that's I think that's fair to say. I I think they would
- be maybe if not 407, it would be close to that. These shoes, the super shoes have changed everything in distance
- running, >> right? Because it it puts in perspective the forecasting. So, the forecasting is
- really really hard when you are when you are assuming or don't assume there's some sort of human limit and it changes
- the entire way you do the mathematics. Um, and shoes just really break through that kind of barrier because it it's
- it's not a human limit. It's all of a sudden finding a technological advantage. All right.
- >> Right. Right. Yeah. So if we look back, you know, again, you know, Kipun broke
- the world record, you know, in um in 2023 and you know, before that, you know, in
- 2019 had been down to to 412, but before that, you mentioned 1996 that that was uh Satlana Masterova had the world
- record in 1996. And you know, could she have run 5 seconds faster with Super Shoes? You know, per perhaps. Um, and so
- again, we think about like the cinder track versus rubberized track versus now the really fantastic track surfaces that
- we have, even indoor records, banking, things like that. You know, it's a completely different game.
- >> Jamie, let me ask you, is there >> is there an ideal size for a track and field person that's trying to run a
- mile? Have you I mean, because you're both obviously a doctor of well, physiology. I mean you I assume you
- you're actually just correct me you're a real doctor right now we're like we're PhD doctors but you you got some sort of
- medical degree no >> yeah I I've got a doctor of veterary medicine degree now now how I went from
- veterary medicine >> that's what I thought DM was but I didn't want to okay >> but how I went from veterary medicine to
- a PhD in sports medicine that that those are that's a story for another day but um but as as one of my colleagues put it
- I'm qualified to treat the horse and the jockey I guess although I I really can't
- treat the jockey I could just analyze their performance I'm not a medical doctor.
- >> Could you give us a sense though? What size is Faith? And like is there an optimal size? Like you could argue I
- could argue both ways. Like if she were maybe a little bit taller, she'd have a longer stride length. Maybe it wouldn't
- slow down the speed of her movement and she could still get as many I'll call them RPMs and therefore she could run
- faster. Is there any like is there an optimal size? Well, you know, this is a this is such a loaded question and I I I
- think if if we think back to the pre-susain bolt era, there is some actual research done to show what the
- optimal size is for running 100 meter uh dash and about predictions of the future
- world record holder, what they would be. And then 6'5, Usain Bolt comes along and
- just demolishes these these expectations that the tallest any successful sprinter
- would be I think would be something like 6'1. Um so I think you know it's hard to
- say. Now Faith Kipon she's she's listed as uh being five feet tall you know 5 feet on the dot and you know some you
- read 93 to 97 pounds. Again, these these numbers vary, but you know, she she's pretty short, but again, it's within the
- normal realm of female distance runners. Um, somebody like Paula Radcliffe, who was the former world record holder on
- Marathon, I think she was around 5'6. Uh, I think in the mile and the 1500 for both men and for women, we see a variety
- of um body heights. You know, we see guys that are are right around Faith Kipan's height, you know, maybe 5'2, 53
- to men that are over six feet tall running sub4minute miles and at the worldass level. Uh, and also too, we
- also see a range in um, you know, by dimensions. You'll see some really really lanky people and then you'll see
- some that are a lot more muscular. So, I I think it's hard to say, you know, is there an ideal size? I I think the one
- thing within track and field where there seems to be one specific body type, one
- specific phenotype is the high jump. Every single high jumper is tall and lanky, but other than that, there really
- does seem to be a lot of body, >> you know, Mondo Delantis, he he's he's the best that's ever been.
- I don't know. I I feel like if you saw him in, you know, t-shirt and shirts at Walmart, you wouldn't know that he's the
- best Paul Walter that's that's ever been. I think he's pretty non-escript. I think he's right around six foot tall.
- Yeah, he looks muscular, but you know, I think there's been some more muscular ones, some some leaner ones, maybe Paul
- Vault, but yeah, >> please. >> Yeah. Well, I know I know it's impossible to satisfy uh Eric's
- curiosity. He loves to learn about everything, but there's a big event that happened in with Nike and Faith that
- that that I I did some reading. Um it's extremely interesting and so can you tell us about that event and and what
- happened? >> Right. So, I I think it's important to get to the backstory of the event. Um,
- and that's what made the event happen. So, back in June, um, Nike staged the Breaking Four event in which Faith Kipan
- was going to become the first woman to attempt to run a sub4-minute mile. And so the backstory behind this is in
- February of this year, February 2025, um there was uh some a research paper that
- came out um proposing that Faith Capagon's world record of 407 in the mile if she had proper pacing throughout
- and proper aerodynamics throughout meant if she drafted just as NASCAR drivers draft. if she used like the most perfect
- of the perfect drafting techniques, maybe, just maybe, she could run a sub4-minute mile. In other words, her
- 407.64 mile was equivalent to a sub4minute mile under the absolute perfect ideal conditions. So, this
- paper, >> would that qualify as a world record under those conditions or would it not?
- >> It would depend how it was run. Um, you know, I would I would say probably no.
- like uh if if if this happened organically during a race or even if it was an actual race with actual
- competitors and all of her competitors said, "You know what? We're going to go around you. We're going to try to
- support you, then then it could qualify as a world record." But the only way they could really do this proper
- drafting was by having a bunch of people who could run faster than the sub4minute
- mile pace support her, and that's men. Um, you know, men biologically have many different advantages uh that happen
- physiologically and as a result they're capable of running sub4-minute miles a lot easier. So she needed a team of men
- to surround her to >> or you have a team or you have a team of women who support her for short
- stretches of course. >> For short stretches. Yeah. So you rotate in and out but that would not count for
- a >> so so yeah this paper came out in February and it generated a lot of buzz and the way I got I got into it is um
- yeah somebody at uh NPR had reached out to me Jonathan Lambert uh from their science desk had reached out to me he
- and I had been in touch with some other things and he asked me to review the paper and just provide some expert
- commentary for NPR on it and it was really fun. I looked at the paper and I really want to state the researchers
- behind this paper they did a great job. There's nothing wrong with what they did. There's, you know, I actually I've
- gotten in the field of research integrity and and and I could be a research skeptic with something
- sometimes. These people, these researchers, Roger Cra, Shayla Kip, and and her team, their team, they they did
- fine. There's nothing wrong with the study. They were very transparent about all the limitations in the study. Study
- is great. But the study kind of feels like a bunch of people saying, you know, well, what if we did this? You know
- what? If what if instead of running 1.3 meters apart for wind resistance, what if they ran 1.2 meters? And they they
- they looked at all the literature and they developed a mathematical a series of mathematical models to predict if you
- gave her the ideal conditions, what would she be able to run? And if in certain conditions, maybe she could run
- sub4. And so now what happened is we took this this theory, this interesting science story, this interesting paper
- got translated from maybe this could possibly happen with perfect conditions to headlines say
- Faith Keepon's, you know, mile record is equivalent to a sub4minute mile. She's capable of doing it. It's just a matter
- of time. She'll be the first to break it. And in April of this year, Nike announced they're going to actually have
- Faith Kagun try to do this um and put together a team of male pacers and use Nike technology to make this happen. So
- that's kind of the backstory of how the Sub4 started. It started with a research
- paper and again a good research paper that Nike tried to translate into history.
- >> Jamie, before you tell us what happened, because I know you're going to tell us
- what happened here and obviously it didn't happen, but you'll tell us what happened in all of this. Were they not
- worried about let's even say all the math is correct, the paper had been done correctly, everything else. Um, part of
- it may have been there might have been some extrapolation issues, but ignoring that for just a second, let's just
- ignore that for just one second. What about just intra interday variation? Like, how do they even know?
- Maybe she like that 407 under what she actually ran tomorrow. It could be 412, 411. Like, how about that? Barry, I know
- I just want >> They're making a bet. They were kind of making a bet on both the kind of
- environmental conditions being ideal as well as kind of best day. >> No, no, I know. So, Shane, what I'm
- trying to get Jaime's thoughts on I agree with you. What I'm trying to get Jaime's thoughts on is how much interday
- variation is there and like what a better quote unquote study design is. you know, let's have her run 20
- independent days and let's promise that maybe on one of those days she might be able to do it. But isn't there just
- massive interday variation? >> There's going to be absolutely there's going to be there's going to be interday
- variation. I, you know, as far as how massive it is, I I wouldn't expect somebody at her level to if if she times
- it right, I I would expect her to run a 407 one day and, you know, a 412 the next day given everything the same, you
- know, as far as, you know, she's timed her schedule with her workouts and her previous routine. But, you know, I I
- don't think it's outside the realm of possibilities for her to run, you know, somewhere between a 407 and maybe a 409
- just in day variability. you know, one or two seconds and exactly as you say, maybe that 407.64, every world record,
- everybody's personal best at some point that is the best they're going to do. And maybe for her it's 407.64. Maybe
- that's the best she could ever do. It's the extreme outlier value for her. The >> See, the paper didn't try to didn't try
- to propose what Nike did. That was Nike's decision to try to run this off. The paper had nothing to do with
- interday variance. It said if she ran the same race she ran and they got the 4.7 with the essentially the drafting
- conditions that they estimated in that race which is roughly 30 30 for the four laps. They they said what if it it gets
- to 71% which is the kind of what they essentially estimated you could do. What would she run then? And they estimated
- that at almost exactly four minutes flat. >> You know I I wasn't asking what the
- paper did. I was just asking did anybody even realize that even if all the math were correct there's interday variation
- and that you know I and and also I think Jaime's point is great obviously AI you've brought up the idea of the
- maximum of a distribution many times like I'll call it observed equals true plus error so you know that implies that
- this may well be the place where she got the I'll call it negative residual like
- her true strength is 409 n today just happened to be a minus two second day and that ain't going to happen again or
- it can't you just can't make it happen on demand. >> Yeah. A and so like the research in this
- the researchers in the study like Shala Kip she's an Olympian like she would know that. Roger Crown he's he's you
- know worldleading biomechanics and sports uh sports performance modeling researcher. He would know that too. But
- this is what makes me question how did Nike get themselves into this? Did did Nike not conserve this? Listen, there
- have to be people at Nike. I'm sure they had to have known this. And and that's kind of some of my point. I did Nike
- realize what they were setting themselves up for or did they did they not care? Um, and that's kind of where
- I'm going with this. >> Well, maybe they didn't care. >> Why don't you tell us what happened?
- >> Yeah, tell us what happened. >> So, well, going back to the paper again, as as Audi and Eric, you've both alluded
- to, there's a lot of factors that are going into here. There's extrapolations, there's there's modeling, assumptions
- built upon assumptions built upon assumptions and which model you use. And even in this paper, they come up with
- multiple different results depending on on how you tweak the parameters. Any kind of mathematical model, there's lots
- of parameters and you could tweak them one one way or the other and you you could get lots of different results. And
- so again, the paper's really transparent. But somehow so Nike decided to do this and and to have and to create
- this this event where she's going to run in this perfect formation. But here's here's what happened. If you watch the
- it was about a one-hour broadcast essentially. It was more of a coronation. It was more of, you know,
- she's decided that she's going to be the first or they've decided that this is going to be the first time anybody's
- even going to attempt to to break four minutes or any woman's going to attempt to break four minutes. Which again I had
- an issue with because it's it's as if she she just it never even occurred to her like, "Oh, well maybe I could run
- maybe I could run faster." like that. That's what everybody's trying to do. They're trying to run faster. Nobody's,
- you know, she never set out to say, "Today, I'm going to try to run a 406. I'm not going to try to run four
- minutes." Now, Mando Deontis can do that in the pole vault where he could set the
- bar and and at how high he wants to put it. But, but no runner is is just trying
- to hold back or anything that. So, so that whole thing was an issue. But Nike really emphasized the technology and
- basically they they've got these special super shoes for her. And again, if super
- shoes were new, if nobody had ever done super shoes before, well, maybe there'd be a gigantic leap in performance, but
- we've already had that gigantic leap in performance. We're at that point of diminishing returns. And so these super
- shoes they had for her and they had all these pacers that were going to surround
- her just right. And then they had the 3D printed sports bra. And this 3D printed
- sports bra was going to be more aerodynamic and and and support her better. And yes, that's all important.
- Like good sports bra like is is important for female runners. But was this going to really make the
- difference? Was this going to help shave seven and a half seconds off her mile time? And so, long story short, they
- made this big hype machine and it was this kind of coronation. We're here to celebrate history. She's going to do it.
- Nobody's been brave enough to do this before. And and really the emphasis was all on Nike's technology. And and they
- really did even mention the scientific paper that started all. They didn't mention the researchers. Nike kind of
- put it on themselves like she's gonna break it because of her technology and she didn't run under four minutes. And
- this was the thing. >> Was that >> what did she run? >> Well, it depends what time you count. So
- when she crossed I see the confused look on your face. When she crossed the finish line, the clock read 406.91.
- So she took her her 407.64 down to 406.91. So she saved about 7/10 of a second or so off, but the official
- time was furough 6.42. So after the race, her time actually got faster. A half a second came off. And
- that was because normally when a race happens, the gun goes off, the sound of the gun triggers the start of the race,
- and then when you cross the finish line, that's your time. Well, to just try to get the squeeze the last little bit of
- juice out of this, her 406.42 42 time was based on on uh motion on high resolution uh motion. So when her body
- crossed the start line versus her body cross the finish line that that's not consistent with any race. It's when the
- >> ridiculous that's that's that just makes her completely uncomparable even without
- the drafting. >> Right. So so but here's the thing. >> Let me ask a question just just quickly
- Jamie. So um if this were me and so I'll put on my marketing hat for a second. am
- a marketing professor. What the hell? I'll put on my marketing hat, but I'll also put on my uh sampling hat. I might
- have had her try to do this before doing it on the air and then we would have seen that it's she's going to run 406.9
- something and I'm like, huh, maybe we shouldn't hype this event. >> Was there any discussion of like was
- this the first time she ever tried it under these conditions, too? >> Um, yeah. I don't know the details. It
- they did they definitely did practice. They they practiced having this formation of these 12ers.
- >> There was a lot of practice, but I don't think anybody tried going all out and
- it's a lot to ask an athlete to go all out in, you know, given maximal effort. You know, you could get injured. It
- could it's going to disrupt your training and especially she's got bigger fish to fry. You know, she did have
- world championships this year where, you know, she did actually win a gold medal
- um and a silver medal as well. Um, so I I don't think they actually tried an all-out version, but I think that, you
- know, um I think it it would have been good to at least do some 100% maximum efforts with, you know, uh at least
- halfway through or something like that or at least 95% and I don't know what. >> So Audi, let me give you the one second,
- let me give you Audi the last question before we just ask you Jamie, what you're working on next and now. So Audi,
- please go ahead. >> Yeah. So um I I mean my immediate response is I don't think Nike really
- cares. Uh maybe they do. That would be a question for you, Eric, as a marketing professor. But, you know, I read I read
- an article you wrote um which pointed to another article which was written um also before the race that said that that
- didn't really come to a conclusion in a formal way, but it did say that physiologically women are way way far
- away from being able to hit four minute miles. And that should have given Nike a lot of
- pause that this is a lot resting on a draft estimate that seems to be really really extremal. Um to squeeze out seven
- and a half seconds based on essentially drafting which is that was the point of the the first paper that drafting can do
- that. Um and and so that that that was another piece of evidence that sort of stands out in front of them going
- wondering. But you know I but you talked about the mathematics and I want to respond as a statistician. They built a
- mathematical model to estimate the drafting effect which is probably fine right you know aerodynamics etc but
- there there's a huge difference between in the field and on the paper and I would have proposed an actual experiment
- where we would have done a designed experiment to see >> my point what the percentage that you
- could squeeze out of short distances with different drafting formulations and that would have been the way to really
- figured out and they would have learned ahead of time that their on paper calculation was just way out of bounds
- for >> just for the record for people on Wharton Moneyball. This is the damn question I just asked Jamie a few
- seconds ago, but go ahead Jamie. I'd like to get your last words on this race, how you're thinking about it, and
- also what you're working on now. >> Well, what I think I I what's really important, what I think that the
- interesting message here combining marketing and sports analytics is this that basically Nike set themselves up to
- fail. And did they realize this or not? I I'm not sure but essentially they focus so much on the technology that
- basically we have very few times in life where a a company has hyped technology and and also created an objective
- standard. They didn't say it was going to improve her. They didn't say it was going to help her get slightly faster.
- They said, you know, yes, it's a moonshot, but we think she's going to be able to break four minutes. And you
- can't say that the three-time gold medalist in in the Olympics, who also won a gold medal this year, who also
- almost broke the 10,00 meter world record just, you know, a few months before this. You can't blame her and
- say, "Well, she's not, you know, it's her fault." The only thing we had left to say is the technology didn't live up
- to the hype. This technology was going to save seven and a half seconds off her time. It didn't live up to the hype. And
- and we live in a world of wearables that promise, you know, oh, this is going to
- make you healthier. This is going to help you run faster. And we do. We live this world of attribution bias where oh
- you know I didn't get injured when I I played today where you know I read a new PR it must be the tech it must be the
- tech and the super shoes I think are an exception the super shoes biomechanically really and laws of
- physics do support that super shoes do work but most of this other tech we just kind of buy it and we assume it's going
- to work and I think that's what Nike was going for with this 3D printed bra and and all these other things like she's
- going to break this barrier and we're going to all celebrate and it was the tech that made a difference and it was
- this rare moment where I think the tech failed in front of everybody and that's why we haven't talked about the sub
- four-minute project or the the breaking four project since because it was just kind of all right nothing to see here
- let's uh let's move on >> so Jamie maybe in the last minute or so um if we had you on next year which we
- will again what will you be talk what what are you likely to be talking to us about a year from now
- >> man that could be anything uh that's kind of the way I roll uh you know there's there's all types of different
- things I work on um My guess is it would be sports concussions and some of the technology behind sports concussions and
- howto like uh a 3D printed sports bra. It might not live up to expectations. That would be my guess.
- >> H well we like to thank Professor Jamie Smoliga for joining us here on Wharton
- Moneyball. He's a professor department of rehabilitation sciences director of research doctor of physical therapy
- program Tus University School of Medicine. Um it sounds like uh he writes about these topics in his newsletter. So
- Jamie, where can people find Beyond the Abstract? >> It's on Substack. So you could just uh
- search for beyond theabstract, all one word. Sububstack.com. You'll find me there. Or my last name uh which I'll
- spell s m o l i ga. If you search for that in substack, you'll find me because there's only one smolstack.
- >> Well, Jamie, thank you for joining us here on Wharton Moneyball. >> Thank you so much. I appreciate you
- having me. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's show. We've got open line
- segment coming up for the next 20 minutes or so and then an overtime guest on Ryder Cup. So, we can talk a little
- bit of Ryder Cup and we're gonna have Joseph Lmana in here in a few minutes to talk Ryder Cup in the overtime segment.
- Guys, baseball kicked off a few hours ago. The Tigers just knocked off the end the Guardians in the first first game of
- that wild card series. We've got Yankees Red Sox going off later today. We've got
- the other two uh wild card games as well. I'm assuming that's what's on your mind and I would love to hear your
- thought going into it. Um and then let's after we collect a little bit of that, let's go around to me and Shane and see
- what's on our mind as well. Let's see if we can get a a quick round of what caught your eye. Let's open with Audi
- Winer. >> Well, come on guys. I mean, uh lots of Yankees in my life right now. Lots of uh
- thoughts that the Yankees were not able to overtake Toronto. And reflectively thinking back at years past when ties
- for the division lead were settled with a one-game playoff. Can't remember. Yeah, obviously can remember games in
- the past where that happened and I wish we were doing that again. Um the fact that the the stakes are monumental um
- the difference between having to survive a a three-game wild card as we know coin
- toss Jensen um tells us all is so >> Wait, but but but in the old days it would be a oneame
- flip instead of a three-game coin flip. you favor in the old days. >> Yeah, but the the idea is
- >> it was still a playoff. It was just a shorter one. >> No, no, but the idea is that that's to
- decide who wins the division. It's a tie and we're going to have an extra game. >> But the only value to wins in the
- division is to get the buy and avoid the one. >> Now, now there's only a buy for
- >> game playoff, right? >> Back in the old day, it was you're out, right? You didn't win that. You don't go
- out. >> You're out. >> Um, you know, you play 162 games to decide who wins the division and it goes
- in a tie and then they decide it by the internal record. That sounds very football. Anyway, that's just my way of
- saying it's the the the uh the techniques of the other sports are are are leeching into our our history. Um so
- that was my obvious thing. And then I I have to reflect. I think I was probably feeling a little bit um Cal Rileyish
- couple weeks ago in terms of my MVP. Um, I wasn't settled on that, but I think five home runs and a 10-point leap in
- batting average and a 215 um WRC plus makes it really hard not to throw my my uh modest little weight behind Aaron
- Judge. >> Just comment a couple things that you said, Audi. First, what's interesting
- about the Yankees uh Blue Jays situation is that they're just swap they would have just swapped places the one on the
- four, but they play each other if if they don't recede in baseball. So, if the Yankees were to beat the Red Sox,
- which I I'll get to that in a second, they would play the Blue Jays. If they had been the other way around, if the
- Blue Jays had beaten the Red Sox, they would have played the Yankees. So all that matters is in some sense the first
- round which as we know using the Shane Jensen rule, it at least doubles the probability cuz I I don't know how
- anyone could argue the Yankees are much better than 50% to beat the Red Sox here. There wasn't that much win
- percentage difference. They got this guy uh Crochet pitching tonight. I understand we have Max Freed. That's a
- titanic war. Let me just tell you that's a coin flip. The whole series is a coin
- flip. So the Yankees win probability for the World Series in my view at best is cut in half. I was also wondering how
- much loss there was for home field. This was not the simulation I was talking about off air, but I asked chat GPT5
- um after I was very clear in what I asked it. I asked it after controlling for the fact that the home team has a
- better record, how much is the home field advantage in a series worth in baseball? That's
- what I asked it cuz remember the home team should have some advantage cuz they had the better record of the two. So it
- showed me the mathematical model that it built. It controlled for strength of team and it gave an answer of 1.25%.
- That's the answer it gave. You know, I could have asked for the empirical distribution or just
- >> you could just ask me and I could have made up an answer, Eric. Two 2%. >> Yeah. Why are we dehumanizing this
- process? No, but I I don't know that, you know, I think it was, you know, you're not
- interested at all, Shane, in its answer and how it did it. Even if you don't agree with it, you're not interested in
- how it did. So, I'm interested in your answer or Audi's answer or Kad's answer. >> Not necessarily, Chad.
- >> I mean, I I can tell you that historically the baseball advantage hovers around two and a half%. for home
- field two two to two and a half >> for a single game or for a series. >> No, for that would be a sing that would
- be a single game. >> Yeah. So now I have to think about it. Well, it's not hard to think about in
- the sense that I would say if you want intuition, think in the limits. If you played an infinite number of games, then
- the advantage would be 2 and a half%. Right? So the uh longer the number I have to think about this now maybe I
- don't have the good intuition for a series I have a 2 and a half% advantage I'm adding stochastic
- >> 52 versus 48 a pre noticeably >> is is that noticeable over a four uh seven best of three or best of five or
- best of seven so it's not it is not important probabilistically and uh for the range of series that we
- tend to in baseball. >> No, I mean it should add if it's a three or five game series, maybe it adds in
- total 10%. Um, but you so you'd have to So what chat GBT hopefully tried to adjust for the fact that the home team
- is usually a bit better and then tries to see if there's any residual um advantage based on that and uh and maybe
- maybe it found something. I haven't done that. U did it did it do it? I mean what what
- did it do? That's what it did. It controlled it fit actually it fit a mathematical model for
- um you know uh the probability of team A beating team B as a function it actually
- estimated strength parameters for the two teams. It controlled for those and then it said given that what residual
- variation is there? there. Now, there could be lots of other factors that it didn't control for, but it did control
- for the differential win loss record. >> Well, why don't we why don't we move on? We
- that's worthy of a lot of conversation actually, but at least it's an answer. It's an empirical answer. Y'all got real
- baseball going on right now. So, what what else besides the Yankees Red Sox series has most interest for you?
- Well, I think Seattle's trajectory, Seattle has won the division for the first time since 2001 when I ro was a
- rookie. So, I think that is notable. And so, you know, they're kind of new blood
- in the playoffs after um, you know, having the Astros as kind of the AL West, you know, representative for so
- many years. So, I think that's really exciting. >> But, moreover, they've never made the
- World Series, right? Aren't they the only team in Major League Baseball who's never made the World Series?
- They may be the only team in Major League Baseball that's never made the World Series now that I am thinking
- about it. Yeah, >> that's going to lead me to be the one person on this video who is pulling for
- the American League representative to be the Mariners. Y'all are pulling y'all have your hometown teams, but I think
- that's a good cause in the American League. Um, okay. on the >> and on the National League I think it's
- kind of interesting just kind of based on our previous discussion you don't need chat GPT to sim that the Dodgers by
- again playing in the wildard round should have half the probability of uh you know say the for example the
- Phillies uh that have got to buy from the wildard round >> well then there would also be the
- disadvantage to not having the home field they will not have the home field in the second round
- >> regardless the Dodgers I think are I at least in the odds that somebody posted a
- rundown are like the second highest uh team to win the World Series. >> Yeah, I have no other post that wasn't
- >> What's that all about? What is that all about? And we wait, let's just let's not
- ask >> preseason roster. I mean, that's a heck of a bracket. The Dodgers Phillies
- bracket is the strongest bracket on on the board, right? >> Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean they they would
- play each other because there's no receding. So, the the Phillies are the two, the Dodgers are the three.
- >> That's what I'm saying. That's what I'm saying. That's that's the toughest regional. This is the if this is the
- NCAA, we're talking about which regional is toughest. That's the toughest regional by far.
- >> Now, you're pointing out, Kade, what an advantage it was. Deservedly so that the
- Brewers ended up number one. >> They avoid the, you know, they have to play one of, if they make it, they have
- to play one of the Phillies and Dodgers. >> Okay, we talked about >> they have to go through potentially the
- Padres's who, again, by argue, by by rational them being there, won the division over the Dodgers. You know,
- just to point out, there's extraordinary parody in in the Major League Baseball,
- at least at the top 12 right now. I mean, there's there is Yeah, the the Dodgers, Phillies, Brewers are a bit
- better, but there's no 112 game winner this year. There's no even 100 game winner this year. Yep.
- >> First time in 11 seasons. >> And so, frankly, and and everything kind of changes in these short series with
- the way they use their arms. Um, it is hard just to to imagine that everybody's not in it. It's just some
- >> Yeah, look how different the the marquee of the World Series matchup could vary.
- I mean, it could be two complete blueb bloodoods or complete two complete like nowhere nowhere.
- >> Um, I mean, we'd be excited about a nowhere nowhere'sville Mariners, Brewers. We'd love that, but most of the
- country is not going to show up for that, right? Or it could be Dodgers, Yankees. I mean, come on. Mhm.
- >> So, it's it is it is going to be interesting to see play out. Okay, fellas. Outside, let me let me jump in.
- Since y'all have been talking baseball, let me give you one caught my eye. Let me give you one caught my eye. College
- football. We're rolling into week five. And I talked last time about um some Andrew Persal ensembling for power
- rankings in college football. And something that caught my eye, he posted just I think today his latest he threw
- some data visualizations up there. And let you know remember he he's he's ensembling power rankings like 11 or 12
- systems and he's reporting it he's reporting power rankings in standard deviations. What do you think? Here's
- something that's amazing. Compare the SEC versus the the ACC. So the ACC is still a power four conference and what
- he's finding is that the ACC is really kind of dropping and and the Big 12 actually looks a fair bit stronger than
- the ACC which is interesting. But one of the biggest stories of the year, this is
- this is also a way of me giving you kind of a big story of the year is how flat the SEC is. Like it is anybody's game
- and one and it's interesting contrast to the ACC. So the ACC has Miami head and shoulders above everyone else. You can
- drop twothirds of a standard deviation before you get the second best team in the ACC. Twothirds of a standard
- deviation between the best ACC team and the rest. If you go to the SEC and I I forget right now who's number one in the
- ensemble. Probably Alabama. Alabama or Georgia. >> The fact that you forget right now who's
- number one is already telling. >> Exactly. That's already fun. If you drop twothirds of a standard deviation in the
- SEC, what number in the SEC do you think you land on? What out of 16 teams? What
- number do you think you land on? Remember that got you to number two in the ACC. It's going to get you to what
- in the SEC? >> Six. 11. >> It gets you to the 11th. They have they have whatever that is, nine teams
- squeezed in where there exists none. >> None is more than half the lead. Now, what's interesting about that, Kate, I
- would imagine then that in any sim that looks at the probability that an SEC team wins the championship
- >> would have to be quite high because you don't I didn't say which team is going
- to win, but it but you know, one of those teams and it also would suggest that you know if the committee and I
- know you guys Massie Peabody have built models of the committee at some point there's going to have to be a large
- number of SE teams potentially in there. Assuming the mean level of those is high. Um, you know, could there be a
- scenario, kid? I don't even know how many. Could there be six or seven SEC teams now in there?
- >> Yeah, there's like there's not is there an actual limit on any one conference or
- just kind of convention there? >> There is a limit because >> there is a limit because each of the
- conference champions make it and then the best of the group of five makes it. Um, so that's at least five teams, at
- least four teams that are not from a conference. So theoretically be the rest filling out the field from total. There
- could be eight SEC teams. There won't be, but there could be. >> That's right. But but Eric, you're
- assuming something that you shouldn't assume. And that's also an interesting story here that the Big 10 is not
- doesn't have teams that are higher. So just because the SEC is the most compressed doesn't mean that it has the
- highest top end. And in fact, according according to Persal's ensemble, the Big 10 has a higher top end. and a much
- lower bottom end. And that higher top end has three teams above the best at the SEC. This is the world is different.
- Now, this is me updating you on college football this year. The top of the Big 10 looks stronger. Ohio State, Oregon.
- Oregon, who had a huge win in Happy Valley this past weekend. And um and I think Indiana of all things, I think
- Indiana's looking up really high, but at least Ohio State and Penn State, I Ohio
- State and Oregon are looking stronger right now than the SEC. So that's going to get a little bit in the way of that,
- Eric. All right, that's my quick college football update. Back to you guys, Shane. You haven't had a time at the
- floor here. What's caught your eye? Oh, I I think uh I I guess since we haven't discussed any kind of NFL uh
- type of thing, the thing that caught my eye, the Jets. >> Yeah. Well, I mean, the the Patriots
- finally looking dominant in a week kind of caught my eye, but I I I I did want to just sort of point out kind of
- numerically how interesting that Cowboys Packers game was. Not only is it it's the highest scoring tie in NFL history,
- and it was also a scorami. I'm sure you all know what a score origami is. It's kind of a unique score. I wouldn't have
- expected 4040 to be a unique score, but it was. So, that that was kind of that's
- something that certainly caught my eye. >> I also and sort of something we could
- discuss more. Uh maybe you don't want to talk about Kade, but I I'm so disappointed in the Ravens. I really I
- wanted them to be >> one of the one of those teams that could knock off the Chiefs this year, and it
- does not look like it's uh >> in the cards. >> They're gonna they're gonna have to dig
- out of a big hole. Um, it led Lamar's going to be out for a couple of weeks. It looks like it led to an interesting
- analysis of what that should do to the point spread. And if you talk to bookies, they'll say, you know, on
- average, the average NFL quarterback, if he goes out, it's going to cost about three points. But we know quarterbacks
- vary in their ability and in their backups. And so the biggest gap is much bigger than seven. And there was a study
- done um not a study, a survey done of bookies before the season and they rated all 32 teams on the impact on the
- average starting line if this team lost his quarterback. And the very best is like the Bills being knocked down seven
- points or so if Josh Allen goes out. But the Ravens are right there at the top number three and I think preseason they
- said it's something like six and 6.6 or something. That's a big hit. That's a big hit to take with a quarter with him
- going out and they're already >> that's basically that that analysis also is essentially a prior analysis of the
- MVP >> because it's bookie basically you know >> because there's no way >> basically being like you know what is
- the most impact you >> that's whose loss would lead to the biggest change in line as proxy for a most
- valuable player that's interesting >> that's how you elicit a prior for the MVP if you were to do it I think
- >> well by the way I'm missing Pat Mcomes is the one Josh Allen number one Pat Mahomes right there. I mean, dead even
- with Josh really and then Lamar about.3 below them. >> Eric was going to >> let me just ask you a question.
- I would think that, you know, one of the things I've been looking at, Kate, obviously you've built models for power
- rankings. On what basis are the Eagles number one in people's power rankings? Like it's apparently it's the first time
- in history, by the way, just so you know, that a team is 4-0, but in terms of total yardage, they're 0
- and4. They haven't beaten one team they've played in terms of total yards gained.
- Not yet. >> What about the momentum argument, Eric? When was the last time they lost in a
- nonjalen started game? I mean, >> momentum, but I'm just commenting that they obviously have scored through.
- They've blocked kicks. if you know, etc. But at some point, like I'm just asking
- Cade, what model? Forget the record for a second. I don't show you the record. I
- asked you to build an offensive and defensive power ranking and now I asked you to come up with an overall team
- strength. It's just hard for me to believe that the Eagles would come up as number one using that method. But maybe
- I've got it wrong. No, I mean it's it's reasonable, but it does goes to show you
- that that not all yards are equal and situational football matters a great deal and yards can be quite cheap
- between the 20s, for example. Um, we also used to have a stat one of we only had four stats like I mean our original
- it got fancier over time but our original model was really simple just you know basically passing efficiency
- rushing offensive offens efficiency and um one of the one of the four was what might be doing some work here which was
- points per yard and we picked it up off of a telecast and we turned out to find that it was predictive and it c it's
- kind of a residual it says something about special teams. It says something about turnovers and apparently
- apparently the Eagles are doing well in it this year because to be behind on all
- the yards but ahead in the win column in all games says something about points per yard.
- >> And this is selection bias here though. I have to be you have to be careful with
- this because you watch this. You know, Eagles will they get a fumble or interceptionally run it back. You got to
- give the ball up after you do that. you you just you don't have the opportunities to generate the yards when
- you when you score on these special teams plays. It it takes the it takes your time and possession away. It's not
- saying that they wouldn't have done it. They they did it right. Oops. So, it's it's it's not necessarily an indictment
- of their play to have got a whole bunch of special teams scoring. Um and uh you really have to look at the yards per per
- play and some of those measurements um rather than the fact that they you know because if you don't have the ball you
- can't score yards right so you can't get yards so I I think it's a little less um
- as shocking that statistic Eric then you immediately comes to mind although it is
- >> important this whole discussion is kind of reminding me about the Chiefs last
- year kind of had a similar type season where it was hard to move them down to the rankings because they kept winning.
- >> Mhm. >> Like like in sort of at least the subjective rankings, they kept winning
- so it was hard to move them down, but they weren't looking as imp, you know, they're kind of winning a lot on
- essentially like Mojo or like kind of like kind of chance of Vance block. They had a block kick win just like the
- Eagles did uh more re this season. And so, you know, I I think so, you know, that that's perhaps, you know, uh
- something where maybe maybe it will kind of catch up with the Eagles once or twice this season. I don't think they're
- going to go undefeated, but it is also, I think, evidence of a strong team that they keep have at least they're in a
- position to win every week. >> Yeah, it's it's uh we're talking about asking the question whether there's
- something you can put in the model. This is really the heart of what Eric originally asked. Is there something you
- could put in a model that captures this mojo that Shane just referred to? Is there something objective and predictive
- that you could put in there? And it's a it's a very fair question, guys. While while we're in the NFL real quickly, let
- me just let me just stay on this one just for one more second. I just want to ask my question that I always frame it
- in this way. So, Audi, Shane, Kade, I give you the stats. I I ask you to predict who the Eagles are going to be
- play next week. Okay. I think they're playing the uh Broncos, by the way. >> Yeah.
- >> And I think let's say they're favored by whatever two and a half, three and a
- half, whatever the number is. And I said, "No, no, no. I'm sorry, guys. I forgot to tell you that they've won 18
- straight games or whatever the number is. How much are you changing your prediction? I asked this question on I
- always love to frame it this way. I now reveal this other piece of information. How much are you changing your win
- probability? AI, I'm going to start with you because you always keep it you always keep it real. Yeah. You mean it's
- interesting because I think football 18 straight wins is more meaningful than in
- and really in many other sports because of the well the team kind of component of it. And and here's the thing that I
- would follow up with a question to all you experts in football, which is how much does high leverage performance um
- disparities between low leverage performance inform? Like the the classic baseball line, which is transformed
- baseball, is that we don't care about high leverage versus low leverage performance. It's all randomness in
- football. Is it? And and I would imagine that it's not. and 18 W wins tells me quite a bit about high leverage versus
- low leverage performance diff throwing it out. >> We've been talking about the Eagles and
- Eagles Broncos. I I highlighted what looked to me like the most interesting games this weekend and other than San
- Francisco LA which one has become one of the great rivalries in the NFL in recent
- years. The other four have an interesting quality guys. Look at the other four that I have up there. Dallas
- at New York Jets, Broncos at Philly, Tampa Bay at Seattle, and Washington at Los Los Angeles Chargers. I started
- thinking about those as all games we don't see that very often. How many times do you think those teams have
- played? And in fact, one of them, the one that most jumped out to me was Tampa Bay, Seattle, because I know this, this
- is like the classic old guy thing to say, that's an expansion team game, right? That's an expansion game between
- the 1976 Seattle Seahawks and 1976 Tampa Bay Buccaneers. It's kind of fun to see
- those guys going at it. But in fact, those two teams of these four matchups, those two teams have played the most.
- They played 15 times. The the others have played 12, 13, and 14 times. So these are not match up. You see these
- matchups every three or four years. Like the Cowboys and Jets, that's kind of fun. We don't see that many Cowboys at
- Jets. That's not that common. Audi, you're just might have a chance against that team. But the um God
- >> but also you point out you talk about leverage for the season just like Tampa
- Bay and Philly was a high leverage game because now one has an advantage over the other both in record and in
- tiebreaker. It's not our it's not impossible to believe that Tampa Bay and Seattle will
- be battling for some sort of tiebreaker at the playoffs and this is a huge game therefore in that respect because
- they're both three and one at the moment. Well, that that that's a funny one. That used to be interconference.
- That's not conference anymore. >> Get all technical, but isn't Tampa of all teams the most resistance to
- tiebreers because it's basically locked into winning division >> and like of like of like I understand
- it's a playoff team and all playoff teams should be cognizant of tiebreaking scenarios and and these games do impact
- that, but I feel like like the division winner that's kind of locked into it is the most robust to that. Yeah, I I think
- the Falcons may still have something to say about it in the end, but we'll see. >> I saw some odds on that this week, the
- betting markets. I think those are some of the better odds to win the division. The Bills are by far the best.
- >> Oh, yeah. No, for sure. We can we can we can pencil that in. >> The other thing I just want to observe
- is the the 0 and3 Giants beating the 3 and 0 Chargers is one of the most NFL things. I mean, every year this happens,
- right? Every year week four, some 0 and3 team beats a 3-0 team. You think could couldn't win. There's no way this is
- going to win. But it's also signs of life. Jackson Dart, signs of life. I mean, it's folly to bet too much on a
- rookie quarterback, but still signs of life for the Giants, maybe. Okay, fellas. Why don't we leave it
- there? I know y'all have some baseball to watch. That has been the first hour of Wharton Moneyball. Usually one hour
- show these days, but every now and then we do an overtime segment, and we're going to do one. We're going to talk
- Ryder Cup, a topic we didn't hit because we have Joseph Lammana joining us shortly to talk RDER Cup, the big
- tournament over this past weekend. Welcome to an overtime segment in this week's show. Every now and then, we have
- too much to cover, too much we want to cover to limit ourselves to the one-hour show. And this is one of those weeks we
- didn't have a chance to talk Ryder Cup and we could do a whole show on the Ryder Cup. Certainly lots of people
- doing lots of analysis on the Ryder Cup just after the US. You know, it would have been disaster if not for a major
- comeback on Sunday. Still, many people think an embarrassing showing at Beth Paige. And we thought we'd do a little
- conversation on that with Joseph Lmana. Joseph is first time visitor to this show. I'm I'm going to tell you, I came
- across him in two ways. One, he's done the show Bet the Process with our friends Rufus Peabody and Jeff Ma a
- couple of times. In fact, I think Rufus always makes a fuss over how much Jeff Maul loves Joseph Lammana, one of his
- favorite guests, I believe. But then also, if you start asking around about an organization called used to be called
- the 15th Club, now it's like the 21st Club. Maybe maybe Joseph can remind us of this. This is an organization
- longtime listeners might remember. This is an analytics organization that came out of the UK. They they were first like
- the 21st club because they were the 21st club in the Premier League. providing soccer analytics and then they started
- doing golf and then the European writer cup team glombmed on to them and started
- using analytics and we had conversations over the years with multiple people in that organization. Turns out Lmana
- part of his gigs over the years was working for that organization. So Joseph is a resident here in Austin, Texas. He
- is a Longhorn fan which is not the reason I brought him on I promise. He is a writer and contributor analyst at the
- fried egg which is a fantastic organization looking at golf from a lot of different angles. Joseph has his own
- practice, his own consulting. He has caddied for multiple years. He is a bit of a course kind of a course
- afficionado. He can talk designers and pros and cons. So he is the perfect guy to talk Rder Cup. Joseph, welcome to
- Wharton Moneyball. >> Well, thanks so much for having me. I am a listener. I I love the Wharton
- podcast, the Wharton Moneyball podcast. So, uh, it's I'm a longtime listener, first- time guest, but I really respect
- what you guys do, and I think this is the perfect audience to be talking about the RDER Cup with. Very analytically
- driven audience. So, I'm really excited. >> Well, that's that's good to hear. And
- the only worry is that we we all of us have to go do something at some point, otherwise we could stay here for a long
- time. Eric is going to have to leave first. And I know Eric is going to have some kind of question. Eric, you watched
- the tournament. I know you have strong feelings about the tournament. Hypothesize a little bit with with
- Joseph. Ask Joseph some questions about whatever you're curious about. I'm curious where you go, Eric, after having
- watched three days of golf. >> Yeah. So, Joseph, is there a science like I I can't remember the last time
- the US won in four sums? Maybe they have um four ball. So is there something analytically that can be said about
- pairing people together that kind of you know you know could explain why or or another way to frame it is is it obvious
- that a mistake was made by the US team in pairing people together. Real quickly, you said forsomes and four
- ball. Let's take foresomes just as a sensation. >> Let's start with forsomes, which the lay
- person might know as alternate shot. >> Alternate shot. And so this, you know, the US famously loses Friday, the Friday
- morning is the first, they always play forsomes. They got crushed this one. And so that that's the that's the context
- here. Joseph, >> I feel like there's there are a lot of different directions to to take that
- question, right? There's why does the US struggle historically in forsomes? there
- is what is the strategy in pairing people in forsomes and there's so many different threads you could pull on with
- that question right I think overarching there is a truth to Americans struggling
- in forsomes and you could do an entire podcast episode on why that might be I think there's credence too that that
- Europeans play a lot more alternate shot growing up it's part of the culture there that's part of the way they play
- at clubs in Europe it's part of competition that elite junior golfers play. So, I think there is more of a
- comfort level for Europeans playing alternate shot. How much is that worth? Like, I don't have a great answer for
- you on that, but I think there's something to it. And then in terms of pairing people together in in alternate
- shot, absolutely, there's a lot that goes into that. You want to pair people with complimentary skill sets. You want
- to be conscious on who should be teeing off on the odd holes versus the even holes because that's the way that it
- works at the RDER Cup. I mean, true true alternate shot. Sometimes it's just whoever finishes the putt, the next
- person te's off. But in at the RDER Cup, it's odds and even. So, there's strategy
- involved in that. There's strategy involved in the golf ball that you play, right? Because if you're playing with
- two totally different makes and models of golf ball, you're going to have golfers adjusting on the fly, which they
- may not be comfortable with for good reason. I mean, spin control on your wedges is a huge part of of professional
- golf. So, if you're playing a golf, >> Joseph, just a clarification, I didn't I hadn't even thought about asking this.
- Because of the rain, they were playing preferred lie uh for at least for the first couple days. Does that mean if you
- shoot and now I shoot when I lift your ball, I can't replace it with my ball? >> It is correct that you're not allowed to
- replace the ball on the hole. But and this part I actually don't like about the RDER Cup. You can change the golf
- ball on each hole. They no longer have the one ball rule in effect. So you can change on the T- box. I think you should
- you should have to play one ball the whole time. But to answer your question, no, you cannot pick up the ball as part
- of the preferred lie and then put back down a different golf ball. >> Got it. >> Joseph and Eric, you'll you'll be you'll
- be impressed by this and Joseph probably knows this, but so um Molinari, Edward Molinari, former player, right? And he's
- went big into analytics and he's been consulting to the right >> current player. Yes.
- >> Current current player. Okay. Current player. Uh and he's been consulting to the European team for years now. I just
- saw a clip of a longer interview he did. I haven't seen the whole interview so and I can't even make a proper
- attribution but it's out there. I'm sure it's getting a lot of attention where he
- talked about the analytics they do and figuring out their forome pairings. And you'll get a kick out of this Eric. My
- what I gathered in this one minute clip is that they put guys they they they put
- guys on simulators. So they're going to simulate the course and then they run them through the course as it will be
- played and they run them at different combinations. For example, you know, you put Fleetwood and and Rory together and
- you'd say, "Okay, Rory, you're going to tee off on the one on the odds and Fleetwood will take the evens and then
- we're going to flip it and we're going to do enough of those to get some sense there's an advantage on this course for
- the strengths and weaknesses of those two players." They literally simulate in that way with the guys to figure out
- something about their pairings. And that my big picture take so far, this is just
- Tuesday or whatever and I'm not the most informed, but I've tried to gather as much as I can for a couple days. We
- probably gave up something the US and not being as analytically oriented. But I think the fact that we're not as
- analytically oriented shows that we're just not looking for edges in the way the Europeans are looking for edges.
- It's it's like it's like it's like the Philadelphia Eagles playing the Cincinnati Bengals. You know, it's like,
- yeah, some some years the Bengals are going to have enough talent that they're going to be able to compete with the
- Eagles, but year in year out the Eagles are looking for every last edge possible. They got a cap guy in there
- playing with the cap, running the team now and figuring out other things. They've got player development. They're
- doing everything possible. The fact that the US let Scotty and who was he playing
- with? They just decided to flip the order of their >> Well, they played with the Shambo on one
- set. I maybe that was some >> But Eric, they made a flip on tea off order on their own Saturday and it just
- kind of flippantly did this as opposed to the way the Europeans have studied this, practiced it. It just reveals the
- the lack of diligence. That's my current hypothesis. Joseph, >> look, you're absolutely right. The the
- Americans are always behind on this type of stuff. And I think there are real questions starting to be asked about how
- well the analytics team is performing on the American side. And because as as you
- guys talk about this all the time on on the podcast, using data doesn't mean you're using data correctly. And I think
- that there's now this like now both teams are using data. That does not mean that they're making intell intelligent
- decisions. And so I do think that's a big question that's coming out of this Ryder Cup. Hey, who was making
- decisions? Was Keegan Bradley overriding some of the advice that he was being given.
- But and I I think one maybe the most underrated part of the RDER Cup is some of the
- communication. h how important communication is. I I think the the best example would be something like to use a
- football analogy, John Harbaugh going for it on fourth and two to have the model built and then to have the
- communication to him in real time to have the confidence in the model with John Harbaugh. How strong of a
- recommendation is it? All of those pieces of the process are crucially important and I think Europe has really
- nailed that down. I can't tell you where the United States is exactly failing on
- that, but they are clearly failing on that repeatedly, whether it's the model building itself, which I think there's
- there are clearly some issues there, but also getting the appropriate buyin all the way down to Keegan Bradley so that
- he's making good decisions in real time. I think it's pretty obvious at this point that it deserves scrutiny from top
- to bottom all of that process. >> Joseph, since I have to run this, let me ask you two more questions. Um the first
- one is let's imagine do you ever see a world I we all know Scotty Sheffller is the number one player in the world and
- matter of fact he's played like it it's not even been close I mean he is the number one player in the world is there
- ever a way where let's say he's 0 and3 where you say okay look he's the number one player in the world but there is
- intraday and intraday variation I'm not going to put a tired Scotty sheffller out there for the four sums on day two.
- He's 0 and3 already. You know what? Maybe I just sit him for the singles. Is there any like would that ever enter the
- analysis that's I have another question, but would that ever enter the analysis that someone would actually sit the
- number one player in the world? >> Would it ever enter the analysis? It better be in the analysis. You're you're
- hitting on two things there. One is how much do you weigh long-term form versus short-term form? What level of
- information are you getting from what you see in the first session, the first three sessions? Like abs, if that's not
- baked into what you're doing, then that's a problem. You're also asking about energy conservation, which I think
- is a very important part of the Rder Cup that maybe became more obvious this time
- around, but the golfers who go all five sessions had a really hard time in their
- singles match. And sometimes we've seen historically with Europe like the at the
- last RDER Cup in 2023, they did sit John Rom out in the afternoon session with the knowledge that he was going off
- first in the morning on Sunday and wanted him to be ready for it. Do I think that generally you're going to run
- the number one player five sessions? Yeah. Is there a world where I would leave Scotty Sheffller out of a session?
- There is, but I think more than likely you're probably going to need to ride him for five sessions. But absolutely,
- you should be looking at that kind of stuff. and you're hitting on some of the intricacies that team Europe handles
- much better than the United States does historically. Right? That's another clear example where you could be using
- data to determine something, but you might not be using it correctly of how much that first session actually is in
- is predictive of how they're going to play in the next. I think Ben Griffin is Ben Griffin's the example there that I
- would I would say I think they clearly yanked him after what they saw from the first round, but per perhaps that was an
- overreaction. >> I I I that was I had a lot of questions about Ben Griffin, but let me given my
- time. Let me ask one more question. Forget what actually happened. If I had I want you to give me a probability of
- the following. If I had told you that the singles matches were over. I'm not going to tell you anything else,
- >> but the only win by the European team is Louvig Oberg against Patrick Kentlay.
- That's the only win. >> What probability would you have told me that Europe would win the cup? Zero,
- right? >> Whoa. I can't say zero, right? But uh yeah I don't know 5% something really
- low >> I think it was% >> yeah and also if I had told you also similarly on the beginning of Sunday
- that the US would be alive very alive by the time it got to Shane Lowry you would have said to me how's that
- going to happen in a similar way right >> yeah and again people could say that if
- it weren't a blowout going into Sunday Sunday might have played out differently. I I don't know exactly
- where I land on that. But I do think one advantage that the United States clearly
- had on Sunday was how worn down the Europeans were in particular. I don't know how much people are, you
- know, the fan abuse that was a big storyline coming out of it. I was with the group where all that was mainly
- happening. I cannot believe Shane Lowry was able to to play as well as he did on
- Sunday after what some of the stuff that he and Rory endured. So, I do think a big part of the Sunday performance by
- the Americans was they caught some tired golfers. Rory had very little in the tank. And if you saw what he was
- subjected to out there, I think it is completely understandable that he was spent going into Sunday.
- >> Wow. Wow. Wow. I did not realize until just then that you were out there. So,
- you were in New York for the tournament. >> Yes, I was there. Yep. On on site. So, a
- little different experience that sometimes you don't always have the best feel for everything that's going on. So,
- you'll have to pardon me if I can't get into the specifics of every shot in every match, but at least for the ones I
- was with should have some insight. >> Yeah. Yeah. Well, start with what you just said, which was the crowd, which
- received so much attention. And I've heard I had one buddy who was there who who talked about what a how much fun it
- was, what a great crowd, how interesting it was. And, you know, that's very different from a lot of the reports you
- get. And then you have the commissioner, whoever it was that came out say, I didn't see anything untored and that
- doesn't seem to fit with what you're reporting. Like what what would you say about what you saw from the crowd there?
- >> You know, I I feel like when people when golf media is reporting about how ugly
- it is, there's sort of this backlash that that thinks people are pearl clutching and being uptight. I am a
- massive sports fan. I go to UFC fights, NFL games, like I have a very high tolerance for what should be acceptable
- at a sporting event. The RDER Cup was completely out of line, completely over the top. You're talking about personal
- insults about people's marriages, about their physiques, about what their wives look like. And it's happening, you know,
- not because it's all loud and rockous. It was loud and rockous, but then it would quiet down and Rory Mroy'd be
- standing over the ball and somebody from 10 rows deep was yelling something about
- his marriage that forced him to step back off of the ball while his family is inside the ropes hearing the entire
- thing. It is not People are not going overboard talking about how gross the crowd was. To be clear, these are bad
- actors. It's not like the crowd in mass was chanting things that were inappropriate, but what was being yelled
- was completely inappropriate. Calling golfers fat, you know, again, going after their wives appearances, rumors.
- It was really, really ugly. And it it's appropriate to characterize it that way without, you know, pearl clutching.
- >> Okay, that's helpful to hear from you and helpful context that you're accustomed to some pretty rough sporting
- environments. What do you think? We we this isn't why we brought you on here, but but it does make you wonder. Do you
- think it's an do you think it's policable? Do you think it's in do you think better standards are enforcable in
- the future if an organization wanted you know it's really difficult where my head goes immediately is um most of
- those comments came from areas where there are collection points on the golf course where somebody's 10 rows deep and
- doesn't have the courage to yell it from the front row. So I think that is something you could think about how you
- uh you know control where there are a bunch of crowds organized and think about grandstands and there's clearly
- something there. I've seen some people talk about hard liquor, right? You know, if a beer crowd's different than a hard
- liquor crowd there. There's a lot of different ways you can go. It's very difficult to enforce, but I do think the
- PJ of America is getting a lot of backlash and needs to consider what the next event would look like. Again,
- people aren't aren't being over the top here saying it was ugly. It was absolutely ugly. Something should be
- done about it, but I I don't think this is just a problem in golf. We've seen bad fan encounters in a number of ways.
- I think gambling is involved here, right? I think that has kind of heightened people's propensity to to go
- after athletes when they're mad and they just spent $1,000 on a ticket. They've been sitting there all day. Team USA is
- losing. They could have a couple thousand dollars on the Americans to win the RDER Cup. So, a lot there. It's
- difficult to solve, but it does need to be solved. >> Okay, coming back to the golf, um I've
- seen a range of responses, you know, Dan Rapapore is someone who's been on the show a number of years, and we always
- enjoy Dan and he right on the heels of the tournament, he went to the mat saying, you know, it's not Keegan's
- fault. Coaches don't hit the ball. I'd rather him be a player than a coach. It's all on the players. It's on the
- players on the players. Okay. Um true to it some extent. Of course, the players have to play. Okay.
- But then we have some people are blaming managerial decisions and we can talk about analytics and you know we can get
- worked up about you know this there's all this stuff about data golf said that Morocawa's pairing on Friday and
- Saturday was 132nd out of 132 possible pairings. That's so bad. And people are like you know don't take the analytics
- too far. There's uncertainty on those things and the differences are small and let's not make too big a fuss out of it.
- And I am curious your perspective. I mean you I think you you see the golf you've played golf at high levels you've
- caddy golf at high levels you analyze golf so you kind of see it from all these perspectives what is the relative
- importance of all of these analytics that we're talking about the edges because you know usually analytics make
- a difference but they're not huge differences we're talking about getting every little edge you can but they're
- not huge differences relative to you know chefer playing well or poorly. Yeah, and that's the million-dollar
- question, right? And I think there are so many different pieces of what you're talking about. All of it matters and all
- of it stacks up. And you hear Luke Donald talk about his level of preparation on the European side down to
- changing the betting because he wanted the players to get better sleep. And you know, if you look at his pairings at the
- BMW PGA Championship a couple weeks ago, Europe gets to have input on on who gets
- paired together. and a lot of the golfers that were grouped together ended up being partners in the RDER Cup.
- That's not a coincidence. They are actively preparing. To Keegan's credit, he did the same thing. And at the
- Procore Championship in Napa, those golfers were playing practice rounds with each other, got grouped together.
- And so, I think we have to take a step back when evaluating Keegan Bradley's captaincy and not only focus on the fact
- that Colin Morawa and Harris English were paired together twice in Forsomes, which was a bad pairing. I do I do not
- want to defend that pairing. But to your point, >> I think Rory and Tommy were priced I
- want to say minus 200 minus 210 in that matchup when they got paired with Harris
- English and Colin Morawa. So call it a 65% chance that >> Rory and Fleetwood were going to win. if
- you tossed a better pairing out at them like you know maybe it goes to to 60%ish
- >> and I do not mean to downplay a 5% >> difference on a match but >> no >> I think it's important to keep in in
- check the totality of all of the decisions Keegan made were 2018 the Americans used to do the dumbest most
- thoughtless stuff I still don't like some of the decisions that Keegan made but they've come a long way so I think
- he was getting kind of butchered you know, crucified for for some of the decisions he made that was maybe a
- little out of scale. I I didn't think he was a great captain, but I also think some of the comments are way overboard
- and people had started writing those when the US was way down early versus waiting to watch things play all the way
- up. >> Right. I I think it's important for those of us who do practice analytics
- and um advocate analytics that we keep analytics in perspective and they do provide edges, but they're relatively
- small edges typically and the trick is to stack a bunch of these edges and to practice them consistently. Not that any
- one thing is gonna make that big a difference, but also they do reveal a little bit. You know, we um Kevin Cole
- is an analyst that we have on the show sometimes focuses on football and he does great um like front office
- evaluations and we don't know everything that happens in front offices, but the decisions we do get to see are revealing
- of a broader philosophy. And I think that's something analogous here with the writer cup. like some of the decisions
- they make reveal on the European side a care for all this detail and analysis and maybe not as much care on the US
- side. Um I have two other general questions to ask you. One of them is the course he's
- the the US side. I'm not sure who makes that decision whether it's strictly Keegan or not, but you know a lot about
- courses and course setups and how course setups interact with players. Apparently
- they took the bite out of Beth Bates. They they took the rough down. That's not the way the course usually plays and
- there's a lot of criticism for the people who made that decision. What's your position on the role the course
- played? >> The teams coming in, their skill sets were relatively balanced, at least
- compared to historical RDER cups. Like in 2021 at Whistling Straits, Team USA had a massive distance advantage and
- they were on a big golf course and you want to set it up as distance friendly as possible. Europe's playing from way
- behind. That was not the case coming into this Ryder Cup. the skill sets were much more balanced. Depends how you want
- to look at that just the rosters top to bottom or if you want to start to weight
- it. And I think where Team USA potentially regrets some of the setup decisions is that you think about
- waiting it, you know, Scotty Sheffller is going to go four to five matches, probably five matches. And I do believe
- that setting up the golf course the way they did, chopping the rough down entirely, muted one of their best
- players strength in Scotty Sheffller. is a very accurate driver of the golf ball.
- Bryson de Shambo isn't. So if you're you know if you it's not like chopping down
- the rough changed the the win probability of this thing by 10%. Like I I think people are going a little
- overboard on the core setup stuff in this particular case. This is not Paris. This is not Whistling Straits where the
- skill sets were radically different. They also range which you can't control. So that was part of it. But yes, if I
- were to set the golf course up, especially with the benefit of hindsight, I think some thicker rough
- would have benefit the US team, especially given that, you know, Scotty Sheffler, Russell Henley, JJ Spawn. They
- had some very accurate drivers of the golf ball. But again, people aren't talking about Cameron Young. Cameron
- Young bowled out for the United States, played a lot from the rough. >> Yeah, >> the setup benefit him. So, it's it is
- important to keep some of that in perspective. >> Okay, that's great. That's great. The
- the last thing that I've heard from a few places that I I find compelling is that the owner of the Ryder Cup, the PG
- of America, the the decision makers bigger than the manager have to have some questions answered. Like it's not
- just on the players and the manager. It's like this institutional question. And the fact that the Europeans have so
- much more continuity and institutionalization and training programs for their coaches and all these
- kinds of things, they're practicing the same things year over year or cycle over
- cycle and the US doesn't. The US started this back in the 2010s and then it seems
- to been kind of abandoned. What do you have and this is maybe a little far from your expertise but I'm
- curious I mean this is I think it's a great way to push the dialogue. It's like let's go beyond the obvious things.
- Yeah, they petted poorly and yeah, maybe Keegan had a few questions he some decisions he missed, but what's behind
- the scenes year over year, like years long in the making that what in what way does the US suffer by by that
- comparison? >> Well, yeah, I think you're getting at is there's not a lot of stability and
- consistency year-over-year with the RDER Cup, who the captain, how they get chosen, their relationship with
- whoever's consulting them, getting information. And there's not a lot of consistency there. Versus on the
- European side, they kind of have this thing down and there are consistent voices in the room.
- >> The most you this past RDER Cup had 11 of the same 12 players in the same captain.
- >> It's incredible. >> Some of the overlap in the vice cast like you can't have more continuity than
- they just had. So you almost took it to an extreme and I think that's absolutely
- beneficial. A lot of the listeners of this podcast will understand that better than I will with, for example, like
- changes in offensive coordinators and defensive coordinators in the NFL and some of the uncertainty that that that
- can, you know, create. So, I absolutely think there is something to the US needing to have some more continuity. I
- don't know who on the American side knows golf well enough, honestly, to be that voice. And I think that's what
- they're struggling with. And the other fascinating point I've heard kind of brought up for the first time over the
- last couple days that I never really thought about is that the President's Cup, you know, that's the United States
- versus the international team, which happens every other year, whichever year the Ryder Cup isn't, might be hurting
- the United States in in the way that they prepare for the Ryder Cup. And that they do this thing every year. It takes
- a little bit of the, you know, it's h this thing again, this thing again versus, you know, a little more scarcity
- and really getting themselves prepared for it, really taking a lot of pride in it. Okay, the record since the
- President's Cup started, the United States isn't very good. I don't I don't know exactly how much credence there
- could be to that, but it's an interesting angle to explore that team Europe just takes this thing a little
- more seriously. >> Okay. Okay. Now, let me ask you a couple of cheaper, you know, superficial
- questions, just fun questions. You can just riff, do as little or as much as you want of this. Um, one is as as long
- as we're talking about ownership and captainship, the name everyone's kicking around now
- is Tiger Woods and and he he apparently passed on this time, but like how do you
- from you from your being around golf and from your having been around some RDER Cups, how do you think Tiger would do as
- a captain? Now, that's only one factor, but it's an important factor. How do you
- think Tiger would do as a >> Yeah, if I had to guess, Tiger understands how there how there are much
- fewer responsibilities when you're an away captain, so he probably did not want to be the home captain, but I I
- don't know that for sure. Uh I I'm skeptical of a Tiger Woods captaincy. I think if you believe a ton in the
- emotional side and guys getting up for their captain, then that is a very strong reason that you pick Tiger Woods.
- Who wouldn't want to play for Tiger Woods? and who wouldn't be differential to him and trust him on decision. So
- that's the the pros of picking Tiger. I think there are a lot of cons of picking
- Tiger. One, he never cared about the RDER Cup. He didn't play well in the Ryder Cup. He was pretty vocal about it
- not being everything to him. So, you know, is he going to put his heart and soul into it the way that we'd watched
- Luke Donald do it and tap every edge and, you know, give everything he has to it? I don't know. Does Tiger Woods
- will will he have put out optimal pairings or will he go a little bit more with like you know what I trust Jordan
- Speed in this situation and look at his record from eight years ago? Like I I am
- very skeptical of any Rder Cup captain until we actually see the decisions that they make. So sure could Tiger be good?
- He could be. But I kind of like this angle of Luke Donald. Like the player, they were talking about it on our pod
- today. Like the player who got everything out of their game and was very analytical about their game could
- be the type of captain you want that, you know, is just a little bit more intelligent about the sport.
- >> Okay. When you think about that next generation of players moving into the age where they might become a captain,
- Keegan got there pretty early, obviously. Who might fit that profile that you just described?
- It's a great question. In thinking about it, I could see somebody like Web Simpson who, you know, he never hit the
- ball particularly far. He was pretty good RDER cut player, got a lot out of his game, probably pretty intelligent
- about the game, but I don't know that for sure, right? You'd love to interview them and actually get a feel for their
- relationship with data, how much they understand this stuff, you know, how open-minded they are. I think those are
- important questions to ask. Webb Simpson comes to mind. I think Xander Schoffley
- is actually really intelligent about the sport in in a way that I don't know how
- well he could command a locker room and some of that, but I I think he could potentially down the line be an
- interesting captain. So, I don't know that I have great some people have some confidence in Bran Snedker. I'd be eager
- to see how he talks about it, but uh those are a couple names. Xander is a random one, but I think Sneder and Web
- Simpson you will see in the rotation in some capacity. So, I guess I'm somewhat optimistic about what they would do, but
- again, I want to caution that we haven't actually heard from them. >> Yeah. Right. Well, you said the same
- thing. You said what's their relationship to data, how open-minded they are. I would like to emphasize the
- latter. Of course, you know, being data friendly or data literate would be a plus. But the most important thing is
- that people are open-minded and they're interested in edges from anywhere. This is the best organizations, the best
- leaders are open to edges from anywhere because they realize what we're doing is
- tough here. It's going to be a close thing. We need to find any edge we can take and that means listening to some
- people that might be coming at it from an orthodox perspective. So, I love what you said. Open-mindedness. It seems it
- seems important in lots of other sports. All right, last question. This could go
- a little technical. We'll try not to go too technical, especially without Audi because it's an Audi question, but I
- want I do want to hear your take on putting. I I haven't seen the exact breakdown on
- the first two days, but I and or even into Sunday, but I I gather that the Europe the Europeans certainly seem to
- putt better than the Americans. So, if the stats bore that out, what would you need to see to believe that that was
- more than just chance? And I guess it comes down to your beliefs about putting. You know, it's it's one of
- these events, just stochcastic events in sports that we know make a big difference in the outcome, but we have a
- hard time seeing persistence over time. So, they're not super predictive of like
- next period. And when those kinds of that's like fumbles recovered, fumbles recovered greatly determined football
- games, but they they are pretty much chance. So, there's some thinking. I mean, the the nihilists among us will
- say, you know, these guys all are pretty similar putters um except maybe at the edges and some are going to drop some
- bombs and some are going to miss and that's just chance and that's just what happened. So, I'm curious your take as a
- as a someone who's been around the sport. Where are you on the nihilistic scale when it comes to putting that how
- persistent or luck based is it at that level on days like >> Much less nihilistic?
- >> You are okay. >> I'd say much less nihilistic than I used to be. Uh I think there's it is a very
- unpredictable stat. It is not completely unpredictable. It is not you know blindfold and and throw a dart like it
- is there. You can a I'm also a huge believer in pressure. Putting under pressure and playing under pressure is a
- different sport than you know what your make percentage from 5 to 10 feet when you know you're 10 shots out of the lead
- at the Sanderson Farms Championship. No disrespect to the Sanderson, but you you
- know Justin Rose is an excellent putter. He putt out of his mind again at Beth Page. Is that predicted? Can could we
- have predicted that? Like not necessarily, but I I don't think it's just completely random. I will also say
- that those greens at Beth Page were extremely easy to putt on and dead flat. Not a lot of break in them. The
- conditions were easy. Like if you were missing a lot of putts, you're probably not a great putter. I I know Sam Burns
- didn't have his best putting week and he's a great putter. So, sure, there it's still a noisy statistic, but no, I
- would not say that this championship just came down to putting, therefore, the outcome was random. I'm not on that.
- >> Okay. >> On that, too. >> Okay. Um, you said this thing about pressure, which I think we now people
- like yourself who do golf analytics have established this, and I've heard Rufus talk about like guys do perform worse
- with the lead. That's the single best I think example of pressure in golf. like we know this now. To what extent is
- there heterog heterogeneity and to what extent in these teams these US and European teams do you think there is
- heterogeneity in ability to perform under pressure or have they already gone out and got kind of the cream of the
- crop on guys who can perform under pressure or is it conversely the Europeans are so much more experienced
- bringing back the same guys and we had some newcomers that experience alone might have been a differentiator in
- terms of per Yeah, my very unsatisfying answer is that I think performance under pressure
- is absolutely a real thing, but it is also not necessarily predictive. And we see a lot of golfers who were once
- thought to not be able to play under pressure who then go on to win a major championship and then the entire
- narrative changes about them over two putting strokes. Right. Alexander Schoffley, that was kind of
- >> a pervasive narrative around him. We've seen it with other golfers, too. I mean,
- Cameron Young to a lesser extent. So, do I think there are certain golfers who cannot perform under pressure? Yes.
- Can they figure it out? Maybe. But like team Europe believes that rookies perform poorly on the road and that that
- that is significantly due to playing in a more high pressure, high intensity environment. So,
- >> interesting. I think there's there's absolutely something to that. And they took a bunch of veterans to play on the
- road. It'd be an interesting thing to look at. The data is kind of hard. It's small sample size and you want to look
- at strokes gain. You don't want to necessarily look at records. And that makes looking at RDER Cup, you know,
- historical data very difficult, but um I think it's really hard to nail down who's good under pressure and who isn't.
- And I wouldn't hold it against somebody too much if they haven't been good under
- pressure historically. But again, these these captains have insight we don't have. They're talking to these people.
- Sometimes guys are a little timid about some of this stuff. And I know some names of of golfers who people don't
- don't really believe that they believe in themselves. And I think there is something to it.
- >> Interesting. Okay. Great. All right. Great fun. Joseph, thanks for jumping on
- here with us for the first time. Thanks for slipping away from the tournament you're covering there in Dallas. Thank
- you for um making time for us on a relatively short notice to talk about a topic that is on everybody's mind right
- now in the sports world. Joseph, tell us where people can find your work before you go.
- Yeah, I appreciate you having me. I do really enjoy the show. You can read the Friday golf newsletter uh or all Friday
- golf channels. Like that's the main place to find us. So, I think that's the only thing that I have to plug and hook
- them. >> Hook them. All right. Big game back to SEC play this weekend. Let's let's get
- it going. Joseph, >> thanks for having us and thank you listeners for being with us through this
- overtime segment. Many thanks for the whole team here. Eric Bradlo especially for jumping in and running point in that
- first half. Audi Winer, Shane Jensen, the whole crew here for the whole time. Dion Simpkins making things happen. Deep
- Patel and Marissa Raina, the full team. Many thanks to you guys and thanks to you listeners. Come back and join us
- next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports. [Music]
Brief Summary
Jamie Smoliga discusses Faith Kipigon's mile record pursuit and the U.S. Ryder Cup team's performance, emphasizing analytics and pressure in sports.
Key points
- Faith Kipon's Record Attempt. Jamie Smoliga discusses Faith Kipon's journey towards breaking the 4-minute mile.
- The Impact of Technology on Running. Jamie explains how advancements in shoes have transformed distance running.
- The Future of Running Records. A conversation about the potential for Faith Kipon to break the 4-minute mile.
- Nike's Ambitious Goal. Nike aimed for a historic moment with a female runner attempting to break four minutes in a mile, but the outcome raised questions about their strategy.
- Seattle's Historic Win. Seattle wins the division for the first time since 2001, marking a significant achievement.
- ACC's Decline. The ACC is dropping in strength compared to other conferences, particularly the Big 12.
Episode highlights
- Faith Kipon's Record AttemptJamie Smoliga discusses Faith Kipon's journey towards breaking the 4-minute mile.“That's really fast.”3:45Oct 6, 2025
- The Impact of Technology on RunningJamie explains how advancements in shoes have transformed distance running.“The shoes have changed everything in distance running.”7:36Oct 6, 2025
- The Future of Running RecordsA conversation about the potential for Faith Kipon to break the 4-minute mile.“It's a matter of time.”15:31Oct 6, 2025
- Nike's Ambitious GoalNike aimed for a historic moment with a female runner attempting to break four minutes in a mile, but the outcome raised questions about their strategy.“Nike set themselves up to fail.”26:44Oct 6, 2025
- Seattle's Historic WinSeattle wins the division for the first time since 2001, marking a significant achievement.“Seattle has won the division for the first time since 2001!”36:40Oct 6, 2025
- ACC's DeclineThe ACC is dropping in strength compared to other conferences, particularly the Big 12.“The ACC is really kind of dropping.”40:27Oct 6, 2025
- Tampa Bay vs. Seattle ShowdownTampa Bay and Seattle have played the most among the four matchups, with 15 games.“It's kind of fun to see those guys going at it.”52:16Oct 6, 2025
- 0-3 Giants Upset 3-0 ChargersIn a surprising twist, the 0-3 Giants beat the undefeated Chargers.“Every year week four, some 0 and 3 team beats a 3-0 team.”53:55Oct 6, 2025





