Why Job Hopping Is Different Early in Your Career

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Professor Matthew Bidwell explains why job hopping carries different risks and rewards depending on your stage of career. The conversation explores why early jobs should be viewed as steppingstones, how graduates can navigate a difficult job market, when staying too long becomes a problem, and why adaptability may become even more important in an AI driven workforce.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, as graduation gets closer, it's time to transition to that first job post-education.
  2. And when you think about that, what do you expect to get from that job? How long should you expect
  3. to be there before maybe looking at that next potential position? The term job hopping is one
  4. that comes into play and can have different meanings for employees and employers. Matthew
  5. Bidwell is a professor of management here at the Wharton School, and he joins us to discuss the
  6. topic. Matthew, always great to talk with you. Thank you, sir. Good to see you, Dan.
  7. As always, great to see you as well. All right, so for those soon-to-be graduates, and I'm sure
  8. maybe you've had these questions at this time of the year before, what is the expectation that they
  9. should think about from a first job? You know, I think a first job, it's a starter job. I mean,
  10. I think if you think about what people are trying to get out of it, it's not the forever job, right?
  11. It's not the kind I expect to settle down and spend the rest of my life here. I think what you
  12. want to be getting out of it, you want to be building skills, so learning things that will
  13. help you get your next role. A really important thing is learning about yourself as well. I think
  14. it should be a job where you're starting to get a sense of what kind of work you like, what you
  15. should be pursuing next, and what kind of roles maybe aren't going to work for you. Hopefully,
  16. it's also a role where you're starting to build a reputation network. I think those early jobs
  17. really are stepping stones. You hear about the three-year window being brought into play
  18. in terms of how long maybe you should think about that first job or some people, other jobs as well.
  19. Is that a fair assessment, that first three years of really getting to understand yourself
  20. and your work and maybe the career line that you're going down? I'm not sure it's three
  21. years exactly. I would say probably that the early to mid-20s are a time for figuring out
  22. who you want to be and where you want to go. I would say that usually means moving around a little
  23. bit. It's weird. Actually, generally, I don't advocate job hopping. Generally, my message
  24. to people is employers care about stickability. They don't want people who are always jumping
  25. around. I think it's important to really emphasize that doesn't apply so much to people at the
  26. beginning of their career. At the beginning of your career, people expect you to move around
  27. so much. Somebody in their mid-20s, when they look at resume and say they've already held
  28. three jobs, they're not going to have a heart attack. If on the other hand, you're in your late
  29. 30s and you continue to move like that, they're going to look at it very differently. I think that
  30. beginning of the career, moving around is pretty normal. I think you should be much
  31. less concerned about doing so. There is, to a degree, an expectation from the employer
  32. that this is part of the mix when you're talking about maybe a first job or a second job,
  33. but that job hopper term probably does have a negative connotation to it later on in one's career.
  34. When you hire somebody, it takes a while to get them up to speed. For an employer,
  35. you're hiring somebody hoping they'll stay. To be honest, even for that first job,
  36. employers are hoping you will stay sometimes for quite a while. We're not hiring people that we
  37. expect to leave instantly. If you've done that multiple times, employers will start to get
  38. nervous. Again, early in the career, they understand people are still trying to figure
  39. this out a little bit. I think it's less of an issue at that point. With the economy that we
  40. have right now, does that impact the want to move and this concept of job hopping?
  41. Yeah, I think it does in two different ways. I think the big thing about the economy we have
  42. right now, everyone's going on about this low hire, low fire economy. It is harder to get a job
  43. than it was a couple of years ago, than it has been for most of the last 10 years.
  44. Sadly, that particularly affects, obviously, new entrants to the job market who are looking for
  45. jobs for the first time. What that means is probably a lot of people are going to end up
  46. in a job that's not as good as the one that they might have been able to find in a more vibrant
  47. job market. We do know, for example, people who graduate in recessions, they tend, sadly,
  48. to have persistently lower earnings for a while because you start off in a job that's not so good,
  49. maybe a less well-paid occupation than you otherwise would have got. It's hard then to
  50. move up. It does mean if you're finding a struggle to get a job, if you do end up with one that's
  51. maybe not what you would have hoped to get, you do then need to be keeping on searching in the
  52. hope that you'll then move up. I think it means that it's less likely that first job is going to
  53. be the one you really want. Obviously, it also means it's harder to move up, and so more of a
  54. push to look for the next thing, but more of a challenge as well. We've talked about this from
  55. the perspective of job hopping, but there is also, I would assume, a component of those people who
  56. maybe stay in a position too long and don't look to make that move faster. What do you say to those
  57. people? I mean, it's not always a problem, I think. I don't think you want to move for the
  58. sake of it. One of the things, again, we see in research is there's not generally a strong
  59. relationship between how much you move and how much you end up getting paid. If you start off
  60. a poorly paid job, then you need to move to end up in something that's more rewarding,
  61. but if you start off at a reasonably well-paid job, you don't necessarily need to move. I think
  62. if you feel your career is stagnating, you're not getting the growth that you want, you're not
  63. moving up inside the organization, those sorts of things, that probably is a sign that you want
  64. to move sooner rather than later. I don't think that people need to feel, oh my God, I haven't
  65. moved, I ought to move, if you're somewhere where you like the work and you're doing well.
  66. Does AI factor into this as we move forward as well? Today, probably not. Coming up, who knows? I'm sure it increases the value of adaptability
  67. in all sorts of ways. I think employers are looking for their employees to really make
  68. use of these tools to be on the leading edge. Among the almost infinite range of unknowns
  69. around AI is how destructive it's going to be of current companies. Are we going to see a lot
  70. of companies go out of business as they are overtaken by AI new entrants? Don't know. It's
  71. plausible. In that case, if we see a lot of this creative destruction, it really plays a big
  72. premium on adaptability. The more that you're at risk that your current job goes away, the more
  73. you want to be constantly thinking, am I building the skills that will help me get that next job?
  74. What are the things, I'll finish up on this, that you say to your students about this time
  75. in their lives, going from college into the workforce, and obviously knowing that every
  76. student is going to be different, but there are probably some tenants that are probably similar
  77. just kind of across the board. I think about the career in phases, right? I mean, I think
  78. there is kind of the middle of your career, actually you're going to do better by finding
  79. the right place and kind of settling there, staying there, building a career there. That's
  80. what you're often aiming for. The people who do well are the people who really find that right fit
  81. with an organization, build their career there. The early stage of your career are about trying
  82. to find that. And so I think in that early phase, you're establishing yourself, you're learning about
  83. who you are, what kind of organization you want to work for, and you're starting to build the skills
  84. and the reputation that will make you attractive. And so it's an important phase in your career,
  85. but it's probably more than any other time, a phase where you don't want to be too afraid of
  86. making mistakes. It's a good time to take risks, learn about yourself before you start kind of
  87. that long climb afterwards. Matthew, always great to talk to you and get your insight. Thanks very much.
  88. Great to see you. Thank you. Matthew Bidwell, Professor of Management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Matthew Bidwell discusses job expectations and job hopping for recent graduates amid economic challenges.

Key points

  • Navigating Job Expectations. Matthew Bidwell discusses what graduates should expect from their first job.
  • The Importance of Early Career Moves. Understanding job hopping and its implications for new graduates.
  • Adapting to Economic Changes. How the current economy affects job prospects for new graduates.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes