Do Markets Overprice Disaster Risk?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In normal years, investing in equities can reap extremely healthy returns. But not all of that ROI is based on what you'd think. Some of it is rooted in the fear that everything could go terribly, unexpectedly wrong, Wharton's Jessica Wachter says. More: http://knlg.net/1C8ASrE 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. So my research links economywide disasters to asset prices like stock prices for example. Um this is research
  2. that I along with others have been pursuing recently say it's it's really um taken off over the last five years
  3. and it's certainly gotten a boost from the financial crisis. uh and in this research um part of it
  4. draws on historical data on consumption disasters from the United States and from elsewhere in the world. An example
  5. of a consumption disaster is the Great Depression where consumption fell by 20%. Um but that's actually a relatively
  6. minor disaster. If you look at Europe, um after the Second World War, many countries had economies that contracted
  7. by as much as 50%. Um if stock prices fall in the event of a disaster then that is an important risk that investors
  8. take into account and that can explain why in normal times we have such high returns on stock prices which has long
  9. been a puzzle. It can also explain why stock prices are so volatile because this risk is hard to calculate and very
  10. hard to measure and as investors perceptions of it move around that can move around stock prices.
  11. So the first takeaway is that the world is risky that there are there are these risks for consumption disasters and they
  12. are that's reflected in stock prices and that's why we see such a high realized return during normal times when we don't
  13. have disasters. Also one of the reasons that stock returns are so volatile is because
  14. of these fears of a disaster. Now, you might think of these fears as overreaction because often the disaster
  15. doesn't happen. However, is it overreaction or do people really have a reason to be afraid? Certainly, in 2008,
  16. it seemed like we had a reason to be afraid. Well, stock market volatility has been a puzzle for a long time. So
  17. what surprised me is that when we put the um information this international data from disasters into a model that
  18. this really could explain the magnitudes of stock market volatility that we see.
  19. Part of it is investors risk aversion. So when you have numbers like even a small probability of a 50% decline or
  20. even a 20% decline that really influences investors behavior. Unfortunately, I think some people have
  21. a wishful thinking view of the stock market that if you just hold on long enough that you're guaranteed to get
  22. some of the high rates of return that we've measured over the post-war period, these rates of return being 12% that
  23. this is just something you're going to get if you keep holding stocks. Well, that may not be true. Now this is not a
  24. measure that investors shouldn't hold stocks. I I hold stocks and I think for investors who have positive net worth
  25. stocks are an important part of the portfolio. But in evaluating the risk they could go down and they might not
  26. come back up. So one of them is for investors that investors should be aware that stocks
  27. are risky um that and that the return is not guaranteed. What this means um is not that you shouldn't hold stocks. It's
  28. just that given that stocks might go down, holding stocks in say an environment where you also have leverage
  29. is is putting yourself under a certain amount of risk. Leverage could include um a mortgage. leverage might include a
  30. job employ or employment of some kind where your income is very much um subject to the stock market. Those might
  31. be reasons to limit the stock market part the stock part of your portfolio beyond what say just these wonderful
  32. expected returns would indicate. That's number one. Number two, these concerns about rare disasters
  33. have been part of what's been pricing stocks for a long time. And to me, that suggests caution on the part of
  34. regulators um because I think it's just going to be very hard to eliminate this risk. Part of what might be driving
  35. events like 2008 are fears about future growth prospects and those that those kind of
  36. fears are very hard to eliminate. So if you can't eliminate those fears, you can
  37. make the economy less risky by say um having less leverage on the part of financial
  38. institutions. People have been researching the stock market for a long time. What sets this
  39. line of research apart is the focus on these tail events. And um we don't assume for example that risk is normally
  40. distributed. Now that's a technical term. Um what the normal distribution apply implies is something called the
  41. bell curve. And the bell curve has thin tails for outcomes. So it basically means that risky things are unlikely to
  42. happen and it means that risk is very easily measured. So you can if you think that risk follows this bell curve, you
  43. can almost fool yourself into thinking that you've you understand everything about risk when in fact there are these
  44. rare events that are out there, not that far out there. They're still we see them
  45. in the Great Depression. Um but they can have an important part effect on stock prices if you introduce
  46. them into investors beliefs. I'm looking into links with the macroeconomy. Um so employment and
  47. unemployment is my um biggest focus right now. So, we're writing down a model that can explain why um
  48. unemployment and job vacancies are so volatile even though consumption itself is very
  49. smooth and why these things might track the stock market because recently they have tracked the stock market and a big
  50. part of it is like investing in the stock market. Investing in hiring is something where you need confidence that
  51. the economy is going to be stable going forward. If you lack that confidence, you don't want to put forth this
  52. investment. [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode covers how economywide disasters affect stock prices and investor behavior, emphasizing risks and volatility in the market.

Key points

  • Understanding Stock Market Volatility. Research links economic disasters to stock prices, explaining their volatility and high returns.
  • The Risk of Stock Investments. Investors must recognize that stock returns are not guaranteed and can be volatile.

Related episodes