Is the Rush to Safety Making Corporate Bonds Unsafe?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Skittish investors seeking safety have poured a lot of money into corporate bond mutual funds in recent years. Which raises the question: What happens when that flow reverses? 📂 Finance & Accounting;Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so in this paper investor flows and fragility in corporate Bor funds uh which I wrote with David Ang and ha
  2. young uh we study flows and performance of mutual funds that invest in corporate
  3. bonds let me give you just a brief summary uh assets of mutual funds that invest in corporate bonds have grown
  4. substantially in recent years following the crisis many investors felt that they
  5. did not have many attractive uh investment vehicles and a lot of money has basically flown into uh mutual funds
  6. that invest in corporate bonds now this poses I think a very interesting challenge for researchers for many years
  7. there has been a lot of research studying uh mutual funds that invest in equity uh but there hasn't been that
  8. much research uh looking into bonds uh into mutual funds that invest in uh in bonds and in particular in corporate
  9. bonds now there's a growing concern of fragility uh the possibility that a lot of this money is going to be withdrawn
  10. at the same time from many mutual funds as a result causing effects on uh corporate bonds of the prices of
  11. corporate bonds and uh potentially destabilizing uh the market for corporate bonds and having also some
  12. real effects for the economy as a whole as a result there is an uh I think growing importance to understand the
  13. patterns of flows and performance of mutual funds that invest in corporate bonds and this is what we do in this uh
  14. study previous research on Equity mutual funds basically showed that uh outflows
  15. are not very sensitive to bad performance what we show in the context of corporate bond mutual funds is that
  16. outflows are much more sensitive to bad performance in fact outflows are more sensitive to bad performance than
  17. inflows are to good performance which is the complete opposite of what people tend to find in the context of equity
  18. mutual funds in the context of fragility this raises the concern that in case of
  19. uh bad performance or overall bad times uh there will be massive outflows out of
  20. the corporate bond mutual funds now clearly given that this is an industry that holds about 1.7 uh trillion dollars
  21. in in in assets uh this is uh a reason for concern or a reason uh to sort of watch out and see uh what's going to
  22. happen in case of uh bad developments I think going into this research we didn't really know what to
  23. expect as I mentioned there was a lot of research on Equity mutual funds basically showing that inflows are much
  24. more sensitive to good performance than outflows are to bad performance we did not know what to expect going into the
  25. research on corporate bond mutual funds and we found the opposite that outflows are much more sensitive to bad
  26. performance than inflows are to good performance I'm not sure if I would call it a surprise but it it was uh a very
  27. interesting finding I think we think that the sensitivity of outflow to bad performance in corporate
  28. bond mutual funds is coming due to the fact that they hold illiquid assets but at the same time they allow people and
  29. institutions to take money out on a daily BAS cases based on the last updated price uh what we show in the
  30. research is that this sensitivity depends greatly indeed on the illiquidity of the asset so for example
  31. funds that hold more cash are less subject to this great sensitivity of outflows to bad performance and this is
  32. because if you have uh more cash uh then investors know that they depend Less on
  33. uh the withdrawals by others and as a result they're less Keen to take their money out once there are bad
  34. developments um in the same vein we basically show that the sensitivity goes up uh when IL liquidity is greater at
  35. the macro level and this can be measured by the vix for example which is a measure of overall volatility and other
  36. measures of aggregate illiquidity uh so basically what we show is that funds uh that invest in more
  37. illiquid assets or during more illiquid times are going to be more subject to Greater sensitivity of out flows to bad
  38. performance uh this is something that we can think of as more fragility so you can basically address this fragility by
  39. holding more liquidity or changing the way that investors take money out uh whatever the Redemption formula is
  40. whatever they get out of the fund in case they take their money out so I think that there is an overall
  41. perception uh that mutual funds are not subject to any kind of fragility uh basically people view
  42. mutual funds as being very different from Banks investors put the money in the fund and get whatever is the value
  43. of the assets when they take their money out I think our paper shed some more light on it basically showing that there
  44. is some potential for fragility there is some of this first mover advantage that
  45. we tend to see in the context of Banks and this is because when people take their money out of the fund they impose
  46. some negative externalities on those who stay in the fund this is Amplified by illiquidity and as a result you tend to
  47. see this first mover Advantage uh amplifying uh the uh incentive of people to take their money out in case of bad
  48. performance so this is basically the first paper that looks at the sensitivity of outflow to Performance in
  49. corporate bond funds as I said corporate bond funds have become a very uh important uh investment vehicle in the
  50. economy in recent years it's important to understand what causes withdrawals out of these mutual funds and as far as
  51. I know we are the first paper to to look at that and analyze it um we basically document that there is some sense of
  52. fragility in the sense that uh people when they think that others are going to take their money out of mutual funds
  53. that invest in corporate uh bonds they have greater incentive to do that uh as well in in this particular paper we
  54. basically look at fragility at the level of the fund uh we show that there is a first mover Advantage at the level of
  55. the fund in the sense that if investors think that other investors are going to take their money out of the mutual fund
  56. they have a greater incentive to do so as well uh this is kind of similar to the phenomenon that is well known as a
  57. bank run uh people take money out of a bank just because they expect other people will do that we think something
  58. kind of similar maybe weaker happens uh in the context of uh mutual funds uh in particular those that invest in
  59. corporate bonds because uh corporate bonds tend to be very liquid so this force is going to be stronger I think
  60. going uh further uh one wants to look more at systemic implications the extent to which uh this uh puts the economy as
  61. a whole or the Market as a whole in a tough position in a risky uh position and this will be particularly important
  62. for policy implications so far as I mentioned we only look at it at the level of the fund and we think there is
  63. this Force the first mover Advantage at the level of the fund itself uh but policy intervention will only be
  64. required in case uh this also uh poses externalities on the rest of the economy uh externalities that uh fund managers
  65. themselves are not going to internalize and are not going to address [Music]

Brief Summary

Research shows corporate bond fund outflows are sensitive to poor performance, raising concerns about market fragility.

Key points

  • Fragility in Corporate Bond Funds. Research shows that outflows from corporate bond mutual funds are highly sensitive to bad performance.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes