How Gamification 'Taps into What Makes Us Human'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A new ebook co-authored by Wharton professor Kevin Werbach offers ideas for using game elements to engage customers, employees and others. More: http://knlg.net/1IL6H0Z πŸ“‚ Innovation;Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the gamification toolkit is a follow-up to the book for the win that I also wrote with Dan Hunter and for the win
  2. introduced the concept of gamification using Game Design Elements and techniques to motivate people in
  3. business and we heard from lots of people in companies that they were intrigued by this idea they got the idea
  4. about how they could use game design principles but they wanted uh to dive deeper they wanted to understand in
  5. Practical terms what are these game elements these pieces of games or design patterns that we talked about how do you
  6. apply them and what are some more specific examples of uh companies that have taken these tools and used them
  7. successfully for motivation so that's fundamentally what the gamification toolkit tries to
  8. do one of the key takeaways uh in this book and in all the work that I've done on gamification
  9. is that it's not as easy as it looks these are powerful techniques we're seeing lots of examples in e-learning in
  10. marketing in management in Innovation all these contexts of companies using Game design principles and game elements
  11. but you can't just uh take some and sprinkle them on to a process you need to think in a systematic way about what
  12. are the tools that you have available and then how can you apply them in the right way to achieve your goals so one
  13. of the key key uh aspects of this book The gameification toolkit is to lay out a pallet to show people just some of the
  14. range of different items and design patterns that you can take from games and get some inspiration of different
  15. ways that you can go and apply them to serve whatever your business need is one of the examples we talk about in
  16. the book is Du lingo which is a language learning site and du lingo very quickly has become the
  17. most successful language learning site on the internet in fact they have something like 60 million users so they
  18. are teaching languages to more people than the entire United States public school system and you go and look at
  19. what they're doing compared to other sites there's plenty of other things out there that will teach you languages the
  20. key differentiator is gamification they have a virtual currency they have achievements in the game they have
  21. missions they have little rewards and so forth uh all sorts of systems that are implemented in an integrated way to
  22. reinforce your engagement to reinforce your sense of excitement about the learning experience and uh frankly I
  23. think that the gamification even though you wouldn't call it a gamified service per se it's a
  24. language learning service the gamification is really the differentiator that's helped them
  25. succeed gamification can help to trans form a business but fundamentally gamification involves understanding
  26. psychology understanding design principles and understanding how we can leverage data so it's not that
  27. gamification is some new thing that's going to cause us to do business in a totally different way the reality is
  28. gamification Taps into what makes us human we're engaged by games we respond to some of these game elements not
  29. because it's some cool new idea that someone came up with but because it relates to our basic human drives our
  30. motivation for Mastery our desire to be connected to something broader than ourselves our response to a desire for
  31. achievement and so forth so fundamentally gamification is a tool like lots of business tools where if you
  32. have a goal and you can Define really well what that goal is and you can understand what the population of people
  33. are that you're working with whether that's your customers your employees or some other group and then think
  34. creatively about how to tie in ways to achieve that goal going beyond the very traditional mechanisms that we have it's
  35. not just saying we want to motivate you to do this job by paying you more it's thinking very broadly being informed by
  36. psychology and being informed by data about how we can excite and engage people in very powerful ways so that's
  37. really how it can ultimately be transformative but I always caution people because there's a tendency to
  38. think oh this is some great new technique that will take something that people hate to do and make them love it
  39. no if you hate to do something you still hate to do it but even in activities that some people and in some cases um
  40. they seem boring or uninteresting you can find uh ways to make them seem engaging and ways to actually make them
  41. engaging if you tie them into something that motivates people the biggest pitfall using
  42. gamification is thinking that all you have to do is drop in some game elements so we'll give people points for
  43. something and they'll get really excited just because the points are there and what we've seen time and time again is
  44. the services that just do that maybe they'll get some initial engagement people will sort of get excited or at
  45. least some people will get excited but then it dissipates very quickly and that's not necessarily the end of the
  46. world if what you're trying to do is just stimulate some initial adoption and then you have some great value
  47. proposition down the road but most of the time what companies want is ongoing engagement so what you need to do first
  48. of all is step back and take a broader look at what the tools are and that's really what the gamification toolkit
  49. adds is it gives you a perspective on 30 different game Elements which even aren't all the ones that are out there
  50. but gives you a sense of possibility so you're not just going and using the same
  51. elements over and over again and then what you need to do is have a process uh and in our first book for the win we go
  52. through a six-step process to identify the goals identify the processes identify uh the people involved and so
  53. forth um and ensure that when you're deploying gamification you're doing it in a thoughtful way in a way that uh uh
  54. generates data that you can use to improve the system and in a way that you can have some confidence will give you
  55. some sustained engagement I think of gamification as a fairly horizontal technique it can work
  56. any place you have people and there's a desire to motivate or engage them that's
  57. just about anything you can think of um and so there are examples that we're seeing of gamification everywhere from
  58. uh entertainment type sites to uh supply chain and Logistics in very established
  59. industrial companies um in uh virtually all parts of the world there's adoption of gamification so I think it's a
  60. misnomer to think that there's one perfect place for it again the question is identifying the goal and then using
  61. the right tools for that objective in the context of your organization there's not going to be one right way to do
  62. gamification every case some gamification examples for example look very game likee they've got bright
  63. colors they seem kind of fun they're things that show up on screen and pop and so forth some gamification is very
  64. understated um it's very oper irational um because that's right for that context
  65. so I think pretty much anytime you have something where motivation makes a difference There's an opportunity to
  66. look at gamification as a technique and then again the question is figuring out is it right for this particular problem
  67. what are the right ways to do it and how do I systematically think about ensuring
  68. that this is the best technique for the problem I have at hand we're in an interesting phase right now
  69. with gamification about three or four years ago there was a lot of excitement so you had all these consultant showing
  70. up and saying this is this great new thing it's amazing it'll change all of business um and uh not a lot of actual
  71. adoption at that point there were just a handful of examples that everyone would
  72. point to and so uh Dan Hunter and I wrote our first book for the win partly to give people a broader perspective to
  73. organize this space and say all right what is really going on here and what are serious ways to apply gamification
  74. what we're seeing now is most of those um uh Consultants who are hyping this have gone away uh because again lots of
  75. companies have found that if you just throw some game elements on somewhere it's not going to have sustained
  76. engagement so we're seeing now article after article saying gamification is dead oh that was an old fat oh it's
  77. failed that's not at all what I'm seeing when I go out and talk to companies and
  78. I go out and look at the market actually there has never been more adoption and never been broader adoption um I'm
  79. seeing examples in gamification again in companies in every industry and all over
  80. the world what we need now is more data we need uh more research from people like me and other academics to help
  81. identify best practices so when you get the organizations that say okay I get it
  82. I'm sold on the concept but I want to see the evidence I want to see numbers that say this is the right solution for
  83. my situation this is not we've got bits and pieces of that uh but we need to do more um and so a lot of what I'm focused
  84. on now is partly uh trying to do that research but partly trying to pull it together um because the challenge of
  85. gamification is it's at the border of a lot of different fields so you have people looking at gamification from the
  86. standpoint of marketing you have gamification researchers in human computer interaction uh you have
  87. gamification researchers in management um in all these different business fields and so uh part of the role that
  88. um I see myself playing is trying to bring those people together and bring that research together and help to
  89. translate it for organizations who are just trying to make sense of all this [Music]

Brief Summary

Gamification Toolkit offers practical strategies for motivating people in business through game design principles, with Duolingo as a key example.

Key points

  • The Gamification Toolkit. A follow-up to 'For the Win', this book explores practical applications of gamification in business.
  • Duolingo's Success. Duolingo has become the most successful language learning site, leveraging gamification to engage users.
  • The Pitfalls of Gamification. Many companies mistakenly believe that adding game elements guarantees engagement, but it's more complex.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes