'For the Win': How Gamification Can Transform Your Business

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Can work be fun? Can things game designers have learned about what makes games effective be used to engage customers in a variety of industries? Wharton legal studies and business ethics professor Kevin Werbach and New York Law School professor Dan Hunter, authors of For the Win: How Game Thinking Can Revolutionize Your Business, say yes. Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Werbach and Hunter about what gamification really is, how companies are using it and pitfalls to avoid when gamifying. 📂 Innovation

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] love to talk to you about your book which is titled for the win uh where
  2. does the title come from for the win is a a gamer term uh that that PE it usually abbreviated FTW it's it's
  3. something in games people will say some great thing for the win it was originally something you had to do to
  4. get over the top to win an epic kind of battle and it's become just sort of a commonplace expression just anything you
  5. want to do that gives you a real achievement um and so we thought it it echoed um some of these expressions in
  6. gains but also was very indicative of what we're talking about this concept of gamification or game thinking as
  7. something that can actually for businesses provide uh epic wins as well well it's very interesting because
  8. though the book is about gfic uh the starting point to your book is actually the fact that so many
  9. employees and customers are so utterly disengaged today uh now um and and and business just isn't as much fun as it
  10. could be uh what do you think are some of the reasons for that I'll take that one I mean we've
  11. sort of assumed that the way that we motivate people is through Rewards or punishments right and we do that within
  12. businesses we do that sort of within uh the consumer side um there are lots of ways of motivating people and we need to
  13. find new ways of motivating people really at the core of it this book is about finding ways to do that by relying
  14. upon some pretty well tested approaches to to game design and and what makes things fun so what we're really trying
  15. to do is is to put fun back into all of these kinds of areas we've gotten really
  16. good in business at squeezing out operational efficiencies and we have all this technology we're in a globalized
  17. world the the Baseline has been raised to the point where just doing those things just being efficient isn't a
  18. differentiator and you think what's the differentiator it's human beings it's engagement enthusiasm and games we found
  19. are the key to understanding some of the techniques as Dan said to motivating people in in powerful and
  20. differentiating ways so before we go too far what exactly is a game and what is gamification wow you want to handle
  21. that so both of those uh I'll take a start then maybe you can say like those are deeper Concepts than you might think
  22. in fact there are large dense works of philosophy that have been written on what is a game um basically a game is
  23. something that has some rules some objective uh and uh involves an attitude by players that players care about the
  24. outcome of the game so it includes everything you might think of as a game including board games card games Sports
  25. video games uh but also other kinds of experiences that feel game likee where there's a set of constraints and you
  26. care about somehow overcoming those constraints so work can be a game school can be a game lots of things can be game
  27. likee and gamification is taking what we understand about games turns out games have been around for tens of thousands
  28. of years video games uh now are a 40y old industry that generates roughly $70 billion doar a year worldwide and game
  29. designers have gotten really good at understanding what makes those games work um learning from those things
  30. taking those insights from what makes games effective what makes people care about the outcomes and then translating
  31. them into business context so how can applying the lessons from a a game approach or uh introducing game elements
  32. how can that revolutionize a business which is the point that you make early on in your book yeah well I mean
  33. starting off from Kevin's point we can't squeeze out any more operational efficiency gains from this so so
  34. basically it's looking at the business in a completely different way and saying okay so so what are the objectives that
  35. we have in relation to this business and in relation to these business processes
  36. right and then how can we take these these time honored and and now very well understood approaches to game design
  37. right and and apply that to these particular Arenas so you know pick any given kind of business objective you
  38. want to increase engagement you know of of your customers in relation to say your website or something like that okay
  39. so you actually then rather than saying okay we're going to you know pay for them to come or we're going to you know
  40. have prizes or those sorts of things we're actually we're going to approach this as a as a design problem and say
  41. all right what's going to motivate them you know what sort of playful features do people like right understanding your
  42. users you know and saying okay this particular sort of person would like this this particular sort of person
  43. would like that and introducing those game elements into the the overall design of of the process right now one
  44. of the things I really loved about your book is that you one of the things you say is uh that at its core gamification
  45. is about finding the fun in the things that you have to do uh could you uh give some examples of how companies like
  46. Microsoft and deoe have been using this approach sure so those are two examples we give in the book um the Microsoft one
  47. uh is a project that came out of the test group they the people who do the the testing of things like Windows and
  48. Microsoft Office and one of the problems we talked about was that when they were
  49. releasing Windows 7 Microsoft releases it in in dozens of dozens of different countries and languages and they have to
  50. make sure the dialogue boxes work well in every one of those languages and even Microsoft uh would have a challenge
  51. hiring companies that have native speakers in all of those languages to go and sit and look at those dialogue boxes
  52. but it's really important you don't want something to be offensive or incorrect that would that would hurt the
  53. usuability of the applications um so what they realized was that they could make a game likee experience they
  54. created a competition for teams of their employees their sales offices in these different countries to go and find
  55. errors in the localized dialogue boxes and there's no reward uh there was just the the thrill of uh finding the most
  56. problems being good corporate citizens and being the most successful office on the leaderboard they set up just doing
  57. that they got uh their employees to review half a million dialogue boxes and found hundreds and hundreds of bugs
  58. errors in the localization that hadn't been caught in the original translation so that's an example of taking something
  59. that's very mundane very boring no no one would say that reading dialogue boxes is inherently fun or great it's
  60. but it's something that they had to do for a real legitimate business purpose um and that was what we call an internal
  61. gamification example using it inside the Enterprise as opposed to outside for customers the deoe one you mentioned was
  62. about uh Knowledge Management about getting their Consultants to describe what they're working on and what they
  63. know about which is incredibly important task for lots of organizations especially Professional Services
  64. organizations by creating a little bit of competition and a little bit of fun through an internal application they got
  65. much greater participation in that information sharing and in the book we go through examples in all sorts of
  66. areas gamification is not just something for teeny little startups or for youth oriented sexy kinds of companies it's
  67. something that AC applies across the board you distinguish in the book between internal and external
  68. gamification how how is external gamification different well I mean it's it still uses the same principles but
  69. basically you're you're focused on on issues outside of the company so you know the internal one of things like HR
  70. or the examples that that Kevin gave in relation to Microsoft and deoe external you know typically the marketing kinds
  71. of Arenas so so we're thinking about things like Salesforce at the really high end um and at the at the lower end
  72. you other sorts of examples like um Club site uh which was a which was a website
  73. that was gamified for for USA networks um and and those ones are really about trying to improve the the user and
  74. customer experience um trying to to drive revenue and those sorts of things outside of the Enterprise so it's really
  75. just a useful distinction between the the different sort of elements or the different sort of approaches that you
  76. face inside the Enterprise and outside the Enterprise what does it mean to think like a game designer MH and how do
  77. can companies uh use that kind of thinking to do some of the things that you're describing yeah so this ties into
  78. a point that Dan made earlier which is really critical we look at gamification as a design challenge um so it's part of
  79. design more broadly and there there have been other authors and Scholars and practitioners who've written about
  80. design thinking and and this in some way is a special case of that broad approach
  81. but it's a special case that's important uh game design is its own discipline uh
  82. major video games cost tens of millions of dollars and bring in in some cases billions of dollars of Revenue so it's a
  83. a fairly sophisticated and well-developed discipline thinking like a game designer means attacking problems
  84. through the lens of creating an experience for players and the primary challenges of a game designer are one
  85. get people playing and two keep them playing and if you start to think about your business challenges that way you
  86. think about your participants as players they are voluntarily participating in something because they want to because
  87. they get value and enjoyment and fulfillment out of it and find ways to get them in and then once they're in
  88. find ways to keep them interested to create a player Journey if you will that remains valuable as they get to higher
  89. levels of the experience you start to create a kind of environment that is inherently engaging and in the book we
  90. go through lots of specific Frameworks and Concepts that there's a lot more detail than that but that's the basic
  91. approach to to think about what you're doing as creating an experience for a group of players that they find valuable
  92. I mean if I can just jump in there the the reason that we we sat down to write this book um was that we looked at at
  93. the other sorts of approaches that were out there and and basically everyone was
  94. saying oh look gamification it's this huge interesting fascinating incredibly important thing that you should do and
  95. the way you do it is just just slap badges on this or put points on anything right and and those those those
  96. approaches fail right I mean and and we'd seen them fail and we were sort of looking at it and saying well why do
  97. they fail um and and we sort of sat back and said okay so if you approach this in
  98. the way of a game designer and try to understand you know what it is that the players want and actually go through
  99. this entire process that we outline in the book then you can actually build an experience that's engaging um and that
  100. people will keep coming back to because it's fun and at the same time Drive revenue or do all of the sorts of things
  101. that you need for your business process um we we found that there was really just nothing out there that was a sort
  102. of a guideline along those along that those sort of lines so so that was really the motivation for the book to
  103. sort of think as as a game designer without being a game designer you know we absolutely don't want people to be a
  104. game designer at the end of this we're simply saying look if you approach it this way you'll actually generate these
  105. these really useful compelling experiences for your users so let's say there's an executive who's facing a
  106. business problem how does she or he know whether gamification is the right solution for
  107. that problem buy the book first right and yeah and it's very engaging and well written and um uh but but no I
  108. mean what they they need to do is sort of try to work out what is the actual process that they're they're looking to
  109. gamify what's the objective out of all of this you know what do they need to do right and then they go through the steps
  110. in the book and they'll actually have within a very short space of time a kind of an idea about um what it is that
  111. gamification can give them at the end of this of this experience I mean not every
  112. not every business objective you know can be can be gamified there there are lots of ones that are just not going to
  113. work because your your you know customers or your players are not going to be engaged they're not going to be
  114. interested in it um or that there's a mismatch right you know that the the nature of the activity um is so serious
  115. that that you know introducing game elements is going to make the the the player or the user think hang on what's
  116. this doesn't make any sense um so you have have to think carefully about that and and that's really what the book's
  117. about yeah there's a matrix in the book which is a little too detailed to get into here but the starting point is
  118. motivation so if you're a business manager you say let's say I could wave a magic W and get this population whether
  119. they're my customers potential customers employees this group to be more motivated would that really drive a
  120. business benefit in some Metric I care about in my business and there's sometimes where it wouldn't either
  121. because it's something that shouldn't be made fun or it's something where motivation would get people to be more
  122. excited but wouldn't drive purchases or efficiency or anything you care about um
  123. that's the starting point is this something where if I can successfully build something that motivates uh it
  124. would be a real and Lasting benefit to my business and then once you answer that question then you you think about
  125. how to design using some of the steps that Dan talked about to ensure that the system You're Building would in fact
  126. produce those motivational benefits yeah the section on motivation is one of the
  127. ones that I found really fascinating in your book and and uh you know one of the
  128. things that you distinguish there is what you call intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation could you explain
  129. for our audience how the two are different and how they can uh you know motivate people differently uh to alter
  130. their behavior I could go first although I mean Dan Dan did some of his PhD work
  131. in um psychology and and artificial intelligence so part of uh the reason that we we felt that we were well
  132. situated to put this book together was that we had an understanding of the different p pieces the game design is
  133. one piece the psychology is another piece the business aspects are another piece um intrinsic and extrinsic
  134. motivations are wellestablished terms in the literature on the psychology of motivation primarily from a set of
  135. theories called selfdetermination Theory which was developed by uh Ed Desi and Richard Ryan at the University of
  136. Rochester it's a very well-established uh theory about what motivates people backed by dozens and dozens of empirical
  137. studies and the basic idea is is you can be motivated by something external to you something outside of yourself it's
  138. not something that you inherently want to do but you do it because you get paid you do it because you care about what
  139. other people think you want you want status from other people you do it because you need to finish this unit in
  140. order to get to something else you care about to get a promotion your job whatever else extrinsic motivation
  141. intrinsic motivation is if none of that were there you would still do it you want to do it for its own sake and the
  142. lesson from self-determination Theory there there many lessons but one of the key ones is that extrinsic motivation
  143. works but it's dangerous that if you take topics and and areas that are inherently interesting to people and
  144. substitute external rewards they can actually um crowd out as it's called the intrinsic motivation and um that's a
  145. danger in any context it's a real danger in gamification because as Dan said people tend to think about gamification
  146. as just these shiny Rewards well just give people these points and badges and so forth and that can work that's why
  147. frequent flyer programs work it's why compensation systems work in business and so forth and that's part of
  148. gamification um but you need to understand the limits of it and not create a system where those things make
  149. it so that people feel sort of subconsciously this isn't something fun this isn't something I'd want to do I'll
  150. just do it as long as you give me stuff and pay me um what you want is a system that gets to the point where people feel
  151. like in a great game this is fun I want to do this I feel validated in this experience and and it's something that
  152. that potentially gives me that that sense of a win and there's also I mean if you think about intrinsic motivation
  153. about uh within business you know and and all of the sort of recent management theories which take your pick right
  154. about how to get people to do things how to make a better workplace how to ensure
  155. you know that for for better profits better Roi whatever it happens to be these the sort of the recent Trends have
  156. been towards intrinsic motivation right rather than sort of assuming that the way that we're going to do this is is to
  157. you know try to squeeze more out of out of the individuals it's really about sort trying to understand them what
  158. they're doing say within you know within an HR context as one example um and so so the sort of the chapter on on
  159. intrinsic and extrinsic motivation is really trying to get um the the manager to think about what it is that that that
  160. people want right and then how can we build systems in this case G you know game likee systems that actually will be
  161. be compelling and interesting and and be the sort of environment where people will look up and say wow I just wasted
  162. an hour um you know and and I was working you know and that's and that's really where where we we were trying to
  163. get to at the end of the end of the book you also offer uh companies a toolkit that they can use if they are interested
  164. in uh gamification could you tell us about some of those tools that companies can use um so the so the toolkit I mean
  165. are you talking about each of the different game elements that that that you can sort of um build into these
  166. systems well what we you know we put that actually sort of in the middle of the book rather than at the beginning of
  167. the book um because what we wanted to do was to to make it clear that the toolkit
  168. doesn't make any sense unless you understand the overall process right so so by about halfway through you're at
  169. the stage you know and it's not you know halfway through is what 40 50 pages into
  170. the book um is you've got the sort of the point at which you can say okay here are the sorts of elements that we might
  171. be able to use in this particular environment and and those elements are are pretty pretty obvious if you think
  172. of it in game term I mean think of any game or sport that you've played I mean there's elements like like teamwork and
  173. cooperation there are elements like maybe scoring there are elements like you know success states there are sort
  174. of like these big challenges that you know might be this final push you know a sort of like a full-court press in in
  175. basketball terms you know which which you know in video game terms would be a boss fight or something like that right
  176. so there's so there's all of these these sort of um aspects which can get built into um any gamified process and and so
  177. what we we provide is kind of like this this definition and these steps to understand how these things fit together
  178. in a framework and and a hierarchy so that the the manager can can go about Building Systems that actually use those
  179. features you also recommend six steps that companies can take to build uh effective gamification programs could
  180. you take us through some of them only go through four can have to buy the book yeah that's right three that's right
  181. well there'll be a bonus step that they'll they'll get if you buy the book while you're watching this video then
  182. you'll get another one step so we call them the 6ds um and they are um six element of gamification design um now
  183. design is not a linear process and and we talk about this in the context of design thinking and and game thinking um
  184. it's iterative you go through and go back you have to play test and so forth um but these are steps that are
  185. essential to to think about to make sure that you don't ignore um and it starts with um defining objectives which is
  186. what Dan talked about earlier what is my goal here um because your goal is probably not to get people to earn
  187. points or to get people to show up at your website that that might be a an intermediate goal um but but your goal
  188. is maybe to get more conversions to people to be customers or to get your your customers to be engaged more um
  189. whatever it is you as a manager know what your business goal is then you break that down into specific behaviors
  190. what are the activities you want people to do in the gamified system um and then
  191. you drill down on your players who who are these people what do you know about them how do you model them think about
  192. um their methods of Engagement and so forth um so that that gets you down to the specifics um and then from there you
  193. can go on to the further steps and uh model the the specific uh activities what we call activity Cycles within your
  194. gamified system the specific uh tools that you employ the game elements that Dan talked about um and um the the
  195. critical one uh the is the next to last one which is don't forget the fun because what we found Dan and I taught
  196. the first gamification course as far as we know the first one ever offered um at
  197. the Wharton School last year and we're teaching it again this year um what we found was that it's so easy to lose the
  198. forest for the trees um you start to go down this design process and you have to
  199. constantly pull yourself back up and say would someone want to do that um because
  200. that's a critical question and that's the essential question you can't just do that you can't just say gee this looks
  201. like fun and we're done you need to be systematic and thoughtful and model and do analytics and so forth um but you
  202. need to keep bouncing back between those things and a sense of the experience a sense of this is something people would
  203. want to do so the 6ds are are basically a a structured framework to ensure you look at all of those aspects and the
  204. things that people generally start with in gamification again going back to the point Dan made earlier um just you know
  205. spilling out the blocks as it were and sticking them together that's all near the end um because if you do that
  206. without a really good sense of your objectives and who your players are you're going to fail or you're going to
  207. succeed for a little while and then fail which in some ways may be even worse and
  208. and you won't know why you failed right it looked like it was great but then it really wasn't what are some of the big
  209. risks and dangers of gamification and how how do you think companies should avoid them yeah um I mean there is there
  210. there a combination of them there sort of there are some legal risks um there are some ethical risks um and there are
  211. some risks which are really mostly in the nature of um just bad gamification design right so
  212. so the legal risks you know are not are not that serious but but there are ones that you have to you know look out for
  213. things like um you know sweep Stakes rules or competition rules that you might have in your particular state or
  214. jurisdiction um there are some some ethical risks that can can occur um that we we kind of outline in the book um
  215. those examples are where where people are compelled to play your game um then it can end up being something which
  216. which is really sort of Bad Business practice really sort of unethical Behavior or behavior that's going to end
  217. up subjecting you to to sort of some some problems whether it's you know PR or some some issues with with the the
  218. workforce um so you know an example of that is is is using leaderboards um to try to speed up people's workflow right
  219. and and showing that you know that the Dan is really great at this but Kevin is really bad and so that will not only
  220. demotivate Kevin um but it you know it has some some real ethical concerns and so you can't just apply that in in the
  221. normal way um uh you know in the sense of sort of like there's no problem here um and then the final sort of category
  222. are some some risks in relation to just bad gamification design where um you end
  223. up more than anything else just just wasting money you know it's just it's just going to fail as a as a process and
  224. and so why would you start it and so those are the the risk we outline at the end of the book so for each of you do
  225. you have any final words of advice for companies that are eag eager to use gamification to motivate their employees
  226. and engage their customers well one of the interesting things that that we found as we started to research the book
  227. was we started to come upon all of these examples that were already out there that companies weren't necessarily
  228. thinking about gamification um or there were things that people would look at and say were gamification like for
  229. example frequent flyer and loyalty programs uh that turned out to either not really be gamification or be just
  230. bad gamification because they don't have that focus on game design and fun and engagement um so it turns out that just
  231. as if you go into a room of business Executives or professionals and say who's a gamer about you know one in 10
  232. or one in 12 people will raise their hand uh and then you start to ask all right well how many of you play Angry
  233. Birds or Farmville or one of these games that have now literally billions of players around the world when more hands
  234. go up how many of you play golf chess Checkers Bridge poker uh we're all Gamers uh and so businesses need to
  235. realize that this is not just about about how to uh plate the kids that want to be you shooting and killing dragons
  236. all the time instead of doing their job um this is about uh taking some very old
  237. very established insights psychology and design and so forth um and applying them
  238. in new ways given the new capabilities of Technology we now have a concept we have a word for it and we have these
  239. extraordinary capabilities of digital platforms and analytic systems to manage and Implement gamification so I would
  240. urge companies to to to have that kind of Broad View because it turns out that most of them the ones we talk to when
  241. they start to look around they realize they're already doing this they're just not doing it thoughtfully and
  242. systematically um the the advice that I would have is is that I think that the games of the future of many businesses
  243. right every manager needs to understand the gainful thinking um but the main piece of advice would be by the
  244. book thank you both for joining us pleasure thank you so much [Music]

Brief Summary

Gamification can enhance employee engagement and customer experiences, as discussed by authors Kevin Werbach and Dan Hunter in their book "For the Win."

Key points

  • Understanding Gamification. Gamification applies game design principles to motivate and engage people in business contexts.
  • The Importance of Motivation. Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations play crucial roles in engaging employees and customers.
  • Real-World Examples of Gamification. Microsoft and Deloitte showcase how gamification can enhance mundane tasks and improve participation.
  • The 6Ds of Gamification Design. A structured framework to ensure all aspects of gamification are considered.
  • Risks of Bad Gamification Design. Exploring the potential legal, ethical, and design risks in gamification.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes