Why Do People Save Loyalty Points?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Consumers today often belong to a host of retail ‘loyalty programs,’ earning redeemable points when they spend. So why do so many people stockpile points instead of use them? More: http://knlg.net/1g3aNpm 📂 Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. these days everybody's talking about loyalty programs uh whether you're a consumer you're collecting points and
  2. then using to buy things or whether you're a firm offering different kinds of programs we want to have a really
  3. good understanding of different kinds of loyalty programs for instance a lot of programs out there like the Airlines and
  4. many other companies once you accumulate a certain number of points your status changes or the value of your points is
  5. greater than it was before but in many many programs there's none of that in many programs it's just what we call a
  6. linear program and you get a certain amount of points every time you spend a dollar and you can turn those points
  7. back into Dollars uh you know when you when you when you buy things but nothing really changes you can accumulate points
  8. but the rates don't change your status doesn't change so linear loyalty programs are kind of boring but they're
  9. really really common and there's some really interesting phenomena that happened around them so for instance a
  10. few years ago one of my MBA students came to me his family runs a chain of retail stores in Central America and
  11. they have a very standard linear loyalty programs again every time you buy something you get a small number of
  12. points for every dollar you spend and whenever you want he can turn those points into an an even smaller number of
  13. dollars and the and he noticed something really curious which is in a lar loyalty
  14. program you should just be spending those points right away there is no benefit to to accumulate the these
  15. things there's no nothing to be gained from stockpiling them the only thing that can happen is you can you can lose
  16. them or the company can go out of business but people stockpile points in a linear program uh and and it's weird
  17. it's it's not that they're never using the points occasionally they will use them but they pile them up and pile them
  18. up and pile them up and then use a few and then pile them up again so why is it that people pile up points in a linear
  19. loyalty program so so this former student posed this as a puzzle and it became a very interesting research
  20. problem and I was really happy to work with one my one of my PhD students Valeria storm and one of my colleagues
  21. Eric bradow to come up with a statistical model that will sort out lots of different explanations why is it
  22. that people pile up points in a line neology program so we considered lots of different factors some psychological
  23. some economic uh and tried to sort them all out to figure out what the what the the wining explanations were that's what
  24. the paper's all about so we looked at lots of different explanations so maybe it's the case that
  25. it's just it's so burdensome on you to to even think about Redeeming the points that you only do it once in a while uh
  26. or or or maybe uh you're afraid of using up the points because then you won't get
  27. points on that particular transaction but our the main explanation that we came up with is is something that
  28. honestly we didn't even think about in advance although there's very strong psychological theory underlying it it
  29. and that's the idea that in people's minds they have two separate accounts they have a cash account how much money
  30. do I have and how much money would I be losing if I buy this product but they also have a points account so how many
  31. points do I have and how many points would I gain or lose if I buy this product if I use points or if I don't
  32. use points so people have these mental accounts and they're different so it's not that points and and dollars are are
  33. equally interchangeable uh some some Theory tells us that people would be a little
  34. bit more sensitive to to kind of losing cash and other words spending money than
  35. they would be to losing points that is using them for redemptions so you have these two different accounts and
  36. different sensitivities about how you'd make tradeoffs between them so the basic
  37. idea is I'm looking at a purchase I'm thinking about how many points I have I'm thinking how much cash I have I'm
  38. thinking how many points I would lose or how much cash I would lose depending on
  39. how I buy it and I'm going to choose the account that that makes me happiest so it's this idea of mental accounting that
  40. that that explains why people will often pile up points and and not use them even
  41. though economically they should just be using them all the time so now that we know that people have these two accounts
  42. that has all kinds of important implications first of all it's just kind of interesting to know about how people
  43. operate and interesting to be able to predict who is likely to redeem how often and when it's very important for
  44. retailers to have some idea about what these redemptions are going to look like CU after all people are piling up all
  45. these points they're building up all these liabilities on their balance sheet you kind of want to know when when these
  46. redemptions are going to occur and you want to set up your program in a way so you have the just right number of
  47. redemptions you might not want people redeeming all the time because then they come to expect it but you don't want
  48. them to be redeeming too infrequently because then again you have these really big Point liabilities on your balance
  49. sheet so one of the big takeaway from the paper is that by having our multiple account story we can give retailers
  50. specific advice about how different kinds of parameters the Loyalty program how many points do we give you for each
  51. dollar that you spend how many dollars are the points worth when you redeem them we can help you come up with that
  52. just right combination in order to make sure that you're getting that just right
  53. blend of people redeeming their points but not too often so what makes this project unique
  54. first of all is that really clear tight focus on linear loyalty programs they're
  55. really really common if if you if you look around and think about the kinds of loyalty programs that you're involved in
  56. many of them have this this idea that you know you get points you use points but there is no special status or
  57. special thresholds that that you hit so it's it's surprising how little research
  58. has been done on linear loyalty programs Again part of it is that they're just not as as sexy and dramatic and
  59. interesting as programs where you have to hit certain thresholds and what are the psychological mechanisms that get
  60. people to to get to those thresholds so linear programs are boring but they're an important part of business and so we
  61. really want companies to to have just a better understanding about how they operate what are the economics
  62. associated with them and what are the underlying psychological drivers uh that that describe how people use them and
  63. how they would respond differently if companies were to to change certain aspects of the program another important
  64. aspect of This research is this idea of having these two mental accounts so very
  65. often when you look at loyalty program you tend to think that people are very rational and they're making these these
  66. very utilitarian tradeoffs between the points they have and the dollars that they have and they're always optimizing
  67. well that's not true and a lot of this mental accounting that we're leveraging a lot of this is is work that goes back
  68. to uh Daniel Conan and Amos derski two terrific worldclass psychologists Daniel Conan won the Nobel Prize for some of
  69. his work this idea of mental accounting occurs all the time even in situations where you might not expect to see it so
  70. it's I think important to to understand that the way that people approach something that that that should be
  71. economic is often much more psychological and I think that the the story that we tell about these two
  72. different accounts and how they differ from each other and how it leads to a very elegant solution to a very
  73. practical real world puzzle is a very nice contribution by itself as I mentioned the lead author on
  74. this is one of my PhD students Valaria storm and she's been just captivated by this idea of loyalty programs and the
  75. the psychological drivers underneath them and the economic implications that arise from them so this was just one
  76. paper that Valeria and Eric bradow and I did together Valeria is working on her dissertation now uh working on a
  77. different kind of loyalty program with a different company in a different part of
  78. the world uh in this case trying to understand the nature of a coalition loyalty program so very often instead of
  79. having just just one company having its own loyalty program you'll have a loyalty program that lots of different
  80. companies belong to so for instance American Express recently announced a program called plenty that's a coalition
  81. loyalty program because you can accumulate points from lots of different companies like AT&T for instance and
  82. many others and and use those points at variety of different firms not necessarily the firms that you got the
  83. points from so a coalition loyalty program is another emerging loyalty program idea not quite as common at
  84. least in the us as your standard Airline loyalty program but very big around the
  85. world and and and very important to understand how you develop one of these things how you set the parameters for it
  86. what are the exchange rates how should it vary and and under what conditions would a firm want to be part of the
  87. Coalition loyalty program or not so we're just scratching the surface to to try to really understand loyalty
  88. programs inside and out and as much as we keep expanding our research that involves them the number and the variety
  89. of loyalty programs are expanding even more so we we're going to have a hard time keeping up with the Loyalty program
  90. industry but we're having a real good time learning about uh the nature of these programs as we go along
  91. [Music]

Brief Summary

Consumers often stockpile points in linear loyalty programs due to separate mental accounts for cash and points, affecting their spending behavior.

Key points

  • Understanding Loyalty Programs. Exploring the dynamics of loyalty programs and consumer behavior.
  • Mental Accounting in Loyalty Programs. How consumers differentiate between cash and points in spending decisions.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes