Understanding Tokenomics and the Value of Digital Assets

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton guest Shimon Kogan and host Itay Goldstein explores the economics of tokens and tokenization, unpacking how tokenomics shapes the value of digital assets. It highlights why adoption and coordination drive token markets, how programmable blockchains enable diverse token uses, and why stablecoins and tokenized assets are gaining momentum. The discussion also examines the challenges of valuing tokens, the blur between utility and investment, and the behavioral forces behind meme coins and speculation, while raising questions about regulation, sustainability, and innovation.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#tokenomics #memecoins #digitalassets #defi #blockchain ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome everyone. This is uh Wharton Finance the future of finance podcast. This is our second season and in the
  2. second season we are talking about digital assets, cryptocurrencies, tokens, uh decentralized finance and
  3. everything related to that space. I am Mitai Goldstein. I am professor of finance here at Wharton and I'm
  4. currently the chair of the finance department and I'm hosting this uh podcast and today we're going to devote
  5. the episode to thinking about the economics of tokens, the economics of tokenization. Uh this is a term that is
  6. now known as tokconomics. We're going to try to understand what are the fundamental forces that are driving the
  7. market for tokens and coins and how these forces are different from some of the other markets financial assets that
  8. we are used to and that we have been thinking about in the past. I have the perfect guest today to think about those
  9. issues and this is uh Shimon Kogan. Shimon Kogan has been with us at Walton for the last 10 years or so where he has
  10. been uh teaching uh the fintech course. Uh he was one of the first movers into the area of uh fintech when few places
  11. had fintech courses. Uh he already designed one and came to teach it for us and has been doing it uh since then uh
  12. with great success. He also worked on uh related issues in his own uh research and we're going to talk about that as
  13. well. Uh welcome uh Shimon. It's great to have you. >> Thank you. It's a pleasure being
  14. invited. I I'm I'm a I'm a fan of the podcast. Was listening to the to the first episode. So uh looking forward to
  15. the conversation. >> So let's uh dive uh right in and try to understand uh some of the terms that we
  16. are talking about. Uh c can you take a step back and maybe help us understand help the audience understand what do we
  17. think about when we think about uh tokens and uh coins? What are the common uses uh for them? Uh how are they
  18. potentially going to change the financial system? And you know a lot of it is maybe just a pipe dream things
  19. that we are aspiring to but have not been realized yet. So the question is how much is real and how much is still
  20. just a fantasy. May maybe it's too much for the first question but uh you you can start wherever you want.
  21. >> I'll try to deliver on that at least at a sort of at a high level because I'm
  22. sure that we're going to dive into some of the more specifics um during the conversation but but it's it's a it's a
  23. it's a good place to start kind of at the top because there are there lots of terms in this field and it gets uh it
  24. gets quite confusing. So let's start at the top. So in in kind of the world of crypto I think it's
  25. important to distinguish between different class of assets because it tells you something about the underlying
  26. technology and the underlying uh structure right so kind of at the core level we have cryptocurrencies right in
  27. each of these cryptocurrencies is associated with a particular blockchain so you know blood is of course familiar
  28. with BTC right that's not to be confused with Bitcoin right so Bitcoin is the blockchain protocol BTC is the native
  29. currency for that. Here as well, I think it's helpful to distinguish between transactional only blockchains like
  30. Bitcoin or Litecoin where the primary use case of the coin aside for paying for basically the security. So, it kind
  31. of actually came out of of of true and um um legitimate kind of need. But the primary use case in these kind of
  32. blockchains is kind of payments, right? um and um and want to separate that from
  33. kind of the the second generation if you will of blockchains and those are programmable
  34. blockchains like Ethereum, Salana and there there are many other competitors where the primary use case of the native
  35. digital um coin is actually to pay for the execution of smart contracts. Okay, so we have cryptocurrencies as sort of
  36. the main type of asset. Now notice and that's important too that when we talk about cryptocurrencies lots of
  37. cryptocurrencies because each of them is sort of native to its own blockchain you
  38. cannot take you cannot take Bitcoin and transact in Ethereum and vice versa without some third party offering kind
  39. of like bridge services and we can talk about that if if if you're interested. Now on programmable blockchains lots of
  40. things that you can do but as it turns out um you can create tokens right so we want to distinguish between again the
  41. cryptocurrency like Ethereum and tokens build or that live on Ethereum and so those are assets that are created by
  42. applications around various use cases some of them could be payments for services could be
  43. voting could be control we can we'll come back to it when we talk about tokconomics right So in fact the fact
  44. that uh this is sort of touring complete um programming language means that you can create lots and lots of different
  45. varieties of contracts and we see that uh in practice that also introduces vulnerability. So what um say Ethereum
  46. I'm going to many of my examples are going to be from Ethereum because it's simply the largest uh programmable
  47. blockchain. they kind of created templates of uh types of tokens just to make developers life easier, right? So
  48. you don't have to sort of figure out from scratch all the features uh and open yourself up to um security
  49. vulnerabilities. So they designed kind of templates of tokens. So um you may be familiar with ERC20 which is kind of the
  50. the the funible token uh standard that was behind the ICO boom or heavily used during the ICO boom. we have ERC 721
  51. tokens. So that's kind of the template often times used for nonf fungeible tokens. More recently we have ERC400
  52. which is now advanced as a as a kind of format to offer tokenization of offchain
  53. assets. Okay. So again we have token we have we have cryptocurrencies we have tokens. Now those tokens
  54. inherent the security of the blockchain on which they were developed. So as a developer, you have to ask yourself um
  55. where you want to develop your application and where these tokens are going to live because again they don't
  56. port from one protocol to another. And so naturally there's a lot of competition around kind of eyeballs and
  57. attention of developers um by these what we call layer ones by these programmable
  58. blockchains. >> But if you want to think about the main economic uh uses for them, how would you
  59. classify that? The first is and that's a very specific type of token but it it's
  60. so specific that it has its own name and those are stable coins right so stable coins are tokens
  61. um that are designed to sort of keep a peg to typically US dollar but could be in principle anything it's a big
  62. business you know circle went public went from like 30 to 200 bucks overnight um so that's it's a real big business
  63. there's another uh big business around and some some real traction around tokconization. Okay. because that's the
  64. idea of representing um non kind of non-cryptonative assets um um on on crypto infra or blockchain infrastructure right
  65. so black rockck uh for example partnered with securize to offer its money market
  66. fund biddu so basically what you're saying is taking financial assets and putting them
  67. on token and and then what what is what is the what is The advantage of of doing that
  68. >> there could be few advantages right now the use case that we are seeing first of
  69. all what you get is instantaneous settlement right um so even if you're institutional player once you have
  70. stable coins and you have um these these crypton native securities right uh or or representation
  71. of them then you have 247 instantaneous settlement which we still don't have even if you're even if you're a large um
  72. sort of corporation say right I mean you still if you're moving money about settlement takes time depending on on
  73. what kind of asset um you're looking at but there's there's obviously sort of the ambition is is much bigger than that
  74. Robin Hood announced I think I think last week uh that they're going to offer tokens associated with private equity
  75. right so they're going to take I don't SpaceX and OpenAI etc. and represent them as tokens and people are talking
  76. about what's called real world tokenizing real world assets. So those are not securities at all. This could be
  77. anything from your um you know I don't know collectibles to real estate. >> So it allows us to trade on things that
  78. otherwise we would not be able to trade and things that we could trade it allows
  79. us to do it more efficiently. >> That's right. and and for example I mean and and you know look look this is not a
  80. pan of I mean and and I have a lot of conversations with people in the industry about this I mean I think that
  81. it you know there are parts of it that make sense there are parts of it that I still are kind of people are
  82. um I'm not thinking carefully through like for example there are fundamental reasons why some of these assets are
  83. illquid right that ili liquidity I don't think is going to go away by creating a
  84. digital representation and offering ing people to trade it 24/7. That that's that's not a solution to the fundamental
  85. problem that causes these assets to be uh non-tradable. But and you know, I'll take the other side of this, but you can
  86. take assets that have a fairly infrequent kind of price discovery and you know, you're still not going to
  87. solve the problem of of of that price being being um stale, but you can you can now and and again, this is not
  88. fiction. this is this is happening. You can allow owners of these assets to pledge them as collateral and that that
  89. could be kind of a partial solution for for the liquidity problem. Right. >> Right. Yes.
  90. >> So, so I I have an asset that you have a hard time valuing. Right. And you're
  91. saying, look, I don't know if it's worth 80 or 90 or 100, but you know, it's presumably worth, you know, you know,
  92. the probability that it's worth less than 20 is very low. So I'll lend you I'll if you if you if you basically lock
  93. this asset in a smart contract I'll lend you 20 bucks against this right with with
  94. appropriate uh interest. So again you know I think I think it's sort of an interesting solution of kind of indirect
  95. way of giving some liquidity and by making these assets at the very least pledgeible
  96. >> right so when we are thinking about tokconomics the economics of tokens we would like to understand the supply the
  97. demand how prices are formed if we are thinking about other financial assets like stocks I think we have uh very
  98. wellestablished frameworks uh you're thinking about uh future earning earnings, future cash flows, you're
  99. discounting them and so on. Uh those uh rules are not working exactly like that when it comes to tokens and and this is
  100. what makes the economics a little richer and and more interesting. So what what do you think are the other forces and
  101. how should we think about uh the the economics here? >> No, it's a it's a great question. Um
  102. yeah, first of all, let me say that, you know, it should be obvious from from from our discussion so far that this
  103. flexibility uh allows us to create uh all sorts of tokens with lots of different features, right? Uh and so I
  104. think one of the challenges of of this industry is that at least from what I see there's mostly there's very little
  105. theory. uh there's actually not that much even empirical work from academia sort of to guide say new platform
  106. builders for how do they structure so they they often come and ask these questions like well you know how should
  107. I control supply you know what is the emission rate um burn rate um how should etc so lots of different so basically
  108. the dimensions along which they have choices are are are are quite broad right um and so first of all I want to
  109. point out that that there's I think that there's more that we don't understand about sort of optimal kind of contract
  110. design if you will in the context of economics um and um than we do that that's at least my my personal opinion
  111. on this now um I think it's helpful to sort of draw parallels to equities right um so there
  112. are some similarities and some differences right so the the obvious difference so They kind of look a little
  113. bit like uh like each other because both under some circumstances give you some control rights and ownership rights and
  114. and some of them kind of although they don't declare that give you some cash flow rights. Um but but but let's
  115. understand where kind of what world each of these live in right. So in the world
  116. of securities right or equities um essentially what you have is sort of a legal structure
  117. that um that safeguards the holders of securities against um expose bad behavior uh by by managers
  118. or or controllers, right? Um so obviously you do not have that legal protection when it comes to tokens,
  119. right? um at least not under I think on under the current uh legal framework. What you do have with tokens is the
  120. ability to sort of what we call pre-commit, right? So what what you can what you can do for example with tokens
  121. that you cannot do uh with uh with equities is to say you know I'm going to I'm going to program in the rate by
  122. which new tokens are going to be issued and it's going to be a function of these
  123. conditions like in take bitcoin for example right it's purely a condition like it's a function of time right
  124. there's no the price of bitcoin doesn't affect the emission of of Bitcoin, you know, how many miners there are, it's
  125. like all all these um they don't matter. So that's a particular choice that you can do in in in in kind of crypto world
  126. that you cannot uh easily implement with equities. >> This kind of leads me to something
  127. related that uh people would think maybe is on the fringe but is getting a lot of
  128. attention which is uh meme coins. Um and you have coins that are kind of based on
  129. nothing. Uh if you think about uh dodgecoin or uh uh shea you know others uh you you you b you you basically have
  130. uh a token that has value just because other people think it has value and not because it represents anything that is
  131. underlying it that would be uh uh valuable. So would you think about that also uh using the same framework or do
  132. you think this is something completely different? >> So I think I think um that's a good
  133. question. Well I mean you know if you want to be provocative you can ask whether Bitcoin is a memecoin as well.
  134. >> Do you think that Bitcoin is a is a memecoin? >> No. But but what I'm saying is that I I
  135. I personally don't >> but but >> no because at least with Bitcoin in the beginning there was this idea that it's
  136. going to be kind of a new currency. people are going to use it to buy things and so on. Um I don't think it really
  137. panned out this way so far, but there was some uh use case. >> Absolutely. I I I I'm not suggesting
  138. that Bitcoin is a memecoin. All I'm saying is that if you sort of step officially like if you if you kind of
  139. take a few steps back and kind of look for from a kind of high kind of high level perspective, you can ask yourself,
  140. well, what is the what is what is sort of the tangible utility? You're absolutely right. By the way, you know,
  141. with with some of the meme coins, the process kind of it was kind of a faking until you make it in some sense. I don't
  142. think it was designed, right? But, you know, Dodgecoin now is Alan Musk is suggesting that it's going to be the
  143. payment rail maybe for for X, you know, and you have you have now kind of a mini
  144. ecosystem around Shibaino. Again, I don't think it was there in the first place. I do want to mention and and I
  145. and I do think that um there there are there's a lot of other factors that are at play here uh that are more coming
  146. from behavioral finance than anything else in terms of kind of thinking about uh valuation.
  147. But I I do want to mention something that that we found that that I think is relevant for this uh discussion in a
  148. paper where we um we had access to a really interesting data set uh from it Toro. So Tor is publicly traded
  149. companies is basically retail broker that has um operations in over 100 markets. And one of the neat features of
  150. it is that kind of from from the from the get-go um and they offered um retail investors the ability to uh invest in
  151. lots of different types of assets. So they were one of the first to actually embrace crypto. Um and the question that
  152. we asked was really simple. is like do people you know so take the same individual
  153. um do they seem to behave different in cryptos than in in say equities or gold? So we wanted to ask that very simple
  154. question and more specifically what we we're interested in is how expectations of future returns of these asset classes
  155. actually respond to prices which is kind of what what you're getting at right um
  156. and so um you know under some assumptions what you can do is you can back out um the share in your in the
  157. portfolio for users um dedicated to each of these asset classes and you just basically s you can estimate how these
  158. um portfolio shares how they respond to past returns. Essentially what we find is that a very robust finding right lots
  159. of different specifications. We find that when you look at equities um people have retail investors at least in our
  160. sample have contrarian beliefs right so equity uh prices go up people believe that future returns are going to be
  161. lower than they were before right and by the way that's true for gold as well but
  162. not for crypto okay so they they appear to have kind of momentum like beliefs um
  163. in crypto and we try to understand where is coming from. Um and and so for example, we looked at kind of lottery
  164. like stocks to see whether people behave in kind of whether people have sort of momentum beliefs in when when you when
  165. you focus on lottery like uh stocks. So those are stocks that have positive skewess you know maybe young stocks
  166. smaller ones lower like there there various known proxies for this and interestingly we don't find that like we
  167. don't find we still find contrarian beliefs even in these lottery like uh stocks so there's sort of something
  168. specific about crypto >> yeah and this is the role of adoption and coordination I think this speaks
  169. very clearly to that and and you say this can also support uh meme coins that might not have any underlying value, but
  170. the value is just coming from the fact that others are are using it. >> That's true. Although I think that with
  171. memecoins it's it's you know it's it's kind of like a a very extreme case because um because there's basically no
  172. at least as you pointed out like there's no even a pretense by the way I think it's for regulatory reasons right so
  173. part of it started joke part of I think started as as a as a way of avoiding being classified as security there's no
  174. pretense of anything being underpinning its value right so very kind of extreme a case of not where we push fundamentals
  175. to to the future where we have no fundamentals at all. And um >> and you know and and I think it's
  176. interesting and and you know there there's there's some really interesting studies done in the 70s and 80s looking
  177. at experimental markets where they try to do this like they try to basically see what happens when you push
  178. fundamentals further out into the future. And then they found two things that could be actually relevant for this
  179. these markets, right? They found that actually first of all you can you can create these bubbles in a lab like in a
  180. very controlled very simple environment in a repeatable way. But they found two two things. They first of all they found
  181. that expectations are adaptive right. So when these bubbles happen and you ask traders what they think the price is
  182. going to happen like they they they many of them understand that prices get detached from fundamentals but these
  183. fundamentals are not going to be not going to kind of show up until later in the future and so they exhibit these
  184. adaptive expectations. The second thing is that they underestimate how quickly the bubble will burst on
  185. average, right? Um because it's sort of it's it's clear that you know because of
  186. the fundamental at some point there's something anchoring prices. >> There is some parallel also to mean meme
  187. stocks, right? So we talked in the previous uh season uh I talked to Matt Lavine about uh meme stocks and social
  188. behavior in the financial market and uh clearly that is a very strong force here
  189. as as well maybe even more extreme because with meme stocks there is a grain of fundamental whereas here there
  190. isn't. So these are uh may maybe the the same the same underlying forces but uh even more extreme that we see them here
  191. in in tokconomics. I I agree, you know, so so with with with you know, GameStop, AMC, you know,
  192. um you you you know, you would you you would think that at some point, right, the fundamentals that
  193. are going to anchor the the price of a stock with memecoins, it's not obvious what that anchor is. And so, yeah, I
  194. think I think they they really lean on on on sort of similar uh drivers for for for users, right? I
  195. mean in this sort of sense of community, shared narrative um in some cases this this idea that um they're collect
  196. collectively rebelling against traditional uh powers. Um and and I think that's that's very important to to
  197. note as well and we see this elsewhere. It's a great appetite for gambling. Right. So, so I want I want to go back a
  198. little bit to uh ICO initial coin offerings and you mentioned that uh for uh you know a few years ago there was a
  199. wave of ICOs and I think at that point there was hope that there is real economic value behind it because those
  200. are firms that instead of issuing equity they are issuing coins and that is a way
  201. to raise capital and it also supports the products of of the firms but Unfortunately, there was also a lot of
  202. fraud that was associated with that and then it came in to a halt and you know now there's a lot of regulatory
  203. uncertainty where it's going to go. Um so where do you think we are headed with that? You think there is still a future
  204. for this? >> When you say future for this what what exactly do you mean? >> Will we see the revival of ICOs? Uh is
  205. it going to go back to the same uh volume and momentum that we had in the initial phase? I very much agree uh wi
  206. with your uh with your assessment uh and u but I I also want to point out that there are some legitimate um legitimate
  207. platforms uh that were uh built around that. >> Yeah, absolutely. No, I I think that
  208. there were some of them that were certainly legitimate, but there was also a lot of uh fraudulent ones around them
  209. and and and and the fact that it was hard to tell which is which, I think this is what caused uh the the crash in
  210. activity. >> I agree. I mean it it it was sort of combination of that and um and you know
  211. it kind of coincided not exactly but you know roughly around the same time like it the Teraluna debacle, the FDX Celsius
  212. there there are a bunch of like notable um basic cases of of what you would legally
  213. or otherwise probably classify as uh as as as fraud. And so that that led to an obvious response by the regulator, the
  214. SEC. We kind of know what it looks like under the current administration. I I think the regulatory environment now
  215. looks very different in the US. Um and I think that's worth mentioning. And I think that there's hope that under that
  216. sort of new um framework there there will be ways in which uh in which you can actually do this with proper
  217. disclosure and and guidelines and uh um and basically consumer protection right and that that's what that's what we are
  218. concerned about right so um you know now um D may be familiar with the genius um genius act which is standing for
  219. guiding guiding and establishing national innovation for us stable coin act okay
  220. um which is basically a framework for how do you issue payment stable coins and etc again I'm happy to talk more
  221. about that if if you're interested in but it and there's another even actually more ambitious and and broader
  222. um attempt to sort of clarify um what is a security, what is a commodity, right?
  223. Um under the clarity act and um and provide safe harbor to developers and sort of establish market rules and and
  224. compliance rules etc. So um then these two may actually get combined eventually, right? And that's that's
  225. part of the political uh discussion that's taking place right now. And we see very very kind of different
  226. framework slightly but uh we see Europe actually um being a bit ahead of the US in in that way through Mika framework
  227. which it's actually quite I mean it doesn't cover everything but it's quite comprehensive and and talks about again
  228. guidelines for how do you um issue tokens and stable coins and what custody services look like etc. Right. So I
  229. think that yes in the US the um I think everywhere right we we've seen some regulatory lag because this the
  230. industry move very very quickly um I think it's actually kind of fascinating to see how quickly um the the the
  231. evolution cycle in this industry are um and there are some legitimate issues around that or concerns around
  232. regulatory capture and and regulatory arbitrage but you know like I work as an expert witness for for a number of
  233. cryptoreated cases and and I and I see how the level of um sort of basically the level of
  234. understanding um on the on the on the supervisory and regulatory um sides. It's it's it's very different from what
  235. it was a few years ago. So I so I think that you know there's some catching up to do. Um but u but I'm hopeful that it
  236. it's happening and I think that this can can actually um lead to at least from from from from an entrepreneur's
  237. perspective a more sensible framework that's based on activity and not based on type of institution. Right? There's
  238. certainly a lot more to talk about, but I think we touched on the important aspects of the economics of tokens and
  239. what are some of the unique features uh some of the uh complications uh some of the regulatory uncertainty and it also
  240. touches on some of the things that we discussed in the other episodes this uh season. Uh so thank you very much uh
  241. Shimon for joining us. >> It was a pleasure. Thanks for inviting me. >> Okay. Thank you and thank you everyone
  242. for listening. [Music]

Brief Summary

This episode discusses tokconomics, tokenization, stable coins, and the future of ICOs with Shimon Kogan from Wharton.

Key points

  • Understanding Tokconomics. Exploring the economics of tokens and the forces driving their market.
  • The Rise of Stable Coins. Stable coins are designed to maintain a peg to traditional currencies, creating a big business.
  • Meme Coins and Their Value. Discussing the phenomenon of meme coins that derive value from popularity rather than fundamentals.
  • The Nature of Bubbles. Studies show bubbles can be created in controlled environments, revealing adaptive expectations.
  • Future of ICOs. Discussion on whether ICOs will revive and how regulations may shape their future.
  • Regulatory Uncertainty. The rise and fall of ICOs highlight the challenges of distinguishing legitimate projects from fraud.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes