Climate Crisis: What Is Greenwashing and Why Is It Concerning? | Sarah Light — Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW: "Climate Crisis: Why Is Greenwashing So Concerning?" How can regulators stop the deceptive practice of greenwashing without violating firms’ right to free speech? Wharton professor Sarah E. Light explains why this question is so difficult to resolve and what legal steps are being taken to protect the public from false and misleading environmental claims.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 0:54 - What is ‘greenwashing’? 3:58 - Misleading claims from companies 7:26 - Analyzing greenwashing studies 9:43 - Assessing greenwashing's impact 13:37 - Corporate influence on regulation 17:35 - Social media’s role on climate policy 19:55 - Strategies for corporate transparency

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. in the last few years there's been a kind of shift in the way that greenwashing has entered the public
  2. Consciousness for many years it was really all about product-based claims but what the shift has been is over the
  3. past few years firms have increasingly been making claims about their environmental impact as a whole or their
  4. climate impact welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton
  5. faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the
  6. groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the
  7. world today we'll be covering a diverse range of topics bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you can
  8. apply to your life and to work so get ready to dive into new ideas with the ripple effect
  9. all right so this topic of green watching we've heard it talked about a lot in the public it's obviously come up
  10. with a lot in the media for those that maybe don't have a total grasp on it give us a definition of what green
  11. watching is absolutely so green washing is kind of this umbrella expression that
  12. refers to situations in which an entity is publicly making statements about its environmental impact or the
  13. environmental impact of its products or services that are not actually borne out
  14. by the evidence so it could be a directly false claim like this product made by this company is 50 recycled
  15. material when in fact there's no recycled material in it at all it could be um a kind of more vague you know our
  16. product is all natural we don't really know what that means um and it could be sort of there are
  17. many many different other forms but what's really important to understand about greenwashing is that it can refer
  18. not only to a product like a specific advertisement or a product or a service it can also refer to sort of efforts to
  19. paint the entire firm as being more environmentally conscious than it is and I think that's the way in which it's
  20. been coming up a lot more recently so what was it that piqued your interest about green washing and also kind of
  21. also about the First Amendment as well absolutely so as you know from our many conversations over the years
  22. um I'm a professor at Wharton in the legal studies and business ethics department and
  23. um and so my interest in kind of uh the intersection of business and environment
  24. relates primarily to the legal rules and sort of the legal and policy environment
  25. that addresses the ways in which business firms interact with the environment and green washing is this
  26. really interesting case because you know not only has it been coming up kind of more and more as firms are becoming more
  27. and more aware of the fact that their stakeholders want them to be more environmentally friendly or aware
  28. um but the question of are these claims real are they backed by evidence or are they greenwashing has raised questions
  29. about how we need to think about enforcement and how can we prevent firms from misleading members of the public be
  30. they consumers or investors or Regulators about the kind of Bona fidas of their environmental marketing claims
  31. so um so that's kind of The Big Picture answer about how I'm you know why I'm interested in this topic the most
  32. specific answer actually is um is that in the last few years there's been a kind of shift in the way that
  33. greenwashing has entered the public Consciousness for many years it was really all about product based claims
  34. you know this product contains recycled material when it doesn't or this product
  35. is you know um non-toxic but it's toxic but what the shift has been is over the past few years firms have increasingly
  36. been making claims about their environmental impact as whole or their climate impact so for example more than
  37. a thousand firms in the past few years have made public statements or commitments that they're going to get to
  38. Net Zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. some of those claims may be uh real and
  39. bet you know backed by evidence and others may be just kind of puffery and kind of trying to go along with the flow
  40. and so what I'm really interested in and what piqued my interest was situations in which the firm itself is kind of
  41. trying to characterize itself or its business as making a transition to Net Zero uh by 2050 World
  42. um when in fact many of the firms are kind of continuing business as usual or you know uh sort of how to tell the
  43. difference so that's really what piqued my interest in this project a few years ago how prevalent do you think green
  44. washing is out there in the in the business Community these days right so the truth is I think it's really hard to
  45. tell I think that um in a way the prevalence depends very much on what your definition is and it's
  46. this is the really hard part right because when you think about certain legal terms like assault or murder or
  47. something like that or you know fraud those terms have legal definitions a court can say is this fraud well is it a
  48. material misrepresentation of fact that harmed you know that that caused harm right there are elements green washing
  49. is not a legal term of art green washing is like the word that we all use when we
  50. feel deceived and so you might have a much broader definition of greenwashing than I do or I may have a broader
  51. definition than you do right and so when I teach the topic of greenwashing to my
  52. students this is actually really interesting I give them a set of examples that are based on reality
  53. um you know real life uh cases and I ask them is it greenwashing or is it not brainwashing and of the six examples
  54. that I give you know two of them at the very extreme ends one is clearly everybody's hand goes up yes this is
  55. definitely green washing and On The Other Extreme not a single hand goes up definitely not green washing but in the
  56. middle you get kind of 50 50 and it's really hard to know and part of the reason why is because there can be
  57. directly false claims where you know either it's factually true or factually not true and you can test it like the
  58. content of a product um but then they're the kind of misleading ones like a major fossil fuel
  59. company having an ad that um uh highlights its investments in renewable energy and those Investments
  60. are real but those Investments comprise less than one percent of the entire business right
  61. and so it's trying to create an impression or a kind of halo effect that may be misleading
  62. um as customers or investors are thinking well should I buy this stock or that stock should I go fill up my tank
  63. at this gas station versus that gas station right and so it affects consumer choices in the marketplace as well as
  64. investor decisions so it's really the truth is it's really really hard to tell there have been a few studies
  65. um particularly looking at for example The Net Zero claims by Major firms in like the SNP S P 500 and one recent
  66. study um uh suggested that the while you know the firms in the sample had uh stated
  67. publicly that they were going to get to net zero emissions uh by 2050. in fact they were only going to get about 40
  68. percent of the way there so that's one study but that's kind of the the range that we're dealing with so
  69. on the other side of this as I alluded to there's a component of First Amendment here yeah uh and I guess the
  70. question is with the rights that we have under the First Amendment does the issue
  71. of green washing violate those great so super interesting question and um and you know the reason why I think
  72. the First Amendment comes into play here is because the since 1976 the Supreme Court has protected not only political
  73. speech right like I'm gonna vote for so and so but also certain forms of commercial speech as long as that
  74. commercial speech is truthful and accurate and not deceptive or misleading and before 1976 there was essentially no
  75. protection like you couldn't say I have a First Amendment right to advertise for
  76. my business right um you know a state could say no your your lawyers cannot advertise right and
  77. that wouldn't pose a First Amendment problem but beginning in 1976 the the court basically said even commercial
  78. speech is protected what's interesting about it is that the reason why the Supreme Court decided to protect
  79. commercial speech like advertising or marketing claims um is not based on the kind of autonomy
  80. interest of the speaker it's not about you know the Chevron corporation's autonomy to say what it wants in the
  81. marketplace it's about you and me as listeners and our interest in the marketplace in
  82. ensuring that there is accurate factual information so that we can make choices in the marketplace and we can make
  83. choices about how we want to regulate the marketplace that's basically what the Supreme Court said
  84. so yeah go ahead so so when you think about that that issue of misinformation yes and you think about the the
  85. potential impact that it might have on the marketplace there are a variety of different elements where it could have
  86. impact from bottom line benefit to the company to the impact on its uh shareholders to the public you know
  87. there are so many areas that could potentially be impacted here absolutely absolutely so we know from Empirical
  88. research some of which has been done by my Wharton colleagues that um as well as people from other schools
  89. of course um that uh marketing information about firms sort of corporate social responsibility or
  90. their environmental programs um can have an impact in kind of two primary ways the first is on the
  91. consumer so there's one study that demonstrates a kind of halo effect um for products uh produced by a firm
  92. that engages actively in corporate social responsibilities so participants in this study
  93. um were provided information about you know firm a donates money to X cause and then we're asked to rate
  94. um a hair regrowth product um a tooth whitener and a uh an optical character recognition text scanning
  95. program to to basically rate the programs rate these products as to how good they were you know how wide are the
  96. how much hair grew back how how clear is the scan um and another group of participants
  97. were asked to rate the same product but were given no information about donations by The Firm
  98. and the participants who learned that the firm had engaged in corporate social responsibility rated the teeth as wider
  99. the text is clearer and the hair is fluffier um and this is sort of a really clear
  100. demonstration of a halo effect right so when you you know when there are other studies that say that or that
  101. demonstrate that when consumers learn that a firm makes product X using renewable energy or in some other kind
  102. of you know environmentally conscious way they attribute that environmental Consciousness to the firm's other
  103. products they'll say oh well if that product is made with renewable energy then you know all the products may be
  104. made with renewable energy there's an assumption to that effect so there's kind of this Halo of greenness that
  105. comes about and if I'm making a choice in the marketplace about whether to purchase you know from firm a or firm B
  106. and I find out that firm a is using renewable energy I might buy from firm a and so if that's true that I'm making a
  107. good choice if that's green washing and in fact the firm isn't using renewable energy or they're only using it in some
  108. really limited way but they're hyping it up and they're advertising um then I'm being misled and maybe I
  109. would have chosen the other product right so it distorts voices in The Marketplace the second Major Impact
  110. relates to um our role not as consumers but as voters and there are a number of different
  111. studies that show that when when um in sort of in both directions that there are policies delivers so on the
  112. one hand there is the negative policy spillover meaning study has shown that when
  113. um participants learn that all firms in an industry are setting targets that they're going to use you know recycled
  114. materials in their products they're less likely to support public regulation on the same subject matter largely because
  115. of this impression that like the firms have got it right this is under control this isn't an area that we need to
  116. address with regulation on the flip side there are also studies that show that certain segments of the population may
  117. be more likely to support public regulation when they learn that a firm has taken action rather than like the
  118. state of California so my favorite study in this regard his one uh done by uh some uh faculty at Northwestern who
  119. basically showed participants in the study information about either California using cage-free eggs or
  120. McDonald's using cage-free eggs in their supply chains and then they disaggregated the participants by
  121. political affiliation and what they found was that if you're on the liberal side of the spectrum didn't really
  122. matter that much if you learned that California or McDonald's was using cage-free eggs you were generally
  123. supportive of laws against battery hen egg production battery cage and egg production sorry I'm not saying that
  124. right but you know what I mean um whereas people who identified as very conservative when they learned that the
  125. state of California was purchasing only cage-free eggs they weren't super supportive of public policy they're like
  126. you know those Tree Huggers uh they're gonna do what they want crazy State of California but when conservatives
  127. learned that McDonald's was purchasing cage-free eggs they were as supportive of public policy
  128. on cage-free eggs as liberals why maybe if a major corporation thinks that this is an issue as well as if a
  129. major corporation thinks that it can do this you know consistent with its profit
  130. maximizing goals then this is really a problem so I as a conservative and more likely to trust it if McDonald's thinks
  131. it's a problem than if the state of California right and so we so there's an impact
  132. also on like the interest in members of the public to regulate the problem so there's a component then of of trust
  133. that is kind of involved in that messaging as well especially when you're talking about an element of the
  134. government versus a a corporate entity as well yeah absolutely and I think that that's pretty well estab lished there's
  135. this concept credibility right so depending upon you know how I self-identify whether it's as
  136. a matter of partisan politics or as a matter of other you know identity-based characteristics that I may find certain
  137. uh sources more credible so I might find the state of California more credible than the US military someone might find
  138. the US military more credible than McDonald's right you can you can kind of see where it goes based upon sort of
  139. different values that we hold or D or you know uh different factors that that play into
  140. our identity but I want to mention uh just to sort of pick up your question from earlier about the first amendment
  141. that the way in which the First Amendment really begins to come into play is because the first amendment is a
  142. limit on what the government can do right the first amendment basically says I have a right not to be bothered by the
  143. government not to be told what to do by the government in certain types of Regulation and so if we're thinking
  144. about what we want to do to prevent or deter or punish green washing the First Amendment kind of sets the
  145. outer boundaries of what legal institutions like the Federal Trade Commission or the states or the
  146. Securities and Exchange Commission can do to either required disclosure of environmental information or after the
  147. fact to allow the government to sue a firm for a false or misleading statement and so that's kind of the way that the
  148. First Amendment comes into play is sort of what are the outer boundaries of what
  149. the regulatory State can do to address this problem so in this era that we're in right now
  150. where uh social is playing such an even greater role uh in our communities and with the impact around around businesses
  151. how much impact you think a an expectation from the public or uh uh that that that social expectation how
  152. much do you think that that can actually play a role in changing the mind or changing the path of a company uh around
  153. some of these issues so I actually think it's playing a really important role I mean I think
  154. it's playing an important role in in sort of multiple different ways at one level there's like the organized social
  155. movement that's you know boycotting company X for not doing more on choose your issue whether it's
  156. environmental or social or the organized environmental movement you know or the organized movement on the other side
  157. boycotting the company that's doing too much right I mean so there's there's sort of that level
  158. I think that at a kind of More disaggregated Level there are empirical studies that show that consumers have
  159. expressed a greater willingness to pay for products that are more environmentally friendly
  160. um and the fact that you know I have colleagues at Wharton who's who have said and I think that they're right that
  161. as soon as we begin to live in a world in which the marketplace values environmentally
  162. friendliness we're likely to see not only genuine environmental friendliness but also greenwashing right because
  163. firms want to you know some of them it may be completely benign right they want to do something they're like seeing all
  164. of their industry you know competitors announcing these pledges and they're like oh we've got to do something and
  165. they don't necessarily know quite what to do and so they make the pledge and they're not quite ready to support it
  166. with the facts but you know if if they can kind of get on the bandwagon then you know nobody's going to be upset and
  167. then there's the like really you know intentional efforts to mislead um to hide you know and I think
  168. okay so then what do you think needs to occur then to be able to get kind of a more
  169. accurate picture of what companies are doing especially if they are not telling the truth absolutely so
  170. um so as a lawyer it's very important to me to work in at least one or two Latin
  171. phrases during our conversation and so here they are we have the right we have the X ante and we have the X post so X
  172. Auntie means before the fact X post means after the fact so often when we think about something like greenwashing
  173. we think about Expo who can sue the company when they've published the ad and the ad is misleading
  174. um that would be the FTC the Federal Trade Commission which has power under the Federal Trade Commission act to
  175. um go after companies that are engaged in deceptive uh marketing practices that affect Commerce and so the FTC has
  176. published something called the green guides which are its interpretation of how that statute applies to
  177. environmental marketing claim and the FDC just a couple of months ago requested and that sort of comment on
  178. how it needs to update the guides it hasn't updated them since 2012 it's due for an update I will be submitting you
  179. know some suggestions right um but at the end of the day that's the x-post that's there was an ad somebody thinks
  180. that it's misleading the FTC Sues and seeks you know cease and desist orders you know take down that ad and pay a
  181. penalty the ex-ante approach is the one that frankly I think is probably more important and more effective and that's
  182. the one that's embodied in the Securities and Exchange Commission um mandatory disclosure uh ideas right
  183. so last year the SEC um published a proposed rule on climate disclosures that would apply only to
  184. publicly traded companies but basically said that in their annual you know periodic report that in addition to all
  185. the other information that they need to disclose on an annual basis they also need to disclose their greenhouse gas
  186. emissions they need to disclose if they are have made a public commitment to reduce emissions how they tend to
  187. achieve that goal do they plan to use carbon credits and offsets Etc um we are now waiting for the SEC uh
  188. issued a proposed rule has accepted comments on the rule got many many many many comments and is now working its way
  189. through them and we're anticipating that sometime this spring um the SEC is going to publish a final
  190. rule which will immediately be litigated in the courts and so not going to come into effect immediately but the idea of
  191. disclosure and and I'm a big fan of disclosure is you know if we're putting more accurate
  192. factual information out into the marketplace not only does that deter companies from putting false or
  193. misleading information into the marketplace but it also gives us a better handle on sort of what companies
  194. are actually doing in a way that we can maybe do a better job of judging when claims are false or misleading
  195. right yeah do you think then do you think we're on on the right path in terms of really making some significant
  196. change uh in this area and having less green washing out there in you know kind of in the business public business
  197. community and with the public as well right so I think that the I think that if the SEC does go forward with this
  198. disclosure rule my understanding and you know the sort of the word on the street
  199. is that the final rule will probably be narrower than the proposed rule based on
  200. the comments but you know we'll have to see I think that it will be a step in the right direction
  201. um I you know I think that it's really really hard for Regulators to catch up with marketing right Regulators have to
  202. go through these really really long and tortured processes to publish a you know
  203. proposed Rule and then accept comment and then a final Rule and all in the meantime more and more claims are being
  204. made about you know the the greenness of our you know of our our Industries and um
  205. and so whether it'll stamp out the problem I don't know but I think that it it's a definite step in the right
  206. direction and probably a better one than just you know expecting that either the Federal Trade
  207. Mission or the states which have similar Powers um are going to go after every advertisement right that's a very that's
  208. a very um laborious process thank you for listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode
  209. informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  210. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the warden School

Brief Summary

This episode covers greenwashing, its legal implications, and the need for regulatory changes to ensure truthful environmental claims by companies.

Key points

  • Understanding Greenwashing. Greenwashing refers to misleading claims about environmental impact. It's crucial to discern the truth behind these statements.
  • The Role of the First Amendment. The First Amendment influences how greenwashing can be regulated, affecting both companies and consumers.
  • Consumer Willingness to Pay. Studies show consumers are more willing to pay for environmentally friendly products, impacting market dynamics.
  • SEC's Proposed Climate Disclosure Rule. The SEC is working on a rule requiring companies to disclose greenhouse gas emissions and reduction commitments.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes