Do Online Reviews Matter to Businesses?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Customer reviews affect the business of online marketplaces in surprising ways, Wharton research finds. More: http://knlg.net/2iYA7zK 📂 Management;Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here with chunchun who is an postdoc researcher with the Mac Institute for innovation management he's
  2. here to talk about his research looking into bilateral rating systems in online marketplaces welcome thank you for
  3. inviting me it's a great honor to be here to share my research with you can you tell us first about your work what
  4. are you trying to study so our paper is essentially trying to understand the impact of the rating
  5. systems on those online marketplaces so notice that a recent years the digital innovations in especially the rapid
  6. development of the mobile Internet of servers as well as the smart forms they have really changed people's everyday
  7. life so one of the greatest example is the sharing economies so the companies like uber and airbnb is so these
  8. companies works like a platforms that connects millions of online individual customers to millions of all fly
  9. individual service providers three very simple applications on their smartphones
  10. so notice that on the demand side of these platforms the count of the customers now is able to make orders at
  11. any time in any place and on the supply side the individual service providers now they can't decide when to work and
  12. how long to work on the platform it is because of these new technologies that removes their physical obstacles between
  13. two parties but on the other hand the psychological obstacles namely that the trust between the two parties is still
  14. there notice that the concept of trust is not a new is not a new concept but it and
  15. never play a important role as in the current economy context and the reason is because so the transactions that's
  16. going to happen on these platforms is between two or two parties of completely strangers and notice that because of
  17. these high liquidity of both parties people the customers and the service providers they are less likely to
  18. encounter with each other for more than once so what I mean is for example you are less likely to stay in the
  19. same accommodation listed on the Airbnb website and the reason is because probably you you want to change a
  20. different place to visit in your next of application right and even if your take
  21. the ubers to go to office every day still it is less likely that you meet the same driver so exactly because of
  22. this high liquidity of both side and also almost negligible entering cost of the supply side this create a big issues
  23. in establishing the trust and notice that the customers it is very difficult for the customer to judge how serious
  24. the service provides provider fears about his own business activity and the willingness to continue provide service
  25. in the long run okay and the rating system has been proved that it is an effective tool to
  26. establish the trust between two parties it is natural that people want to have reassurance from other users so that
  27. they can make sure that they didn't waste their money with the money on the bad products or better service it is the
  28. rating system that makes the waste of crowds available that brings the people who's completely stranger people's
  29. together to conduct business activities and our papers what we really are trying
  30. to understand is how this impact of these rating systems on the three parties of the game which is the
  31. platforms the service providers and also the the customers so what are your papers key takeaways and were there any
  32. conclusions that surprised you so we're still in the process of analyzing our model but we have I think we have
  33. already some interesting results to share with you so we first in the first stage we consider a platform without a
  34. rating system versus a unilateral rating system in a sense that only the customers is able to submit their
  35. ratings to the service providers and in a next stage we're going to analyze the bilateral rating system where both
  36. parties they can read each other after the transactions so currently what we found is that the rating systems will
  37. have different impact on the free party of the game the the service providers customers and the platform so from the
  38. less will talk about this one by one so first are from the perspective of the plat platforms
  39. we found that it is always their best interest to implement this rating systems and the underlying intuition
  40. behind is because by allowing the customers to read the service providers it makes the service providers have more
  41. motivations to exert more effort because now their effort is more transparent and
  42. observable through the ratings so these kind of make the customers feel a little
  43. bit happy because they get some extra utilities and this kind of in turn makes the other platforms more flexible in
  44. redesign is pricing strategy so for example right now the platform's is able to increase the price a little bit and
  45. also increase the fee charged by the a charge of from via the service providers a little bit so that's kind of both a
  46. boost of the revenue of their platform ok so that's for the platforms so then when we turn to the service providers
  47. one would attempt to think that these should get worse after the implementations of the rating systems
  48. and this is also what we think initially because simply because first they have to work harder because their effort is
  49. now observable and a second as the reason we just mentioned the platforms now going to increase the fee a little
  50. bit so it sounds like that the service provider they are in create double loss and it is true that for the year revenue
  51. per order they do get a decrease but this is not the whole story this is only part of the story and because we know
  52. that on average now the service providers there are making more effort so he's gonna attract more customers to
  53. use this platform to book service so that's indeed what we found so under some circumstances the transaction
  54. volume gonna increase so great such that is going to exceed the the loss of the revenue promoter so in that case the
  55. service provider is actually getting better due to the fact that they are being rated and the last part is for
  56. their customers so it is natural to think that after the implementation of the rating systems the customers are it
  57. should attract more customers to join this platform and however we found that it is actually not always the case and
  58. the reason is really deep on the pricing strategy of the platform and notice that the platform care about
  59. I care about two things one is the revenue per order the other is a transaction volume and you notice that
  60. usually there's a tension between these two factors so if you want to have a higher profit margin per order usually
  61. you cannot at the same time achieve the goal of having a high transaction volume
  62. right so okay so then what we found is that if the customers valuation about the service itself is at a pretty low
  63. level and then in that case the transaction volume plays a more important role versus Avandia the
  64. revenue per order to the platforms so in the in that case what the platform's gonna do is they're gonna they're gonna
  65. adopt a less aggressive pricing strategy such that it's gonna charge the fee from
  66. the server's a relatively lower and then it's gonna induce all the servers on the
  67. platform to exert some F some level of extra effort so that's got to make the customer feel happy so more customers
  68. gonna involve in these platforms and increase the transaction volume while on the other hand if the evaluation of the
  69. customers to the service itself is already pretty high so which means that they are already very satisfied with the
  70. service even if without any extra amount of effort by the service provider in this case we found that the revenue per
  71. order plays a more dominant role than the transaction volume so in this case the platform will adopt a very
  72. aggressive stress pricing strategy in a sense that is going to increase the fee charged from the service provider so
  73. that's gonna make only part of the service provider exert some extra amount of effort but
  74. the remaining service providers they were just produced the usual the the basic service without the actor effort
  75. and these kind of this amount of the service providers they're they just barely make a living on the platform so
  76. in this case the the customers the amount of customers that involving these platforms is actually lower than the
  77. system are they on the platform without a rating system that's that's our main findings what are some practical
  78. applications of your research okay based on our analysis first we know that okay it is it is always the best
  79. interest for the platform to implement such a rating systems and then a second in terms of his pricing strategies first
  80. we think that the platform should conduct some marketing research to gathers the informations about how the
  81. customers feel about the service itself so for example they need to know that what is the woodenness to pay off the
  82. customers to acquire this service and after they know this information they can identify which region of the the
  83. customers valuation falls in and then according to that information they know either they should adopt a aggressive a
  84. pricing strategy or a mild one okay so what sets your research apart from work in this area from prior work okay so for
  85. the previous or works and they can be described into two stream of literature's so the first string is they
  86. start at a perspective of the platforms they try to understand that the optimal pricing strategy of the platform but
  87. under the assumption that they they they think that the rating distribution or the effort distributions across the
  88. service they are pre pre given so they are not changed so this is the first string and a second string of the
  89. literature is they start from the precepts perspective of the service provider they try to understand the
  90. optimal decision of the service provider and under the assumption that the prices
  91. structure in the system is given and as you may have noticed that actually the the price decision of the platform and
  92. the decision of the service provider they are interrelated so they're going to affect each other and eventually
  93. they're going to reach an equilibrium so that that is our research we endure endure tonight both the a decision of
  94. the platform and also the decision of the service provider and also in the next stage were also endogenous the
  95. decision of the customers together so and solve for the equilibrium that's gonna give us a more complete picture
  96. about the system so how will you follow up your research okay yeah as we said that we're we're still are this is still
  97. a ongoing research so in the next stage we're gonna keep focused on analyzing the bilateral rating systems
  98. we're also the servers they can read back the customers and notice that lease is a very important feature in the
  99. platforms such that the customers there they are not just a purchase a physical product they actually purchase a service
  100. so in this case both the customers and the service providers they're going to interact with each other for some period
  101. of time it could be as short as a ride like uber or as long as couple of months like Airbnb so in this case that the
  102. service provider is also under the potential risks from the customer side because the customers misbehavior may
  103. may damage the the asset of the service provider like the service cars or house right so um and that's going to affect
  104. the server's future ability to provide a service so for the platforms like this where the customers they're buying
  105. service rather than a physical product a bilateral Reading System is needed and this is what we're going to focus in the
  106. next stage well thank you so much for joining us today okay thank you very much for inviting me
  107. you [Music]

Brief Summary

Chunchun discusses his research on how bilateral rating systems impact trust and pricing in online marketplaces like Uber and Airbnb.

Key points

  • Understanding Rating Systems. Research focuses on the impact of rating systems in online marketplaces.
  • Trust in the Digital Economy. Trust remains a critical issue in transactions between strangers online.
  • Key Findings on Service Providers. Service providers may benefit from rating systems despite initial concerns.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes