Innovation Networks

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Innovation 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. well to understand the study I think some background is useful right so companies especially high tech companies
  2. are facing two important trends one is the technology development is increasingly more complex so they have
  3. to partner with other companies more and more right to do R&D alliances and things like that the other one is that
  4. technology and ideas and markets are more globalized than ever so firms are not just having to do partnerships but
  5. international partnerships so you see companies involved in these global R&D networks now this can be very good but
  6. it also creates a bit of a dilemma for companies because on the one hand if you think about it if you have partners from
  7. all over the world and you're exposed to new ideas and new ways of doing things new business systems that can help you
  8. be very innovative on the other hand though you also have to manage a much more complex network so you have to deal
  9. with cultural differences legal differences institutional differences you name it right and so think you know
  10. of a pharmaceutical company and it has partners in the United States and Germany and Japan China India that
  11. sounds like a promising network in terms of innovation but it's also complex to manage so against that backdrop we
  12. really asked a very simple question we we thought well there there must be kind of an optimal mix of domestic and
  13. foreign partners in your network and how that affects your innovation okay so if
  14. you think of the most basic unit of a network which is a simple triad of firms where I'm the firm and I have two
  15. partners there's essentially three basic configurations everyone can be foreign everyone from a different country that's
  16. an all foreign triad or you can think of everyone being from the same country that's all domestic or a mix of foreign
  17. and domestic so our question was simply out of these three which one is best for innovation
  18. and to do that we had some data from the life sciences or biotechnology industry
  19. involving companies from 57 different countries and we studied the types and amount of patents that they produced
  20. from those partnerships so the key takeaway is it really depends on what kind of innovation you are
  21. trying to produce so when it comes to innovations that we call radical these are innovations that are path-breaking
  22. and they really break from the status quo in terms of the knowledge of the industry those innovations were most
  23. strongly associated with the all foreign partnerships with the all foreign networks not with the all domestic and
  24. not with the ones that have a mix of foreign and domestic in contrast if you're going to produce what we call an
  25. impactful innovation so this is an innovation that's more incremental it's still economically valuable but kind of
  26. preserves the status quo in terms of knowledge those were associated with having all domestic network partners in
  27. the R&D alliances not with all foreign or with the mix of foreign and domestic and the other interesting thing is that
  28. these general patterns hold even if we account for the ways in which countries are different so think of cultural
  29. differences or institutional differences or or anything like that so in a nutshell I think what it tells
  30. you is that if you're a manager that's in charge of global R&D and especially global R&D partnerships you have to be
  31. aware of the entire network and the mix of foreign and domestic partners and how
  32. that's affecting the types of innovations you produce and and the efficiency with which you can produce
  33. innovation and I say that because when I talk to managers often I see that firms
  34. are very good at what I call the dyadic level they're very good at when they're gonna form a partnership screening that
  35. partner making sure that they trust that partner that that partner brings something new but managers typically
  36. don't look beyond the Dyanne to consider the entire network and how the configuration especially the global
  37. configuration may may affect how innovative they are and what they're getting out of those partnerships the
  38. other interesting and practical thing is that it seems like you really have to commit so you either have to commit to
  39. sort of the all foreign or all domestic and this kind of mix the foreign and domestic partners isn't producing much
  40. for firms and of course that depends on what you expect to get out if you're going for the home run radical
  41. innovations it's really you you get that out of the the foreign partnerships and
  42. if you're going for more the incremental profitable type of innovations then those are going to come more from your
  43. domestic partnerships well I think a general statement is that the science of networks has advanced a
  44. lot in the last 20 years mathematically and in a lot of other ways what's interesting is that there's a gap
  45. between what we know about networks purely and how networks and globalization relate to one another
  46. but the paradox of course is that we see that firms are involved more and more in
  47. global networks so I like to close that gap a little bit so for example the study I just described tells us about
  48. the consequences are the outcomes of what you might get from international versus domestic networks a natural
  49. follow-up is to see if firms are doing something in in their network formation behaviors right do they account for
  50. differences across countries do they account for the global pattern of partnerships in the way they structure
  51. their relationships particularly when it comes to seeking for innovation and new
  52. ideas and knowledge the other thing that I think is important is just to understand not just if you're getting
  53. different things out of your networks but what are the underlying processes right why is it that it's hard to manage
  54. foreign partnerships and what can managers do to make that process more efficiency to overcome all those
  55. frictions in terms of culture and institutions and just the basic differences across countries to make
  56. these foreign partnerships that seem to be so valuable function more efficiently
  57. you

Brief Summary

Domestic and foreign partnerships affect innovation differently; radical innovations thrive on foreign networks while impactful ones come from domestic ones.

Key points

  • The Dilemma of Global Partnerships. Companies face a complex dilemma in managing international partnerships for innovation.
  • Optimal Mix for Innovation. The study explores the best mix of domestic and foreign partners for innovation.
  • Radical vs. Impactful Innovations. Different types of innovations require different partnership configurations for success.

Related episodes