Do You Know Your Team's PWR Score?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guests today are Randy Street and Alan Foster uh and they have just written a book called power score we're
  2. going to talk to them about that today uh Randy Alan thank you so much for joining us today it's our pleasure it's
  3. great to be here great Randy I'd probably start with the first question with you uh you describe power score as
  4. a as a grand United theory of leadership boiled down to a single number what exactly does does that
  5. mean so we've been on a journey for the last 20 years as a firm and as individuals U thinking about
  6. leadership um boards and CEOs would call us and say hey we're we're about to make
  7. a big leadership change or decision of some sort and we need help to figure out how do we get the right people so our
  8. our day jobs have been interviewing CEO candidates and uh senior leaders for organizations of all different shapes
  9. and sizes uh and each interview has been a 5H hour interview or so and then 15 hours of analysis around that uh and
  10. over the course of the last 20 years we've we've interviewed over 15,000 people and it occurred to us there's
  11. there's probably something to learn from that in terms of what what do successful
  12. leaders really do uh and over the last five years we've been digging deep into that data to understand it and what we
  13. have found is there are in fact three factors that drive success in leadership and we called the Grand unified theory
  14. uh very much like uh the way scientists describe the universe so scientists have
  15. been looking to figure out you know what is the grand unified theory of how the universe universe works and we figured
  16. if they can describe the universe surely we can describe leadership and in fact we've got these three factors that
  17. describe what success looks like absolutely so I'll turn to Alan to ask exactly what the power score is and how
  18. it's calculated and how did you come up with a concept what kind of research did
  19. you put into it yes so power score power is really an acronym the the P stands for priorities
  20. the W stands for Who and the r stands for relationships and uh as part of the 15,000 uh executive interviews that
  21. we've done over the last 20 years we we got a phone call about uh five years ago
  22. from Professor Steve Kaplan and a colleague of his at the University of Chicago he said aren't you sitting on
  23. what's probably the world's most valuable database of leadership I've got an Army of phds uh who I'd love to pour
  24. over it code it and analyze the heck out of it I bet we could learn something um
  25. are you up for that we said sure and uh and so we did and so they've been kicking the tires on on what really
  26. makes the difference and we actually had a whole different theory of leadership when we started writing the book but it
  27. the data the data didn't uh match it it didn't pan out so we we really had to say like what do leaders do differently
  28. and what we found is is they they all go about accomplishing three things they set the right priorities they get the
  29. right people in the right roles the right who the W and then they make the relationships work um the the the ARA
  30. relationships and so what we do with our with with the teams and the executives we work with is to say on a scale of 1
  31. to 10 uh to what extent you have the right priorities give yourself a score out of 10 to what extent do you have the
  32. right who the right people in the right roles score out of 10 and what extent do
  33. the relationships work again a score out of 10 and you've got three numbers out of 10 multiply them together and you've
  34. got yourself a score out of a thousand and that's the score we've been calculating with uh thousands of
  35. Executives to find out to what extent do they run at full power power being priorities who and relationships and
  36. what have you found so far of uh uh when you talk to Executives do you find that
  37. of all the three variables that make up the power acronym uh executives are good
  38. at all three or are they some that are they are better at than others so all three matter it's it's something like a
  39. triathlon if if you can't swim you're not going to win the triathlon and the same is true with the power score PW
  40. andr you have to be able to do all three and most leaders only do one or maybe two of those really well uh very few
  41. actually think to do all three much less are really good at all three but the stati statistics are amazing those who
  42. do all three well are easily twice as successful as the average leader and they're 20 times more successful than
  43. leaders who don't do any of those three things which of the three which is the easiest for most leaders to manage and
  44. which element of those three do they have the most trouble with so the easiest is definitely the r
  45. relationships so most leadership theories focus on behaviors and traits and how you should show up as a leader
  46. and that's all very important in leadership of course uh and so about half 47% of the leaders
  47. in our data set were reasonably good at building the the relationships that make
  48. a team function on the flip side uh the hardest one is the W the who which is hiring the right people uh removing
  49. people shifting people around on your team to make sure you've got the right people matched to the right priorities
  50. only 14% of leaders were excellent at that which means 86% of all leaders are completely ignoring one of the most
  51. important factors of being a successful leader which is getting that who question right it's funny and uh I was
  52. uh at a conference last week with about 150 CEOs and we were going through do you have the right priorities the right
  53. who the right relationships and at the end I say Okay a show of hands if you think about your score in each of those
  54. Dimensions the score you've given yourself which is the lowest which is pulling your overall score down the most
  55. and show of hands about 80% of the audience put up their hand for The Who as in like they struggle the most with
  56. getting the right people in the right roles interesting I i' come back to the who but let's let's start with the with
  57. the priorities uhan is are priorities the same as goals uh what's the difference well uh
  58. it's funny we we we had one client and and I said I said to the uh Chief Operating Officer um to what extent do
  59. you have the right priorities he said absolutely we do we we we we set goals I said well how many do you have and he
  60. said well I have 164 and and I said you know that that must keep you quite busy he goes yes
  61. we're a very inclusive culture we're very bottom up we like people to set their own goals I mean it was a it was a
  62. it was a high achieving environment but they had no focus at all and so we find the best leaders are very good at
  63. setting priorities which actually means saying no to things like it's looking at
  64. all your potential goals and saying which are the three four or five that really matter goals really are what
  65. needs to happen and that's great but they don't really give you a sense for uh which ones actually tie back to your
  66. mission and why why they're important or how they relate to one another so you can have 164 goals no sense of priority
  67. a lot of diffused Focus through the organization so how do you think leaders can become better at setting priorities
  68. how did this leader go go about it so we uh you can obviously hire consultants for uh um millions of dollars and I'm
  69. sure they'll come up with a a great presentation we we have a slightly simpler way we we encourage leaders and
  70. Leadership teams to write what we call a scorecard which is to say given the mission and vision of what you're trying
  71. to do what are the five priorities and how do you talk about them in terms of like uh if you fast forward two or three
  72. years and you're thrilled with what you've got done what will you have delivered and it forces people to
  73. talking numbers it forces people to to have trade-offs and then we get a CEO if they've done that to share that with
  74. their leadership team and then we find everyone has a different point of view and then you just lock the door and you
  75. don't let them out until they've actually had some of these tough conversations about what are we not
  76. going to do versus just what we are going to do how how do you think priorities are
  77. linked with purpose and can you give any examples of leaders who are able to tie
  78. their priorities to the reason why the organization exist we've been working with a toga one day
  79. who uh is using a lot of his thinking around the checklist Manifesto uh to apply to um some of the
  80. most complex diseases and Health Care Health Care issues and uh when we very first spoke to him he said we said like
  81. why do you exist and he said I am trying to save harm or suffering from More Than
  82. A Million Lives over the next three years and and he's written about that and he has founded a laboratory an
  83. innovation lab called ariadne labs and what we find is it's like putting up a beacon into the sky like the bat signal
  84. and and and surgeons and Medics and professionals flock from all over the world um because his his mission uh just
  85. resonates with them um and then he then goes from that to say what are his three
  86. to five priorities but it all links back from that sense of purpose his his mission of what he's trying to do
  87. um how can you uh decide if your team's priorities are clear and and effective so it's one thing to think
  88. you've got the right priorities but then to make sure that you transmit them through the organization is another
  89. challenge I had a client recently share with me that he he had a senior team get
  90. together and think through priorities and they all padded each other on the back and said oh we've got our
  91. priorities we all agree and then they had a conversation with the next level down in the organization and there was a
  92. little more debate what really are our priorities I'm not sure are we aligned here and then they took the conversation
  93. to the next level down and that group of people basically said what priorities uh so there's definitely a
  94. challenge in organizations as you go through to create Clarity and the first thing that you need to do is limit
  95. yourself to that that three to five you know five really is the absolute limit of priorities that that we as humans can
  96. process and remember uh and the second piece is communication so just constantly communicating these are the
  97. five things whenever something comes up that's outside of those priorities calling it out saying you
  98. know what that's interesting that might even be important we should look at that
  99. but not now it's not part of our priorities I had a client say another client say whenever someone comes to her
  100. with something that's off the list she says make me care if you can show me how that connects to and supports one of our
  101. five priorities then we should think about doing it but if you can't we're not going to do it we're not going to
  102. put resources behind it so it's a combination of shortening the list from 164 down to five and then communicating
  103. it constantly throughout the organization got it so now let's come to the really difficult part of the the
  104. power equation which is the who part how how can a leader select the right people
  105. for her or his team and make sure that they focused on the right priorities well you've actually begun to
  106. answer the question right there with that second piece which is make sure they're focused on the right priorities
  107. so uh the first mistake leaders make when it comes to hiring and thinking about their team is they're haven't even
  108. thought about their priorities in the first place assuming you actually have thought about your priorities the next
  109. question should not be how do we accomplish these priorities but rather who should accomplish these priorities
  110. which is where the the next big mistake comes most leaders don't think that they
  111. think about about the what questions and the how questions what do we need to do
  112. how do we need to do it rather than who do we need on the team to do it uh so question two is all about that who once
  113. you understand the priority who do we need on the team to accomplish it from there it's about following a structured
  114. process uh most leaders don't because they're not asking the right question in the first place uh and because they're
  115. distracted with all of the noise and you know the meetings and the conference calls and the 200 emails a day and all
  116. the other things coming along they don't put the actual energy into hiring the right people thinking about mapping
  117. their team to the right priorities and one of the things I found very interesting is you write in your book
  118. that this is the aspect of management that gives leaders the most heartburn uh how how can leaders become
  119. better at selecting the right people so it probably Begins by acknowledging what are all the mistakes
  120. that they typically make and on average uh nearly all the research proves that leaders are making mistakes about 50% of
  121. the time so half the time toss of a coin they're getting it wrong uh and they're
  122. using just a lot of um ill-informed techniques we call them uh uh Voodoo hiring uh uh tricks and uh for example
  123. uh should I be interviewing someone who is British and baling and has a slightly
  124. quirky sense of humor I'll probably think you know what they're pretty smart yeah I really like I can't put my finger
  125. on it but I really like that guy and we we tend to project ourselves onto the people that we see and yet we don't
  126. realize we have all these unconscious biases so the the very first part before you even get to like asking the correct
  127. questions is to acknowledge what are the mistakes that you're making right now but how do you go about removing
  128. underperformers and getting a players on your team how how how would you do that
  129. so first thing is understanding where you've got a B and C players if you want to use a sort of a classification system
  130. of your team and that goes back to the priorities Allan mentioned a little earlier a tool that we call a scorecard
  131. which basically just documents your priorities your mission and then the key priorities that you're pursuing uh and
  132. the best leaders actually take some time maybe once a quarter sit down look at the priorities map the team against them
  133. and ask the question how comfortable am I that these people are going to accomplish these things and if you have
  134. any doubt in your mind if there's a if you think well maybe it's 5050 that's not very good you're looking for a much
  135. higher degree of confidence 90% or even 100% degree of confidence that those people will accomplish those priorities
  136. I'm I'm thinking of uh the our client um Panos who uh who who took ry's advice and did exactly that and and he uh he
  137. emailed us about a year and a half ago and said uh you know what I've been following your advice we like well what
  138. advice would that be we can't remember and he said well every quarter I sit down and I map out who's my team if I
  139. was only allowed to have 50% of my people who's on my boat and then he goes okay now if I was allowed 75% of people
  140. who would I add to the team then he goes to 85% and then at 85% he goes who have
  141. I not who's not on this team who's not on this boat and he guys at that point I need to look in the mirror and ask
  142. myself some pretty tough questions about whether or not these are the right people moving forward and to make some
  143. tough decisions do you have any examples of leaders who do a really good job of managing The Who and I would love to
  144. know what they do differently than other leaders so from a a process perspective uh the best leaders that we
  145. work with start by thinking about their team against the priorities uh the second thing is they do remove the
  146. weaker people and in some cases that means moving them to a different place in the company or the organization uh
  147. and then third they get very aggressive about hiring um Kristen Russell comes to
  148. mind she is the uh former uh head of it in the state of Colorado and she had some big jobs at Oracle I believe and a
  149. couple of big uh big it shops she considers herself a chief recruiting officer she says you know I may be a CIO
  150. but my real job is cro chief Chief recruiting officer and she's constantly on the hunt for great talent constantly
  151. sourcing interesting people that she may be able to bring into her organization or maybe refer to other people uh within
  152. the organization or other organizations for that matter um and then she follows a structured process to actually hire
  153. those people as well which is the other piece of the magic so it's it's understanding that you need to have
  154. these people it's putting that Chief recruiter Hat on at all times then following a structured process to to
  155. hire them against the priorities it's funny when we did the analysis of if you look at every single
  156. executive we've ever interviewed and met and we look at what's the number one risk or regret of that of that executive
  157. the thing they wish they' done differently W by far the number one is I wish I had moved faster on the people I
  158. deep down knew weren't the right people on the team but we feel conflicted we feel like well maybe it's my fault
  159. they're not performing maybe I should give them one more chance maybe it will look bad it will look bad on me and so
  160. they we we're very good at justifying why tomorrow we'll probably be a different person we'll take action but
  161. just for the just for the moment let's just keep the team as it is um I wonder if you could since you
  162. talk about recruiting uh uh discuss a little bit about the interview process and what are
  163. some of the most common errors you find the voodoo hiring the voodoo hiring that
  164. people make and and and how can you eliminate those errors from the from the interview process sure so I we can maybe
  165. banter back and forth on this because this is this isent of them Rich territory one that comes to mind uh that
  166. I think is very very common is the hypothetical question we call it the fortune teller mol what would you do if
  167. you joined our team which right now is a little dysfunctional how would you fix it it's it's a forward-looking question
  168. and the problem is you get hypothetical answers so if you were to ask me you know Randy um I understand that you you
  169. followed the uh the space shuttle and the Apollo program when you were a kid how would you get to the moon I could
  170. actually answer that question I know how to get to the Moon how to get to the moon but I couldn't get you to the
  171. Moon uh and the same is true here you could based on your education based on examples you've seen you could make
  172. things up and unfortunately that's not really a predictor of how somebody will behave their past performance is a
  173. predictor but not some projection of the future so don't ask hypothetical questions what's another good one
  174. Alan another another voodo technique that we see is um what we call the the Sutter and this is when you know you've
  175. got a good candidate in front of you and you feel immense pressure to try and impress them and to somehow make them
  176. join your company so you talk and you tell them how great it is and why you joined and you you're just trying to
  177. sell them and then you get to the end of 40 minutes and you've forgotten to ask them any questions any difficult and
  178. you're like well I I quite liked them but I probably should have got a bit deeper um and and and we find that all
  179. too often happens again we're trying to get the data to understand what's this person really about and does that mean
  180. they're going to be able to accomplish my priorities or not one last one to mention it's what Allan mentioned about
  181. that strange attraction he has to the balding men when he's like balding British men I think they're going to be
  182. really good in the job we tend to be art critics you know you you see the painting on the wall you like it for
  183. some reason you can't really tell why it's just something you like and so you end up hiring that person uh it could be
  184. a common interest or common background or something and you end up hiring people not based on what they're able to
  185. do for you and with your team but based on some gut feel that's not substantiated by any real data I had a
  186. client last week and and I said well why did you give the offer to the CFO and and the CEO said to me say he
  187. was reassuringly tall that may be true but that's not the same person who can close the books on
  188. time execute on the m&a or the things you actually need them to get done so let let's turn now to the r part of the
  189. of of of the power uh score uh how how can leaders develop relationships that actually deliver
  190. results as you write in your book yeah that's right um we we we find that uh um I don't know about your calendar but
  191. mine is full of meetings and it always has been and they seem to be getting more frequent and longer and um we find
  192. that this is true across across uh America and around the world people are just putting stuff into my calendar and
  193. what we're finding is often the wrong people are coming together at the wrong time to talk about the wrong things in
  194. an unstructured way and you know meetings lack healthy conflict they lack any sense of coordination and forward
  195. progress and so one of the number one things we do is um having good relationships isn't about just liking
  196. one another it's about how do we get coordinated here how do we bring the right people together at the right time
  197. and probably half your meetings should be uh 30 minutes shorter and some of them should be much longer um and most
  198. of us our calendars uh look the same as they kind of did two years ago and we don't update like who are we talking to
  199. and when and why so getting coordinated is one of the the key thrust the other two big ones are uh building commitment
  200. with your team and challenging your team uh and this is where most leadership theories and leadership books and uh
  201. programs really focus their energy on these two things building commitment is all about building commitment uh Mutual
  202. commitment with one another uh commitment to the organization and the cause commitment to the leader uh and
  203. there's obviously a wide range of things that you as a leader can and should do chief among those is how you show up as
  204. a leader so this is where role modeling comes in and following through on commitments and getting things done as a
  205. leader uh comes in and how you how you set the stage to enable that team to create Mutual commitment and then the
  206. challenging piece is how do you challenge the team to be their very best this is where motivation and inspiration
  207. comes in this is where uh you begin to push people beyond what they think they can do on their own and to see what's
  208. possible to do when you bring the collective talents together into a group so getting coordinated as Allan shared
  209. and then working to help the team commit and challenging them those three levers
  210. really seem to uh be the big ones that that form the relationships where 1 plus 1 equals 5 and you get that multiplier
  211. effect in terms of results so I mean there are so many meetings that I have attended and I'm sure that you may have
  212. attended uh simply are about status updates uh C can you suggest some ways that meetings can become more meaningful
  213. MH yeah so we uh we believe in healthy conflict we think that there needs to be if you're
  214. not feeling slightly awkward or you know if you can't feel uh you you you leaning
  215. forward um then then you're probably talking about the wrong things like this is not about process updates and and uh
  216. and scheduling and the rest of it this is about how do we cut to the thing where we fundamentally disagree where
  217. reasonably smart people disagree let's talk about that and you want to see drama and and if it's not memorable then
  218. then then you should probably shift the agenda so what a tool gnd who we spoke about earlier did actually threw he blew
  219. up the status meeting completely threw it out and and basically said to everyone you have to submit a problem
  220. that we're going to solve and this is going to be a problemsolving meeting rather than a status update and at first
  221. you know people were very uncomfortable with that over time it has become electrifying for the team I think
  222. because now they're coming together to actually tackle real issues solve real problems not give each other status
  223. updates which could be read on an email or shared in another format how how important is commitment to a
  224. team success and do you think it's inborn or can lead us created go ahead Alan yeah yeah so we
  225. um let me think um we we believe commitments really important uh if you uh if you don't feel
  226. like your colleagues have your back then you're you're really going to be um FL foundering um you know we we see the
  227. most committed teams have actually really gone through some pretty tough times so they haven't just been out on a
  228. Sunday drive with the sun shining they've actually you know been to Helen Back um and as like as Winston Churchill
  229. said like If You're Going Through Hell keep going and and so um we find the most committed teams have either had
  230. this incredible like Crucible moment where they've leared to work together but we also find other leaders they try
  231. and accelerate that process and that discussion and some of the best leaders we know they say at some point this
  232. project this team it's going to suck it's going to be terrible like it's going to be a we don't know what it's
  233. going to be now when that happens upon what can we rely on in each other and and having that conversation ahead of
  234. time almost like rehearsing for the bad times uh can really make the difference two two leaders coming to mind one is
  235. caperton flood who is actually a former colleague of ours at uh banan company and he actually has that conversation
  236. upfront when the case team comes together what Mutual commitments are we willing to make to each other as we do
  237. this project uh and this is when people will say well you know what I I prefer not to work past 8:00 pm because I've
  238. got children and I want to be putting them to bed well what happens if the client calls and there's an urgent
  239. matter so they actually problem solve that before they even get into the real life scenario so that's the rehearsing
  240. uh that Allen was sharing and they they drafted up and signed this document this
  241. is what we're committing to so that's one version another coming to mind is John zilmer uh John zilmer uh uh at one
  242. point was in in charge of a division of Aramark and when he inherited it his boss said hey you know John is taking
  243. this on he's going to be the caretaker of this business and John thought caretaker I don't want to be a caretaker
  244. and it was a poorly performing business and he didn't want to caretake this poorly performing business so he took
  245. his team his new team offsite and basically shared all of the results from the past year which weren't particularly
  246. good and they said all right I want you to come back tomorrow at 8:00 a.m. and we're going to do something and wear
  247. your gym shorts and the leaders were thinking gym shorts uh oh they show up the next day in their gym shorts a van
  248. takes them out to a skip Barber racetrack so this is kind of that classic team building and they have a
  249. wonderful day racing cars together and when they come back John all right looks like you can learn new tricks so what I
  250. want to know is what are you willing to do as a team what's possible here and over the next few hours this group of
  251. people actually began to challenge one another and they came up with goals that were actually greater than what John had
  252. envisioned and over the course of the year he fostered it so he said all right here's the deal if we can accomplish
  253. these goals we're going to come back next year we're do the we'll do the three-day racing
  254. course so first quarter they were making their numbers John sent them racing gloves and a note that said
  255. congratulations second quarter they're still making their numbers he sends them the racing suit with their their names
  256. on it third quarter they're making their numbers he sends them the the helmet and
  257. sure enough they make it they they show up the next year and they did this this wonderful three-day program and it was a
  258. just a wonderful Testament of how a leader almost manufactured commitment in a team that didn't have it by creating a
  259. shared experience and building on that shared experience that they took ownership of and
  260. ultimately delivered the results against so let's as a last question try to put it all together because I think
  261. we could keep talking about this for a long time uh if you look at all the three elements that youve talked about
  262. the P the W and the r how can leaders improve the power score of their teams so what we're finding with our a
  263. lot of our clients is they sit down and they have a conversation with their team
  264. and they said what's our power score to which the team said what on Earth are you talking about H and and then he
  265. explains it said okay everyone get out a piece of paper uh get out of pen and now
  266. write down a number between 1 and 10 as the answer to these questions to what extent do we have the right priorities
  267. do we have the right who the right people in the right roles and do the relationships work and then they all
  268. held up their scores multiply them together multiply your three numbers together all the scores
  269. are different and it's and and it Fosters a lot of curiosity and puzzlement and like really you scored it
  270. a four I scored it of nine that's and then and then it leads to the right discussion and what our best clients do
  271. is they don't just have that as a one-off conversation it becomes something they actually begin to track
  272. monthly or on a quarterly basis once you identify what's what's so the beauty of the power score going back
  273. to the Grand UniFi theory is it does highlight where you have an issue so if your overall power score is
  274. 432 uh what are you going to do about it where are you weaker is it the priorities aren't clear is it that the
  275. who aren't right is it the relationships aren't working it very quickly allows you as a leader and as a team this is by
  276. the way a leader with his or her team exercise not something you do in a vacuum so the whole team can look at
  277. that and say what do we need to do how do we go from 432 to 500 to 600 to 700 and up uh it becomes an enormously
  278. clarifying vehicle for identifying the issues and focusing in on those those issues that will drive the results and
  279. the beauty of it is the research shows if you can drive the P the W and the r you will get results you'll be more
  280. successful than the average leader and the average team by orders of magnitude and that's where the fund starts great
  281. well that's a great note to end on So Randy Allan thank you so much for speaking with knowledge at Wharton our
  282. pleasure thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Randy Street and Alan Foster discuss their book <i>Power Score</i>, outlining a framework for effective leadership based on priorities, people, and relationships.

Key points

  • The Power Score Explained. Randy and Alan introduce the concept of Power Score, a metric for leadership success.
  • The Importance of Priorities. Leaders often struggle with setting the right priorities, impacting their effectiveness.
  • Hiring the Right People. Most leaders fail to hire effectively, often ignoring the importance of the 'Who'.
  • Transforming Meetings. Shifting from status updates to problem-solving can electrify team dynamics.
  • The Power of Commitment. Committed teams thrive through tough times, fostering mutual support and resilience.
  • Measuring Team Effectiveness. Using a power score helps teams identify strengths and areas for improvement.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes