Lessons from the Nepal Earthquake

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. We're here with Warren Professor Howard Kruther who will talk about the implications of the earthquake in Nepal
  2. and the lessons it holds for other countries around the world. Welcome professor. Good to be with you Deborah.
  3. Well to first of all tell me what lessons do you think the United States and other countries can learn from what
  4. happened in Nepal and how they can better prepare for disasters? Well, first let me just say a word about
  5. Nepal if I could in the sense that this is an unbelievably devastating earthquake for the country and they are
  6. trying to recover and we will have to we can get into that a little later on but
  7. I did want to at least acknowledge the fact that they really are a country that has some challenges and are going to try
  8. to meet them. But in the context of the lessons for other countries, I think that what happened in Nepal is something
  9. that happens everywhere in the world. If something doesn't happen for a long period of time, it isn't going to happen
  10. to me is is basically how people feel. And Nepal had a very serious earthquake 80 years ago. And it was it did
  11. devastate the country. And in the process, of course, people were a little bit more reluctant to think about the
  12. fact that an earthquake could actually occur in the future. And that is certainly true here in the United States
  13. as well. People do not take preparations for uh disasters until after they happen. And the countries that have
  14. actually learned from earthquakes may do a bit better. And Chile being one example of that. Mhm. Can you tell me
  15. more about the extraordinary steps that Chile took in order to prepare for disasters? Well, Chile is a country that
  16. has had a number of earthquakes and we were very fortunate, my colleagues Mike Yuseim and Awan Michelle Kjan and myself
  17. to have had access to a number of the top leaders in Chile, including former President Pinera to really look at
  18. essentially how they had recovered from uh the 19 the 2010 earthquake that was a
  19. very serious one. And the reason that they were successful with respect to recovering from that earthquake is that
  20. they had two features that I think are very important. One is that they had a past history of a number of earthquakes
  21. and they had learned from them and as a result of that they had taken steps including well- enforced building codes,
  22. people purchasing earthquake insurance to protect themselves. And the second is that they had leadership in the context
  23. of the new president who came in actually was sworn in two weeks after the earthquake and his leadership
  24. actually was enormously important and the our book called leadership dispatches really highlights that point.
  25. So how do you compare what happened in Chile to how the US government handled hurricane Katrina and hurricane Sandy
  26. for example? Well, hurricane uh Katrina was a real challenge as I think we know.
  27. There were levies that were really poorly designed. Uh and as a result, there was an enormous amount of damage
  28. and there were real challenges in the recovery process. And as a result, not only were a number of people killed as a
  29. result of that, but it took quite a while for the and still in the process of actually restoring uh elements of the
  30. city uh because of that damage. Are there certain states like such as California that actually do an
  31. extraordinary job of disaster preparedness? California does a remarkable job of of preparedness for
  32. earthquakes because they've had a number of earthquakes and they've learned from
  33. those earthquakes and as a result there is a lot of measures in place that will I think reduce the damage. Although I
  34. will say that very few people today only 10% of the California residents have earthquake insurance. So there's going
  35. to be an interesting question as to what's going to happen if we do have a severe earthquake in terms of their own
  36. recovery. So from that vantage point, preparation on the part of the residents is is relatively uh in ineffective at
  37. the moment. When it comes to less developed nations, there's always the struggle to prioritize funding for
  38. immediate needs versus funding for uh future uh disasters. So what can a uh a developing country do to make sure
  39. they're uh prepared for disasters but at the same time they fund ongoing needs of
  40. the country. Right? Well, let's talk about Nepal as an example of that since they went through this very horrendous
  41. uh earthquake. Nepal actually did take some steps uh in the sense that many of the newer buildings were really enforced
  42. uh were built according to building codes that were enforced and to my knowledge and of course we'll find that
  43. out in in in the next week or so most of them did not suffer as a a large amount
  44. of damage uh and as a result of that I think you can the the city is at least KMU in the area was better prepared on
  45. the newer construction the challenge with a country like Nepal as we've all heard and and read about uh is that they
  46. have so many old buildings and a city like Bakapore outside of Kotmandu which historic treasures was really badly
  47. damaged and Kotmandu itself was damaged. I I should indicate uh I've learned a great deal about Nepal because my
  48. daughter Laura Kruther uh is an anthropologist who has studied Nepal and is obviously I've been there a few times
  49. for that reason and uh I'm tremendously impressed with the Nepales and their ability to sort of deal with the
  50. situation but we have discussed this since the earthquake and I think the general challenge that the country has
  51. is the leadership side and we'll have to wait and see how the government is going
  52. to have to deal with these issues because in a you do need leadership. Uh that's what Chile had. It's harder for a
  53. developing country. Haiti had enormous challenges after uh their earthquake. Uh Nepal is in far better shape in that
  54. sense than Haiti was where over a 100,000 people were killed. Uh the death toll is 5,000. That's a large number,
  55. but really pales compared to what happened in Haiti. So I think we'll have to wait and see whether the government
  56. is going to be in a position to be able to take advantage of the situation. We do learn from catastrophes and there are
  57. the silver lining is you can do things better after a catastrophe than you can before. And let me give you one example
  58. in the United States just to highlight that uh before Hurricane Andrew that occurred in 1992. So a few years back
  59. now uh onethird of the buildings were built that did not satisfy building codes that the and they would have been
  60. saved had they met the codes and Florida was really not enforcing these codes. There was a wakeup call for Florida
  61. after hurricane Andrew and today they have the best building codes in the country or one of the best. So they
  62. learned from the disaster and the hope is that the developing countries can also learn and we're all hoping that
  63. Nepal can come out of this with a better understanding of how they're going to have to deal with disasters.
  64. In your opinion, what are some of the biggest mistakes that developed nations make when it comes to disaster
  65. preparedness? Well, I think the biggest mistakes and I wouldn't even call them mistakes. I think it's more in the
  66. context of constraints as you alluded. They don't have a lot of resources. So it's hard to all of a sudden say we are
  67. going to build everything so sturdy that will be prevented from another disaster.
  68. That's why the fact that new buildings in Nepal were built according to to code is a testimony to the fact that the
  69. country is doing that. Haiti for example did not have any building codes at all and a lot of the destruction occurred
  70. because of that. So it's the lack the resources and the constraints that really are a challenge and I think
  71. that's why in some sense uh you do need organizations like the World Bank uh to help out in in situations like that to
  72. maybe try to support uh these situations from the vantage point of individuals. They have a very similar problem. There
  73. are so many other things on their mind that it's very that are immediate needs that it's very very hard for them to
  74. devote time and resources to try to even think let alone deal with what they could do for a disaster. What about for
  75. developed nations? What are some of their biggest mistakes? Well, I think the biggest mistakes that that we face
  76. in in our country is what I alluded to earlier. the feeling that somehow it isn't going to happen to me and as a
  77. result I don't have to worry about this and that the costs associated with actually taking steps now are too high
  78. for us to put the resources in. And this is an issue that we have all of us have
  79. been thinking very very uh uh closely and deeply about in in the in the Wharton risk center. How do you begin to
  80. develop essentially strategies that are long-term that essentially are long-term
  81. in nature but that satisfy the shortrun needs? And so I think there are ways to begin to think about that and the
  82. develop hopefully the US will try to adopt some of these which is begin to think about long-term loans for example
  83. as a way of really spreading the upfront costs over a number of years. think about affordability issues and how
  84. you're going to deal with affordability in a way that will encourage essentially
  85. development in areas, but at the same time recognize that you have to be careful in terms of what you do and you
  86. have to make sure that you take care of people who can't afford a very high insurance premium. If there's a high
  87. premium that reflects risk and you have to help them out, but don't do it with an insurance premium, try to find other
  88. ways like means tested vouchers or some other mechanism that helps the low-income people because otherwise I
  89. think we're going to be in real real difficulty with respect to implementing some of these strategies that we all
  90. believe are desirable. What regulatory changes do you recommend that the US government take to make these remedies?
  91. Well, I think building codes being one example certainly not only with respect to earthquakes but with respect to
  92. floods and other disasters, making sure that buildings are welld designigned, that they are well enforced. Land use
  93. regulations are important with respect to that. And I'll tell you one regulation that we have been thinking a
  94. great deal about is related to insurance. And there is a general feeling that you need to subsidize
  95. premiums to help the low-income people as I alluded to. And one of the things that could be done and we feel is
  96. important let the insurance premium reflect the risk so that people know what they have to pay for to cover their
  97. risk and they also get rewarded. If it turns out that they take steps to reduce the risk they get a lower premium. So
  98. the premiums reflecting risk becomes important but then you have to feel figure out what you're going to do with
  99. the low income and the people who can't afford it or who need special treatment.
  100. That sounds logical but what is impeding these changes on the regulatory side. Well I think what's impeding it is we
  101. are all you know people are thinking purely about the short run in many of their decisions. We have a little
  102. expression that we've used and since you're asking this question I will use it here. Uh nimto behavior which is true
  103. of probably all of us but certainly true of politicians. Any idea? Can you explain? Not in my term of
  104. office if I can avoid that. And so thinking very short run makes it very very hard to deal with some of these
  105. long-term issues unless you can figure out a way to get rewards in the short run. And then I think in the United
  106. States uh certainly we have a certain degree of polarization in terms of different views on how to deal with this
  107. and that makes it very hard to get anything passed as we are aware of and hopefully that will change over the next
  108. couple of years and we'll just have to wait and see. Thank you professor. Good to be with you.
  109. [Music]

Brief Summary

Professor Kruther discusses disaster preparedness lessons from the Nepal earthquake and compares recovery efforts with Chile and the U.S.

Key points

  • Lessons from Nepal's Earthquake. Professor Howard Kruther discusses the implications of Nepal's earthquake for global disaster preparedness.
  • Chile's Disaster Preparedness. An exploration of how Chile successfully prepared for earthquakes and the lessons learned.
  • Comparing US Disasters. A comparison of how the US handled Hurricane Katrina and Sandy versus Chile's approach.
  • Challenges for Developing Nations. Discussing the struggle of developing countries to prioritize disaster preparedness amidst immediate needs.
  • Mistakes of Developed Nations. An analysis of the biggest mistakes made by developed nations in disaster preparedness.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes