Is the Reshoring of U.S. Manufacturing a Myth?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

While it’s true that some companies are bringing manufacturing back to the U.S., just as much new outsourcing is underway, according to new Wharton research. More: http://knlg.net/1bexyUl 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. uh I'm engaged now in this uh very ambitious research project a benchmarking research project with a
  2. Consortium other universities to address three fundamental questions about the sourcing of manufacturing on a global
  3. scale we're interested in a what are companies doing where are they sourcing manufacturing are they changing the
  4. locations the countries where they're sourcing manufacturing years past many went to
  5. China and low labor cost countries in Asia and we've seen changes in relative labor costs and there's been predictions
  6. that we'll see an immense amount of reshoring and yet on the other hand we see major restructuring going on and so
  7. there's confusion as to what in fact companies are doing second is why companies doing it what are the main
  8. reasons for doing this and is there some dominant reason like labor cost or technology or does it depend on exactly
  9. where they're going who they are what technology and the third which is the hardest to answer is what is going to be
  10. the impact of this in terms of jobs in terms of economic efficiency in terms of growth and market share so that is what
  11. we're trying to address to give it a sound empirical basis by benchmarking leading companies all over the world and
  12. asking them based on the actual decisions that you have made in the last two or three years affecting the sh the
  13. sourcing and Manufacturing tell us what you've done why you did it and what the impact either was or expected to
  14. be couple of take takeaways from our research number one there is an unprecedented amount of restructuring
  15. going on companies are addressing the question of how and where to produce products and they're opening factories
  16. they're closing factories they're shifting employment so there's just been a lot of change going on uh number two
  17. that change is hap is not in One Direction it's not everybody reshoring back to the US or to Europe it's not
  18. everybody offshoring again to Asia or to China uh South America Eastern Europe uh
  19. you know every part of the world is engaged and we see companies making a range of decisions for what seems to be
  20. a variety of reasons so what is there's a lot of change but it's a very complicated picture so we need to
  21. understand where where it's happening and why it's happening first of all it seems pretty
  22. clear that predictions of wholesale reshoring back to you know Market related countries Like Us Canada Europe
  23. is not happening on a large scale it is happening and in selected Industries you
  24. know it's it's a major thing but just as much as companies are returning there are other situations where companies
  25. continue to Offshore either to Asia or to other parts of the world so that is number one headline that it's not a
  26. simple Flowback there's a complicated pattern of flows that's occurring some are
  27. leaving some are coming some are going to different locations I'd say that was the main
  28. observation the other thing is the we asked for the the the drivers of these decisions and we we offered a variety of
  29. possible choices so it's not just labor cost is it access to Market is it worry about intellectual property is it
  30. government incentives is it Technology robotics automation is it access to labor market we had about over 20
  31. possible different factors and we ask companies we had a very unique way of of pursuing this in the Benchmark it's very
  32. difficult to ask a company the question where should you be producing your product just think about
  33. that that's a very complicated question it involves all parts of the company there are many players involved and the
  34. decision is companies make multiple decisions and so we saw companies were sometimes doing what look like
  35. contradictory things while they were going in One Direction they were also going in the other direction and so we
  36. decided that the only way we could get a handle on this was to use as a unit of analysis the decision what decisions
  37. have you made give us examples of decisions and explain to us why you made that decision and so our observation is
  38. based on a sample of decisions drawn from these companies which is a very different way of doing a benchmark
  39. instead of asking the company what are you doing what are you thinking what are your what are your you know your
  40. priorities were saying you made a decision tell us why you made it and that gave us the ability to ask much
  41. deeper and more nuanced questions and we learned a lot from that so I don't think I was surprised
  42. that reshoring was dominant other people have noticed this already and there you
  43. know there have been Publications what surprised me was that companies were making often times what seemed seem to
  44. be opposite decisions I'm going to go to China I'm coming back from China same company simultaneously making what seem
  45. to be opposing decisions and when you ask them why they would give the same reasons it's because of labor cost it's
  46. because of Market access it's because of this and that and this at first surprised us and then we thought about
  47. it and said well no we understand this because you know this is an area you know that has been studied we have
  48. modeled Global Supply Chain strategy decisions for a long time you know I've worked in this problem over the
  49. years and what it it came the conclusion it's not an easy conclusion to to maybe
  50. Express but companies seem to be going through very complex or at least involved
  51. tradeoff and risk analyses they're taking into account multiple factors and depending upon what is dominant in a
  52. particular case for a particular product it could push them in one direction or the other direction they're doing all
  53. these different things because they're evaluating these decisions and they're making tradeoffs because they can no
  54. longer view it as a no-brainer they have to use their brain they have to analyze
  55. this problem and so what I saw which I think it was surprising and I think gratifying that there the level of
  56. analysis that seems to be going on is is actually quite deep well I think the the main misperception
  57. is there is no one dominant reason and you know the one that everybody talks about is labor cost you know our labor
  58. costs are are not going up and therefore you know this is going to drive everybody back that was that a lot of
  59. people have proposed that another one is it doesn't matter what labor costs are because everything's going to be
  60. automated so the robots are going to make the product it doesn't matter what the human labor cost is um so I think
  61. that we found that that is it's not that simple another thing that surprised us is that the places like China and Asia
  62. and parts of South America have become very attractive not just because of low labor costs but because of high quality
  63. because of access to markets that seem to be a major driver a lot of companies are going into China not so much because
  64. they want to save money but because they want to have access to that huge market
  65. and the only way they can have effective access is to be there on the ground so you know these are all valid reasons and
  66. once you look at them it doesn't surprise you that this is happening but it's not just chasing a low labor cost
  67. or getting rid of Labor and using robots it's not that simple and what that some
  68. of these developing countries are attractive for reasons like quality and Market access which we you know nor
  69. don't hear about so much well I think that uh the this this wave of restructuring that is definitely
  70. occurring I mean every day you see press releases from companies saying we've shifted our production from A to B from
  71. country A to B this is happening and it's continuing to happen and governments are continuing to to put
  72. pressure on companies to bring job jobs home to bring activity home and and the stakes couldn't be larger and the issues
  73. have become more and more focused and I think so I think that this problem not that it has ever gone away you know it's
  74. always been a part of overall strategy is become you know is going to continue to be with us and as we see technology
  75. developing as we see markets evolving as we see different labor forces going through different demographics and
  76. different uh you know having different prices uh that companies are going to have to be
  77. on an ongoing basis evaluating these decisions and be prepared to make changes and I think that's the main
  78. takeaway at a practical level well I think one of the most uh publicized stories has been the General
  79. Electric story having to do with Appliance Manufacturing in Kentucky so um you know not so many years back G
  80. decided to more or less shut down that activity at Appliance Park which was the the major manufacturing center for
  81. appliances this is the white goods appliances refrigerators stoves things of that sort and um shifted it overseas
  82. to Asian countries and they announced with great Fanfare that they were I think going to
  83. invest a billion dollars in reopening those plants and hiring American workers and reshoring so it was one of the major
  84. examples of the reshoring phenomenon and things have not gone so smoothly there was a recent article I think in the
  85. Sloan management review uh by professor shei of harvon or yeah I think with slow
  86. management review evaluating you know the bumps in the road that g has encountered in trying to do that uh it's
  87. not so easy to find skilled workers American workers don't want to work in factories anymore when they hired them
  88. after 3 days they had to fire them because they said this is what you want me to do I don't want to do this so they
  89. had an enormous turnover uh people aren't trained to think that way anymore so I think that
  90. um will we ever go back to where we were I don't think so but at the same time you know we have new technologies and
  91. new products and New Opportunities so I I'm not pessimistic about the opportunities for the future but they're
  92. not going to be based on what we did in the past and so the G story is quite instructive they had trouble finding uh
  93. skilled workers retaining those workers there was a big issue of of uh labor cost the union made major concessions
  94. that they could hire people to enter at PRI at wage rates that were lower than they normally would have required
  95. otherwise it wouldn't have worked and even in spite of that it you know it's been it's been a tough go so I think
  96. that that that's one instructive example that it's not so easy to pull this off and there are a lot of issues to look
  97. at okay so you take your iPhone from Apple uh I labor cost is clearly under 10% and so you could argue it doesn't
  98. really matter what happens to the labor cost in China or Thailand with respect to their cost of the product it's more
  99. important that they can de velop new products and have access to flexible high capacity highquality manufacturing
  100. and that the the actual labor cost is it's not that it's insignificant but it's not the most important
  101. factor on the other hand take the apparel industry which is labor intensive to this day we see Chinese
  102. companies Outsourcing to Vietnam because labor costs in Vietnam are lower than in
  103. China we see Chinese this is what we've seen in our surveys we actually have you
  104. know results that Chinese companies are going from the coast where cost of living and wages are high to the
  105. interior where it's cheaper so they're not leaving the country they're just going to another place and so it depends
  106. very much on what the product is what the cost composition is what type of technology and these are the things that
  107. we found in our survey that these kinds of factors either for the product or the
  108. technology are significant and different answers therefore are generated in different Industries and some go this
  109. way and some go that way labor cost may drive me if I'm in an apparel industry but if I'm in a high-tech industry not
  110. so much on the other hand take Aerospace and defense another industry we looked at there are companies like uh
  111. Rolls-Royce that only makes products in the highest labor cost countries in the world the US Great Britain and Norway
  112. you can't find countries in the world with higher labor costs and that's where they make their engines talking about
  113. aircraft engines and Marine products and they'll argue that that's where they have access to the skilled labor and
  114. that they couldn't find the labor that they needed in other countries even if the wages are lower so it may not so
  115. labor is also probably not a major component of the cost of building an aircraft engine but you you got to have
  116. skilled labor it becomes essential so again it illustrates how the tradeoff come into play and how industry and
  117. product and Technology factors become very important so one interesting thing we
  118. observed in our survey is that companies in capital intensive Industries in some
  119. cases are moving their production into China and to some that may be viewed as counterintuitive because you know you
  120. think of going to China and Asia as places you know where labor costs have a bigger or more or more
  121. dominant and that Capital intensive products with high in you know Advanced Technologies aren't the places that you
  122. would go and so part of the explanation for that is you can no longer view countries like China or or Brazil for
  123. that matter or countries in Eastern Europe as being places where you have unskilled labor they have highly skilled
  124. labor and they're very anxious to expand into these high-tech Industries China is
  125. investing billions to build up its Aerospace and defense Industries commercial aircraft they're build you
  126. know they're they're they're competing directly with Airbus and Boeing for regional Jets at least they've announced
  127. you know that they're going to do that and so there are highly skilled labor forces now in places like China and uh
  128. they may be cheaper and they may be just as good so we can no longer you know fall back on this comfortable notion
  129. that well you know when it comes to these types of jobs we can't find them even though some companies will tell you
  130. like Rolls-Royce we have to be in these highly developed countries because that's where we find our labor some of
  131. their competitors don't agree with that you know Sikorski is a company that has gone the other way you know and so it's
  132. just fascinating how in the same industry with the same products and the same Technologies some will choose to go
  133. in One Direction and some will choose to go in the other Direction so that suggests that their local evaluation of
  134. the tradeoffs might be different they may have other factors other constraints other reasons for making those
  135. decisions well Apple's another interesting case in point uh they have announced and have indeed started
  136. producing some computers back in the US remember in the when they started they had one Factory in California and
  137. then they built a second Factory in Texas and then they went you know they expanded but you know uh and they would
  138. they would argue that they were you know an American-made product even though 90%
  139. of their cost of goods was imported Parts even then so uh most of Apple's products are made
  140. offshore and for all the reasons we we discussed but yet they have done this project where they've taken certain
  141. high-end computers and are now manufacturing them in the US it's a very small fraction of their
  142. total activity it's a very small fraction of their total capital investment it's gotten a
  143. disproportionate amount of publicity you know they can point to that and say we're doing the right thing
  144. we're coming we're ruring so Skeptics would say that there was a political motive u i I don't know but you know I
  145. think objectively that's certainly not the dominant thing they're doing so yeah they everybody's doing some of it but is
  146. it is it a major sea change for them I don't think so so that's become a very important
  147. aspect of this whole you know Global sourcing issue because we have in many Industries manufacturing Industries
  148. where products are assembled uh the use of contract manufacturers contract manufacturers is
  149. where you Outsource production to another third party they build your product in their Factory with their
  150. workers uh some of them like foxcon and others I think have like foxcon has over
  151. a million workers in China they make and they make in the same Factory competing
  152. products so you will see laptops with two different brands competing coming down the same assembly line and so we
  153. that's that is the nature of global supply chain you know we you search the best source of supply and very often it
  154. might be the same source for your competitor as for you and so these contract manufacturers have become very large and
  155. a major player in certain industries where especially where you you need assembly of Peace Parts where you need
  156. fine motor control and so uh what they've done is they would hire young people young women who have good eye
  157. hand coordination and motor skills and they can put together little pieces and assemble them and you know they've had
  158. there have been a lot of you know terrible situations suicides people you know going home for the
  159. holidays and not coming back all kinds of disruptions uh you know arguments that
  160. they're mistreating their workers and not paying them well and you know uh and this has led some of the customers to
  161. impose an ethical standards on their suppliers we see of course see the same thing in the apparel industry you know
  162. with with the use of child labor and and unsafe work conditions in third world countries so what's the ethical
  163. responsibility of a company that outsources to another company maybe another part of the world to maintain
  164. standards that we would think are minimal in our country this is a very complex question but it acts as a kind
  165. of a additional constraint if you will or an additional incentive to either go or not go to certain plac places or to
  166. control the how you do it so even some of these contract manufacturers like foxcon that has over a million workers
  167. in China has stated publicly that it wants to replace them with a million robots now they're not doing they're not
  168. going to do that but it was an interesting statement that they view that you know one of the one of the ways
  169. to solve these ethical problems is get rid of the people robots don't complain about work conditions you know we used
  170. to talk about about lights out factories with robots you don't need to have the lights on when the robots are working so
  171. um I mean it's I don't think it's going to replace it but I think that there's going to be a rebalancing and a and a a
  172. different increased role of Technology but it affects the sourcing decisions in some cases in a major way it needs to be
  173. considered as part of the overall evaluation of where to go and how to go there it's been very Gra ifying we we
  174. initially did a pilot study in China where um we got 50 companies to respond and we've analyzed that data and we're
  175. writing that up and it's going to be distributed uh we then brought in uh created a Consortium of seven leading
  176. universities with leading Global Supply Chain Scholars people who work in this area and we're all working together and
  177. we started the initial phase and I think we got about 35 40 companies and we held
  178. a meeting in December to review the preliminary results and one of the main conclusions was we have to continue
  179. doing this and expand the sample and get more companies involved and some of the
  180. companies have actually said they want to help us get more companies their own customers to be involved and they're
  181. going to go out and and solicit them to do that and and we're growing the sample
  182. and we're getting more and more companies to to participate and we want to by the end of this year have a large
  183. enough sample and this is not just China specific but this would be all regions of the world because one of the
  184. hypothesis that people put forward is there is no overall Global strategy anymore it's all very Regional what a
  185. even a multinational does in China is going to be very different than what it does in North America or what it does in
  186. Europe and by asking these questions in different parts of the world you're going to get a very different
  187. perspective so we've expanded this to be more truly Global in terms of where and
  188. what companies and increasing the sample maintaining the basic analysis the basic
  189. survey which seems to be validated quite quite well and quite sound but just to grow it and then I guess long term you
  190. know we'll write it up both at a academic level for publication and also at a level where we can communicate this
  191. to the business community and the political Community which you know we we plan to do but I think this could be an
  192. ongoing research project could keep us busy for [Music] years

Brief Summary

Companies are reshaping global manufacturing strategies amid complex factors like labor costs and technology access.

Key points

  • Restructuring in Global Manufacturing. Companies are addressing how and where to produce products, leading to unprecedented restructuring.
  • The Complexity of Reshoring. Predictions of wholesale reshoring are not happening on a large scale; it's a complicated picture.
  • The Role of Labor Costs. Labor costs are not the only factor driving companies' sourcing decisions; quality and market access matter too.
  • The General Electric Story. GE's reshoring efforts in Kentucky highlight the challenges of finding skilled American workers.
  • The Rise of Automation. Companies like Foxconn are considering replacing workers with robots to address ethical concerns.
  • Global Supply Chain Research. A consortium of seven universities is expanding a global supply chain study.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes