The Re-wiring of Global Supply Chains
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Offshoring, reshoring, nearshoring -- manufacturing around the world is undergoing some seismic locational shifts, many of which the conventional wisdom did not see coming, and for reasons that may surprise you, say Wharton’s Morris Cohen and Georgetown's John Cui. More: http://knlg.net/1OMI9lN 📂 Management 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I'd like to welcome Maris Cohen who is a professor of operations information and
- decisions here at Wharton and his colleague John qu who is a professor at Georgetown University to talk about the
- latest update on some very interesting research they're doing on Supply Chains It's especially interesting I think
- because it's coming up with a lot of counterintuitive um results things that people wouldn't have predicted U which
- is always interesting when research does that um so it turns out that a lot of the conventional wisdom is wrong what
- they're thinking about today and I'm going to just turn it over to you to talk about uh we have talked in the past
- about the phase one part of the study now you have phase two which is even bigger in the sense that your
- questionnaires and so forth have you've cast The Wider net you have more people involved so a bigger a bigger uh result
- uh so why don't you tell us about it okay so let me briefly just remind you of what the study was all about if I may
- so this is a benchmarking study that is dealing with the issue of the sourcing of manufacturing in a global supply
- chain Network and as you know most companies large companies today operate globally they have factories positioned
- all over the world and uh in recent years last 10 15 years there have been major shifts in the location of where
- companies have sort their production and in particular there's been a major shift out of the
- developed economies the US in particular to Asia China in particular and this has
- of course led to a loss of actually millions of manufacturing jobs and a lot of consternation amongst the political
- classes and the commentators and you know commentary as to how can we bring these jobs back how can we Revitalize
- our manufacturing sector and so on and this uh political season uh these issues have not gone away and
- in fact they probably the discussion has become even more heated and so the original purpose of the Benchmark study
- was to gather objectively some empirically based information based on what companies were actually doing not
- on stated intentions or not on predictions but on actual decisions that were made and last time I was here I
- discussed the first phas which dealt with a benchmark study of about 50 companies uh that were
- operating in China these were global companies and we talked about the results we saw and since that time we
- did a second phase with about as it 75 companies I think it was uh to which were much more globally
- dispersed also global companies uh same questions to see what was their current set of decisions what were the drivers
- of those decisions what was the expected impact of those decisions phase one I know when we spoke
- uh one of the things that had been in the news leading up to that for probably a couple years was this idea that oh
- American companies are starting to resure bring production back from Asia China in particular um as labor costs in
- China rise and as there's I guess increased Robotics and and and Automation in the US that it suddenly
- becomes more viable to manufacture in the US again but you found that that wasn't necessarily the case at all well
- in phase one that is true uh we did not observe too much of this reshoring or shifting of production into North
- America into the US in particular phase two a bigger sample uh much more diverse
- set of companies we actually saw a significant amount of Shifting of production back well I shouldn't use I
- have to be care not back but into the US what was surprising was where this was coming from this was not coming from
- us-based companies this was coming from european-based and asian-based companies
- so they are shifting production into the US and American companies not so much I
- don't know if you want to add to that John or um yeah I think the statement that Morris just gave was is entirely
- correct and part of the reason that we did not observe um similar results in phase one was because the respondence
- that we had in phase one with Chinese divisions of the global companies so they may not have the um um the complete
- picture of um the company's movement but when we get to phase two which involves
- a lot of um us and global companies headquarters and we were're able to identify this unique shift from non us
- companies entering the US so a lot of people hearing this will be scratching their head and say saying wait a second
- you're telling me that Europeans and others can come in here and manufacture profitably but um but us companies are
- still struggling how can they do it and US companies are not as successful or or is
- that well that's actually not the case no that's a very good question and of course as part of our study we ask
- companies why are you making these decisions you know what are the drivers of those decisions and the drivers that
- are driving companies particularly non- us companies to come to North America for manufacturing are Market access and
- access to Innovation not for low labor costs obviously uh you know and uh what the market this is one of the biggest if
- not the biggest Market in the world still but I should also say that those are the same reasons that a lot of
- companies continue to go to China not for low labor costs but for access to their huge and growing market so the and
- that raises another point that what we saw was there was no dominant pattern in what we saw we saw a very complex set of
- flows of manufacturing from one location to another uh you could call that or we
- call that rebalancing of of production we also saw what we called reloading of production where some companies would
- increase their capacity in their domestic country but not necessarily shift to another market so um to answer
- your question you know it's it's an interesting qu I'm not I don't know if we have a definitive answer as to why we
- saw that but clearly they claim Market access and Innovation are what's driving them to this country and you might argue
- that the US companies already have that access to the market and therefore the incremental benefit to them is not as
- great know if you want to add yeah I totally agree and um um we we we thought that that could explain why the US
- company do not um benefit as much as foreign companies entering the market and also um I agree moris that cost is
- no longer the single dominant factor that firms consider when they're making those reshoring decisions it used to be
- um dictating their decisions but these days that we observe much more complexity in their decision making and
- in terms of the outcomes that we observe yeah no doubt you'll have all these answers after phase three there is
- a phase three there'll always be of course be or maybe phase four but we we never stop phas and in in another
- conversation we had um quite a while back but it was in in the context of Japan right moving manufacturing out of
- Japan and one of the things you said at that time with was I thought was very interesting is that um emerging markets
- in general uh you know for a company to come in and start selling their products
- they want to get from them some kind of guarantee that we want you to bring your
- technology and and and create jobs here and and build things here that you can sell here we're much happier if you do
- that than if you just export things to us um and that that's a that's another Trend so it's kind of related right
- everyone in order to sell someplace it seems like companies are realizing you're going to have more success if
- you're actually in those countries Manufacturing in general well and that's that's actually not a new development
- that's that's been around for a long time and and governments have imposed local content and import quotas and
- various incentives which by the way we also saw as being uh important reasons in some cases for for shifting
- production um but you're absolutely right that uh countries not companies but countries want companies to locate
- in their jurisdiction to create jobs to create wealth create opportunities for their citizens and they want to have
- access to technology now of course that often times raises questions about intellectual property and things of that
- sort so sometimes there are risks attendant with that as well and presumably gets you closer to
- the markets you understand definitely get you closer to the market yes um so were there other conclusions from
- the study that surprised you um I think that uh you know there are a couple of things we saw in the
- second phase which reinforced what we saw in the first phase I think I had already mentioned that there was no one
- dominant reason there was not one dominant flow uh that there seems to be a complex trade-off analysis that
- companies are undergoing and what's really interesting to to us is that the this is pervasive that there we are in
- the midst of a major restructuring of Global Supply chains in region after region company after company companies
- are asking the question do we have the right structure do we have the right sourcing locations are we bringing our
- product to Market in the most effective way and they're often times shifting capacity changing the way in which they
- produce products adding technology this we saw like for example technology and R&D across the board everybody's
- investing in this so I think that we're in the midst of a period of Flux Of change which is redefining the way the
- world produces its products do we know where it's going to end up no I don't think we do that's why
- we need more phases need more Fae of course um well I that's interesting and one of the things that you mentioned
- last time about phase one which I thought was particularly intriguing was that within the same company they might
- be Outsourcing something from a particular country while at the same time being the outsourcer for that for
- that that other country um so it's you talked about a Cris Crossing of these Supply chains that didn't use to happen
- there were more steady Flows In One Direction or another it it had been perceived as you know at a one way flow
- your loss is my gain type of thing but now we see two Street we see direct you know movement in both directions and
- that's why we call it a rebalancing which is one of the dominant modes uh and so a lot of companies are
- making multiple decisions sometimes offsetting decisions for the reasons you said to gain access to developing
- economies and their markets um to gain access to their labor to their suppliers so um there is no one one way to go but
- there is a lot of Shifting back and forth and that's so we we saw that as one of the dominant trends of this
- rebalancing if you want to add to that or um no I think that was a that was accident answer I wanted to ask if you
- it was what was the most interesting thing that came out of uh phase two in your opinion um to me um I'm a Chinese
- which is quite obvious to you so I would just like to add a few things that we observed um concering China in phase two
- study which is very consistent of uh we will we found in phase one so we found that um companies European companies or
- non China nonch Chinese companies are moving into China for Market reasons so China is growing to be the largest um
- Market of the world um but then at the same time we also observe companies moving out of China but not for Market
- reasons this time for cost reasons so those are the company for example in the apparo industry we observe lot of
- companies moving out of China they go into um South Asia countries like Vietnam Bangladesh those countries that
- have even lower cost than China so I just find it amazing that companies going in and CH or going out of China
- for different reasons but let me add that what we saw in phase two consistent with phase one
- is the biggest flow was still into China even now in spite of the Rising labor costs in spite of the fact that some
- companies in China are moving out of China if we asked where are you going what are you doing the biggest observed
- flow was companies moving into China often times Chinese companies expanding within China we call that reloading or
- foreign companies moving into China but that was still the most popular decision
- to and we're talking about manufacturing here so that's interesting also for because of Market access we hear a lot
- about China needing to shift from an export Le economy right to a consumer based one so they're preparing for that
- which is uh I guess already underway to some well you know everybody knows the statistic I don't know how many hundreds
- of millions will be in the Chinese middle class 400 million 600 million to and this is a huge huge market and to
- have access to that market well cannot you cannot ignore that if you're a global player and and so that's one of
- the reasons another thing that we saw in in very pronounced in phase two was that
- quality was a positive reason to go into China not a negative also counterintuitive right because well you
- know it depends on your perspective you know at some stage years back one might have said oh if you leave the US and go
- to Asia you may have quality problems but certainly that's not true in Japan for a long time and it seems to no
- longer not be a problem in China that high quality complex you know uh products labor not
- necessarily you know labor intensive but you know complicated products are being
- produced in China in very high quality so um sounds like the decisions been made you have to be in the US you have
- to be in China what about Europe now Europe is a very interesting qu point in both studies and I think even more in
- the second study Western Europe was the one place that we saw negative decline shifting production in North
- America there was actually stuff coming in not from the North America as I said but from other places if we add it up
- all over the world we're gaining not at great amount not at a great speed but we
- are gaining ground or recovery the US has a net gain yes but Europe is a net loss except of course for Eastern Europe
- and Russia which is perceived to be a nearshoring location just as Mexico is to the US so their in but Western Europe
- is declining so um what would you say to just sum this up well I'd say that the the the global economy is not
- flat that there are many possibilities and many opportunities and I think one thing in
- particular that we should bear in mind is that there are opportunities in this country to grow our manufacturing and to
- grow our economy and that it may be based on Innovation it may be based on different types of of
- Technology uh but I think we should uh we should recognize that the world will come to our door you know as long as we
- we manage that process correctly thanks very much to both of you for joining us today thank you much appreciate it
- [Music]
Brief Summary
Cohen and Qu reveal surprising trends in global supply chains, with non-US companies increasingly moving production to the US for market access and innovation.
Key points
- Counterintuitive Research Findings. Recent studies reveal surprising shifts in global manufacturing trends, challenging conventional wisdom.
- Manufacturing Shifts to the US. European and Asian companies are increasingly moving production to the US, while American firms lag.
Episode highlights
- Counterintuitive Research FindingsRecent studies reveal surprising shifts in global manufacturing trends, challenging conventional wisdom.“A lot of conventional wisdom is wrong.”0:33Mar 2, 2016
- Manufacturing Shifts to the USEuropean and Asian companies are increasingly moving production to the US, while American firms lag.“You're telling me that Europeans can manufacture profitably here?”4:59Mar 2, 2016
Episode quotes
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





