From Offshoring to Reshoring

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] so Maris I wonder if we can start with you uh years ago uh there was this a lot
  2. of hubub about uh offshoring uh with uh you know work being sent overseas uh to basically lowcost
  3. countries uh recently uh there's been uh some research and youve you've taken the
  4. lead on that uh on a phenomenon called reshoring and I wonder if you could uh start by explaining exactly what that is
  5. sure maybe um I could start by just putting the whole thing in context because you said you know there's been
  6. this phenomenon of out sourcing or out offshoring and now which suggests that companies thinking primarily of us
  7. companies but it applies in fact to any company in any operating anywhere of taking their operations their
  8. manufacturing operations and moving it somewhere else and the the the the most favored or the most obvious choice in
  9. the last 10 years has been China and other Asian sources but there's been a lot of other places that manufacturing
  10. is gone so just to put things in context if you look at statistics of the manufacturing sector and you look at the
  11. employment in manufacturing and you look at the output of the manufacturing sector there these two lines the output
  12. for the last 50 100 years has been going up steadily employment has been more or
  13. less flat at about 20 million people for 40 50 years and so that raises the question how could this happen how could
  14. we be producing more and more manufactured products not only here but this is also true in other developed
  15. countries and and around the world with fewer and fewer people and there are many explanations automation maybe
  16. everybody went to the Wharton School and learned how to be more efficient we can
  17. hope right that we had some small impact there but you know productivity has definitely gone up and this this is you
  18. know this is this is what's considered to be the the normal pattern of economies
  19. developing the same thing happened a 100 years ago or more the agricultural sector as well but if you go back 10
  20. years this line of 20 million employment dropped by 5 million and we're now below
  21. 15 or 11 12 million something like that which has not which had not happened for decades so when we say
  22. there's been out Shor or globalization that has been going on for decades but there has been a fundamental shift a
  23. transfer of manufacturing operations out of the US in the last 10 years and we've
  24. lost 5 six million jobs meanwhile output continues to more or less go up with some fluctuation so that has been the
  25. phenomenon and it's become a very politicized issue you know the last election campaign all the candidates
  26. told us they had an answer to this and and one of the phenomenon that people are starting to suggest is that we can
  27. solve this problem by bringing manufacturing back to the home country and that's what the concept of reshoring
  28. is generally understood to me so thank you Morris now uh Scott turning to you from your your Vantage Point in the it
  29. space uh do you see uh uh the the same Trend that Morris talking about of of jobs essentially coming back to the US I
  30. think the uh it's a tremendous parallel between what's happened in manufacturing
  31. and what's now happening in technology uh it's almost identical but maybe just a little off in terms of timelines if
  32. you look at the technology space ever since really about Y2K there's been a tremendous push of uh technology work
  33. and it work offshore and the primary location for that has been India so manufacturing to China technology to
  34. India it's almost identical parallels but we're we're definitely seeing uh especially over the last even maybe just
  35. 12 months maybe two years a reshoring uh ground swell happening in the technology
  36. space as well the first thing to realize is that there's a tremendous demand for
  37. technology talent and this is a global you know demand uh you see the same thing in Europe you see it in Asia you
  38. see it in the states uh everybody's in in need of Technology talent but what we're seeing now is that cios who are
  39. the primary buyers of of Technology talent in the market are really looking for four options they're looking for the
  40. ability to have technology Talent on site they looking to still be able to Offshore uh certain pieces of their
  41. portfolio they're they're starting to Now look for Nearshore options uh to support their businesses in in Nearshore
  42. uh regions but the new phenomenon is they're looking for onshore uh options and these would be in you know lower
  43. cost um but still high quality areas so tremendous parallel between manufacturing and technology is is now
  44. happening that's great and we come back to each of these factors in some more detail but for the moment I just want to
  45. coming back to you moris about what you said about manufacturing so uh are there
  46. any striking examples of companies that have reshored their operations and uh that that you could offer
  47. us there are many many of them and many of them have been reported in the Press uh one of the most uh widely cited one
  48. and I'm only going back let's say in the last 12 to 24 months uh General Electric
  49. investing a billion dollars to bring back all of their Appliance manufacturing to Kentucky 5 10 years ago
  50. they had shut were ready to shut down the factory offshored everything and now they're bringing back Appliance
  51. manufacturing they're also bringing back uh ge as other manufacturing uh that's one example but there have been other
  52. examples uh Apple announced that they're going to be making or assembling some computers in the US Lenovo has announced
  53. that they're going to be assembling computers in the US uh there are many many examples the question though that
  54. everybody is asking and go back to my original Point we've lost 5 million jobs jobs are coming back and and we can
  55. talk later about the arguments why that's happening but there are those who say we're never going to get those jobs
  56. back maybe we'll get half a million back maybe we'll get a million back but we're
  57. not going to ever get back to where we were before and others you know the government is saying no we're going to
  58. we're going to Quick jump start this whole process and this this we will return to where we were so this is a
  59. very open and hot contested question you know yes there's reshoring but you know
  60. the same question by the way is asked in China and Japan uh the the reshoring to them is
  61. offshoring our reshoring is their offshoring and they're also looking to Offshore and so these questions are
  62. being asked everywhere so so the uh if you look year to year just to for a quick followup uh which where is the net
  63. outflow or inflow of jobs is it still being more offshored rather than reshored or is the trend starting to
  64. change I think we we gaining jobs in the last year net positive uh but as I said
  65. the numbers are much smaller than the numbers that have gone out uh and we're still losing jobs right now what do you
  66. see Scott in the in the in the technology space uh uh is it still uh do you see the volume of jobs coming back
  67. is it still uh greater than the is it Greater than the volume of jobs that's that may be still going out see I think
  68. again it's a very interesting parallel and it's almost the same companies that are doing the same thing you see uh ge
  69. and General Motors and MetLife has just announced uh you know a what they're calling a domestic Development Center or
  70. us delivery Center uh in the states and so it's those large companies who are now starting to build up their own
  71. operations uh in the US or working with Partners like a m tree to do it for them
  72. uh but this is probably in the early days I think manufacturing has a couple years Head Start where we saw uh
  73. micromanufacturing starting to happen and now you see some you know larger waves of manufacturing starting to
  74. happen but I think this is early days for technology but it's clearly a trend that is very visible uh and I think
  75. it'll be very hot uh there will be definitely uh a lot of companies in the market looking for local
  76. talent uh Morris I wonder if uh uh you give some great examples of companies uh is there some U broader Trend we can see
  77. in terms of Industries where re shuring is most visible and countries that are sending the most jobs back any overall
  78. observations there that's a great question you know if we go back to the origins of this I mean what what has
  79. happened in the last 10 years is um the decision to Offshore primarily China and
  80. other plac to Asia uh has been became what was called a no Bri trer you didn't have to do very much analysis the wage
  81. the labor cost the wage differential between China in the US was you know an order of magnitude if not more and so
  82. companies said you know under a dollar an hour and we're paying $25 an hour whatever the differences are this is a
  83. quote a no-brainer and so for 10 years companies and continue to do that uh have said we know we're going to go
  84. there now in many Industries there are many other costs associated with where you Source in the supply
  85. chain as you can imagine plus uh there are some very interesting Trends the labor costs in China have been going up
  86. much faster than here um the exchange rate continues to be an issue uh government regulation continues to be an
  87. issue and there are some people now saying that we're approaching what they call a Tipping Point I don't know if you
  88. know Hal cirin from BCG you know is one example where he's famous for saying you
  89. know once that wage differential gets below a certain point and we're close to it then this Advantage will come will
  90. have dissipated and they will come back now what to your question where does this matter obviously in Industries like
  91. apparel which have a high labor content this is a no-brainer but if you go to you know one industry I do a lot of work
  92. with is Aerospace and defense making aircraft engines it's not such a no-brainer you know so where you need
  93. High te a lot of Talent technology and I think it is a very interesting situation
  94. where it's not just a question of lowcost Labor it never was but in some industries that was to be dominant but
  95. if you look at the labor cost in the fully loaded cost of a computer an Apple computer it's probably under 10% so it
  96. doesn't really matter that much from the purpose of where they Source if it's just a question of labor cost and so all
  97. these other factors are coming into play some are pushing back to reshoring some
  98. are continuing to push out and the answers will very much depend on the technology and the
  99. industry SC what's your perspective yeah and it's almost identical in the tech sector so I think the initial out
  100. Outsourcing and certainly offshoring efforts were clearly driven by labor Arbitrage but that's starting to change
  101. as well companies are looking for additional things like value ad and productivity increases and time to
  102. Market uh increases things like that so there's more than just labor Arbitrage going into the equation but I think it's
  103. important to note in the tech sector I don't believe that it's an either or I think it's that near Shoring or um or
  104. reshoring will continue to rise but I think Off Shoring will continue to rise too because I think the whole Tech
  105. Market is in a growth mode so companies are really not looking for one or the other they're looking for both and it
  106. goes back to my initial point that uh cios and and you know and larger companies are really looking for options
  107. they want to have the ability to get the best tech talent in multiple markets so
  108. it's not like they're choosing India over the us or South America over India it's really that they want all of that
  109. but they just want to figure out what's the right balance for their [Music] company

Brief Summary

Morris and Scott discuss reshoring trends in manufacturing and technology, highlighting examples from companies like GE and Apple.

Key points

  • The Rise of Reshoring. Reshoring is becoming a significant trend as companies bring jobs back to the US.
  • General Electric's Reshoring Example. General Electric invests a billion dollars to bring back appliance manufacturing to Kentucky.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes