From Offshoring to Reshoring
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] so Maris I wonder if we can start with you uh years ago uh there was this a lot
- of hubub about uh offshoring uh with uh you know work being sent overseas uh to basically lowcost
- countries uh recently uh there's been uh some research and youve you've taken the
- lead on that uh on a phenomenon called reshoring and I wonder if you could uh start by explaining exactly what that is
- sure maybe um I could start by just putting the whole thing in context because you said you know there's been
- this phenomenon of out sourcing or out offshoring and now which suggests that companies thinking primarily of us
- companies but it applies in fact to any company in any operating anywhere of taking their operations their
- manufacturing operations and moving it somewhere else and the the the the most favored or the most obvious choice in
- the last 10 years has been China and other Asian sources but there's been a lot of other places that manufacturing
- is gone so just to put things in context if you look at statistics of the manufacturing sector and you look at the
- employment in manufacturing and you look at the output of the manufacturing sector there these two lines the output
- for the last 50 100 years has been going up steadily employment has been more or
- less flat at about 20 million people for 40 50 years and so that raises the question how could this happen how could
- we be producing more and more manufactured products not only here but this is also true in other developed
- countries and and around the world with fewer and fewer people and there are many explanations automation maybe
- everybody went to the Wharton School and learned how to be more efficient we can
- hope right that we had some small impact there but you know productivity has definitely gone up and this this is you
- know this is this is what's considered to be the the normal pattern of economies
- developing the same thing happened a 100 years ago or more the agricultural sector as well but if you go back 10
- years this line of 20 million employment dropped by 5 million and we're now below
- 15 or 11 12 million something like that which has not which had not happened for decades so when we say
- there's been out Shor or globalization that has been going on for decades but there has been a fundamental shift a
- transfer of manufacturing operations out of the US in the last 10 years and we've
- lost 5 six million jobs meanwhile output continues to more or less go up with some fluctuation so that has been the
- phenomenon and it's become a very politicized issue you know the last election campaign all the candidates
- told us they had an answer to this and and one of the phenomenon that people are starting to suggest is that we can
- solve this problem by bringing manufacturing back to the home country and that's what the concept of reshoring
- is generally understood to me so thank you Morris now uh Scott turning to you from your your Vantage Point in the it
- space uh do you see uh uh the the same Trend that Morris talking about of of jobs essentially coming back to the US I
- think the uh it's a tremendous parallel between what's happened in manufacturing
- and what's now happening in technology uh it's almost identical but maybe just a little off in terms of timelines if
- you look at the technology space ever since really about Y2K there's been a tremendous push of uh technology work
- and it work offshore and the primary location for that has been India so manufacturing to China technology to
- India it's almost identical parallels but we're we're definitely seeing uh especially over the last even maybe just
- 12 months maybe two years a reshoring uh ground swell happening in the technology
- space as well the first thing to realize is that there's a tremendous demand for
- technology talent and this is a global you know demand uh you see the same thing in Europe you see it in Asia you
- see it in the states uh everybody's in in need of Technology talent but what we're seeing now is that cios who are
- the primary buyers of of Technology talent in the market are really looking for four options they're looking for the
- ability to have technology Talent on site they looking to still be able to Offshore uh certain pieces of their
- portfolio they're they're starting to Now look for Nearshore options uh to support their businesses in in Nearshore
- uh regions but the new phenomenon is they're looking for onshore uh options and these would be in you know lower
- cost um but still high quality areas so tremendous parallel between manufacturing and technology is is now
- happening that's great and we come back to each of these factors in some more detail but for the moment I just want to
- coming back to you moris about what you said about manufacturing so uh are there
- any striking examples of companies that have reshored their operations and uh that that you could offer
- us there are many many of them and many of them have been reported in the Press uh one of the most uh widely cited one
- and I'm only going back let's say in the last 12 to 24 months uh General Electric
- investing a billion dollars to bring back all of their Appliance manufacturing to Kentucky 5 10 years ago
- they had shut were ready to shut down the factory offshored everything and now they're bringing back Appliance
- manufacturing they're also bringing back uh ge as other manufacturing uh that's one example but there have been other
- examples uh Apple announced that they're going to be making or assembling some computers in the US Lenovo has announced
- that they're going to be assembling computers in the US uh there are many many examples the question though that
- everybody is asking and go back to my original Point we've lost 5 million jobs jobs are coming back and and we can
- talk later about the arguments why that's happening but there are those who say we're never going to get those jobs
- back maybe we'll get half a million back maybe we'll get a million back but we're
- not going to ever get back to where we were before and others you know the government is saying no we're going to
- we're going to Quick jump start this whole process and this this we will return to where we were so this is a
- very open and hot contested question you know yes there's reshoring but you know
- the same question by the way is asked in China and Japan uh the the reshoring to them is
- offshoring our reshoring is their offshoring and they're also looking to Offshore and so these questions are
- being asked everywhere so so the uh if you look year to year just to for a quick followup uh which where is the net
- outflow or inflow of jobs is it still being more offshored rather than reshored or is the trend starting to
- change I think we we gaining jobs in the last year net positive uh but as I said
- the numbers are much smaller than the numbers that have gone out uh and we're still losing jobs right now what do you
- see Scott in the in the in the technology space uh uh is it still uh do you see the volume of jobs coming back
- is it still uh greater than the is it Greater than the volume of jobs that's that may be still going out see I think
- again it's a very interesting parallel and it's almost the same companies that are doing the same thing you see uh ge
- and General Motors and MetLife has just announced uh you know a what they're calling a domestic Development Center or
- us delivery Center uh in the states and so it's those large companies who are now starting to build up their own
- operations uh in the US or working with Partners like a m tree to do it for them
- uh but this is probably in the early days I think manufacturing has a couple years Head Start where we saw uh
- micromanufacturing starting to happen and now you see some you know larger waves of manufacturing starting to
- happen but I think this is early days for technology but it's clearly a trend that is very visible uh and I think
- it'll be very hot uh there will be definitely uh a lot of companies in the market looking for local
- talent uh Morris I wonder if uh uh you give some great examples of companies uh is there some U broader Trend we can see
- in terms of Industries where re shuring is most visible and countries that are sending the most jobs back any overall
- observations there that's a great question you know if we go back to the origins of this I mean what what has
- happened in the last 10 years is um the decision to Offshore primarily China and
- other plac to Asia uh has been became what was called a no Bri trer you didn't have to do very much analysis the wage
- the labor cost the wage differential between China in the US was you know an order of magnitude if not more and so
- companies said you know under a dollar an hour and we're paying $25 an hour whatever the differences are this is a
- quote a no-brainer and so for 10 years companies and continue to do that uh have said we know we're going to go
- there now in many Industries there are many other costs associated with where you Source in the supply
- chain as you can imagine plus uh there are some very interesting Trends the labor costs in China have been going up
- much faster than here um the exchange rate continues to be an issue uh government regulation continues to be an
- issue and there are some people now saying that we're approaching what they call a Tipping Point I don't know if you
- know Hal cirin from BCG you know is one example where he's famous for saying you
- know once that wage differential gets below a certain point and we're close to it then this Advantage will come will
- have dissipated and they will come back now what to your question where does this matter obviously in Industries like
- apparel which have a high labor content this is a no-brainer but if you go to you know one industry I do a lot of work
- with is Aerospace and defense making aircraft engines it's not such a no-brainer you know so where you need
- High te a lot of Talent technology and I think it is a very interesting situation
- where it's not just a question of lowcost Labor it never was but in some industries that was to be dominant but
- if you look at the labor cost in the fully loaded cost of a computer an Apple computer it's probably under 10% so it
- doesn't really matter that much from the purpose of where they Source if it's just a question of labor cost and so all
- these other factors are coming into play some are pushing back to reshoring some
- are continuing to push out and the answers will very much depend on the technology and the
- industry SC what's your perspective yeah and it's almost identical in the tech sector so I think the initial out
- Outsourcing and certainly offshoring efforts were clearly driven by labor Arbitrage but that's starting to change
- as well companies are looking for additional things like value ad and productivity increases and time to
- Market uh increases things like that so there's more than just labor Arbitrage going into the equation but I think it's
- important to note in the tech sector I don't believe that it's an either or I think it's that near Shoring or um or
- reshoring will continue to rise but I think Off Shoring will continue to rise too because I think the whole Tech
- Market is in a growth mode so companies are really not looking for one or the other they're looking for both and it
- goes back to my initial point that uh cios and and you know and larger companies are really looking for options
- they want to have the ability to get the best tech talent in multiple markets so
- it's not like they're choosing India over the us or South America over India it's really that they want all of that
- but they just want to figure out what's the right balance for their [Music] company
Brief Summary
Morris and Scott discuss reshoring trends in manufacturing and technology, highlighting examples from companies like GE and Apple.
Key points
- The Rise of Reshoring. Reshoring is becoming a significant trend as companies bring jobs back to the US.
- General Electric's Reshoring Example. General Electric invests a billion dollars to bring back appliance manufacturing to Kentucky.
Episode highlights
- The Rise of ReshoringReshoring is becoming a significant trend as companies bring jobs back to the US.“We can solve this problem by bringing manufacturing back to the home country.”3:39Jul 15, 2013
- General Electric's Reshoring ExampleGeneral Electric invests a billion dollars to bring back appliance manufacturing to Kentucky.“They had shut down, offshored everything, and now they’re bringing back manufacturing.”6:16Jul 15, 2013
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





