Future Trends in Reshoring

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] in this uh final segment of our discussion uh would love to talk about
  2. uh what's coming up next so moris uh I wonder if uh starting with you we could look at the prospects for ruring over
  3. the next year 3 years and 5 years what do you think it's going to happen well I don't have a definitive answer for that
  4. uh not surprising and in fact we're doing research now surveying companies around the world asking them what
  5. decisions have you made what are your intentions and what are the reasons for making that and what do you think the
  6. impact will be and we're in the in the midst of collecting such data uh all past Studies have shown a remarkably
  7. High number of companies on the order of 30 40% admit publicly that they're considering or have made decisions to
  8. resore or to restructure their supply chains a comparable number also thinking about Outsourcing as well so it's going
  9. in both directions I I I would say we are at a at a time of great ferment of great change that there are a lot of
  10. factors that we've mentioned here on technology on education on government regulation on cost Trends uh that are
  11. are driving this and will have different impacts in different countries and in different Industries I think that the
  12. you know there's a a realization that this is this is very important for the future welfare of our country we have to
  13. get back to closer to where we were and we and yet we will never get back to where we were as well so it's going to
  14. be different technology has changed so I'm bottom line it's going to increase I'm an optimist I think we're going to
  15. see uh multiple changes in different Industries but it's a global economy we're not going to go back to where we
  16. were in the 1950s where we dominated in certain industries you know and we have to learn
  17. to live with the fact that every region in the world has the same objectives they want their children to be employed
  18. they want them to have valuable jobs they want them to have you know to add value and so I think that the what the
  19. equilibrium will be I don't know but I think generally we will we've seen the low point and I think we're we're
  20. improving and I think over the next 5 10 years we're going to see more manufacturing jobs come back and you
  21. know so bottom line I'll say I'm an optimist uh what does your crystal ball say Scott yeah on the technology side
  22. I'm very optimistic as well but I think that you know that it's it's important to understand what the what the the
  23. secret formula is for setting up us delivery centers in in various parts of the country and it's it the best formula
  24. is to be in partnership with a major research University in a tier 2 City to that keeps costs down and in a business
  25. friendly State and I think when you look across the country there's a finite number of them so I think what you're
  26. going to see over the next year or two is a Mad Dash to uh set up Partnerships with those University cities and states
  27. M tree as I mentioned earlier has set up a 400 person Center in Gainesville Florida with the University of Florida
  28. but we're going to open up another one this year in the Midwest and another one a year later in either the Mountain Time
  29. Zone or the Pacific time zone and then we're just one company in the space there's other companies you know doing
  30. it as well so I think at some point that we're going to get we're going to get to
  31. an area where that there's there's a cap to how much we can do and we really need
  32. the tech Talent to keep continually increase and maybe other universities to step up we can't just rely on the big
  33. engineering schools you know maybe some other universities will step up and some
  34. other states will step up but I think the most important thing to realize is that it takes that ecosystem in order to
  35. make these things successful yeah you can't just have one of those pieces in place and and think it's going to work
  36. so I'm very optimistic but at the same time I I know we've got to move fast to make sure that we stay ahead of our
  37. competitors and and lining up these Partnerships so in addition to Florida which other states are likely to benefit
  38. the most from this trend yeah so I think you know it's it's got to be in states that have high tech Talent um but uh can
  39. but can keep the cost down um because at the end of the day cost is still a driver and when a CIO is making a
  40. decision about where they're going to put the tech Talent cost does come in they're running a business um you know
  41. it doesn't have to mean that they have to match uh cost overseas it just has to be a competitive cost and uh so again
  42. it's it's it's a finite number of states and cities and universities uh that can
  43. that can pull this off um and I think the good news is that they're all rallying to that cause right now they
  44. realize that there's a window now and that they need to uh get into that and uh it's good news for everybody but I
  45. think um it's the most important thing is that we continue to to to you know enable kids to get into stem and
  46. continue to increase the number of kids that are graduating because there's certainly jobs for them Maris what would
  47. you consider to be the kind of jobs that are most likely to come back to the US uh over the next uh you know few years
  48. well it's an interesting question um it's clear that the kind of jobs that are going to grow are not the jobs that
  49. you know we had in the past uh it's they're going to have more information technology content they're going to be
  50. more technology driven um I don't think we can compete in this country uh with providing low cost labor uh in the way
  51. that maybe you know we we provided it Generations past so it's got to be a more educated more technologically savvy
  52. uh the other thing that we haven't talked too much about is that you know we're in a service economy 70% of all
  53. employment is in service and one of the areas that I do a lot of research is in the interplay between services and
  54. manufactur uring and most products today are not just sold as products they're sold as services and they have Services
  55. bundled with them and most people even in manufacturing companies aren't making anything they're providing Services
  56. either internally or externally so I think that we have to understand we're in a service economy we're in a
  57. high-tech economy where skills are important and the jobs that come back have to somehow leverage off the fact
  58. that there has to be a high service content there has to be a high technology let me one final comment just
  59. last week we had a forum jointed with Wharton and MIT on this topic and our keynote
  60. speaker was Mike molar uh from the Bureau of Standards who is heading up the the White House program on
  61. manufactury and he announced that uh or he described the current program that the federal government has put forward
  62. to promote all of this and they are setting up centers of excellence across the country they're getting different
  63. levels of schools from community colleges to universities uh they're getting companies and and it's a very
  64. exciting prospect that you know they're really getting a lot of of of input and they're they're investing large amounts
  65. of money they want to turn the tide you know this has been you know President Obama said in his State of the Union
  66. we're going to do this and they're now have launched a program so I think this is good and the states are also doing
  67. this and the cities I was just asked to participate in if I was interested in participating in a in an RFP from the
  68. city of Philadelphia who wants to add manufacturing jobs to the city of Philadelphia Mayor Nutter has said we
  69. have to promote this so this is happening at all levels of government in all locations everybody recognizes what
  70. the what the problem is and and so I think with all of that Ingenuity and all of that attention that this country can
  71. throw at it I think I think we're going to see some interesting things happen that's really interesting uh SC what do
  72. you think in terms of the kind of work that can be done in a place like Bangalore versus what can be done in
  73. Florida are you seeing you know different jobs coming back to the US than what may have been uh sent overseas
  74. I think it's a little different in the tech space because I think there's a there'll be a a small percentage of jobs
  75. that come back but I think what's more important for job growth in the US and the tech Bas is that this the pie in
  76. general is growing so the jobs that are created here in the US on the tech technology side will probably be
  77. slightly different than what was outsourced in the future one of the big trends in technology is a move toward
  78. agile software development agile software development is a faster way to build applications but it requires a a
  79. much more high level of touch with the business user who's driving the requirements and it's hard to do that
  80. from 7,000 miles away or wherever you might be so a lot of the tech jobs that that we're creating uh in the states and
  81. that we're seeing are competitors create are more focused on on projects that are
  82. that require a high level touch with a business user almost a day-to-day interaction or multiple uh interaction
  83. points per day and a change toward faster software development so that companies can hit these time-to Market
  84. uh aspects that they're looking for the other thing is obviously there's a drive
  85. toward mobile app development uh and there's certain components of mobile app development that are are easier done in
  86. the states as well because same reasons that uh the process of creating a mobile app
  87. is a very visual process and you want to be sharing those visual constructs with
  88. your business user on a on a very interactive almost Dynamic basis so there's a lot of uh a lot of change
  89. that's certainly happening in in the industry in terms of how things get developed and and certain Technologies
  90. so I think the nearshoring I'm I'm sorry the reshoring that's occurring in the tech space a lot of it's being driven
  91. just by the new things that are happening in the space great now as the phenomenon of reshoring plays out over
  92. the future do you think it's going to lead to some sort of a global shift in competitive Advantage between the US and
  93. the Emerging Markets or will things never really go that far what do you think I think there there has
  94. been you know fundamental shifts uh you know one of the things we haven't touched on is
  95. demographics uh you know we say we need jobs we need high-tech jobs we need jobs
  96. you know where are we going to find them you're going to find them in people in India you're not going to find them
  97. going as much going forward in China you're certainly not going to find them in Japan you're going to find them in
  98. South America these are the large pools of available labor and I think that uh it's clear that economic activity is
  99. going to have to continue to grow in those areas notwithstanding they also have huge domestic markets so there have
  100. been major shifts and so the US still is is a leader you know I I'm not sure if today China is a bigger manufacturer
  101. than the US they're they're about even now and and it's gone back and forth in the last year or so uh but you know we
  102. no longer have the obvious assumed dominant position that we had a generation or two back it's a
  103. much more competitive world everybody understands what what the stakes are and I think there's going to continue to be
  104. a shift and a balance and I think this country and every country has to look for its comparative advantage you know
  105. there are things in our Marketplace that deal with Innovation with the nature of
  106. of our markets the nature of our population that give us certain advantages and there are other places in
  107. the world where they have advantages and so the balance is going to work out so uh all I can say is the future will not
  108. be like the past and what about the IT industry uh do do you see a competitive shift and
  109. Advantage there yeah so I think the IT industry again a little different because there's a Glo there's a global
  110. shortage of it talent and that that is a a little bit of a differentiator to to the space that I'm in and again I think
  111. going back to what's happening with reshoring I don't think it's it's an either or uh combination between whether
  112. companies want to do the work in the US or whether they want to do it offshore versus India they actually want to do
  113. both they want to have both options but what I think the uh where I think the biggest effect of reshoring we'll have
  114. is on the Nearshore centers so Nearshore being primarily Canada Mexico Latin America South America I think what we're
  115. seeing from a pricing standpoint is that the difference in pricing between Nearshore providers and onshore
  116. providers in these tier 2 you know highquality locations that we talked about is very thin and so I think
  117. companies are starting to realize that there's not a lot of reason for them or a big driver for them to Outsource it
  118. work to a Nearshore Center versus doing it here in the states what I think their
  119. Nearshore gen uh centers will do is they will service their business in those regions so you know companies will have
  120. Nearshore centers in South America but primarily to support their business in that region not necessarily to export it
  121. work from the US to that region I think the at the end of the day they'll settle
  122. on three locations which is doing work on site doing work offshore in a in a local cost Place high quality place like
  123. India and then doing work in onshore Development Centers or delivery centers I think that's the shift that we think
  124. we'll see so so just wrap things up I have one final question for each of you let's assume that uh a CEO of a major
  125. company comes to you Morris and says so uh you're doing a lot of very interesting research on
  126. reshoring uh as how can my company uh what advice would you give my company uh to take advantage of this phenomenon
  127. what's in it for my company what would you say well I think what I would say is that don't take anything for granted I
  128. mean there are a lot of generalities that have been stated about should you resore should you not resore where
  129. should you resore and these are generalities that don't hold up to scrutiny I think that every company has
  130. to look at their situation which is unique and they have to look at it very extens intensively
  131. they have to make a comprehensive analysis of the business case taking into account all of these risk factors
  132. and cost trade-offs trying to understand what future scenarios they are they have
  133. they have to do do the analysis to support it I think what has happened in the past is the the labor the wage cost
  134. differential was so high that it became the default we all offshore it's a no-brainer we we'll just everybody else
  135. is doing it we're going to do it and now some are coming back some are not coming
  136. back some are combining it in a combination it's a lot Messier it's a lot more complicated as it should be and
  137. I think that any company that would come to me I'd say let's look at the numbers
  138. let's look at the Strategic issues and let's do you know do an analysis that is appropriate for your company and your
  139. industry don't take things for granted right uh same question for you Scott U CEO has approached you uh with uh a
  140. proposition to possibly reshore it operations what's your advice to them I think I'd say three things I would say
  141. one the time is is right I couldn't have said that two three four years ago I can
  142. say that today the time is right to look at this the second thing I would say is
  143. pick your location very carefully the success or failure of of of reshoring or building a tech center in the US is very
  144. dependent on the location you pick so look at the demographics look at the trends um you know we we did that when
  145. we picked picked our first center we looked at the simple migration trends of the US population and the business
  146. community and it certainly shows east to west and north to south which is why our
  147. first center is in Florida it makes a lot of sense people want to live there you can attract Tech Talent there
  148. there's a lot of of reasons a lot of high quality of life pick to Center very carefully if you pick it in a place that
  149. you won't be able to scale it then it'll fail and the third and last thing I would say is you know you know talk to a
  150. a company like a m tree who does this for a living you know we can help with that
  151. process great well thanks to both of you for thank you very much discussion thank
  152. you yeah appreciate it [Music]

Brief Summary

Morris and Scott discuss reshoring trends and the future of U.S. jobs in technology and manufacturing.

Key points

  • Future Job Prospects. Experts discuss the potential for job growth in the U.S. over the next decade.
  • Advice on Reshoring. Key insights for companies looking to reshore operations, emphasizing careful analysis and location selection.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes