The Science of Personality

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. i'm adam grant i'm here with brian little who teaches at cambridge he's also a senior fellow here at the wharton
  2. school he's a personality psychologist and the author of me myself and us a wonderful new book and it's not every
  3. day that i actually get to interview my mentor on camera brian for starters tell us about your
  4. book the book actually grew out of experiences you and i had uh which were at harvard a few years ago
  5. i had stumbled upon the opportunity of teaching a class and as the class sort of went on after a few
  6. days it got bigger and then bigger and i thought oh isn't this wonderful all the students are
  7. coming but in fact it was the ex-boyfriends of some of the students in the class were coming
  8. because there seemed to be something that touched their their hearts and let them think that
  9. there was something of value here beyond the classroom that may actually influence
  10. their lives and then it started to happen that the parents would come and and belligerent uncles and things like that
  11. and so i thought in about the year 2000 that it would be a good eye it would be a good idea to write a book
  12. that would engage with those people who weren't taking personality psychology as
  13. an academic course but as a way of illuminating their lives and understanding the people
  14. they love and work with i remember sending every one of my roommates actually forcing them to take
  15. your course and everything i remember that too i i of course got repaid for that by them
  16. coming back and diagnosing all of my problems and pathologies which i suppose i deserved
  17. but one of the most interesting things we learned about in the course was this idea of free traits
  18. talk to us about that thank you i think the the the setup to this is that right now the study of traits is
  19. in the ascendancy as as you know there was a time when trait psychology was was in deep trouble and it was uh as a
  20. result of walter michelle's 1968 book uh personality and assessment where uh he drew the the conclusion that
  21. stable traits of personality were non-existent he's modified that position more recently but at the time it dealt
  22. quite a blow to the to the field in the um in the ensuing years trait psychologists
  23. those who study the big five dimensions of personality gained regained ascendancy
  24. and it's become i think certainly the most active field of personality research but i have some concerns about it let me
  25. let me tell the essence of my concerns about about traits um the big five dimensions um spell out
  26. the acronym ocean openness conscientiousness extroversion agreeableness and and neuroticism and
  27. many who study traits believe that we can be adequately and effectively described
  28. by our status on those five dimensions and i think there's some truth to that and i lecture as you know
  29. um about these in in the book i uh spend a couple of chapters talking about these relatively fixed
  30. traits of personality and perhaps the most um topical and hot topic is is that of um
  31. extroversion largely the result of our mutual friend susan kane's uh book quiet and um
  32. one of the which i strongly recommend your viewers to to read except for chapter nine
  33. because chapter nine is about the uh machinations of a strange little canadian uh guy who taught at harvard for a few
  34. years uh who used to hide from the students in the washroom and um i and i explained that behavior i
  35. guess it's somebody very similar to me and um it i explained that behavior by invoking the notion of free traits
  36. i am and this surprises my students um a very introverted person i'm off the bottom of the scale
  37. as an introvert but because of something that matters dearly to me which is a personal project to
  38. professing with passion and alliterating in a public place i i will act as an extrovert when i'm
  39. lecturing i'll speak loudly as as you do when you're addressing a class at the beginning
  40. i'll gesticulate wildly i hope not too wildly wildly because i think we need to not to
  41. be overbearing when we're professing but we need to keep students awake at eight in the morning
  42. and so i act like that and i'm engaged in what i call a free trade um and much of me myself and us the book
  43. deals with how free trait behavior differs from trait behavior or fixed trade behavior and the free trade of in my
  44. case pseudo extra version plays out by advancing my core project which is engaging with my students whom
  45. i love um and and it advances that core project in ways that will redown to my benefit
  46. but there are potential costs i'm not rare many people act out of character through free trades
  47. there are highly agreeable people who for all of the month of march act out of character because they're
  48. trying to get a better place for their mother in a care home and they have to bash down the doors of
  49. administrative um resistance and an advance a project take care of mom that enjoins that
  50. person to act in a disagreeable way we can do this it's called professionalism it's also called
  51. love but we may pay a price if we act protractedly act out of character um for uh for a long period the the
  52. empirical evidence on that is still growing i'd say right now it's mixed but uh there is
  53. growing evidence that acting in ways that go against your first nature as i call it may um may be problematic
  54. at the same time as it advances our well-being so when we take this into the workplace
  55. one of the things that you touched on is this idea that we all have personal projects
  56. these commitments that we make to courses of action that matter deeply to us how can an understanding of the personal
  57. projects the people i work with enable us to work more effectively together well i think it it offers an explanation
  58. for their action in ways that simply monitoring or attending to their their outward invisible behavior would
  59. not um i think we can watch a person who is engaged in a pattern of behavior that
  60. makes us say that person is neurotic um and therefore i may write that person down because
  61. he appears to be anxious when dealing with clients but in fact that person may be engaged in a personal project
  62. that um is entirely explicable by no by noting what that core project is that core project
  63. may be that i've got to pick up my kid um he's waiting outside in the cold um i know i'm a little distracted and i may
  64. give the appearance of not understanding what's going on in this financial meeting once you understand what a
  65. person's core projects or even ask a person how's it going david it puts us in a
  66. position where we can actually treat humans as humans and that to me is going to pay
  67. enormous benefits in the long term now you sort of take a stand in the book about some more effective and less
  68. effective ways of thinking about personality and one of the more popular ones of course is the myers-briggs type
  69. indicator which you've been observing for almost half a century now yes um where do you
  70. stand on that as an assessment instrument um i in the in the book i i take a few
  71. whacks at the mbti um but then i i come back and and look at um the the function that it serves of
  72. getting people to talk about individual differences in personality and that's good
  73. i think that it opens up a way of thinking about each other uh and thinking about ourselves the
  74. validity and reliability leaves a lot to be desired from a hard-nosed psychometrist perspective but
  75. i think it does serve a purpose and so unlike some of my students who would totally castigate it
  76. i would say that there is a room for that but we need to be cautious and the best example is by invoking free
  77. traits again that people who walk around with a i am an extrovert or i'm uh an intuitive
  78. introvert um sometimes reify it so much that they actually think that there's a kind of
  79. neurological circuit in the brain that declares itself as i am an extrovert or i am an introvert
  80. and that is palpably false and i think by cordoning ourselves off from refutation
  81. by claiming as a core sense of our identity that i am an extrovert we or any of the other myers-briggs
  82. designations i think we reduce our degrees of freedom to be fully human adam let me just use a random name maybe
  83. quite introverted but he could act out of character and advance the core projects that matter to him such as his
  84. students at wharton and and all that is is important but if he just walked around
  85. with i am an introvert on his forehead the degrees of freedom would be severely curtailed
  86. probably my favorite chapter in the book was the one about self-monitoring which
  87. i think captures some of the the fundamental questions around when do some people essentially end up
  88. adapting to the situation whereas others choose to say this is who i am yeah talk to us a little bit about
  89. what we should know about self-monitoring self-monitoring um boomed in the in the
  90. 70s with mark snyder's work and i sort of revisited and tried to cast it in terms of
  91. of the whole issue of fidelity to to our beliefs and um and and authenticity and the current
  92. debate about authenticity um high self-monitors are those who will adapt themselves to the uh
  93. to the to the current situation so at a party they will act party at a funeral they were
  94. act funeral um and um and those who are low self-monitors will shape their behavior
  95. to accord the high self monitors will shape their behavior to accord uh to the situation
  96. the low self monitors will act on the basis of their own um beliefs and their own personality traits and so
  97. if they're feeling particularly funerial at party a low self-monitor says well that's the way i am
  98. i like to be glum at a party uh the high soft monitor would say good god it's a party
  99. why are you standing by the coffin staring at it i mean um you've got to shape yourself up by
  100. adapting to the situation to which the low self-monitor says i don't get it why people who are stand-up chameleons have
  101. no character and those who are high self monitors will say those who are rigidly
  102. themselves have no humanity because they're insensitive to the needs of others and so the conclusion i reach after
  103. giving a bunch of the research in this area is that i think on balance high self-monitoring is very adaptive
  104. as long as it doesn't blend itself into what's called aesthetic character disorder
  105. where you are so imbued with the um with the demands of the situation or the delights or the aesthetics of the
  106. situation that you will act in ways that go against your core values and there have been some politicians who
  107. have been accused of having ascetic character disorder and i think that it in turn blends into a kind
  108. of insensitivity that can be downright downright dangerous in closing we often think that great leaders are
  109. great teachers and i think it would be great to hear a little bit of wisdom on what we can
  110. learn from one of the true great teachers you won canada's highest award for university
  111. teaching you were the one of the favorite professors of the harvard class every year you taught there
  112. um what can leaders learn from the way that you teach in the classroom oh first thank you um i've been giving a
  113. lot of thought to this recently um and part of it was stimulated by by your own work uh and by the
  114. evidence that uh introverts can be good are good listeners and that balance between
  115. talking and listening asserting and reflecting and the capacity to shift between them
  116. seems to be really critical so i don't think that there is a one size fits all personality type for
  117. leaders i think there's a there are diverse set of factors the key aspect of which is the ability
  118. to choose select and empower the most virtuous forms of your own personality the capacity to listen the capacity to
  119. say i've listened i must act the capacity to show alacrity moving in and dealing with the
  120. situation instead of puzzling and all hamlet-like and not being sure but overdoing one or the other i think
  121. leads to to problems uh both personal and and political thank you brian thank you
  122. adam you

Brief Summary

Adam Grant interviews Brian Little on personality psychology, free traits, self-monitoring, and effective teaching in leadership.

Key points

  • Interview with Brian. Adam Grant interviews his mentor Brian about personality psychology and his new book.
  • The Concept of Free Traits. Brian explains the idea of free traits and how they influence behavior.
  • Self-Monitoring and Authenticity. Brian discusses the balance between adapting to situations and staying true to oneself.
  • Leadership Lessons from Teaching. Brian shares insights on what leaders can learn from effective teaching methods.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes