What Ostriches Can Teach Us About Risk

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A new book by Wharton professors Howard Kunreuther and Robert Meyer offers an innovative solution for addressing the biases that prevent people and groups from adequately preparing for disasters. More: http://knlg.net/2kfOEXy 📂 Finance & Accounting;Innovation;Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton professors Howard kther and Robert Meyer to talk about their new book the ostrich Paradox
  2. why we under prepare for disasters Howard and Robert thanks for being with us thanks so much now I first wanted to
  3. ask you about the title of the book because like most people I assumed what it meant was that we should we should
  4. not be like ostriches that we should not keep our heads in the sand when it comes
  5. to disasters but actually it turns out that that's not quite the case so could you tell us yeah absolutely the um uh
  6. that what motivated the book because we were very much interested in writing about uh why it is that uh we can't seem
  7. to get a hold on disasters that that even though scientific abilities to forecast hurricanes and so forth has
  8. really grown considerably over the years that hasn't really been matched with it
  9. with any sort of a noticeable decrease in the uh uh in the costs both in terms of lives and monetary losses from uh
  10. from natural disasters or man-made disasters and and often the the reason that that's given is whenever that
  11. happens we say that well people are putting their heads in the sand they're they're ostriches and uh and that's sort
  12. of the the old cartoon notion of what an ostrich is when thread is coming a lion
  13. is coming they dig their head in the sand and sort of pretend it doesn't exist um and it turns out that actually
  14. that that's uh ostriches have been given a a severe bum wrap for that over the years because actually ostriches are
  15. incredibly good at dealing with risk uh they have enormous limitations they can't fly but the but the Nature has
  16. allowed them to overcome that by having enormous ground speed and have all sorts
  17. of risk of avoidance strategies so then occurred to us that actually therein is sort of like might be a a key to the way
  18. in which we can get people to be better uh at preparing for risk rather than being um less like ostriches actually to
  19. be more like ostriches to first start off and say what are the limitations that we have what are the psychological
  20. limitations that prevent us from being better and preparing for disasters and once we understand what those are are
  21. think about ways in which we can better adapt to those limitations so we're more
  22. like ostriches rather than less hence the Paradox yeah and the only point I'd want to add to Bob's comment is uh that
  23. I learned a bit about ostriches just in the context of the discussion that the two of us had together in terms of what
  24. they did and also that we do bury our heads in the sand often and so in some sense we felt that in a way using the
  25. ostrich as the as a way of an analogy to kind of the things that we do we might be in a position for people to pay
  26. attention and I think the real challenge in any of this area is for people to pay
  27. attention before something happen rather than afterwards and ostriches are very good at doing that and we hope that
  28. human beings can do a better job than they have up until now right now I mean the book actually starts with a really
  29. interesting example of galvaston Texas it was two I believe it was hurricanes hundreds of years apart maybe almost but
  30. the same reaction even though for the second time technology had Advanced significantly science had Advanced
  31. significantly Communications had Advanced significantly and yet there was still this same under response to the
  32. disaster and I wondered I guess the book is actually full of stories like this and
  33. was there one in particular that inspired the book well actually let me jump it there because for me the thing
  34. that inspired is actually a story which is not in the book okay and uh and it was like in I think it was 2008 I was um
  35. visiting New Orleans and I decided uh to take a drive along the Mississippi Gulf
  36. Coast and as I was driving along near the town of past Christian Mississippi which was an area which had been
  37. devastated by Hurricane Katrina I was sort of noticing how how quickly the place had recovered and there was what
  38. there was just a lot of nice grass fields and I was walking along I was driving along the road and I noticed
  39. that in one of the fields was a an ATM machine that was just sitting up by itself and uh and I and I looked at that
  40. and I pulled over and I said what's an ATM machine doing out in the middle of a field so I kind of walked up to it and I
  41. looked at it and then I began looking around and then I discovered afterwards that what what this was was used to be a
  42. shopping center that used to be right on the coast that had been completely destroyed by Hurricane Katrina and the
  43. only thing that was left was uh the the the the ATM machine and then I kind of did I was interested in this this how
  44. this happened and then the interesting thing was it turned out that this shopping center was built on the exact
  45. same spot that in 1969 a condominium complex used to be there and 23 people died when the condominium complex was
  46. blown away by a hurricane and and so basically so I contacted the the the person who was uh who own the land of
  47. the shopping center and I said did you know that this used to be have this horrible history and they said yeah it'
  48. been but it been so many years since there had been a storm I didn't we didn't think it was in under much risk
  49. and so then I said well what do you plan to do with the property he says well we're thinking about us selling it and
  50. hope to put build up a condominium complex here again and so I was sitting there and I was thinking there's got to
  51. be a story there there there there has to be uh uh you know what why is it that we kind of keep uh don't learn from
  52. experience why is it that we're not better at thinking had in terms of what the the consequences are of of uh of of
  53. threats like this and so what are all the different types of psychological factors that that caus us to be so poor
  54. at preparing for disasters I think that U just to follow up on on a story in the
  55. book that actually did started off is a story of Glenda Moore who uh was in a position where she had to figure out
  56. what decision she was going to make after Hurricane Sandy and I think all of us were very very cognizant of the
  57. challenges we face after a storm occurs in in the sense that we know there are things we should do and we are things
  58. that we might not do but we don't really know them as well as we should and I think that Glenda's first concern was to
  59. be with her husband who had actually left and she and was in Brooklyn and made a set of decisions without
  60. necessarily carefully thinking them out and our concern I think when uh with respect to pointing this out to others
  61. is that to a large extent we react to two situations at the moment without necessarily doing an analysis of all of
  62. the possible dangers and the communication mechanisms are sometimes good but we sometimes don't hear them
  63. and so she actually made some decisions to leave that actually resulted in her losing her children and as a result of
  64. that uh there was a whole set of media attention given to that and our feeling was it was a way to start the book to
  65. point out the fact that we would like everyone to reflect on what could happen after a disaster then and do some steps
  66. beforehand to prepare and also to listen to the kinds of things that one is hearing and try to get the right kind of
  67. information so one doesn't do the things that could result in tragedy and now you
  68. actually outlined six different biases that may be at play that may lead to some of this under preparation for
  69. disasters and I somewhere in the book you had mentioned or maybe it was in this other interview that came with my
  70. book about that perhaps the most dangerous one of these six might be optimism which I thought was very
  71. interesting just because we usually think of that as a good thing yeah yeah yeah no absolutely I think in fact it is
  72. the good thing to have in life I mean uh you know we've been fortunately endowed
  73. with an optimistic Outlook uh uh and so forth the problem is is that in fact I think this is true with almost with all
  74. of the biases that we talk about in the book these are things which uh which the
  75. reason why we have them is they serve a good functional purpose and most of the time and most the the decisions we face
  76. on a day-to-day basis they basically serve us well and and um however it's also the case that when when you
  77. suddenly now we're in a situation of facing very very rare events things that we decisions we don't have to make on a
  78. day-to-day basis uh that's where when you start applying these same heris sixs all of a sudden all sorts of stuff goes
  79. wrong and optimism is a great case of that um you know it is good to look on the bright side of life and all of that
  80. sort of thing however when uh when you're talking about something that might happen to you that might mean the
  81. end of your life uh then being optimistic is not necessarily the best thing to do and and uh and one of the
  82. things we talk about is sort of you know what are the different ways in which people become erroneously optimistic in
  83. a way that's harmful and I think one of the things with optimism is that we try to find ways to sort of defend our
  84. optimism and so we think about a a n a disaster a flood or a hurricane we don't really want to think about those
  85. disasters we're optimistic because we are living in an area that we say this is a great place for us to live and we
  86. want to sort of keep that image alive and so we say well let's you know this is so low the chances of anything
  87. happening are so low that we're not going to really think about it it won't happen to us it may happen to others it
  88. won't happen to us it's below we we use the Expression our threshold level of concern we're not going to worry so we
  89. keep that optimistic bias in the sense of trying to avoid having to think about things that we probably should be
  90. thinking about beforehand and our whole idea in bringing that up along with the four or five other we have six biases uh
  91. is to say they're all connected in some sense uh and in one way or another we have to try to figure out ways to let
  92. people know that these are things that we all do and we all have our own personal examples and then we can think
  93. about ways to improve the decisions by trying to avoid them in the future and now your method of improving this what
  94. you lay out in the book is called the behavior risk audit and this sort of this involves looking at each of these
  95. risks and kind of turning I mean each of these biases and kind of turning them on
  96. their heads and seeing how can we create polies that actually address these biases and maybe get around them can you
  97. talk a little bit about how people could do this well let let me illustrate with
  98. one and and Bob May pick one another one um myopia is one of the biases that we have people are have very very short
  99. term we all have short-term Horizons we want to get immediate returns in some sense and if there are things that we
  100. can do for the long term we often find they are very prohibitively expensive they're costly we can't really do them
  101. let's take an example of having to make our house safer against uh Hurricane Sandy or flood uh or hurricane uh
  102. there's a lot of cost to doing that you could elevate your house but that's very
  103. costly you could maybe flood proof or you could do a set of things and people will say well look what are the benefits
  104. that I'm going to get from that in the next period And so they'll be very reluctant to put in the money because
  105. they say the benefits we have to get are going to be very short run and they're right I mean in some sense if you're
  106. going to get a short run benefit like a reduction in your insurance premium uh you'll say well I'm not going to get
  107. enough to pay for that expense so we would recommend that instead of thinking about just the long term with respect to
  108. this there are two things that one can do one is you might give a person a loan to help them out and spread the cost
  109. over time and the other thing to deal with the it won't happen to me instead of saying it's going to be a one in a
  110. 100 chance of a flood occurring next year which is kind of what the probability is stretch the time and say
  111. to people think about the fact that there might be a a hurricane in the next 30 years and that likelihood is greater
  112. than one in four or one in five and then people will think about the long term and maybe decide that they can take some
  113. action yeah another example another one of the biases we talk about is uh is simplification and the the idea there is
  114. is that most people don't like to consider lots of different factors when making decisions and uh and one feature
  115. of this is a thing called The Single Action bias and what it is is that when you're faced with the problem uh you
  116. basic as soon as you take like one action to try to solve it there's a tendency for your brain to go good there
  117. was the problem I took some action problem solved and uh so in a lot of walks of life that's kind of an okay
  118. thing to do but think about in the context of of preparing for natural disasters when in fact there's large
  119. numbers of things that you need to do or or you're trying to build a safer house
  120. in which in order to make the house structurally sound there's lots of different things that you have to do
  121. well often kind of historically the way in which uh agencies like uh uh Noah and
  122. and FEMA and whatnot have encouraged people to prepare for disasters is to give them checklists and the checklist
  123. will have 60 items on them and you say make sure you do this with your dog make sure you do this and so forth well the
  124. single action bias will say people are going to ignore most of those things but they are going to see the list they are
  125. going to be aware that there's a threat the problem is is that they're going to go down this list randomly and take care
  126. of the dog or whatever and once they've done that that's the end of the list and
  127. they feel that they're sort of prepared for the disaster when and they're they're really not so so one of the
  128. remedies for that is to say now that we know people simplify and they tend to focus on one action what an agency needs
  129. to do is don't give them a massive checklist say if you're going to do one thing here's the one thing to do okay
  130. and once you've done that here's the second thing to do and you have to kind of walk people through that and that's
  131. going to be a much more effective way of of of getting people to prepare now do you
  132. know of examples of agencies or governments or companies that are that are doing things like this that have
  133. developed policies like this or do we do they all need to get a copy of the book
  134. they got to get a copy of the book they definitely have to get but I'll give one
  135. example and and related to what I said a few moments ago the Federal Emergency Management agency is very concerned with
  136. communicating risk and they have actually changed the way they're presenting information on the flood
  137. Hazard they used to talk about a one in a 100e flood or return period they're now telling people think about the next
  138. 30 years when you and what could happen to you and you should be considering buying insurance for next year even
  139. though uh you are thinking about the fact that it's low probability it could be greater than such and such for one
  140. and four for a disaster to occur so they are actually trying to take that seriously we don't but they have to do
  141. this in such a way that they communicate so people at least read that which of course is a challenge and of itself I
  142. mean because I would think with that it's like they're taking it from 100 to 30 actually takes it back within the
  143. realm of their lifetime so they're doing it for them not for the people who are going to live there in the future that's
  144. exactly right they want to get a reasonable time period but if they said and and they and and when they do that
  145. they of course stretch the probability and make it a lot higher than it would occur next year now could a family or an
  146. individual use this Behavior risk AIT to help themselves prepare for disasters or
  147. is it more for policy makers ERS or companies no I think it's absolutely can be used for for individual households
  148. because I think that often it's the case that that often it's the case the companies themselves at a very very high
  149. level are actually fairly good at thinking through all the details and having very well-developed um you know
  150. risk avoidance plans or something like that for example a a a utility compan has actually tend to be very good at
  151. this sort of thing on the other hand a lot of the kind what with this book I think is a little bit more targeted at
  152. is uh organizations which aren't necessarily all that experts in terms of R risk preparation and so for any given
  153. family uh you need to sit down and think through well well how is it that we as a
  154. family are thinking about risk and these biases actually even more so apply there
  155. um and Howard was given the example of start that started out the book about uh the Glend deore family where a woman um
  156. uh hastily put her children into a van and then took them down and uh in front of the and they she lost the children
  157. and in a Hy in a Hast evacuation I that you know we would like to think that this is a book which kind can help
  158. households like that um make sure that those events never occur and what it does is it says look you know when
  159. you're faced with disasters these are the kind of mistakes that you're likely to make and it's not because there's
  160. something wrong with you you're just human and these are these are hard grain hardwired biases that we have and once
  161. we understand what those are you can kind of anticipate the kind of mistakes you're going to make and so and then
  162. that's the first step in trying to avoid them here's what our hope is there are a
  163. series of stories that are graphic and people do react to graphic stories in a way that they don't react to just the
  164. facts or whatever and and our hope is that people will read these stories and recognize that it can happen to them in
  165. some way and it has happened to others and that they'll pay attention to the very last part of the book on here ways
  166. to improve and then we would like to use one of our biases that we hope makes this book more than just one person
  167. reading it and that's the her effect and we hope that there will be somehow a notion that people will see this and say
  168. you know this is something I'd like to talk to a few other people about and it isn't just our situation it may be
  169. others and I hope it becomes a topic which generally is not a topic of conversation of the fact that we have
  170. these kinds of biases we have these things and we all think of our own sets of activities that might reflect that
  171. and we have our own personal ones which we can experience and that that becomes really more of a social Norm that this
  172. is something that people should recognize they have and there's a tendency with with the kinds of events
  173. we're talking about for people not to want to pay attention and our hope is that the stories that we tell here will
  174. resonate enough so that people will want to actually think about them I mean it seems like we don't you know we hear
  175. about hurricanes when they're a day away or two days away or maybe in the immediate aftermath but then we don't
  176. hear about them again until the next one comes along and you talk a lot about those types of events in the book but
  177. you also talk about more long range events specifically about about climate change which is not something that the
  178. be the worst part of it's not going to happen tomorrow or next week next year maybe even not in the next decade but
  179. how does the behavior risk audit apply to something like that where it's more of a long-term broader risk well this is
  180. a real Challenge and I think we recognize it's a challenge that we're facing right now because climate change
  181. is not necessarily being discussed in a way that I think we would like to see it
  182. discussed it is a critical problem um and Miami where Bob has lived there for a while and can and can talk about that
  183. directly is facing major problems with sea level possible sea level rise and people may not be paying attention right
  184. now and I think what we would say I and a way to say it is first of all construct some scenarios that you begin
  185. to see what might happen and think about how you can take some steps now to avoid
  186. those scenarios and also to think about the fact that it isn't just yourselves but there's future Generations at stake
  187. and what is going to be what is this going to do to my children and my great grandchildren and how can we take some
  188. steps and try to make the case to recognize that there's a tendency to say this is not going to happen and it won't
  189. happen necessarily tomorrow but there has to be planning and it isn't just for the individuals it's for communities and
  190. that's why I point out Miami being one example of that uh yeah that as Howard said I think long run risk is very
  191. difficult uh and particularly if it's the case of let's say if you're living in in any Coastal area you're worried
  192. about SE level rise and you say well scientists are forecasting that in 60 to 70 years this area that you're living in
  193. is going to be underwater uh well that's I'm not going to be living there in 607
  194. years so why should I particularly care about that and you what how do I justify
  195. that and this is particularly the case for communities who are thinking about doing things like raising taxes and bond
  196. issues to put up Public Works projects to prevent sea level rise when the people who are voting for them are going
  197. to have to pay these taxes aren't going to be the ones that are actually going to be benefiting from it and so I I
  198. think that that people might understand well maybe we need to take care of it but maybe we should just do this next
  199. year okay that uh this to put off yeah it's it's easy to put off because nothing's going to change that much and
  200. so so of course what happens is you keep putting it off till the next year and it
  201. never never gets done so some of the things we we were kind of thinking about within the book are what are ways in
  202. which you can kind of get people to take uh safe actions or have a culture of safety in a situation where they don't
  203. have to they're not the uncertainty is actually not is on taking risk rather than than not taking risk so for example
  204. um normally it's the case of you have your your city budget and one of the light items should be should we put
  205. multi-million dollars into a pumping system okay and that's an add-on and then you have to think through is this a
  206. good use of the money now well what if it was the case that every year just is a standard starting point in the in the
  207. in the community budget that there's money set aside for infrastructure improvements but then that can be
  208. removed so all of a sudden then the discussion is uh do we want to not take a safe action this year or not and then
  209. that might be just enough to basically keep some of those items still on the budget which they might have might have
  210. otherwise been removed and the hope is through those little sorts of steps that might we get a little bit closer at
  211. dealing with some of these these extremely difficult Long Run problems and you could couple just what Bob is
  212. saying with the notion of let's not make make sure we don't have the cost immediately on top of us having a
  213. long-term loan so that you do spread it over a number of years will make it more
  214. attractive and then if you can show that there are benefits that are going to occur even in the short run that maybe
  215. property vales will go up maybe people will want to move into the area and you can sell your home a little more easily
  216. by the fact that one recognizes the community is taking steps now to avoid this problem that might be really
  217. serious 20 or 30 years from now and now would be a lot less serious and I think those are problems facing coastal cities
  218. again bringing up Miami that really has to be concerned about what is going to happen to the property values of their
  219. homes all of a sudden when people say we're not really taking the steps and now we are seeing that this is going to
  220. be a major problem so I think if we can combine these things with economic incentives with the default option that
  221. Bob mentioned and which is one of our Notions is if you don't do this the fact is you have to say I'm not going to do
  222. this rather than I'm going to do this and also to recognize one of the challenges and Bob brought it up very
  223. directly on the political process we have a little acronym that we occasionally use and I'll use it right
  224. now uh Nim not in my term of office if we can avoid that avoid the notion of having
  225. expended and recognize that there are benefits of being doing this in my term of office rather than saying it's not in
  226. my term of office then I think we have a chance of at least getting people to pay
  227. attention now what about different kinds of risk like political risks I some of the things that I read in the book
  228. really reminded me a little bit of some of the things that you know you heard heard people in the UK say around the
  229. time of brexit that oh this won't happen it won't pass or even around the time of
  230. the election that I feel like there was maybe some myopia or or optimism at play
  231. a little bit there do I mean do you think that the principles in the book can apply to different types of risk
  232. other than natural disasters or environmental risk well uh I mean we haven't thought explicitly about brexit
  233. uh in terms of that or and use an example but I think there is a a notion here that the of a feeling that people
  234. may not really necessarily appreciate all the elements of a particular problem I think that's what I would want to use
  235. and I think we can say about brexit and I think we can say about the election that occurred that there was a degree of
  236. optimism by people who felt that they really didn't have to be concerned about necessarily voting in a particular way
  237. on the basis of feeling that this was a foregone conclusion that things were going to work out that way and so in
  238. that sense we come back to the optimism bias in terms of what one hopes will happen but may not actually happen yeah
  239. and I I certainly you can go through those biases and they can provide kind of an explanation for why maybe a lot of
  240. people were very surprised by the uh uh the the uh the last election or alternative looking at half you know
  241. half the country was not at all surprised and the other half was extremely surprised and and I think that
  242. the part that was extremely surprised was influenced by things like herd think uh they went around and the people that
  243. they talked to were people had their same values that they did and they became under the belief that this is the
  244. way the world is and uh and and and so on and so on and you know simplification there's a tendency to to not look
  245. broadly and looking for evidence that maybe there are people out there who don't think like you do and and when you
  246. take all these things together all of a sudden there's this group think which in
  247. many cases may have led for a lot of people who were for example Clinton supporters to feel they didn't need to
  248. vote on and so forth and it's such a foregone conclusion so Howard and Robert thanks for being with us good to be here
  249. yeah glad to be here thanks [Music] [Music]

Brief Summary

Wharton professors discuss disaster preparedness and psychological biases in their book, <i>The Ostrich Paradox</i>, emphasizing the need for proactive measures.

Key points

  • The Ostrich Paradox Explained. The book reveals why we underprepare for disasters and how we can learn from ostriches.
  • Lessons from Hurricane Sandy. A personal story illustrates the consequences of poor decision-making during disasters.
  • The Role of Optimism. Exploring how optimism can hinder disaster preparedness, despite its positive connotations.
  • The Challenge of Climate Change. Climate change isn't just a future problem; it's a critical issue we must address now.
  • Planning for Future Generations. We must consider the impact of our actions on future generations and take steps today.
  • The Danger of Complacency. It's easy to delay action on climate change when immediate consequences aren't visible.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes