How to Regulate Innovation -- Without Killing It
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Regulations don’t always evolve as quickly as technological change — at least that’s the perception. So what should policy makers and regulators do? More: http://knlg.net/2jLJ4ez 📂 Innovation 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Digital innovation is giving rise to new business models. Uber and Airbnb are household names today when not so long
- ago we were all learning about the sharing economy. But regulations don't always evolve as quickly as uh technolog
- technological change at least that's a perception. Uh so what should policymakers and regulators do? Here to
- talk about some his some of his insights is uh Wharton professor Kevin Warbach. He recently wrote a policy brief for the
- pen Wharton policy public policy initiative. Uh welcome Kevin. Thanks. Glad to be here. So in your article you
- mentioned something called the internet of the world. Can you tell us what that is? Well I think there's something big
- going on and it's it's a bigger trend than most people realize. There are three trends that each in of themselves
- is significant. One is uh what we often call the sharing economy. I think it's really more the ondemand economy. It's
- not just about sharing resources, but services like you mentioned like Uber and Airbnb which give ondemand access to
- resources. The second piece is the internet of things, all kinds of devices, billions and billions of
- devices gettingororked. And the third is big data and analytics, the ability to understand and manipulate trends coming
- out of all those devices. What those three things together mean is that all of the world potentially isworked. It's
- not just that you go somewhere to a computer, you go to your phone to get access to information. It's that
- potentially everything is a generator of data and all that data can be integrated
- and analyzed and processed and manipulated. Um, and so what that means is the kinds of trends and the kinds of
- developments that we saw online are now happening offline. they're happening to things and physical objects in the world
- as well. You also point out that the scale of ondemand services is potentially much greater than the legacy
- industries they challenge. How so? So there's this uh kind of cheap talk about new technologies disrupting old
- technologies. And actually the theory of disruptive innovation which goes back to
- Clayton Christensen at Harvard Business School is a a serious academic theory. Uh but far too often people in business
- and entrepreneurship and the media kind of use the word disruption as just kind of a synonym for new technology. And the
- reality is it's not that you have one market and suddenly a bunch of new companies come in and replace that
- market. Often what happens and this is what we're seeing with things like ondemand economy is that the new markets
- are different. So it's not that Uber takes the taxi market and every taxi gets replaced by an Uber driver. Uh in
- fact Uber has put out some numbers for the past several years that show that the scale of the market they are tapping
- into is actually much bigger. So they generate far more revenue in the cities where they are mature than the taxi
- industry as a whole does. So what that means is it's not just a competitive threat and certainly it is a competitive
- threat to the incumbent industries but it's creating something new. It's unlocking latent demand that the
- previous approaches didn't reach. You also say that um you also pointed out that throughout the different techn
- technological waves since the 1990s we went through e-commerce, social media, now mobile that regulations have always
- been seen as an enemy of innovation. But you say that this digital dichotomy is actually misunderstood. Can you explain
- that? Sure. So there's two pieces to it. One is the term that you reference that
- I use in the paper called the digital dichconomy. That is a misunderstanding that the online world is inherently
- different from the offline world. Uh and the reason that's not true is what I said at the beginning. Um increasingly
- there is no difference even if you're using a physical thing. So take the Uber example and it's such a perfect example.
- Uh the per there's a person there's a physical person driving a physical car but from your standpoint running the app
- and pushing a button and saying make a car appear. It's as though that's something that's in cyerspace. It's as
- though it's something digital. an extension of the software infrastructure of Uber. Uh even though it's a physical
- thing, a physical person driving a physical car. Um and so we tend to assume that there's one set of rules for
- the real world, there's one set of rules for the digital world. And that's a mistake because increasingly there is
- just the world. Software, technology, networks, all these trends in what I call the internet of the world are
- affecting everything. So that's the first piece. the assumption that uh we can just ignore the rules of the
- physical world because we need totally new rules for the digital world. Um the larger issue though uh is this question
- of innovation and regulation and again there's this common assumption that innovation needs to thrive with no
- regulation and anytime government gets involved that's a check and a drain and a block on innovation and that's not
- really the case and what I talk about in the article you referenced uh and the larger larvy article it's based on is
- that if you go and look at the history uh how the internet developed how electronic commerce developed in the
- 1990s A surprising amount of the time it was government action actually facilitating
- innovation and uh the emerging startups actually pushing for that government innovation to help create a more
- innovative marketplace. That's an interesting point and uh in your article you also pointed to uh one challenge for
- regulators and that is um a lot of these new startups don't really fit neatly into industry categories. So uh and the
- example you pull up you use is uh Uber versus Skype. Can you go through that example? Sure. So I should be clear.
- It's not that regulators always get it right. They make mistakes and they have lots of flaws and lots of reasons why
- they act in a certain way. Uh and we should definitely criticize bad regulations. Um we just shouldn't assume
- necessarily that they are bad and necessarily what what startups do is good. Um the Skype and Uber comparison
- is basically that both of them were companies that when they started were illegal in most jurisdictions. So Skype
- which is the very popular internet communication service originally voice calling now also video and messaging and
- so forth eventually now owned by Microsoft. Uh Skype was illegal in most of the world when it launched because
- there were rules saying you could not do a communication service, a telephone service outside of the existing
- regulatory infrastructure in the US because of what we did. I was at the Federal Communications Commission in the
- 1990s when we had to think about voiceover IP. We very deliberately left open the door. Even though things like
- Skype were outside of the regulatory structure, we made a conscious decision to allow them to develop. And that's an
- example where regulators consciously deciding not to impose a whole set of rules early on when these were nent
- technologies allow them to grow. Um so Uber is similar. Uber is illegal in most of the cities where it operates. Uh and
- the story of Skype I think is a hopeful story because what happened with Skype is that first of all you had regulators
- like the FCC in the US who understood that these new internet calling technologies were an opportunity. They
- were a way to lower prices and create better service and new service and innovation. Uh and so that we shouldn't
- rush to impose all the traditional rules on them. And then as these companies grew, they were able to work with
- regulators to address the rules that were necessary. So for example, it's a concern if you're using Skype or some
- other voiceover IP service. What if you want to call 911? What if you have an emergency? Um those services were all
- outside of the infrastructure of the emergency calling system. And that's a problem if you have your phone and which
- app you're using determines whether if you have an emergency you get through to the police or the fire department. Um
- that's a technical problem that was overcome through regulators working together with the companies. Um and it
- could only be done by a willingness to not immediately impose rules that would have shut these companies down on day
- one, but work through how they can actually help in addressing some of these concerns. And I think that's the
- path forward for companies like Uber and Airbnb as well. What we've started to see is they began with this very strong
- keep no regulation, keep it away from us. Uh, and gradually we're starting to see them recognize that they need to
- work together with the regulators. But don't you think there's one critical difference between Uber and Skype and
- that is, you know, with Uber there's the issue of safety of the users or the writers, but that's not the case with
- Skype. So the example I gave about the 911 service, the emergency, that's a safety issue. Um but no question uh all
- these companies are different. Uh and it's not the case that there's one set of rules, there's one regulator that
- applies to everything. Um I'm making the general point that these new services that spring up outside of the
- traditional regulatory structure. Um they raise public policy issues uh and you can't get away from that. So Uber
- raises a whole host of issues. It raises issues about worker treatment. It raises
- issues about safety of the people in the cars as you mentioned. raises issues about the Americans with Disabilities
- Act. Do they have to provide access for people in wheelchairs and so forth? All these issues. Um, and the way to address
- those issues is not to say it's new, so therefore regulators stay away, they'll figure it out. The way to address them
- is to say, okay, let's look at the issues. So, um, is there a way to address what we really care about in
- safety? What we care about is you don't want people to get into a car and someone be an axe murderer who's driving
- the car. All right. there's different ways that we can solve that problem and and maybe there are solutions and in
- fact Uber because they have all this data and they've got an app and they know everything about the driver maybe
- there's a better way they can solve that problem. Um so the way to work that through is to have that discussion and
- say identify what it is the regulators are trying to do and figure out how we can do that. The problem is initially so
- much of the reaction was the regulators are necessarily bad. um they have nothing to do but to stop the
- innovation. Uh and I think that's not a helpful conversation. Uh your point is that government can actually be a
- positive force in innovative markets. Can you give us more examples of that? Sure. So we saw a lot of examples with
- the growth of the internet and electronic commerce starting 20 years ago. Um one of them was the antitrust
- case against Microsoft. So Microsoft was the dominant company on the personal computer with the operating system
- market and lots of startup companies, companies like Netscape realized if they wanted to innovate, they wanted to build
- the internet economy as we know it today, you couldn't have Microsoft standing there using its power at the
- time. It's hard to realize today with what's happened, the growth of Apple and the growth of smartphones and so forth,
- just how much power Microsoft had as a bottleneck. Microsoft controlled access to the PC and the PC was the only game
- in town. Um, had it not been for that action by the government in filing that antitrust case, Microsoft may have been
- able to warp or slow down the growth of the open internet economy. And it turned
- out most of the startups were on the side of the government in that case wanting to open it up. Um, a similar
- more recent case is the fight over network neutrality rules where lots and lots of startup companies went to the
- Federal Communications Commission and said, "We don't want broadband providers, the access providers, the
- internet service providers or ISPs as they're called to stop us from getting into the market or to basically tax us
- to say, well, you can only get to customers if you pay us this special fee." Um and so they were actually
- urging government to act in order to create a more open market. Great. Um you also say that ondemand services would
- bring what you call algorithmic competition policy questions to the four. Why is this important? What do you
- mean by that? This is a really interesting issue. So competition policy, I gave the example of Microsoft
- um is tremendously important to the digital economy and uh the Microsoft case was an example where there was a
- new kind of uh business model. Microsoft was one of the first to build this platform network-based business model
- where Windows benefited from all the applications on top of Windows. uh but Windows would always want to uh ensure
- that none of those applications would then compete with it. Um and there was tremendous benefits of that model. You
- know, Microsoft did great things for innovation. Uh but uh the Microsoft case put a spotlight on some of the dangers
- and the downsides. What we're seeing now with these next generation platforms, these ondemand platforms is a new twist
- on that model. Um companies like Uber and Airbnb are built on algorithms. are built on software that understands
- supply and demand uh and matches people on both sides of the network. Um and again that's a tremendous boon for
- competition and innovation. I'm not saying it's bad by any means but it does put the platform owner in a position of
- unimaginable control. Um how do you know that what you are paying for that Uber ride is the efficient price? Uber says
- well by definition it's what the algorithm gives you. Well but who controls the algorithm? Um, and what
- stops the algorithm from colluding with someone else's algorithm uh behind the scenes to fix prices? And again, we have
- antitrust doctrines about things like price fixing, but those are based on people in a smokefield room saying,
- "Okay, you're going to charge this and I'm going to charge that and if you defect." Um, now it's all happening
- silently through software. Um, and so I think this is one of the great competition policy challenges of our age
- is how to prevent those kinds of mechanisms from uh raising costs and raising prices and hurting consumers
- while still allowing flexibility for companies to innovate and do things that most of the time actually wind up uh
- helping consumers. So that brings us to the point you made about algorithmic cartels. So how could
- those come about? Uh well so again uh the algorithms can talk to other algorithms and we see this um already
- you look at uh pricing on Amazon.com. So Amazon has this platform that allows anyone else to sell on Amazon.com and
- they can set their price and a lot of the companies that are sophisticated that do this uh set their prices
- algorithmically. So they might say Amazon is charging this price automatically charge 2% less than
- Amazon's price. So when it comes up they're the cheapest price. Um, but what happens is you get this increasingly
- complex uh war between the algorithms because they're all basing their prices on each other and so forth. And what can
- potentially happen is uh companies decide well no let's both agree we'll set a price higher as opposed to
- competing and a race to the bottom and we'll both be better off but who's worse off is consumers. So um that's a concern
- that we're starting to see on platforms like Amazon and it's more of a concern on these digital ondemand platforms
- where again everything is in software uh and where you have lots of different actors coming together um and uh we
- don't even know what the mechanism is to get access to the data to see if that's
- what's happening. So how do you regulate that? Uh well so it's a good question. The first is you start to have a
- conversation where the regulators say here's what we're trying to achieve and the companies say here's what we're
- doing and you figure out what's possible. Um ultimately as I said there needs to be access to the data. Uh and
- this is a great opportunity because these new platforms generate tremendous amounts of data. uh and if they uh and
- they use the data internally to be more efficient and to provide better service,
- but if they could provide more transparency of that data um that would give regulators the opportunity to
- identify what the market performance is and this can be done in a secure way in a way that doesn't uh harm them with
- competitors and so forth. um but it's actually making the regulation itself more algorithm making the regulation
- itself more datadriven which is a healthy and a good thing and so I think this is potentially the new model we're
- going to come to uh but it takes the company's willingness to work together and not to you know make these sort of
- great you know statements uh that oh we don't need any regulation so you mentioned alternatives to direct
- direct regulation which are self-regulation and what you call co-regul regulation and delegated
- regulation. Can you explain the differences among all those? Yeah, these are models that actually are used much
- more widely elsewhere in the world, especially in Europe for things like internet content. Um, and there's a
- whole variety of different models, but basically u they start with the notion that um companies individually and
- industry collectives and industry groups um potentially know the most about their
- market. uh and if they're well-meaning, they can come up with mechanisms that achieve the goals of regulators without
- government having to be intrusive and without government having to be inefficient. Um because regulatory
- agencies don't have the data and they're not set up to operate in that way. The problem is you need some accountability.
- So just saying let companies regulate themselves is meaningless because there's already always incentives for
- companies to cheat or to game the system or to basically help themselves at the expense of the public. Um but there's a
- variety of mechanisms where for example government sets goals and then gives industry or either individually or
- industry groups uh uh opportunities to meet it and then to report on how they're doing and again to provide
- transparency of the data. Um they're mechanisms that basically say all right in the first instance you have this
- opportunity to act but if you don't act in a way that we find appropriate then we're going to intervene. Um and uh
- again there's a variety of different variations on these mechanisms. Uh but it's an approach that says instead of
- everything starts with the regulator the regulator says yes or no before anything
- happens in the marketplace. It says, "All right, companies can come into the marketplace, especially new companies."
- Goes back to what I was saying before, nent small innovators, should have lots of running room. Uh because even a good
- rule will kill them off when they're too small. Um but that doesn't mean that when you've got an Uber, which is a $65
- billion company, it's one of the, you know, the largest companies in the world, even though it's not even public,
- and has hundreds of millions of uh people that it's serving around the world. They're not a small company. um
- they're fairly new, but but they're now a large player that's having big impacts. It doesn't make sense to say
- that that approach makes sense for them anymore. Um so the question is, can we allow them in and then have a process to
- then collaboratively have them work with government uh and have them be more transparent? And again, there's a
- variety of ways to do that. And I'm not arguing for any particular one as being perfect. I'm arguing for an openness and
- a recognition um that um regulation isn't a dirty word. Any final thoughts for policy makers and regulators?
- Um so regulators have to take action here too. It's not that they need to just stay where they are and expect the
- companies to come to them. Um often there's lots of legacy in regulation and some of it is regulators fault and some
- of it is the fault of for example the legislators that set up the rules. Um, a lot of what we're seeing in these
- markets is the need for legislative change, for um, governments to change the structure of the rules because the
- rules use terms that no longer make sense or they have categories that no longer make sense. Um, and so there
- needs to be a lot of dialogue between industry and regulators and legislators to say, all right, where are these
- glitches? Let's fix them. Um, and regulators need to be part of that and not to just assume that the status quo
- is the right approach. Um, regulators also need to be open. They need to go to these uh companies and say to them,
- "Okay, we have shared goals here. We're not here to put you out of business. Um,
- but we care about consumers and we trust that you do too. So, let's let's come up
- with a solution." Um, and so it really has to go both ways and and ultimately this is about trust. There needs to be a
- mutual process of generating trust between these industries and the regulators. Um, and in a lot of cases
- that's lacking, but I'm hopeful and I think the examples that we saw with the growth of the internet really are a
- story about um, good work on both sides uh, that facilitated this extraordinary explosion of innovation and wealth
- creation that we saw. That's very well said and thank you so much for joining us. Thanks. My pleasure.
- [Music]
Brief Summary
Kevin Warbach discusses digital innovation, regulatory challenges, and the evolving relationship between startups and government in the on-demand economy.
Key points
- The Internet of the World. Kevin Warbach discusses the merging of online and offline worlds through technology.
- Disruption Misunderstood. Warbach clarifies that disruption isn't just about new tech replacing old.
- Regulation and Innovation. Warbach argues that regulation can facilitate innovation rather than hinder it.
- Algorithmic Competition Policy. The rise of ondemand services brings new challenges for competition policy.
- The Role of Regulation. Regulation is essential for innovation and trust between industries and regulators.
- Building Trust. A mutual process of trust is crucial for collaboration between companies and regulators.
Episode highlights
- The Internet of the WorldKevin Warbach discusses the merging of online and offline worlds through technology.“There’s something big going on, a bigger trend than most people realize.”0:46Feb 3, 2017
- Disruption MisunderstoodWarbach clarifies that disruption isn't just about new tech replacing old.“It’s creating something new, unlocking latent demand.”3:05Feb 3, 2017
- Regulation and InnovationWarbach argues that regulation can facilitate innovation rather than hinder it.“A surprising amount of the time it was government action facilitating innovation.”5:15Feb 3, 2017
- Algorithmic Competition PolicyThe rise of ondemand services brings new challenges for competition policy.“How do you know that what you are paying for that Uber ride is the efficient price?”12:00Feb 3, 2017
- The Role of RegulationRegulation is essential for innovation and trust between industries and regulators.“Regulation isn't a dirty word.”19:06Feb 3, 2017
- Building TrustA mutual process of trust is crucial for collaboration between companies and regulators.“There needs to be a mutual process of generating trust.”20:21Feb 3, 2017
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





