How AI and Analytics Are Changing Sports Performance and Strategy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Artificial intelligence and big data are transforming sports across coaching, player performance, and front office strategy. Wharton School Professor Cade Massey explores how analytics are used in injury prevention, scouting, and even referee evaluation.They cover developments in the NFL, NCAA basketball, and baseball, highlighting both the current impact and future potential of AI in sports.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#SportsAnalytics #ArtificialIntelligence #AIinSports #SportsTechnology #PlayerPerformance #Moneyball ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, certainly the world of sports has changed quite a bit in the last couple of decades with the advent of big data and
  2. the massive sums of money being brought in. Now, we are obviously in the advent of AI, which is already having an impact. How
  3. much and how much might sports continue to develop? We bring in Cade Massey, who's a Practice Professor in the Operations,
  4. Information and Decisions department at the Wharton School. You also hear him as host of the Wharton Moneyball
  5. podcast. Hi Cade, how are you, sir? Cade Massey: Good, Dan. Good to see you. Thanks for having me. - You know, you and I are obviously big
  6. sports lovers, and so you've watched it a lot, this side of it, a lot closer than I, but it has been just amazing to
  7. see how sports, in general, the operation, the playing on the field, has changed in the last couple of decades because of
  8. big data, and now, in part, because of AI. - Yeah, I mean, something's obvious. People
  9. complain even about how much it's changed baseball, how much it's changed basketball. It's not obvious that it's always changed
  10. it for the better. It's just accelerating optimization. And sometimes, when that happens, you realize maybe the rules need
  11. to be tweaked, maybe optimization for these particular rules isn't what we actually want. And so, you know,
  12. basketball is thinking about changing. Baseball is always experimenting with changes. But big data has definitely
  13. accelerated that in multiple sports over recent years. - Is there a moment in time that you can think of that
  14. really kind of started to make the turn occur?You know, whatever the sport was. But the involvement, I guess
  15. maybe the moneyball kind of philosophy kind of coming into baseball kind of started this process.
  16. - Yeah, I mean, you know, all sports, they say this about the NFL, but it's really true about all leagues, are copycat
  17. leagues. And so when somebody sees something that works, really kind of whether it's by chance or not, it gets copied.
  18. And then in some sports, that doesn't last very long, you know? People got a little curious about going for two
  19. until Belichick went for two on his own 28, or whatever it was, and didn't get it, and all of a sudden set the whole thing back
  20. for years. But with baseball, the moment I think about is with the shifts. You know, people had shifted for decades,
  21. but whenever advanced analytics started suggesting, well, we can really figure out player tendencies,
  22. and we can position our defensive players in a way that substantively changes their success getting on base, and one
  23. team adopts it, they adopt it kind of extremely, right? So you see people do things they hadn't done in
  24. decades. They have some success, and it just runs through the league. And I don't know what year that was. IYou know,
  25. 2017 or something like that, but you saw this was an analytics driven innovation, and as soon as it was proven to be
  26. advantageous, it was contagious in the league and other teams adopted it. - So I guess is it any surprise to you then that, with the advent of
  27. a lot of this data and how it's being used in terms of coaching and playing the game, that obviously, front offices
  28. are using it as kind of a marker in terms of how they're paying out contracts and the length of contracts, and how,
  29. you know, these business decisions are being made by front offices around the world of sports?
  30. - Well, you know, probably the single biggest example, we just had a game last night, Dan, that was a real high
  31. watermark for the analytics world with Florida under Todd Golden winning the NCAA Men's Championship. We haven't had
  32. that many moments like that around sports. So obviously, Theo Epstein with the Red Sox and the Cubs in baseball. There's not
  33. been one in NHL. Arguably, there really hasn't been one in the NBA. I mean, Brad Stevens is not really an analytics guy, per se,
  34. with the Celtics. Daryl Morey, he's famously never won. In football, it's kind of an open question, because Howie
  35. Roseman is not strictly analytics. He's a salary cap guy, right? But they've really been, obviously, successful now
  36. with almost two different teams. And Howie's approach to salary cap is what you're talking about, is much more analytics-y,
  37. Moneyball approach to salary cap, and that has really run through the NFL, and that has made big changes across the NFL.
  38. And it's not quite AI, but it's a predecessor to AI, and it's in a different part of the building.
  39. - So how is AI having an impact in the world of sports right now? - Well, it's still an open question. That's the big thing,
  40. Dan. It reminds me of when motion tracking hit football, you know, probably six, seven years ago, and you'd talk to teams
  41. and they'd say, "What's going to happen?" Like, I don't know, but you need to be involved, because things are going to change as a result.
  42. So get the data, start getting used to metabolizing it and using it, because it's going to matter. It feels the same way
  43. with AI right now. We don't know exactly what the consequences are going to be, but they will be there. So if you
  44. think about sports broadly, we divide it from an analytics world, we divide it into a game day, in game strategy. And then
  45. there's the personnel side, all the scouting. And then there's high performance, like individual player and injury
  46. prevention, that kind of thing. And if I had to put my chips on one of those three areas, Dan, I would put it on the latter. I'd
  47. put it on high performance. And the thinking, my thinking is the in game strategy, it's not quite optimized yet, but it's
  48. pretty close. I mean, these teams have been playing under these rules for a long time. I don't think there's any huge
  49. gains that AI is going to generate there. On personnel, there's a different kind of problem. Personnel, yeah, we're
  50. going to get some gains out of it, for sure, and we could dive into that, but you're never going to forecast personnel
  51. perfectly. It's just, we can't expect perfect forecast. And so there's a limit to the advantage of this kind of data.
  52. But on performance -- go ahead. - That's the dynamic, because when you talk about personnel, there are so many other components that
  53. could come into play that can change the path of a player in terms of how he performs, he or she performs on the field, not
  54. just the data itself. - That's right. I mean, there's a lot of path dependence there from his life or her life, but also teammates, from
  55. chance, from coaching staff. I mean, there's irreducible uncertainty. This is the fancy phrase we use in my
  56. world, irreducible uncertainty. And as forecasters, as human beings, we hate that, we're loath to accept it. But on the
  57. personnel side, you're never going to perfectly forecast, we're just not. I mean, maybe in a thousand years, I don't know,
  58. whenever we think -- what, right now, we think is random, we figure out what's not random about it. Right now, we just lump all the
  59. things we don't understand into randomness. That's going to be that way for a while. The domain that is more susceptible, I'd
  60. say, is the performance side. Just take injury prevention, for example. It's probably the biggest frontier, the biggest
  61. margin that we can make improvements on in sports, and it's still pretty wide open. I mean, people are still figuring
  62. out, how can we anticipate injuries better? How can we prevent them better? And the data that can go into that are
  63. almost unlimited, and the models we need to pulling signal out of those data are yet to be invented. And I think that's
  64. probably the biggest frontier, biggest margin. - One final thing, because I also saw an article that talked about
  65. how AI is going to have an impact on the refereeing or the judging of sports as well, which I think is very interesting,
  66. because there's obviously, depending on the sport, there's a lot of conversation about, you know, are the referees good? Are
  67. the umpires good, or are they not? Should they be replaced by technology? You know, I mean, obviously that's kind of
  68. a next area to watch as well. - Well, you can think about the -- I think that's interesting, Dan. There's
  69. a few different things that strike me straight away. One is like the baseball umpires, of course. I mean, those guys could
  70. be almost perfectly replaced. Obviously, there's some limits, but calling balls and strikes is pretty straightforward. What if
  71. we had models, though, that evaluated referees in soccer, for example, and had a sense of, here's what this ref is
  72. attending to, here's what this ref is missing, here's what this ref is good at, this is what the ref needs to work on. Could we
  73. evaluate refs in that way? Could it be a tool to make them better? In a way that we use -- right now, we're using, you know, data on
  74. pitches to improve umpires over time. Could we do something with AI to improve referees? But then, obviously, the easy one to
  75. think about is, all these sports that have judges, like Olympic sports that have judges, right? That dive. How do we know who's
  76. really saying which dive is a better dive in the Olympics? And could a model help us do that a little more precisely? Even if
  77. it's just an assistant, you know, kind of an advisor to an actual judge. - Cade, great insight. Thanks very much. - Thank you, Dan. Any time.
  78. - You got it. Cade Massey, who's Practice Professor in the Operations, Information and Decision Department here at the
  79. Wharton School, and you also hear him as host of the Moneyball podcast.

Brief Summary

Cade Massey discusses how big data and AI are transforming sports operations and player performance.

Key points

  • The Evolution of Sports. Cade Massey discusses how big data and AI have transformed sports operations and strategies.
  • AI's Impact on Refereeing. Cade Massey explores how AI could revolutionize the way referees are evaluated and trained.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes