Does Short-selling Need the SEC's Oversight?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

"There's really nothing illegal about it" is a phrase often heard in descriptions of the practice of shorting, or short-selling, which are essentially bets that a stock price will decline. But after some market watchers accused short-sellers of unfairly depressing the stock prices of several key financial institutions, the Securities and Exchange Commission imposed new rules. Wharton finance professors Marshall Blume and Franklin Allen suggest the impact will be minimal. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu for more
  2. information there really is nothing illegal about it is a phrase often heard in descriptions of the practice of Short
  3. Selling or shorting perhaps that's because many casual stock market observers know only one thing about the
  4. practice it's a bet that a particular stock will soon decline in value to bet in favor of someone else's bad fortune
  5. carries a nefarious ring for many people but there really is nothing illegal about short selling at least not in the
  6. United States that phrase has been repeated frequently in the days since the Securities and Exchange Commission
  7. announced that it would impose at least temporary restrictions on certain methods of shorting the stock of 19 key
  8. financial institutions including the government sponsored mortgage firms Fanny May and Freddy Mack those rules
  9. were introduced after short sellers were said to have helped drive down the sh of
  10. several major financial institutions knowledge at Wharton asked Wharton Finance professors Marshall Bloom and
  11. Franklin Allen to talk about these issues could you describe for us the mechanics of Short Selling Short Selling
  12. is a a very simple uh procedure uh normally when you buy a stock let's say you buy it at
  13. $50 you uh make money if the stock goes up and you lose money if the stock goes down so if the stock goes from 50 to 60
  14. you make $10 if it goes from 50 to4 you lose $10 well short sale reverses that so if the stock goes from 50 to 60 you
  15. lose $10 and vice versa if it goes down you make money now how does this work well
  16. it's not really a very complicated uh process uh let's say this $50 stock I think it's going to go down to 40 what I
  17. do is I borrow the stock from somebody and then I sell it when I sell it I have $50 in the bank the stock then uh Falls
  18. to 40 I buy it back at $40 give the stock back to the uh person uh from whom I borrowed it and that person still has
  19. one share but I have $10 ahead 50 uh less than 40 now it's important to realize that there's many other ways to
  20. make money when stocks go down uh you can buy uh uh puts uh I could buy a put at
  21. $50 and a put at $50 allows me to put the stock uh to the uh writer of the put at any time within say 3 to 6 months or
  22. longer depending upon the put if the price goes down now to 40 I buy it at 40 and I put the stock to the uh writer of
  23. the put and make $10 he'll give me 50 and I but just paid 40 now there are other ways too for
  24. instance I could do what's called a swap a swap is basically I swap my one return
  25. for another return so what I do is I say to a broker when uh I want to enter into
  26. a swap contract uh and if the price of the stock goes down they'll pay me uh the amount that it goes down if the
  27. price goes up they'll pay me the uh um I have to pay them now of course I've got
  28. to give them something for this and it's usually a short-term interest rate plus
  29. a premium uh and there are many other ways to short stocks so um we I think we lose focus when we say that we only can
  30. short stock by borrowing shares the's new rules focus on the first of those the borrowing of shares specifically it
  31. prohibits what are known as naked shorts on the shares of those 19 firms can you
  32. tell us a little bit about naked shorts a naked short sort of pejorative term uh a naked short
  33. uh means that I sell a stock and I don't borrow it first uh now if I do it within a day
  34. there's no real problem because I uh short the stock and then I buy it back and there's a netting so I never have to
  35. deliver the stock what the SEC rules uh said is even if I want to short it for a
  36. day I've got to borrow the stock first and then uh uh sell it and then buy it back uh now when you have liquid
  37. stocks that's not really a major uh concern it's easy to borrow liquid stocks um uh very easy to borrow um when a
  38. stock is in short supply then it's hard but here is just going to increase your transaction cost a little bit to go
  39. short as in any Market bet there are upside and downsides for short sellers but are there not also upsides and
  40. downsides for the companies that are the subject of their bets I think that's a question of manipulation underlying all
  41. these concerns that people have about short sellers so particularly for small companies they can have a big problem if
  42. people simply go out and and short sell their shares and drive the the price down and that's an example of trade M
  43. manipulation where people wonder is there some information that these people have and so that can cause problems for
  44. the for the company particularly if they're not doing very well anyway among the bigger companies the the real
  45. problem is what's known as information-based manipulation which is where you circulate rumors about something
  46. negative about the company and hopefully Drive its if in terms of making money hopefully Drive its price down and then
  47. close out the short now that's illegal but it's very difficult for the SEC to to prosecute those kinds of cases and I
  48. think that's that's the thing that the the SEC is currently most concerned about that was why it was made difficult
  49. back in the 30s when the SEC was founded because there was some evidence then of
  50. that kind of information-based manipulation Franklin what would you say to the following um a u person has a negative
  51. view on the stock they uh sell the uh stock short and they then call up their friends and say I had a negative view on
  52. this stock I sold it short and then they the other people then sell short helping
  53. to drive the price down is that market manipulation so some people would call that a be raid and in that case it would
  54. be illegal if they did it with the intention of driving the price down so I think one has to be very careful as to
  55. how exactly one does this but you're quite right Marshall there are there are many cases where if you have a negative
  56. View and you talk with your friends then then that's you know quite legal to do that and I think there's a very fine
  57. line between those so I think it it it is very difficult to to draw these lines as to what's legal and what's illegal
  58. and it's very difficult for the SEC to prosecute any clearly illegal actions some people have said that the downfall
  59. of Bear Sterns and the swoons of Freddy Mack and Fanny May have been attributable at least in part to the
  60. activ activities of short sellers what do you think about that theory well I think certainly there are some views
  61. that uh these P these companies were overpriced correctly so and they drove the price down more rapidly than they
  62. would have otherwise but they drove it not to a price which was inappropriate what are the stakes for the broader
  63. markets in which these bets are placed so I think in general that the way to the academic evidence is that it has a
  64. good effect because it helps price discover and helps information get into prices much more quickly than in is the
  65. case in countries where for example it's illegal to short stock so I think it's a
  66. by and large a very good thing in the case of these financial crisis it's a little bit more delicate I think because
  67. there is an issue if there is manipulation which as say it's illegal but it's very difficult to Pro prosecute
  68. but if people can successfully circulate rumors which are which are patently untrue they have the
  69. potential to make a lot of money from doing that little chance of being court and going to jail but they could
  70. seriously disrupt the financial system so this the classic example at the moment is Leman for example so the
  71. chairman of lhan thinks that there are people out there trying to do that and he's very concerned about that and it
  72. may well be that that they have serious problems and Lan could for example be forced to uh be sold and some people
  73. believe that that's what happened with bare Sterns that really this was just a form of manipulation and of course the
  74. SEC is looking into that so I think they do have to be careful and they do have to check these this potential breaking
  75. of the law uh but it's a delicate issue more delicate than in general I would say what benefits might ACR from the new
  76. regulations I think it won't have much effect in terms of stopping shorts it it'll raise the transactions costs a
  77. little bit as Marshall was indicating earlier but I think this is part of a wider campaign that the SEC is involved
  78. in which is to send a signal to the markets that they're concerned about short selling and I think this is one
  79. way of them them doing that so whether or not it affects directly apart from the slight increase
  80. in short sale I think it's it's more that they want they want to signal to the market that they're worried about
  81. this I I think that they will aggressively pursue some of the hedge funds if they find any emails which
  82. suggest that there were false rers being circulated and this is all part of of that campaign do you see any unintended
  83. consequences I I don't see any uh unintended consequence of this elimination of uh naked uh uh shorts for
  84. a particular group of stocks it's a a minor change in the rules I would agree with that
  85. yes for more information please visit knowledge. won. up.edu [Music]

Brief Summary

Key points

  • Understanding Short Selling. Short selling is a practice where investors bet against a stock's value, potentially profiting from its decline.
  • SEC's New Restrictions. The SEC announced temporary restrictions on short selling for 19 key financial institutions.
  • The Risks of Short Selling. Short selling can lead to market manipulation, especially for smaller companies.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes