Vivek Wadhwa on Globalization and U.S. Competitiveness
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
When Vivek Wadhwa, a high-tech entrepreneur who has built and sold two IT companies, became executive-in-residence at Duke University's school of engineering, students asked him a question that stumped him. What courses, they asked, should they take in order to "make their jobs outsourcing-proof?" That question forced Wadhwa, who had long been involved in outsourcing, to begin researching the impact of globalization on U.S. competitiveness and the role of immigrant entrepreneurs in helping the U.S. maintain its economic edge. At the recent Wharton India Economic Forum in Philadelphia, India Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Wadhwa about his research, his own entrepreneurial journey and his brief foray into Bollywood.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- This podcast is brought to you by India Knowledge at Wharton. Please visit knowledge.warton.upen.edu/india for more
- information. India Imagine was the theme of the 2008 Wharton India Economic Forum
- that was held in Philadelphia recently. The dayong event attracted several leaders including APJ Abdul Kalam,
- former president of India as well as CEOs of Indian companies, nonprofit groups, consulting and private equity
- firms. Indian knowledge at Wharton brings you one-on-one conversations with these leaders. We're going to speak
- today with Vive Guadada who is a fellow at the labor and work life program at Harvard Law School and also executive in
- residence at the Pratt School of Engineering at Duke University. Vive, thanks so much for joining us today.
- Thanks for having me here, M. Before we talk about your work in academia. Uh, I know you have a very interesting
- background as an entrepreneur. Could you tell tell us a little bit about your entrepreneurial experience? Sure,
- absolutely. I grew up to the ranks of IT basically programmer, systems analyst, project manager and eventually I
- developed some technology at first Boston which led to the creation of my first startup company called SEI
- Technologies. We were developing revolutionary technology to generate systems from high level specifications.
- C was a very successful company 0 to 120 million in 5 years IPO spectacular success and then after IPOs you often
- get on go on the rocks so I exited soon afterwards to start my second company which was re-engineering legacy systems
- and modernizing them that was also a spectacular success until the com bubble burst and until my uh health I started
- having health problems and I realized that I had to take a break from the rat race. Where were where were the were
- these companies based? Uh first the first one was a spin-off from first Boston in New York City and we moved it
- to uh to the Raleigh area Raleigh Durham area and the second one was uh in in the
- same area. Now is the entrepreneurial experience in the southern part of the country different than it might be say
- in the northeast or in Silicon Valley? I'll give you I'll tell you what happened. I mean I despite the fact I
- had built $120 million company taken it public. It's probably one of the most successful software companies of its
- time. I had access to anyone. I I got emails returned from Scott McNeely, um, Bill Gates, you know, who's who of of
- the tech industry and then I was starting my second company. Um, any if I was in the Silicon Valley, I would have
- had venture capitalists tripping over each other to uh to come to me in the Raleigh area. I couldn't get them to
- return my phone calls. Why? Which I found out later on after networking through the Silicon Valley and through
- Boston because my people didn't make good managers. That's this is how the Silicon Valley used to be 20 years ago
- for um for Indians and for immigrants. That changed. The uh south is still running behind in that sense that you
- still have these old images of uh Indians being low-level you know technicians and not being successful as
- managers and there's a discomfort generally in funding uh you know immigrant firms. If you look at you know
- if you looked at all the take North Carolina other than my company I don't know one other company in the last 15
- years that's been funded who which had an Indian CEO that's interesting have these experiences helped to shape your
- research agenda as you have moved into academia and could you tell us a little bit about that absolutely I started off
- by studying globalization generally we were looking into uh you know what really triggered off my research at Duke
- was when I joined that I students came to me because I had been a pretty well-known tech entrepreneur and they
- were asking me for mentoring and advice and there was one question they asked me
- which really stomped me. They asked what courses could they do that would give them uh they would make the jobs being
- they would make the jobs outsourcing proof and I should have known the answer to that because I had been involved with
- outsourcing. I'd involve been with globalization. The trouble was I didn't know why they were worried and what they
- could do about it. So I started researching it and the more I researched the more I got concerned about US
- competitiveness. So then I had to shift gears. I wanted to look at what the US could keep do to keep its edge. And this
- is where my past came in that I knew that in the tech industry that immigrants were playing a increasingly
- larger uh role that in particular I I knew there were a lot of Indians who were starting tech companies. I also
- wanted to to compare the different regions compare immigrant entrepreneurship you
- know across the region. So basically I I worked I got together with Dean Analy Saxian of UC Berkeley and we tried to
- update her 1999 study which found that a quarter of the tech startups in Silicon
- Valley were founded by immigrants. In a nutshell what we found was that the trend which began in Silicon Valley had
- become a nationwide trend that 25% of the of the companies nationwide were founded by immigrants. 52% of those in
- Silicon Valley were founded by immigrants and Indians were by far the largest founding group of these
- immigrants. It it confirmed what I knew. It also showed me on a region by region
- basis that the entire RTP area is at the bottom of of the list in terms of immigrant entrepreneurship. It proved in
- numbers what I had known through anecdotal evidence. That's interesting. Did you also find any uh evidence on on
- about revenues and jobs created by companies launched by immigrant entrepreneurs? Yeah, we found that in
- 2005 these immigrant founded companies in the engineering and tech sector, they generated $52 billion in revenue and
- employed 450,000 people. Now, you know, to the people who are opposed to skilled
- immigration, if you added up all the engineers and technologists that entered the US in that 10-year period in which
- we did the survey, uh they would they generated the number of jobs that these immigrant founded companies were
- generating was more than the number of immigrants we allowed in that entire 10-year period. Plus, they were fueling
- the economy. The fact that you have 25% more startups than you would may have otherwise have had is is hugely
- important for the US economic uh growth and for global competitive advantage. you know like uh the the issue you
- mentioned about uh the the the entry of skilled immigrants into the US uh another issue that has been somewhat
- controversial uh is is the out outsourcing of jobs overseas especially skilled jobs going o overseas uh have
- you looked at that in your research and what have what what's been some of uh your your what what does your research
- show in that area we looked at R&D going offshore because it's one thing for you
- know when when manufacturing goes let's take dress Dress making, dress making goes, you still have dress design,
- right? Now, if dress design goes, what do you have left? So, what's happened right now is that whether we like it or
- not, a lot of low-level technology jobs have gone overseas, that's fine. As long
- as we're still doing the design and the analysis in the USA, what we're seeing is that increasingly R&D is shifting
- overseas to India, China, and all over the world. Now, you can't stop it. No matter what the US does, it cannot stop
- the fact that that India is rising rapidly. China is trying very hard to rise and catch up with India. But but
- our research has shown that they're having lots and lots of problems because you can't mandate innovation. It's what
- the Chinese are learning the hard way. So India's rising. China is struggling but nevertheless they're spending
- massively on R&D. So what can the US do? I mean we can't stop it. We not going to
- shut our borders and we're not going to shut down R&D happening overseas. What we have to do is we have to now figure
- out how to how to adapt to it and benefit from it and to uplift our entire workforce. And how how how does the US
- do that? Well, this is another thing that the conclusions I've come to from my research because one of the things we
- discovered was that um that India was it education system is really weak that the
- number of engineers that graduate is much much less than is commonly believed and the fact is that they're graduating
- only 800 900 PhDs a year in engineering 30,000 35,000 real masters a year in engineering. So this contradicts
- everything I've just said about India rising in R&D. The question is how can a country in which the education system is
- is so weak in which it's politicized and in the even though they're now talking about making investment the fact is that
- that it'll take 5 years before that investment has any benefit how is it that India is rising so rapidly the
- answer that I've discovered in after meeting with dozens of uh of companies over there is in the workforce training
- that Indian companies have taken the best practices from the USA and from Europe and moved those up a couple of
- that they can train managers in you know in the USA to go from the equivalent of
- a fresher in India which means a recent graduate joining a technology company to
- manager takes about 10 years or so in India they can do that in three years or maximum four years because they
- perfected the art of training people they invest heavily year by year in upgrading the workforce we've forgotten
- how to do that our best companies used to do this I mean some of them if few still do but the vast majority of
- American companies don't invest in the workforce anymore India has learned how to do that from the USA and they
- perfected the art. So the if you ask me what's the number one thing the US could
- do to keep competitive you know yes we keep talking about improving K to2 education and it's very important math
- and science are important but the fact is that the 120 million people in our workforce invest in them start with uh
- with upgrading your workforce and you'll become competitive so could you offer some examples of the kind of things that
- you have seen companies in India or China do to invest in their workforce that could be replicated by companies in
- the US I I can tell you from India because in China we haven't seen the same level of innovation in China. The
- innovation is largely been being driven by multinational corporations and they're simply replicating the US
- practices in in China. Nothing more. I haven't seen anything advanced beyond that in China. Now in India, it was just
- amazing. You know, you start off with recruiting. The fact is that um you know Microsoft for example gets two or
- 300,000 rums a year from programmers. They have software that goes through it and it's just wrote based on rums.
- They'll weed through it and and do it and then they select the people they want to interview. Well, in India, the
- education system is pretty weak. And if you went simply by degrees and resumes, you won't hire anyone. Yet, the industry
- has to do it. So, you know, companies like Converg, companies like Genpacked. What they've done is they've set up
- storefronts that you go to, it's like going to a shopping mall, and they have video presentations where you can take
- your family, learn all about the company, and you can do an interview on the spot. If they think you have
- potential, then they'll they'll put you through a process, hire you, and then they'll train you in in the local area
- as well. Now, that's innovative. The fact is that they're not relying on rums the way we rely on résumés. And then you
- start work. Well, uh you go to emphasis and they put you through a 4-month training pro program which is like a
- boot camp. By the time you're done with that, you're you've got the equivalent of a master's degree. It doesn't stop
- there. In the USA, once you, you know, graduate and join a company, you're expected to now be productive. And
- that's typically the last training you go through. you know uh companies like IBM offer you uh online training and
- they and they they facilitate you know your learning if you want to learn but the fact is there's no incentive built
- in the system well in India you go to companies like Satyium Infosys and so on they mandate that you must receive 100
- to 200 hours of training every year um of your career so basically we the Indians
- receive more training Indians at the top receive more training than Americans receive in vacation and then they get
- rewarded for doing market and then there systems set up to manage the progression
- of the career. We have HR directors well they have talent directors which important to CEOs of the companies as
- well. They give talent development the same level of importance that we give HR development over here. So they manage
- your career. They help you through it. They guide you through through the entire process. The CEOs and executives
- spend an inord inordinate amount of time training their employees and building the workforce and so on. So I can go on
- and on for half an hour about the amazing things that that are doing there. The US needs to learn from them.
- You know, this is getting back to how can the US keep its edge. It's time for us to learn from from our disciples. You
- know, we're the we've been the guru so far in management and workforce training. India has been the disciple.
- It's now time for the guru to learn from the disciple. That that that's really interesting. Uh just to change ts for a
- little while. I I know along with your uh uh work in entrepreneurship as well as uh in IT uh and in academia you had a
- brief foray into Bollywood. Uh tell us about that experience. You want me to confess my sins now, right? Please. When
- I first uh disengaged from the tech world, I know I had been working so hard that I didn't get time to spend with my
- children. My son had decided he wanted to be he wanted to be an Indian. He wanted to be a movie star and he was
- fascinated by Bollywood. Um I was really worried about him leaving his technical
- career, his you know promising u technology career and moving into Bollywood. So I decided to take him into
- it. I basically got involved with some producers and and helped produce a film in Bollywood and I gave him a a role in
- the film and uh you basically went through the entire experience of Bollywood. By the time we were done, he
- says, "Dad, thanks for taking me there, but no thanks. I'm out of here. I want to go back to the tech world." And I
- also learned how crooked Bollywood is because we were dealing with American producers and Hollywood people. I tell
- you, Bollywood for all of its uh bad fame doesn't hold a candle to the crookedness of Hollywood. They're both
- very corrupt industries. How so? Uh just entire system, ML. Everything from uh from the way financing is done to the
- way it's managed to the way uh the system is rigged in in in favor of uh the large studios. I mean the entire
- system is uh is very weak and both industries are equally corrupt. Well, we we must come back at some future date to
- a more detailed conversation about that. But for now, can you tell us a little bit about what kind of future research
- projects you you're working on? Right. Um, you know, one of the the things we learned is that industries have changed
- now. Before you used I mean, I'm sure most people even now when they think of the automotive industry, they think of
- the American automotive industry versus the Japanese automotive industry. Now you hear about an Indian automotive
- industry. Well, the fact is there's no such thing as an American automotive industry. that uh the uh the technology
- for American cars is built globally. The technology for Chinese cars is built globally. The parts for the Indian Tata
- car are are assembled globally. What's happened is that entire industries have globalized. Take the farmer industry,
- the same thing. The fact is that the entire pharma industry has now dispersed diffused that you're now increasingly
- seeing drug discovery happening in India and China. You're seeing clinical trials
- happening in India and China. You're seeing almost every segment every value segment of of that industry happening in
- India and China. The same thing with the aerospace industry. The same thing with
- the semiconductor industry. Industry by industry. I'm actually analyzing six industries to show that they become like
- sand now. It's Lego blocks. It's no longer monolithic blocks anymore. It's sand which is dispersing. So we're
- demonstrating how globalization has changed the entire face of industries. I'm doing an extensive new project on
- workforce training and education. I'm also doing a follow-up on the on the immigration research to understand you
- know what has happened to returnees because what we're finding is that increasingly returnees have been driving
- innovation in China and they did in India but India has become self self- sustaining in terms of innovation it's
- really built the domestic capability to do what it needs to do it's not dependent on returnees anymore but we're
- doing extensive new research on returnees and then my favorite topic is entrepreneurship also looking into the
- backgrounds of Americanborn entrepreneurs and so so on so on So you'll be hearing a lot from me and uh
- we'll be publishing quite a few interesting papers over the next 12 months or so. I look forward to seeing
- them and Vive, thanks so much for joining us today. I enjoyed being with you, Michael.
- For more information, please visit knowledge.warton.upen.edu/india. [Music]
Brief Summary
Vive Guadada discusses entrepreneurship, immigrant contributions, and the need for U.S. workforce training to remain competitive globally.
Key points
- Entrepreneurial Journey. Vive Guadada shares his rise from programmer to successful entrepreneur with two startups.
- India's Workforce Training. Vive discusses how Indian companies excel in training and developing their workforce.
- Globalization of Industries. Vive explains how industries have globalized, impacting innovation and production.
Episode highlights
- Entrepreneurial JourneyVive Guadada shares his rise from programmer to successful entrepreneur with two startups.“I developed some technology... that led to the creation of my first startup company called SEI Technologies.”1:13Jul 24, 2008
- India's Workforce TrainingVive discusses how Indian companies excel in training and developing their workforce.“India has learned how to do that from the USA and they've perfected the art.”8:46Jul 24, 2008
- Globalization of IndustriesVive explains how industries have globalized, impacting innovation and production.“Entire industries have globalized... it's no longer monolithic blocks anymore.”14:30Jul 24, 2008





