How U.S. Tax Policy Pushes Jobs Overseas

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW In this episode of The Ripple Effect, Wharton finance professor Daniel Garrett discusses his research on how international tax policy—specifically the “check-the-box” rule and repatriation holidays—impacts U.S. multinational firms and domestic employment. He explains the competing forces of a wealth effect, where firms grow and potentially invest more at home, and a substitution effect, where firms shift operations abroad due to lower foreign tax burdens. Garrett’s findings reveal that the substitution effect often dominates, resulting in reduced domestic investment and employment.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Daniel Garrett: What we're going to argue in— in my paper is that there is also a
  2. substitution effect. That is to say, instead of just saying that, yes, the US companies get wealthier and so they get
  3. bigger, and that has some positive spill ups for workers, it's also that they're now facing marginal tax costs in different
  4. jurisdictions where doing more business in the US is relatively more expensive, and doing more business outside of the US
  5. is relatively cheaper. So we're going to say, yes, there is a wealth effect, but there's also a substitution effect. And
  6. we're going to show through kind of a particular study of a 1997 regulatory rule that I think we're going to get to in a
  7. minute— we show that the substitution effect seems to dominate when we look at the local markets in which these firms operate.
  8. Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
  9. Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  10. Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today.
  11. Dan Loney: Well, there has been for some time conversation about what the tax structure
  12. around international businesses is, and maybe even should be. Daniel Garrett is an Assistant Professor of Finance here at the
  13. Wharton School. He has done some research recently into this, especially the potential impact on companies back here in the
  14. United States, and he joins me here in studio. Great to see you. How are you? - I'm doing well. How are you, Dan?
  15. Thank you. I guess let's start with kind of looking at the basics of international tax structure, because it's a topic that
  16. probably not a lot of people talk about a lot, but it's obviously a very important one,
  17. to draw your attention for this research. I'll say in my circles, a lot of people talk about it a lot. A whole
  18. lot, in fact. So the basic structure of international taxation can have two flavors. The way in which it has been in
  19. the US historically has been what we call a worldwide tax system, where we have corporations. So you can imagine
  20. your large corporations, your Apples and Googles of the world. They operate not just in the US, but they operate in many
  21. countries around the world, and they make income in many countries around the world. And so historically, the US has kind
  22. of said we're going to tax all of your income, regardless of where it's generated. Another approach is called territorial
  23. income taxation, which is to say, instead of taxing Apple's profits all around the world, we'll only tax the profits they
  24. generate directly in the US. Of course, where that gets really tricky is trying to say exactly, when you are a big global
  25. company that's making sales, where are costs allocated, and where are revenues allocated? And so such, where the profits
  26. allocated, can be quite tricky, a tricky thing to pin down. And so then, when you talk about the research that you did, part of
  27. it was to look at how all of these components kind of factor in and potentially impact corporations, but also domestic
  28. workers as well. Yeah. So I think whenever we talk about tax reform, we're usually
  29. thinking about, the end goal is trying to come up with increasing welfare and increasing opportunity for
  30. people in the US, is usually kind of the— the political statement that people are making when they're saying we want to lower
  31. tax rates. We want to raise tax rates, et cetera. What we do in our research is we try to say, okay, a lot of countries around the
  32. world have been moving from worldwide systems where they're going to tax all of the profit of the corporations that reside
  33. in their jurisdictions, to only taxing the local profits. And so we're trying to say, what does this do to the way in which
  34. firms invest in local communities, and what does that do to the prevalence of local jobs and that sort of thing? So
  35. yes, to really distill that down, we want to say, when we cut Apple's tax rates in Europe, what happens to the number of people
  36. Apple is employing in the US, and the number of people that are being employed in support roles?
  37. Not just by Apple, but by other companies. And I guess to a degree, the expectation is that there would
  38. be a— maybe a potential backside benefit here in the United States, if you have the lower rates overseas, that there
  39. should be a benefit coming back to the US at some point. - Yeah. So the idea is one of an income— what I'll describe as a wealth
  40. effect, or maybe an income effect. The idea is we have big multinational corporations in the us. Most of the largest
  41. corporations in the world are US firms. So the idea is, if the US government can maybe make these firms just a little bit more
  42. competitive in foreign jurisdictions— so we'll say, "Okay, so you have to pay a 21% tax rate in the US, but sure,
  43. you can only pay a 12 and a half percent tax rate in other jurisdictions, so you can be really competitive. The idea is
  44. that's going to make these US firms bigger. It's going to make them more competitive. It's going to make them wealthier.
  45. And then that's going to kind of flow down into how many workers they wind up hiring, or how much domestic investment they wind up
  46. doing. So that's what I'll call a wealth effect. What we're going to argue in my paper is that there is also a
  47. substitution effect. That is to say, instead of just saying that, yes, the US companies get wealthier and so they get
  48. bigger, and that has some positive spill ups for workers, it's also that they're now facing marginal tax costs in different
  49. jurisdictions where doing more business in the US is relatively more expensive, and doing more business outside of the US is
  50. relatively cheaper. So we're going to say, yes, there is a wealth effect, but there's also a substitution effect. And we're
  51. going to show through kind of a particular study of a 1997 regulatory rule that I think we're going to get to in a
  52. minute, we show that the substitution effect seems to dominate when we look at the local markets in which these
  53. firms operate. And that being the check the box, as you refer to in your research.
  54. We call it check the box. Yes, that's— that's the common term for this particular accounting rule.
  55. Well, when you talk about check the box regulations, which did have an impact, I guess, going back to the— the end of the 20th
  56. century, what kind of impact has it had over the last— what? I guess three decades at this point?
  57. Yeah. So, we look at check the box, which was a 1997 rule that essentially made profit shifting and tax avoidance for US firms operating
  58. outside of the US much easier. What we show is that the firms that benefited most from this new flexibility to engage in
  59. profit shifting and tax avoidance in other jurisdictions, so in non-US jurisdictions, that these firms seemed to decrease
  60. their investment in the US and employment in the places where these firms operate declines in the US. So showing that,
  61. essentially, these firms are moving— appearing to move employment from US operations into foreign operations.
  62. But this also came kind of full circle, going back, I guess, to the first Trump Administration, with the TCJA and the repatriation
  63. holiday, what, back in 2017, I guess. So there's a mandatory repatriation, kind of a one-time very low tax on
  64. permanently reinvested earnings abroad and unrepatriated earnings by US firms. This happened in 2018. There was an
  65. earlier— I guess it technically, of course, was passed in December of 2017. So, some— some firms started reporting
  66. interactions with this tax in the fourth quarter of 2017. It mostly happened in 2018 and beyond. What we look at is
  67. actually an earlier version of a repatriation holiday, which was in 2004 as part of the American Job Creation Act, AJCA, which
  68. also gave an optional lowering of repatriation taxes for earnings that were housed in corporations outside of the US.
  69. So they would— they would get to lower their repatriation tax cost by 85% if they repatriated. And so what happened in 2004 is
  70. most firms didn't repatriate. Many firms did repatriate, and they brought back about $300 billion in 2004, which is much
  71. less than the most recent kind of bunch of repatriations. So then, when you have a situation where you have
  72. check the box regulations and a repatriation holiday all kind of in the mix, does that kind of almost double the impact that you see coming
  73. back against workers here in the US? So we think of these as kind of two separate but very much
  74. interacting rules. So check the box says, essentially, you can engage in profit shifting as long as you do it outside of the
  75. US. A repatriation holiday says, okay, so those profits you shifted outside of the US, now when you want to bring them back
  76. to the US, they're a little bit cheaper. So we think that essentially lowering the tax rates should kind of change the
  77. marginal cost of operating in different places, but lowering the repatriation costs should essentially allow us to now move
  78. all this cash that we've built up overseas and bring it back into the US, potentially. So those are two kind of very
  79. related ideas, but different mechanisms that the government has at their disposal in order to kind of raise these taxes.
  80. How much focus is this starting to draw right now, I guess? Oh, it's drawing a lot. I think it's actually drawing probably a
  81. little bit less than it did in the first round of TCJA, and that most of the mandatory repatriations have already
  82. happened. So we have a lot less kind of cash built up overseas. I think a lot of what we're going to be talking about is
  83. this marginal tax rates of US versus non US jurisdictions, and maybe trying to make those, that— that gap, a little bit smaller,
  84. maybe making that gap— so I think that's— that's where I see a lot of the focus. Not so much, on the repatriation taxes and
  85. the repatriation holidays. Which, of course, in my research, we do find that the repatriation holiday has very
  86. little impact on domestic markets, whereas check the box and lowering foreign effective tax rates does seem to have a
  87. material impact on domestic markets, with— with lower foreign taxes being associated with lower foreign— or
  88. lower domestic employment. Excuse me. In terms of doing this research, was there anything
  89. that kind of caught your eye, that maybe surprised you to a degree? So let me— let me point out two things that I think are really
  90. interesting. So in this research, one of the things we're able to do that I think is really cool, is we can tie US
  91. firms, publicly traded firms, to the global footprint of where they operate in the US. And we can show that— of course, they
  92. don't operate everywhere in the US. Most places in the US have large publicly traded firms, but there are very— there are
  93. geographic clusters where they operate a lot. These clusters, starting around 1997 and going through 2006, had pretty
  94. substantial declines in employment relative to places where these firms didn't exist. I think that's an interesting
  95. stylized fact that no one has ever really shown before that we're able to show with a bunch of statistical rigor. The second
  96. thing that I think is really interesting, that went against what my intuition was, is that most of the foreign employment
  97. growth of US firms during this period was not in developing markets. It was not in China or Brazil. It was actually in the
  98. Eurozone. Which, of course, is kind of commonly thought of as a very high tax place. But US firms, who are benefiting from
  99. check the box, are able to pay very low tax rates while they're operating in the Eurozone. So I think there's kind of a little
  100. bit of— I was very surprised when I started looking through the BEA data on kind of where US multinational firms
  101. have non-US employment. One of the other things that you noted in your paper is also the
  102. impact of the scale and the size of the company in terms of this process as well.
  103. So this is— there's another strand of literature that we're kind of speaking to about the nature of organizational
  104. complexity. And so, of course, one of the things that— I told you check the box kind of allows profit shifting— or allowed
  105. profit shifting, I'll say. Of course, a lot of the profit shifting that was done required very large and complex
  106. structures, such that firms that have more subsidiaries in more places—one of the famous styles of subsidiary organization that
  107. allowed profit shifting is called the Double Irish Dutch Sandwich, that required having at least two subsidiaries in
  108. Ireland and one in the Netherlands. And so lots of very large firms got very large and very complex around this time.
  109. Now assigning causality to tax law versus other maybe regulatory ways in which firms want to move their costs and
  110. revenues— there could be other things moving on that we're not able to kind of rule out everything, but we do think that
  111. these tax laws are part of what is driving a lot of this increasing complexity. But the dynamic of how some of these countries have changed,
  112. you know, how they operate their tax law— Ireland, you mentioned being one of them that's really been focused on a lot in the
  113. last few decades— really has brought a lot of this conversation, a lot of this tumult, to the forefront, hasn't it?
  114. Yeah. So yeah, Ireland is a big one. There are lots of big— what the literature will refer to as tax havens. We do think Ireland
  115. is a particularly big part of the story that we are measuring, insofar that the US multinational firms at this
  116. period were really increasing their employment in Europe a lot. I don't know if I have too much to say about the specific
  117. countries that were doing it. But has been— there have been a bunch of regime changes. So the Double Irish was actually
  118. wound down in the last few years. There are all sorts of kind of changes in which countries are vying for getting
  119. US subsidiaries to be formed in their jurisdictions, and that sort of thing. But I don't think we— it's really hard. I'll say
  120. that there's a lot of research into exactly which jurisdiction— which foreign jurisdictions are doing exactly what activities
  121. and how that's impacting US multinational work. We're kind of looking at the US side of, how is the US allowing or
  122. disallowing using those sorts of mechanisms? That being said, how much do you think this continues to be a
  123. policy question as we move forward? And, how much, you know, are our corporations
  124. obviously thinking about this as we move forward as well? They're thinking a lot about this. When corporations
  125. are choosing— making location decisions, they're always, of course, going to be thinking about, what is the tax rate? Is
  126. it likely to go up to 28%? Is it likely to drop to 15%? Those are kind of substantial differences, in the required return an
  127. investment needs to make, depending on kind of what the what the effective tax rate's going to be. I think this is a
  128. big discussion going forward. The last decade or so, the big discussion has been driven by the OECD Base Erosion and Profit
  129. Shifting group, which— the BEPS group— thinking about trying to push a global minimum tax. I won't speak to whether that is
  130. politically possible or not possible at this point, but I do think we are likely going to keep talking a lot about this
  131. international tax competition. And this— in the literature, we broadly call it the race to the bottom. And different countries
  132. having an incentive to try to say, "We want to undercut our neighbors, so that our neighbors' firms come to here."
  133. Let me finish up with this, then. Is there a path that you could see where the dynamics of this change, but also there is a
  134. benefit to the domestic worker as well? Yeah. So what would benefit a domestic worker, according to
  135. our paper, would be a— a— a— I want to call it an equalization of foreign and domestic tax rates. So right now
  136. we say there's a tax wedge where if a firm could choose wherever they wanted to be, they would not make the choice of— of the
  137. countries that they operate in. That's not the same choice they would make if the taxes were equalized. - Right. - So insofar
  138. as there's some— some deadweight loss because of the mismatch between where firms are operating and where firms would
  139. like to operate if there wasn't this sort of tax consideration, that fixing that could make things better off, insofar as
  140. if all of the corporate tax rates hit zero, that might make things a little bit better. But then, of course, that makes it
  141. really hard to tax capital income, which I think there are other potentially equity reasons that we might want to tax
  142. capital income. There are lots of arguments about that in the literature. But I do think that we are moving, potentially,
  143. toward a world where those— that gap between foreign and domestic effective tax rates is getting a little bit smaller.
  144. Dan, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much. Dan, thank you so much. Thank you. Daniel Garrett, who's Assistant Professor of
  145. Finance here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode
  146. informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight
  147. from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Daniel Garrett discusses international tax structures and their impact on U.S. companies and workers, focusing on wealth and substitution effects.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Exploring the groundbreaking research of Wharton professors and its real-world implications.
  • Tax Structure and Employment. Daniel Garrett discusses the impact of international tax structures on US employment.
  • Check the Box Regulations. Research shows how profit shifting regulations have affected US employment.
  • Repatriation Holiday Impact. Analysis of the effects of repatriation holidays on domestic markets.
  • Future of International Taxation. Discussion on the ongoing policy questions surrounding international tax competition.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes