Joann Stores Bankruptcy Explained: What Went Wrong in Retail

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Joann Stores announced it will permanently close all 885 locations following its second bankruptcy and acquisition by new ownership, leading to a full liquidation. Wharton School Marketing Professor Cait Lamberton discusses how the closure stems from challenges including high inventory demands, declining foot traffic in traditional retail locations, and growing competition from e-commerce platforms. The broader retail industry faces similar pressures, compounded by inflation, shifting consumer preferences, and tariff-related supply chain concerns.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#retail #retailers #retailstores ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, we have seen our latest retailer ready to shut its doors for good. Fabric chains JoAnn Stores announcing
  2. recently that it's going to close all 885 of its locations after reaching an agreement for new ownership that's going to
  3. lead to a liquidation. But it also comes at a time when retail is still feeling the pinch from inflation, and as well, consumer
  4. decision making. And now you get to throw in the component of tariffs. Pleasure to be joined by Cait Lamberton, Marketing
  5. Professor here at the Wharton School. Cait, lots to discuss with you. Great to talk to you, as always.
  6. Thanks for having me. Let's start with JoAnn, which I read was entering its second
  7. bankruptcy within a year. So obviously, things were not going great for the company to begin with.
  8. Yeah, a second bankruptcy is tough. It's not that you can't survive it. So the famous case of a firm that did survive a
  9. second bankruptcy was Sbarro, the pizza chain that you might be familiar with. They partnered with private equity, came back
  10. with a rebrand. They were able to be resilient to a second bankruptcy, but it's hard, and that's a different business than
  11. JoAnn is in. So if JoAnn— JoAnn has so many things, that— retail is tough, but what JoAnn does is even tougher, right? So
  12. they have to carry this massive amount of inventory, because by its nature, that is a business where people want extraordinary
  13. amounts of variety, and every option matters. You know, it matters whether they get rid of a velvet or they get rid of a
  14. lace, or they get rid of a tie dye, because for somebody, that's the thing they wanted. And so they need enormous
  15. amounts of space, and they need enormous amounts of inventory, and they're often located in areas that have been— have
  16. been seeing declines in foot traffic anyway. So whether it's near a shopping mall or some area like that, those areas are
  17. already not seeing the walkers that they used to. So a lot of things working against them that make it— made it particularly
  18. tough for them to stay alive right now. - And had they been a company impacted by the wave of e-commerce as well
  19. in recent years? I mean, obviously people feel like they can find more options at times online.
  20. Yeah, and it's interesting. I'm going to be curious to see what they're doing. So right as of right now, they still have JoAnn.com open.
  21. But previously, the fabric shopping experience was a very tactile experience. You know, it's not like other things,
  22. where it's a pure search good. Unless you know exactly what you want, very often you're going to go and you need to have an
  23. experience with the good. You need to almost believe that it is what it advertises that it is, to make that purchase. So
  24. yes, online retailing affected them, but it was going to take a long time for the traditional JoAnn shopper to have faith
  25. that what they bought online was going to measure up to their expectations. Now, interestingly, so JoAnn started
  26. its going out of business sales on February 15. February— in the month of February, Shopify reported that actually demand
  27. for a lot of the things that JoAnn sells were through the roof. So they saw a quilting thread up 200%, quilting rulers
  28. up 130%, craft cutters 88%, straight pins 87%. So it's not, the demand isn't there. It's definitely there. It's just that
  29. I think their cost structure and the nature of— of the business itself made it very hard to survive right now.
  30. So then what's the benefit for the new owners of just going straight ahead and shutting the doors and doing the liquidation?
  31. I mean, they're going to have to get some money out of the inventory. And they're going to have to, you know, sort of end
  32. these— these enormous leases that I'm sure are incredibly costly. Likely they will find some kind of online model. Many,
  33. many companies are trying that with mixed success. So you might be familiar with Lord & Taylor, which is trying right
  34. now to shift to an online model. I think it's going to be a painful process. Again, because in part, what people are looking
  35. for is a retail experience. And for some of these brands, it's really hard to replicate that online.
  36. Bed Bath and Beyond was the one that I was gonna bring up. - Yeah. That's seemingly the latest one to try and do that.
  37. And Bed Bath and Beyond, again, did come back from bankruptcy, right? They were sold to Overstock, which helped, because
  38. Overstock knew how to do online. Then Overstock changed its name to Beyond Inc. So they took the brand equity of Bed Bath and
  39. Beyond, and the online expertise of Overstock, and they were able to successfully emerge from a bankruptcy.
  40. So what do you think is the state of retail right now, and I mentioned at the top, with all of these different impacts? And
  41. then now we're going to be talking a lot more about tariffs, especially with companies that have products
  42. that are coming from Canada or Mexico. Yeah. I mean, retail is hard. Retail has always been hard. And
  43. so it seems like every year we're saying it's the end of the world for retail, but that's— retail is just really tough. And
  44. I think— but I do think there are a few new pressures that make it— make it particularly challenging, that are
  45. creating threats to these legacy brands, these older companies that are really very good at what they're good at. You know,
  46. you saw Big Lots close, you saw Party City close. You saw Foot Locker closing a bunch of stores, Macy's closing. These
  47. are just huge brands, right? They're at least closing stores, if not closing altogether. One thing that I think does create a
  48. unique new challenge is the availability of really easy to access, easy to buy dupes, and the rise of what I would call
  49. ephemeral brands through social media. At one point, there was an idea that you would want to buy an established brand, and
  50. that that was the signature of quality. That you were doing the cool thing because you had the established, high quality brand.
  51. But now there's more of a cachet for a brand that's going to be gone in a minute. You have the thing that is of the moment. No
  52. one expects it to last, and I can buy it. I don't even have to go to a website. I swipe right and click a button on my phone,
  53. and it's coming to my house. So the— the amount of friction that's been removed, and the number of options that I have
  54. available create a really big challenge for a brick and mortar retailer. So you have this drive for the removal of friction. At
  55. the same time, if you're going to be a brick and mortar retailer, you have to provide this incredibly rich, expensive
  56. experience. So— so that's a tough— a tough tightrope to walk. Now, when you think about that, when you think about the
  57. tariffs, that's an interesting challenge in a number of ways. About a week ago, there was a survey that said one in five
  58. consumers said that they were accelerating their purchases ahead of tariffs. Today, I saw one that said 32% of people said
  59. that they had accelerated their purchases ahead of tariffs. So that kind of purchase acceleration is a— it's a— it's a
  60. supply chain problem in some ways. But you know, if these are durables, it's also a longer term problem, because now people
  61. have stocked up. We don't know what happens. So that— that's one issue. And then the other question, of course, is how
  62. people are going to respond to those price increases that are likely to come. Look, we've been down the road with supply chain before, so
  63. it's not the first time and it won't be the last. It's very true. Thanks, Cait. All the best.
  64. All right, take care. Bye. You got it. Cait Lamberton, who's a Marketing Professor here
  65. at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

JoAnn Stores closes all locations amid retail challenges; Cait Lamberton discusses e-commerce impact and consumer behavior.

Key points

  • JoAnn Stores Closing. JoAnn Stores announces the closure of all 885 locations amid financial struggles.
  • Retail's Tough Landscape. Cait Lamberton discusses the unique challenges facing brick-and-mortar retailers today.

Related episodes