Wharton Professor Marshall Fisher: The New Science of Retailing

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

n today's economy, retailers are hard pressed to increase revenues. Among the biggest challenges they face is matching supply with demand. In The New Science of Retailing: How Analytics Are Transforming the Supply Chain and Improving Performance, Wharton management professor Marshall Fisher and co-author Ananth Raman argue that retailers have the data they need to manage supply chains more efficiently and increase sales and profits. Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Fisher about what types of data are most important for retailers to collect, how they can use this information to identify home-run products and why the retailing industry might be missing as much as one-third of sales. πŸ“‚ Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Marshall thank you so much for joining us today my pleasure M thank you for
  2. having me I'd like to start talking about your book with a simple question you you say that retailers often fail to
  3. match supply and demand what are the consequences of that failure for them um well you see one of the consequences
  4. when you walk in many stores um which is huge piles of merchandise uh on sale at
  5. deep discounts as much as 80% there's a department store I visit from time to time for various reasons and you'll see
  6. the aisles sorted into maybe three sections 50% off 70% off 80% off so that's one consequence um the
  7. consequence uh for retailers is uh is obviously lower profit which can come in one or two ways the the access that we
  8. just talked about which means you're selling things uh frequently below what it cost
  9. you to to buy it and get it into the store so you lose money uh or uh that's the excess side or you don't
  10. have enough of something and the customer walks in and can't find what they're looking for and that's a lost
  11. sale so there's a couple interesting statistics that uh until 1995 when it um got embarrassing
  12. department stores used to um collect and Report uh an industry number which is the markdown percentage
  13. okay in the mid if I remember right in the mid 70s that was about 6% and by 95 had had grown to something
  14. like 33% it's not publicly reported anymore but I heard a statistic that for one leading department store that number
  15. would now be 40% which means that the average item sells for 40% off of full price uh that's on the excess side on
  16. the shortage side there's a consulting firm that does an annual survey of consumers this is in apparel um where
  17. it's maybe hardest to match Supply with demand but they routinely uh find that uh people who respond to the survey will
  18. will say that about a third of the time they walk into a store with a clear idea
  19. of what they want to buy and walk out empty-handed because they couldn't find what they came
  20. for which is pretty amazing if you think about it that A2 billion doll retailer is really a $3 billion retailer but that
  21. third billion in Revenue they're not getting because the the of the third of the people who walk out empty handed
  22. because they couldn't come find what they came for now does that imply that if retailers are able to make even small
  23. improvements in matching Supply with demand that this would have a fairly big impact on their profits yeah absolutely
  24. for a simple reason retailing is a high fixed cost business it costs a lot of money to maintain a store base and pay
  25. the associates that work in those stores and you incur that cost whether you sell
  26. a dollar of merchandise in the in the store or 10 million so small increases in Revenue have a big impact on profit
  27. uh typical numbers for gross margin would be somewhere between 30 and 50% so take a retailer whose gross margin is
  28. 50% uh 5% increase in sales uh with a 50% margin is 2 and a half% of Revenue increase in profit
  29. which for a lot of retailers would double their profit so this one-third that walk out empty-handed because of of
  30. stockouts or they can't find the product in the store or some sort of shortage problem just correcting a little bit of
  31. that uh you know cut that number from a third to to 5% less uh could double the Retailer's profit that's very and what
  32. imp applications does the relationship of the stock market valuation of a retailer have to its ability to manage
  33. its inventory um that's an interesting question because most analysts uh I think don't pay enough
  34. attention to uh to inventory or other operating variables of a retailer uh and you can think of a
  35. number of them but if we take uh inventory as an example a retailer can uh enhance its Revenue line with
  36. more inventory okay so come back to the example I described is that you'd like to have U Better in stock so that people
  37. find what they came for uh when they walk in the store uh the the best the the right way to
  38. accomplish that is more effective management of your inventory better forecasting U you know better analysis
  39. of the margin of error on the forecast so you can risk adjust the heavy-handed way to
  40. accomplish it is just jack up your inventory levels and you can uh improve in stocks with a in inefficient process
  41. a retailer who does that will see an increase in Revenue but it's not a real Improvement in the effectiveness of
  42. their performance but it can look that way to the stock market so if the market doesn't take into account the
  43. relationship between revenue and inventory uh they can be fooled that a retailers is having a good year when all
  44. they're doing is uh forcing sales by by uh pumping excess inventory into an inefficient
  45. system that brings us does that make sense yes no absolutely it's sort of a subtle little bit complicated idea but
  46. yeah no absolutely uh in fact that that uh brings me to uh one of the really interesting points in your book where
  47. you note that ret many retailers are drowning in numbers but lack an Insight uh how do you think they can correct
  48. this problem uh well well that was actually a poster on the door of a woman that we
  49. worked with who was the vice president for uh merchandising technology I think was her
  50. title and the quote was we're a washing data and star for information interesting yeah well the short answer
  51. to your question is they should buy this book and read it and implement the results because that's essentially what
  52. we tried to do in this book is report about 10 years more than 10 years of of experience we've had working with
  53. retailers who who were a wash in data but star from information and helping them to
  54. interpret uh all kinds of data starting with POS sales data uh customer satisfaction surveys and um demographic
  55. data about their Stores um if you think about what would cause you to be a wash in data but star
  56. from information um there are many things but I'll mention a couple one is one is a
  57. lot of retailers until recently have not had sufficiently granular data this may
  58. surprise you but an apparel item this shirt I'm wearing what they would see is sales of
  59. this shirt for the entire chain across all sizes okay they would not see the sales
  60. of this shirt in a medium in XYZ store last week so they're left to to guess uh the level of in stocks across
  61. the stores they're left to guess is what is the right size mix so so that's point
  62. one is until recently the data was was too aggregated to be useful you need at the microscopic level how's this shirt
  63. selling in the Iowa store in a medium today the second point is that it's not enough
  64. to to to know whether an item is selling well whether it's hot and you want to get more of it it's not enough to know
  65. at sales level you got to know it sales level and other conditions that might affect uh uh the sales of that product
  66. competitive activity weather uh how it's priced how it's presented in the store is it well presented or is it somehow
  67. hidden in the back room and so most retailers don't collect that data they don't interpret it uh so
  68. you need to look at sales and a handful of factors that are sales drivers uh in order to accurately
  69. uh predict from how an item selling how it we'll sell in the future those are a couple things that could go on and on
  70. and on but it's it's uh doable but but nontrivial to look at the the huge amount of data retailers have available
  71. to them now it makes sense out of it but but you can and then it's very powerful
  72. well one of the things that makes it powerful is uh you also mentioned in your book how retailers can crunch their
  73. sales numbers to identify some home run products which they may be missing uh can you explain how how that how they
  74. can do that yeah absolutely so retailer the retail assortment is the set of products that's in the store at any
  75. point in time when you walk in and retailers will periodically update their assortment they'll get rid of products
  76. that are not selling so well and add some new products that they think will sell
  77. better the uh and you can think about those two decisions get rid of the worst Sellers and add some new products which
  78. is the easier the decision at least on which to get rid of is easier because you've got sales data so you can tell
  79. the dogs you got to be a little careful that that product that's not selling very
  80. well is the favorite product of some of your best customers and if you get rid of it you not only lose the sales on
  81. that product but you lose the customer and everything else they're buying it's a it's a serious problem in grocery okay
  82. but other than that kind of subtlety that's pretty easy to figure out what to get rid of but what to add is harder so
  83. a lot of retailers do something kind of like uh Jin rmy you know the card you discard your worst card and you draw
  84. randomly another card from the deck so they'll add another uh product my colleagues and I thought
  85. about how could we give better guidance on that and the idea we uh deployed is to think of a a product a stock keeping
  86. unit we call it a skew as defined by its attributes so this shirt I'm wearing would you know would be a knit it's
  87. short sleeve it's a certain color it's a certain size um and then use the sales of your
  88. current products and we would do this in each and every store to estimate the demand that customers have for uh for
  89. attributes and then you can do something very powerful which is to um if I know there sales of this color
  90. and of short sleeve shirts and of mediums I can figure out uh sales of other products that are different
  91. combinations of attributes that I'm not currently selling and we found amazingly
  92. that there'll be uh products that the retailer thought there was no demand for uh so they didn't have very much of
  93. it but if you analyze the data right you see that there's a huge demand that can
  94. you give an example yeah sure Tire we worked with a tire retailer um and one of the attributes was the price
  95. and quality level they had six different price quality levels from cheapest to to
  96. highest price they didn't think uh it appropriate to carry very much of the cheapest tire so across something like a
  97. hundred different sizes there were only nine of these sizes in which They Carried the lowest price lowest Quality
  98. Tire and so therefore they didn't sell much of it it was only 5% of their sales therefore confirming
  99. their belief that customers really didn't want to buy this cheap tire if you looked at the
  100. sizes the nine sizes that They Carried this lowest price point in uh across the six it represented 60%
  101. of Revenue it outsold the next next bestselling I think by 10 to1 so the customers if you look carefully at the
  102. data we're screaming hey price matters to us you know we and and the neighborhoods that these stores were in
  103. were less wealthy neighborhoods it was not surprising so there was a whole set of call them home run products that they
  104. were not aware of because of this self-fulfilling prophecy that we don't think our customers want to buy low pric
  105. cheap tires so we're not going to carry them and we don't sell a lot of them and
  106. we were right in fact they were dead wrong and there was a huge opportunity there so so that's something we found to
  107. be very interesting absolutely well another issue that uh you you bring up in your book is that uh inflexible
  108. Supply chains is the ban of almost all retailers uh what are some of the ways in which a supply chain can become more
  109. agile um well I would start answering your question by referring back to the beginning of this interview where we
  110. talked about uh the average markdown in a department store now is 40% signaling a
  111. huge amount of of excess supply of some products yet uh C customers who fill out
  112. a survey uh say onethird of the time we can't find what we came for so there's also
  113. shortage uh how do you correct that how you better match Supply with demand have less of
  114. the wrong products more of the right there there really three things you can and you need to do all three together
  115. more accurate forecast a better choice of the right inventory levels and a flexible supply chain which
  116. means uh short lead time the ability to uh Supply the quantity the market needs efficiently which might be a lot or
  117. might be a little uh what has caused uh Supply chains to be INF flexible uh over time I think
  118. is uh a number of but probably the biggest one is the pursuit of low cost uh by sourcing from Asia China
  119. being at the head of the class in terms of countries that people Source from uh I actually first visited China teaching
  120. in a warden program for six weeks with my family in 1982 in Shanghai and the uh pretty much the only
  121. other westerners we saw were buyers from apparel companies and they were the first wave you know that was really the
  122. beginning China normalized relations with the US in 1979 um and that's when apparel
  123. companies realized that wage rates in in China were what 3% of what they were in the
  124. United States and that caused a flood of gravitation of sourcing of of products from apparel toys consumer electronics
  125. uh many other things from China and other Asian countries so that's a lengthen the supply chain from miles to
  126. halfway around the world that's probably the biggest Factor that's caused Supply
  127. chains to be uh inflexible there are lots of other choices you make in a supply chain
  128. between slow and cheap versus fast and expensive like do you ship by boat or by air you can measure cost and companies
  129. are very conscious of costs the value of speed is harder to measure that value is
  130. better in stock better Revenue but you don't have a direct measurement so you know it costs you an extra $3 to ship
  131. something by air the gain you get from that is um is unknown and probably in the future you
  132. you pay the $3 today the gains in the future so there a tendency for what's immediate and measurable cost to be
  133. overweighted relative to what's harder to which which is valuable but harder to measure speed and flexibility of the
  134. supply chain so every time there's a fork on the road for companies do I pick slow and cheap or fast and expensive the
  135. bias is to take the slow and cheap route yeah now you do mention in your book the
  136. example of companies like world and Zara yes that have done really some very Innovative things with their supply
  137. chains uh are there lessons that other companies could learn from their experience I of course of course there
  138. are well described in the book I think um the uh I think the first lesson is to know in this choice between slow and
  139. cheap fast and inexpensive when is it appropriate to choose fast and inexpensive um it's not appropriate
  140. for stable product with very predictable demand we use an example of Campbell's chicken noodle soup it's been around for
  141. more than a hundred years um long shelf life uh so excess inventory is not going
  142. to go obsolete you'll sell it eventually you may have to hold it a little longer
  143. uh very predictable demand uh you don't need speed and flexibility in the supply
  144. chain for that you can contrast that with fashion apparel toys uh with this huge Spike demand at
  145. Christmas uh many consumer electronics products products that have a a gross margin of
  146. 50% or more so missing a sale is extremely expensive uh for those products um you
  147. need flexibility Zara uh which is pretty well known world as a Japanese retailer less well known in the west
  148. because they sell only in Japan but some similar practices to Zara and then just
  149. a couple miles from where we're sitting here in Philadelphia's Destination Maternity um a company started by
  150. Rebecca Matias a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania uh with a crushingly
  151. dominant 50% share of the women's maternity Market all three of these apparel uh firms have adopted uh a DNA
  152. of speed and flexibility they they can get back in stock produce more and get back in stock on a hot
  153. selling item in two weeks whereas that number for uh other retailers would be measured
  154. in months usually four months or more which it which for a seasonal product means it's game over if it's selling
  155. well too bad you can't get back in stock and they do a whole set of things some of are sort of obvious and mechanistic
  156. they they'll buy undyed fabric uh and keep it in inventory so they can quickly cut it and dye it they
  157. use a laser for cutting so they can cut a single layer of fabric the less mechanistic obvious thing they do
  158. which I think many retailers Miss is they realize that if you want to quickly react to demand get back in stock on a
  159. hot seller the time uh to make decisions needed to do that uh for many retailers
  160. will be rather lengthy and will be a big part of the L time so they Empower uh product brand-based teams in
  161. the trenches uh the lowest rung of the of the organizational ladder to be empowered to make decisions you want to
  162. make more of this product you can't get exactly this button but you can get one like it is that okay they can decide yes
  163. or no yeah it's okay the team will have a designer on it and they'll say yeah that'll work so they'll be somewhat uh
  164. Scrappy and Street Smart in uh in matching what the materials they can get with what the Market's telling us is
  165. needed by the market uh any any thoughts on how retailers can improve their store
  166. level execution first of all I think we all shop and we all uh Experience Store execution uh when we go to a store can
  167. we find a parking spot or not uh is it easy to find the entrance when we get in is the store easy to
  168. navigate uh does it look neat and tidy or messy if we need help can we find somebody there's a whole set of uh
  169. components of our shopping experience uh that affect how we feel and are we going to next time we get to
  170. the end of our driveway are we going to turn left and go back to that retailer or turn right and go to the competitor
  171. when I ask my students when I talk about stor execution uh who's had a bad experience
  172. shopping uh every hand goes up who's had a bad experience that made you really angry every hand goes up and I could
  173. spend 80-minute class just listening to viscerally angry stories about bad experiences they've had trapping I just
  174. suspect you've had that I know I have everybody has and it's a huge huge problem for retailers right
  175. uh there's a a couple ideas described in the book that I think are important one
  176. is getting Staffing levels right in the store the uh quantity and experience of the store associates we
  177. worked with a number of retailers who collected customer satisfaction data surveys from their customers on shopping
  178. experience and you could correlate uh how satisfied was the customer and their overall number with factors that might
  179. drive that satisfaction and almost always across a variety of retailers it was three things if I need help can I
  180. find it is the person knowledgeable and helpful to me the store associate and can I find the product I came to buy so
  181. at the end of the day people who shop have a mission and if they can accomplish their mission they're happy
  182. uh so we've generally found that stores on average are underst staffed and again it comes back to the
  183. measurable being overweighted relatively unmeasurable you write a check at the end of the month for salary for your
  184. store associates that's measurable known and immediate the value of having 10% more payroll budget and therefore 10%
  185. more people in the stores um is harder to measure so retailers tend to staff we developed a statistical technique for
  186. correlating Revenue with level of Staffing in a retailer based in part on these customer satisfaction surveys and
  187. we found in one example that uh every dollar more you spent on payroll added $10 in revenue on average
  188. it varied by store and by months so you had to apply it in a granular way cuz some stores were overstaffed you wanted
  189. to cut them but but this technique lets you measure the revenue impact of payroll uh now you think about the
  190. economics to spend a dollar this month to get $10 in Revenue this month uh with a 50% margin you're
  191. getting $5 in profit for a dollar in expense that's a great deal and it's not an investment because it happens within
  192. the current month so that was what we saw as a execution void is number one an overweighting of of the payroll expense
  193. viewing labor as sort of an expense rather than an investment and number two not being able to to
  194. staff in a way that takes into account the impact of Staffing on on revenue and one final question Marshall what advice
  195. would you give managers of retail companies to help them Succeed In The New Normal global economy oh well this
  196. uh New Normal is uh hard to Define but uh let let's first of all say what how that phrase is often used is we've just
  197. been through the worst e economy or in the midst really in some ways if you look at unemployment are the worst
  198. economy that you and I have experienced so far I think the Great Depression of the
  199. 30s is in first place but who knows how this is all going to play out so there's
  200. this sense that the economy will recover but that it will be uh somehow fundamentally
  201. changed uh in ways that are uh hard to discern I'll just mention one possibility which many retailers
  202. believe is that during a recession uh people become more price conscious and if you look at the impact
  203. of the recession on retailers for the vast majority maybe 90% it was bad news Revenue went down
  204. surprisingly there's some retailers that are counter that do better do as well or
  205. better so who would you guess would be a counter cyclic retailer that does better
  206. in tough times probably the the discount retailers yeah so who be at The Head of
  207. the Class the Walmart Walmart yeah Walmart auto parts retailers right right any any do-it-yourself
  208. retailer uh did as well or better during the recession will that persist um is a very interesting
  209. question uh and of course the W Walmarts of the world say of course it will fundamentally people have changed their
  210. buying Behavior avior and price matters more now and will and there's a whole generation that went through this lousy
  211. economy like the depression generation and they're going to think about life differently and they're going to be more
  212. price conscious um the other thing that's going on now and I think will persist for a long time it's
  213. deleveraging people are paying off their credit card bills which means they're spending less so there's a great
  214. reduction in consumer spending levels that's going to have a big big impact on retailing
  215. great Marshall thank you so much for speaking with us today M it was my great pleasure thank you for having me
  216. [Music]

Brief Summary

Marshall Fisher discusses retail supply issues, inventory management, and adapting to consumer behavior for improved profits.

Key points

  • The Cost of Excess Inventory. Excess inventory leads to markdowns and lower profits for retailers.
  • Retailers and Supply-Demand Mismatch. Retailers often struggle to match supply with demand, leading to lost sales and profits.
  • The Importance of Inventory Management. Effective inventory management can significantly boost a retailer's profits.
  • Retailers Drowning in Data. Many retailers have vast amounts of data but lack actionable insights.
  • Agility in Supply Chains. Flexible supply chains are crucial for retailers to meet demand effectively.
  • Retail Staffing Impact. Every dollar spent on payroll can lead to a significant increase in revenue.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes