Lawyer Morris DeFeo: Why Partnerships Are Key for Outsiders Navigating the Indian Legal System

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

India has its own legal system, regulations and heritage. It is difficult for an American lawyer to chart his way through that maze. The way to go is to tie up with an Indian legal firm, says Morris DeFeo, a partner with the Crowell & Moring (C&M) corporate group. DeFeo is head of the law firm's India and MENA (Middle East-North Africa) practice. But both sides of any partnership must accept that they have much to learn from each other, notes DeFeo in this interview with India Knowledge@Wharton. 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. thank you welcome Mr divio thank you very much for joining us today uh knowledge Edward and
  2. for the water in the economic Forum my pleasure thank you for letting me be here it's a pleasure to have you uh we'd
  3. love to start off I know you are an Alum of the University of Pennsylvania so welcome back thank you have you been
  4. back a lot since you graduated I wouldn't say a lot not as much as I would like to but it's going to be 30
  5. years since I graduated which I try not to tell too many people because well now
  6. it's on camera and now it's on camera right now so now I'm unfortunately dating myself which is uh not a good
  7. thing but it's uh it was it was certainly a cherished memory of mine to be a pen I enjoyed being there for the
  8. four years and it's hard to imagine that 30 years have gone by but I'm proud to be able to come back and contribute in
  9. some respect to this very important event yeah and it's a pleasure having alumni come back obviously thank you to
  10. the campus I would love to start off talking about Krillin Mooring and uh why are you guys why your firm decided
  11. to enter India or do you work in India no I've been delighted to Kroll is a U.S based firm of about 550 lawyers now we
  12. have offices throughout the U.S but also throughout the Middle East and in Europe
  13. um and about my background I'm actually by background at Capital markets and M a
  14. lawyer with a particular focus on cross-border transactional work and I manage our Middle East and India
  15. practices I think the reason that we would focus on India is very simple and that is that our clients are focused on
  16. India when we have meetings with some of our Marquee clients which are among the
  17. Fortune 50 and 100 companies in the United States and their counterparts in Europe they would all list India as
  18. being one of their top two or three most important markets I'm a big believer in
  19. going where our clients go and what our clients want to focus on India that means we have to focus on India as well
  20. that in addition to the fact that India is just intrinsically an incredibly important and growing part of the world
  21. economy would make it critical that we as a major law firm with International reach would want to be present to the
  22. extent we can be and for our clients in India again we add some timelines to the
  23. Trends you've been saying you know when you say your Market clients who are looking to have an India strategy
  24. when has this when what are these timelines that you've been seeing when did this start happening and how
  25. strongly is this momentum going forward well it's certainly been happening for quite a number of years and I think the
  26. world economic downturn in 2008 kind of created a sort of disruption in the flow
  27. of things but I think that certainly over the past two years I've seen a dramatic increase in interest among some
  28. of our Global clients our firm represents a significant number of U.S government contractors and some
  29. household names that everyone would be familiar with not only the defense industry but also just in Government
  30. Contracting generally and then excuse me in particular in the past couple of years they've all been very very focused
  31. on India one of our clients which has a multiplicity of subsidiaries in every imaginable field one of the one of the
  32. largest companies in the United States has said that they have one ambition strategically by the end of 2012 and
  33. that's to have a certain number of strategic Sciences which they've ranked by tears and in tier one India ranks
  34. with one or two other countries I think that's very indicative of where a lot of
  35. the major multinational businesses that are based in the US or in Europe are looking yeah yeah so since your firm and
  36. you personally have been doing work related to India for the last couple of years or more
  37. share some of your perceptions for us on the Indian legal system as a whole now obviously India as a country especially
  38. when you compare to other fast growing economies in the world often is touted as you know strong democracy with
  39. vibrant institutions including you know Judiciary its legal system how do you view it
  40. um without exception India offers I think a degree of comfort that many other jurisdictions do not to let's say
  41. Western businesses that are either doing business in India or with Indian counterparts there is a widespread
  42. recognition I believe that the Indian legal system because of its Heritage its long tradition of Independence and it's
  43. a similarity for example uh to UK and some Western legal systems as well as the language familiarity which cannot be
  44. understated um and the and the the cultural comfort that I think the legal profession in
  45. India has dealing with Western clients are all significant contributing factors to why American and European uh
  46. companies for example find it more comfortable to work in India and with Indian law firms than they would in
  47. other parts of the world that is also enhanced by the fact that India I think in many respects is uniquely positioned
  48. to look both East and West when it comes to businesses and I think that in many respects India and Indian law firms can
  49. act as a bridge between not only India and the west but the west and the rest of Asia
  50. um having said that I think that you know not wanting to be in politic or on diplomatic I I do like to think that
  51. there are things that both Indian law firms and lawyers can learn from Western law firms and vice versa and I and I
  52. think that we are seeing some of those Trends uh emerge when I talk to our U.S clients for example they generally
  53. remain largely more comfortable if for example an American lawyer were to be involved in in the transaction or into
  54. the project and not simply go directly to Indian firms I think over good food which is good for me and so we are
  55. somewhat in a in a conflicted position in that sense but we we try to manage that correctly and always do what the
  56. client wants but I think it's indicative of the fact that there is still perhaps
  57. a ways to go for Indian lawyers and law firms to be more Western in their in their approach to things and to yeah
  58. us oh sure what would that imply what would that mean I think perhaps the most important thing for if I were to be
  59. presumptuous enough to give advice to Indian lawyers it would be to to try to think more the way Western clients think
  60. and to act more the way they expect their lawyers to act and and that their lawyers their successful lawyers do act
  61. in the West in terms of responsiveness getting back quickly for example on email when a western client says they
  62. need something they generally don't want to wait a day or two they very often don't want to wait more than an hour or
  63. two to get an answer I think that's one thing I think the efficiency of responding is also very important in
  64. terms of not necessarily having to crank out a voluminous memorandum on every topic but to be able to provide quick
  65. practical not academic not winded explanations when a client says I'm need to know can I do this or can I not do
  66. that or what are the ramifications to be able to respond swiftly and clearly and
  67. concisely is very important and I think also part of it is mindset there I have met and there are undoubtedly many other
  68. Indian lawyers who are very much business focused have have the kind of business Acumen not simply legal Acumen
  69. but business Acumen to stand in the shoes of their clients that many successful Western lawyers have and I
  70. think Western clients like that they want to be able to talk to a lawyer not simply as someone who knows the law but
  71. someone who can take that in a very practical and real way and apply it to their specific needs and maybe answer
  72. questions that the client itself hasn't even asked so if I can flip that around and ask you what have you seen in the
  73. way law firms are managed in in their some of the larger law firms or in the way the legal system works or in the way
  74. lawyers approach their work are there any lessons that you've seen that you can draw for the U.S lawyers or
  75. other lawyers around the world um well I do I do think that American lawyers and Western lawyers in
  76. particular need to understand uh that just because something works for for an American client or for an American
  77. client doing business in the United States or in Europe doesn't necessarily mean that that's the way it's going to
  78. work in India we need to be aware of the fact that India has its own traditions and its own ways of doing business and
  79. its own ways of dealing with legal issues so clearly for me working very closely with qualified
  80. Indian lawyers that I have chemistry with and that I feel comfortable with and that just as importantly feel
  81. comfortable with me is critical we are not going in to India in in some backdoor way that we know
  82. frankly other Western Law Firms have done um we would rather go in in tandem with
  83. qualified Indian lawyers when we have a legal issue for example or one of our clients has a legal issue my preferred
  84. way of handling it is to be an advisor to my client the same way I am anywhere else in the world but to acknowledge the
  85. fact that I will never understand the Indian legal system or the culture or the business Community or political
  86. context as well as a qualified Indian lawyer and I would rather than reach out to one of my counterparts at an Indian
  87. law firm and team up on providing a solution that the client will benefit from right
  88. if I can then quickly change tag and ask you about the regulatory hurdles that some of your clients have faced you know
  89. from your clients perspective especially the U.S companies that you're representing or helping out with in
  90. India what are some of let's say like the top three issues that they would want to see changes in
  91. without exception of breaking down of barriers on FDI would be very helpful right in various
  92. sectors the liberalization of some of those rules aware currently non-indian investors cannot participate or they can
  93. only participate with prior government approval or in a very restricted way I think
  94. um I can give you countless examples which you know which I which I'm not at Liberty to but Commerce examples where
  95. we have had to either back away from transactions or completely restructure them and or and spend a lot of time and
  96. money restructuring them in order to conform to some of these rules I think liberalization of the FDI regime is of
  97. critical importance to further work by U.S and European counterparts I think in increased adherence to
  98. transparency um and I don't simply mean that from um from a avoidance of improper uh
  99. conduct which you know is not in any way unique to India it's it's endemic throughout many countries including to
  100. some extent in the United States but uh the the certainty of dealing with a transparent business process that is
  101. fair and Equitable and open is incredibly important and then I think the Third Kind of flows from that which
  102. is a an increased efficiency and elimination of bureaucracy and dealing with business and legal processes would
  103. be very important yeah finally one element of the U.S sort of interaction within us the U.S and Indian legal
  104. systems other legal fraternities has been this uh emergence of what we call lpos legal process outsources yes the
  105. equivalent of bpos which have been around for much longer any quick thoughts or your perspective on where
  106. you see the legal process Outsourcing industry going and how you see that relationship between the U.S and Indian
  107. uh I guess legal entities growing forward I think it's an important attribute and a
  108. comparative advantage that American law firms have been slow to embrace because they view it I think is kind of a way of
  109. siphoning business away from it but I I just don't think that's the right way to
  110. look at it we've actually embraced this outside of India to some extent by opening up our offices in the Middle
  111. East where the cost structure for example is considerably lower right now that's a little bit easier for a law
  112. firm to embrace because those are our lawyers and so the revenue stays within the firm but as part of the overall way
  113. of doing things it fits squarely into what we're doing in India so for example when a client comes to us and says we
  114. have a major project in India they clearly want us to be involved in a very significant way but we will very often
  115. in addition to bringing in the Indian counterpart the Indian Law Firm or lawyer in order to handle the matters
  116. that we cannot legally handle will very often push a lot of the the elements of that transaction or project into the
  117. Indian firm which may take Revenue away from us in some respects but it keeps the overall budget in line and allows us
  118. to win the work and I'd rather win the work and give up some Revenue than not be able to do the project at all so I
  119. think that the comparative advantage is a is a tremendous asset that we have already gotten comfortable with in other
  120. parts of the world and I think that we will continue to do that and our clients will continue to insist on it when we
  121. deal with work in India and now beyond that of course there are things that could be done by Indian lpos that are
  122. not directly related to work in India and so by virtue of the high quality of and training of the lawyers there that
  123. you're going to see an increasing amount of that work being outsourced and I think that we would be comfortable with
  124. that I think we have a ways to go to embrace it ourselves and understand it I don't mean to suggest that Kroll is
  125. ahead of the curve I would say quite the opposite but I think that we have more flexibility maybe and and more
  126. willingness to do that than some law firms might sure well it's been a pleasure having you Mr dufio with us
  127. thank you again for sharing the time and we hope you enjoy the rest of the Forum
  128. thank you very much it's been a great pleasure thank you so much

Brief Summary

Mr. Divio discusses Kroll's focus on India, the Indian legal system, and challenges for U.S. companies operating there.

Key points

  • Returning to Roots. After 30 years, an alum reflects on their cherished memories at the University of Pennsylvania.
  • Focus on India. A law firm emphasizes the importance of India in global markets and client strategies.
  • Legal Process Outsourcing. The discussion highlights the growing trend of legal process outsourcing between the U.S. and India.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes