A Prescription for Affordable Housing in India

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Our guest today is Rajesh Krishnan. He's the CEO of Brick Eagle Group uh located
  2. in uh Mumbai, India. Uh it's a developer of affordable affordable housing in India. Rajes, thank you so much for
  3. joining us at knowledge at Wharton. It's my pleasure. Thank you. Uh now understand your background is
  4. actually in banking. How did you get interested in affordable housing? Um actually brick eagle is more a
  5. financial services platform for affordable housing. Uh what we really do is connect capital with execution
  6. capability. So to that extent actually my my background in banking is extremely helpful. Um see while affordable housing
  7. is always known as a huge um depressing social need and an opportunity um the fact is there's a disconnect between
  8. capital and execution capability. And I happened to just stumble into it. I started investing in affordable housing
  9. in my personal capacity and that's when I learned that the risk adjusted returns
  10. in affordable housing is actually superior to many other asset classes out there. So at one stage I just decided to
  11. do it full-time. Okay. So we we'll come back to the to the returns but before we do that could you
  12. tell us a little bit about the housing market in India and spec specifically the need
  13. for uh affordable housing? Sure. How how big is the market? As you know, MKul, we have over a
  14. billion people in India. Everybody needs a roof over their head. Um there are various studies by McKenzie, Deutsche
  15. Bank and all written on this topic. Uh but I'm told the demand for affordable housing is over 5 million units every
  16. year in India. Today we are short of $20 million. But then it's a growing problem
  17. because of urbanization, right? So the annual housing demand is 5 million units. Um however the important point is
  18. supply is minuscule compared to that right so we're not even there at 10% of demand and as a result in a place like
  19. Mumbai as you know over 50% of people live in slums and substandard accommodation so it's a huge deal
  20. uh what is uh brick eagle's strategy to fulfill part of this demand and enter this market
  21. sure um see essentially we realize that the guys who want to do affordable able housing typically lack access to
  22. capital, right? And we started as a land banking company for affordable housing because we realized that what they need
  23. money for is usually to buy land, right? So we started investing in lands for affordable housing development. Soon we
  24. basically realized that the value chain for affordable housing is broken. So we decided to invest in developers and
  25. service providers in the affordable housing value chain. Right? And now we are looking to set up a housing finance
  26. company to also fund home buyers. Yep. So in a sense we are basically making investments across the value chain. So
  27. we are able to take it from start to finish. So I understand you recently celebrated
  28. your fourth anniversary. That's right. Uh can you tell us a little bit about some of the major milestones and what
  29. you've been able to accomplish so far? Uh sure. Um so as a for a 4-year-old company we today manage about,250 acres
  30. of lands which when fully developed will house about 88,000 families. Um we spread across um Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu
  31. and Gujarat through three states. Um today we have a team of 400 people uh doing this. Um last year we delivered
  32. 1,00 houses. As a group we've delivered about 4,000 houses so far but then we are slowly ramping it up. This year the
  33. target is to deliver 5,000 houses but I surely hope we start doing 10,000 50,000
  34. houses uh you know within the next 5 years. Uh who would you say is your main competition Rajes and how does your
  35. approach differ from theirs? I don't look at anybody as competition, right? U I look at everybody out there
  36. as partners. You got developers, you got private equity shops, you got construction technology companies, you
  37. got various people out there, but what we find is everybody out there is missing some piece of the puzzle, right?
  38. So what we really want to do is basically plug those gaps and help those guys deliver scale, right? For instance,
  39. um recently we incubated a developer in in um in Puna, right? U they have access
  40. to funding. They are very good at construction, but they don't understand branding and distribution, right? So we
  41. put together the branding and distribution strategy for them, right? On the other side, we just recently made
  42. an investment in another developer in Gujarat. Uh they're actually very good de developer. They actually they won the
  43. award for the best affordable housing developer of the year and they've already delivered 3,000 houses. But they
  44. needed capital to scale up, right? So we told them, look, you run operations, let
  45. me take care of finance for you, right? So we actually look at ourselves as a plug-and-play service to essentially
  46. help others deliver scale. So what it seems to me from what you're saying, Rajes, is that what you're doing
  47. is leveraging the entire housing ecosystem. That's right. uh and and your goal, if I
  48. understand it correctly, and please correct me if I'm wrong, is to deliver houses uh that would cost the customer
  49. around $5 to $10,000 in that price range. Could you explain your approach of how does leveraging the housing
  50. industries ecosystem and the technology ecosystem allow you to develop houses at
  51. that kind of prices? Uh sure. I would like to make a small distinction here um between affordable
  52. housing and what we call social housing. Right? Affordable housing in my mind is
  53. a market-based solution uh for housing the middle and low-inccome segments. And there the trick really is to make small
  54. format homes livable, right? Because this is a market-based solution. It it is so the per square foot rate is a
  55. market rate. So the key value driver of affordability is size. So we put a lot of thought into making a 300 ft² home
  56. livable, right? So there basically the design the interiors and and all the amenities and stuff like that has a huge
  57. impact on the way the product is designed. But then the point that you're touching upon is what I would call
  58. social housing right because when we say India needs 20 million homes today all all the demand is is in the less than
  59. arguably $15,000 price point right $5 to $15,000. So there um essentially you need a
  60. radically different approach right because this segment per se is not so profitable. So you need to actually come
  61. up with some kind of product process or financial engineering to cater to this need, right? Like people like Habitat
  62. for Humanity are doing a wonderful job on the process engineering in terms of sourcing materials, labor at subsidized
  63. rates, right? Um but then the where we want to focus on is financial engineering. Um see today when we do
  64. affordable housing, we our investors seek 3x return in five years. That's about a 25% annualized return for them
  65. to be able to invest in affordable housing. But I'm saying if you have access to capital from impact investors
  66. who are happy with 5% annualized returns, we can use the benefit of low cost of capital to subsidize housing for
  67. the poor, right? And it turns out if you just get money at 5%, we can deliver houses at5 $10,000 in scale in the
  68. outskirts of Bombay. That's to me is like magic. So who are your investors today? are
  69. they primarily impact investors and uh what is your pitch to them as you uh aim for higher scale?
  70. Uh what sort of a pitch do you make to impact investors? See, so far we've been going to
  71. commercial investors. The pitch to them has been look um let's invest in lands for affordable housing development. So
  72. it's for you it's a fully secured investment that will target a 3x return while serving a pressing social need.
  73. Right? So that's the pitch we've been giving so far and we collected some 40 $45 million on this pitch right but now
  74. what we are very excited about is basically doing social housing for at the bottom of the pyramid right and for
  75. that we need to go to essentially endowments foundations impact investors right um who are who are basically happy
  76. to take a slightly higher risk for a slightly lower market return right we're not asking for charity uh we're saying
  77. we'll actually make 5% returns or 10% the need be Right. Um there we got our first check for a pilot project from a
  78. from a family office in India. It's actually the times of group in India uh who gave us 20 cr rupees that's about $3
  79. half million uh to run a pilot right. Um but then we think there is a lot of money available from impact investors
  80. globally especially from institutions pension funds in Europe right banks who have allocation for social impact and so
  81. we want to reach out to them this year. Well the flip side of any investment opportunity is always the risk.
  82. Uh so uh any red herring document outlines them. So what do you see as the primary risks of investing in affordable
  83. housing in India? Um look it's India so you can get hit from all directions so you just have to watch out. Um see but
  84. then it's it's mainly idiosyncratic risks if you ask me. Um so people often ask me hey you know what about cost
  85. escalation? What if u you know what if you're not able to get material on time, cement on time, construction technology?
  86. To me all of that is nice. You can have you know it can erode into your profits but you're not going to lose your shirt
  87. right those are all execution risks correct right but then most projects in India get stuck for two other reasons
  88. right not because of engineering process reasons it's mainly um it's fair to say
  89. majority of projects in India are stuck because they ran out of money right so financial closure is very important
  90. ensure that you're backing the right guy who has access to funding right um the second would be just idiosyncratic risk
  91. Right? So because the legal framework is fragile. So if you go to court, it can take 20 years to settle a lawsuit.
  92. Right? So you got to just stay away from shareholder disputes, local disputes, you know, and you know just you know
  93. keep it clean, right? No, I I understand. Considering that you are aiming at uh social housing, have you
  94. made any efforts to reach out to organizations like H uh Habitat for Humanity or even you know there are so
  95. social entrepreneurship foundations like Ashoka. Have you reached out to any of them to for support?
  96. Interesting you mentioned this. um Ashoka actually identified housing as a pressing social need about four or five
  97. years back and they've done phenomenal work and we met them and um so essentially what they were doing is that
  98. they was aggregating demands at the grassroot level and encouraging developers to supply right and turns out
  99. many more lot of developers were not interested in supplying at those price points right so we flipped the problem
  100. the other way around we said look this these are the areas where we can supply can you please aggregate demand for us
  101. here so we can ensure that it goes to the most deserving and beneficiaries. So, we're working with them and in fact
  102. we're just talking to them about partnering together to set up the social housing fund. Right? On the other hand,
  103. we're also speaking to Habitat for Humanity on how we can potentially partner because in essence our goals are
  104. the same. We both saying can we enable a million homes in the next 15 20 years and they realize that with their current
  105. approach they may not be able to hit that number in India right so we saying hey maybe if you know combined forces
  106. there's a good possibility we can make it happen right so so uh brick eagle has completed
  107. four years uh where do you see yourself in the next four years next four years um actually the next 10
  108. years is actually easier question to answer next 10 years right um see essentially we got a
  109. two-prong goal on one side uh we are saying hey can we deliver 1% of India's housing need right that turns out to be
  110. like a million units in the next 20 years right so which by the way is like a herculan task right so we set
  111. ourselves to achieve that goal right so that's our stated goal we want to deliver 1 million units in the next 15
  112. 20 years right on the other side also and done we are a market player right Um McKenzie says affordable housing is a
  113. hundred billion dollar market opportunity right and with as with every market we think the top 10 20% of the
  114. players are going to have the 80% share right so we we want one of our invest companies to be there in the top 10
  115. right in the next 5 10 years right and right now as far as I can see the field is wide open there is no front runner
  116. right and so I think we have a decent shot at it great uh one last question Rajes that is
  117. uh based on your experience with affordable housing so far what can developers of other affordable housing
  118. projects in different parts of the world learn from break eagle. Ah um that's a difficult question. So
  119. see it's a it's a very local play right. Um one thing I would say is always have
  120. a local partner um for every place that you go to. uh interestingly for instance
  121. right home you know one of the biggest affordable housing developers in the world they came to India they spent five
  122. years they couldn't launch a single project right so so I mean while they of course know the game there are huge
  123. local barriers to entry um so in a way recognize the fact that you need to have local partners to execute and that in a
  124. way is also been the reason why a lot of modern developers corporate developers in India have not managed to scale up
  125. and because the decision- making is very centralized. So this is a very local game. You need to have a local guy out
  126. there taking the decisions on the fly. Yeah. Um so that would be uh one important learning I would say. Um but
  127. yeah, affordable housing is a global need. So there is enough to play. Well, good luck to you Rajes and thanks
  128. so much for joining us at knowledge at Wharton. Thank you so much. It's a pleasure.
  129. [Music]

Brief Summary

Rajesh Krishnan discusses affordable housing in India, Brick Eagle's strategies, and the need for local partnerships in the housing market.

Key points

  • The Housing Demand in India. India faces a staggering demand for over 5 million affordable housing units annually.
  • Investment Strategy. Brick Eagle connects capital with execution capabilities to address housing needs.
  • Brick Eagle's Mission. Rajesh Krishnan aims to tackle India's housing crisis by delivering affordable homes.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes