How the Twittersphere Helped Donald Trump Win

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton research shows that sensational tweets have staying power, aiding Donald Trump’s ascent. More: http://knlg.net/2kn1y97 📂 Technology 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. make America tweet again that's the provocative title of a new research paper out of won that looked at the
  2. Tweet surrounding the 2016 Republican primary debates here to talk about the paper and its surprising findings are
  3. Wharton Professor Ron Burman and doctoral candidate Coleman Humphrey so welcome thank you deorah so tell me why
  4. did you decide to analyze Twitter versus other types of communication so that's actually a very interesting story so our
  5. co-authors professor Robert mayor and shirim maluma do a PD candidate at Columbia business school they were
  6. starting to work on a project using Twitter data um and the focus was how emotionality and the device he use
  7. changes the patterns but then uh we realized that uh in um elections and debates what happens is that people
  8. today use Twitter as the main forum for pushing their opinions and debating with
  9. everyone Etc so this has become like the Twitter election and as a result we wanted to focus very much to see what do
  10. voters think given what they see on Twitter but also what do voters do on Twitter and how they interpret that now
  11. we this was about in August at that time it was clear that Trump has a big advantage on Twitter and he's uh getting
  12. a lot of uh voter opinion and voter advantage through Twitter so combined with that it was very very interesting
  13. to look at Twitter as does it reflect voter opinion but also can you use Twitter to also influence voter opinion
  14. and how that works during a debate and can you give us an overview a quick overview of how you conducted the
  15. research well sure so first um to decide what data to collect we decided to focus
  16. on three very pivotal debates so the first one was the August debate which was the most viewed primary debate of
  17. all time um and people were clamoring to see Trump versus bush and who would do better we also um had the February
  18. debate um which was just before super Tuesday so it was kind of like the last chance for uh one of the other
  19. candidates to try and derail Trump and his uh amazing poll numbers and then finally the March debate which um people
  20. were buzzing about because it was back U Trump versus Megan Kelly the the second
  21. time I guess so within there we collected all the relevant uh tweets from all debates so from an hour
  22. beforehand to uh two hours after the debates just all tweets that that had the main hashtag in them so we knew they
  23. were tweeting about the debate uh and from there from this data we were able to you know we have um who tweeted and
  24. who retweeted what time that all happened at and we also then we applied this program called Luke which um it
  25. finds was there a negative tone in the Tweet was there a positive tone did you use like um oops sorry did you use
  26. personal pronouns um was a kind of uh based on like was it a power tweet or a reward tweet and then for a subset of
  27. the data the kind of the most popular tweets we also sent them off to MK to get humans to look a little bit further
  28. at the tweets we got um humans to decide is there a picture or a video in the Tweet or does it contain humor or
  29. sarcasm uh as well so what are the key findings of your paper um so so we found a a few very interesting things some of
  30. them just didn't conform with past research results and some of them were just brand new the first thing we looked
  31. at was um what do people see during the debate do they mostly see new tweets or do they
  32. see more and more old tweets because of retweets of other people and we found that over time you basically have a more
  33. dated view of of the debate which means if you look very towards the end of the debate actually you're going to see
  34. mostly tweets from very early on in the debate the second thing we looked at was
  35. what was the sentiment during the debate uh for different candidates and we found
  36. that if you looked after the debate versus during the debate you would get a very different view of the sentiment for
  37. so example for Donald Trump the uh sentiment after the debate was uh very positive while during the debate
  38. sometimes there were controversies maybe Sensations that generated a negative um
  39. sentiment uh and finally another thing we noticed is that the Tweet stream becomes more and more Sensational and
  40. less substantive and in the words of of Bob Mayer another professor o on this colleagu is that during the debate you
  41. get the New York Times after the debate you getting the New York Post and this is something thing we found out which
  42. was very interesting do you think this explains why Trump defied expectations to get the Republican nomination for
  43. president sure this we feel like this what Rono said definitely speaks to um to one of the reasons why perhaps he was
  44. so popular um Twitter kind of like a lot of other media I guess just really focuses on tabloid or Sensational stuff
  45. especially afterwards like that's that's what sticks um one of the things we analyzed was was sentiment people
  46. positive or negative towards certain candidates and you can see for Trump that even as something like the Trump
  47. University is being discussed um like quite heavily and he's really getting hammered for it in the debate his
  48. sentiment just like doesn't really seem to drop like uh and and especially after
  49. debates you can see his sentiment actually goes right back up and and is generally positive after the debate so
  50. people just really don't care about this this the negative stuff he says just doesn't seem to matter um and again
  51. building on on what Ron's saying it seems like Trump is the perfect cidate for the the Twitter election um since he
  52. is so used to generating like Sensational um news and and generating controversy and kind of leading towards
  53. all the Tabloid stuff and and also avoiding policy where he's probably weakest out of all the candidates on the
  54. stage and that's what sticks so absolutely um Twitter seems to seems to be the medium the medium for him so what
  55. are the implications of your findings on voter opinions so there are a few implications
  56. we think are are playing like are play there there there implications on trying to to gauge or to understand voter
  57. opinions and and one of the findings is that if you analyze Twitter data you might get the wrong idea so if you look
  58. during the debate maybe you'll get one sentiment after the debate you might get a different sentiment so it really
  59. matters when you look at the debate and the other thing is um that voters who there are some voters who are very
  60. activing the debate and watch it and tweet about it Etc but most of the people probably open the newspaper the
  61. next morning or open their Twitter and say what happened during the debate yesterday and then they look and they
  62. see this backwards view which means the influence on them is probably much stronger U than what you would get if
  63. you watch during the debate one for example one thing we notice is that tweets that came from news sources
  64. during the debates were very influential during the debate and were retweeted a lot Etc but after the debate they were
  65. kind of going down if you think about it it used to be that there was a debate and news sources maybe would uh um kind
  66. of summarize or comment on the results after that and you would get what happened Deb during the debate in in a
  67. newspaper after that if you look at Twitter you would get a very different idea which means that perhaps Twitter is
  68. not either a good measurement or maybe Twitter is a reflecting uh Forum of the results and the news media is not a good
  69. measurement and reflecting uh Forum of the results which might cause surprises later
  70. on did any conclusions surprise you so one interesting uh finding we had which was surprising was how media was almost
  71. um inactive during the debate in actually commenting on it what they were doing is picking up mostly quotes from
  72. TV and just tweeting them they weren't saying who they think is winning they weren't commenting on facts they were
  73. just quoting and as a result during the debate people were retweeting them a lot
  74. but after the debate they had very very very little influence this was one surprise finding the second one is that
  75. for many tweets so this comes to academic research typically we assume there's something called a diffusion
  76. pattern you would have an idea that goes up gets retweeted and goes down and dies
  77. for many things we saw they barely had any influence during the debate they basically died during the debate and
  78. then had the Resurgence after the debate so for example um this um basically fight almost between Megan Kelly and
  79. Trump in August at the beginning generated some attention during the debate but then died off and but then
  80. after the debate it became the primary thing everyone was talking about and just building on that what was also
  81. perhaps surprising is that strong positive or negative emotions didn't didn't help much at all in fact what
  82. actually in in our case hurt the popularity of tweets both before and after the debate um and just kind of
  83. building on what we've been saying like being being everything being so Sensational and not being the most
  84. popular stuff um uh like it's it was especially clear afterwards so for example beforehand one thing that
  85. actually did stir some interest was the economy when people some people did tweet about the economy but afterwards
  86. it was just nothing there was just no no substantial policy not even policy that
  87. was popular during the debate um this was so it was a bit almost surprisingly sad that
  88. Twitter you might expect that Twitter is finally the way for everyone to debate and argue and and maybe get an
  89. understanding of of the issues but actually everyone towards the end was focused more on Sensations which means
  90. maybe Twitter is not the place you want to look at and kind of understand what is important in this election at at
  91. least in terms of the issues so how is your research different from prior work in this area um so so research is
  92. different on both methodology and a bit on findings so methodology it's interesting because we looked both at
  93. who tweets and who retweets and who gets gets followed by whom but also we looked
  94. at the sentiment and the topic of the tweets so this is one methodology difference and another one is the
  95. setting most people that analyzed uh tweets were looking at you know are people tweeting more about uh pop
  96. culture versus music or something like that if it's an event which is very active and you get more than 200 tweets
  97. a m a second right a second then there's this fight for attention and everyone is
  98. trying to say something this creates a very different Dynamic um and we think this is very unique because no one has
  99. has previously analyzed Tweets in a very short period of time in a very um kind of energetic active uh event so how will
  100. you follow up this research so building on what Ron just said we we or others might hope to um analyze other similar
  101. situations such as um sports or um any any other situation where it's very highly focused not over a long period of
  102. time um another area of focus we're interested in is um this the phenomenon of a lot of tweets being picked up by
  103. this by different users and what we mean by that is not just that something is retweeted but is is tweeted like not a
  104. retweet an original tweet um as opposed to just being like a very popular tweet like someone says something funny and
  105. everyone thinks it's hilarious and retweets so one example is is um quotes So sometimes a quote is so
  106. instantaneously interesting that everyone picks it up and just to give you one example from the debate U Mike
  107. hucke in one of the debates said um uh the purpose of the military is to kill people and break things and and this was
  108. retweeted this was tweeted excuse me not retweeted tweeted out by just over a 100
  109. people just immediately people were thought this was fascinating it actually wasn't that popular of of an idea like
  110. it didn't um last for ages and ages afterwards but it was initially very popular as opposed to this some quotes
  111. are only interesting because they get brought up by a person in context so actually in the same example um Pat and
  112. oswal um tweeted out um kill people and break things Mike Cooke just described the GOP and that itself is a very
  113. popular tweet and there are definitely some quotes that get picked up in that way just someone someone gives them more
  114. context that becomes super popular or sometimes just the quote itself just goes on and that's not the only thing we
  115. have um you know token tweets like who won is of course very popular but but it's it's interesting to see that in
  116. certain circumstances some tweets are either completely ignored of course some are picked up because one one user
  117. tweets something funny and that gets retweet a lot and sometimes just one idea or one moment who just gets picked
  118. up so much like I guess another moment that was a big deal was um uh the debate between Rubio and Trump's uh who had the
  119. bigger uh hands so to speak so these are and the other thing we didn't analyze so this was um a
  120. debate where people were trying to VI for the Republican nominations so these are not opposing ideas or issues this is
  121. just who gets the most attention we also have data from um the the primary debates right between Hillary Clinton
  122. and Donald Trump and I think it would be very interesting to understand if you had the same phenomenons and the same
  123. patterns there and would it be would have have been able to allow you to predict maybe who's going to win or or
  124. do issues matter or Sensations matter more and basically applying the same findings from this research to another
  125. data set to see if you get the same things does it generalize or is it very very specific well we can't wait to find
  126. out what you discover in your new research but thank you very much for joining us today thank you very much d
  127. [Music]

Brief Summary

Wharton researchers analyze Twitter's influence on voter sentiment during the 2016 Republican primary debates.

Key points

  • Make America Tweet Again. A new research paper explores the impact of Twitter on the 2016 Republican primary debates.
  • Surprising Findings on Sentiment. The study reveals how sentiment changes before and after debates, particularly for Trump.
  • The Role of Media During Debates. Media's influence wanes post-debate, focusing more on sensational quotes than analysis.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes