Maneet Ahuja on Hedge Funds and the 'Alpha Masters'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Maneet Ahuja began her career at age 17 as a credit risk analyst at Citigroup. Now, 10 years later, she has been named to the Forbes 2012 "30 under 30" list, is a producer for CNBC's Squawk Box and has written a new book called The Alpha Masters: Unlocking the Genius of the World's Top Hedge Funds. Knowledge@Wharton recently talked with her about the alpha masters she profiled in her book and about where she thinks the hedge fund industry is headed. πŸ“‚ Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] hello I'm Jeff Brown with knowledge at Wharton today we're with manit Ahuja uh
  2. who is a producer for CNBC and more importantly author of a new book called uh the alpha Masters Unlocking The
  3. Genius of the world's top hedge funds so welcome to Wharton thanks for having me
  4. tell us a little what brings you here today well I was fortunate enough to get a scholarship from the South Asian
  5. journalism Association to attend uh Wharton seminar for business journalist so I've been here for the past couple
  6. days and it's been great and it's been a nice fall for you uh for this visit now
  7. uh it's a wonderful book uh I can tell people is very readable it's profiles of uh 11 hedge fund managers at nine funds
  8. and uh explores case histories of some of the uh some of the big trades they've made some win some lose and uh gives a
  9. good sense of how this industry operates the kind of people who who run it and you're quite young we can say uh and got
  10. into the industry very young can you tell us about that well sure I started uh on Wall Street at City group as an
  11. intern when I was 17 years old uh it was just supposed to be a semester long internship if you go to school in the
  12. city they actually they have year round uh positions for folks like myself uh after 10 months the lady I was working
  13. for decided not to come back after maternity leave and that opened up an opportunity cuz I was able to juggle the
  14. work with school and I found it really uh interesting and fascinating and in addition to CNBC you've worked for the
  15. Wall Street Journal at at one point uh so it's quite a very background for somebody still in her 20s oh thank you
  16. and uh and now a book under your belt so what brought you to this this book what
  17. was the what was the reason for doing this well I was fascinated by one of the first individuals that I met in the
  18. hedge fund industry David Einhorn right in 2007 and early 2008 as the financial crisis was starting to pick up I was
  19. fortunate enough to cover David Ein horn during the whole Leman Brothers analysis
  20. that he put out there at the irone conference and the value investing Congress and as I spent more time with
  21. these hedge f managers analyzing them I noticed that there were a a small group of money managers that had profound
  22. impacts on the market if you think about everyone that works on Wall Street that
  23. runs a mutual fund that runs a hedge fund that runs a private Equity shop there're very few people that when they
  24. change a stock position the market moves so I wanted to dig deeper and see who these people really were and what their
  25. analysis was really all about and I think a lot of us have seen you know these these multi-billion dollar trades
  26. that that are big enough to just move markets and so they draw a lot of attention uh when they're made when we
  27. find out about them which is not all the time it's something of a secretive industry they don't tip their hand for
  28. the most part now uh let's not assume that everybody watching today is uh familiar with hedge funds so we just
  29. want to run through a couple of the basics on what in your mind distinguishes a hedge fund from private
  30. Equity Fund a mutual fund from the other kinds of things we're accustomed to what
  31. are the key features of a hedge fund well a hedge fund you should think about a hedge fund like a startup uh
  32. Enterprise company or startup tech tech shop they're usually start out with just
  33. a handful of very successful money managers that spent a lot of time on Wall Street made a lot of money for
  34. their prior employers and are ready to go out on their own they're private investment companies so you have to be a
  35. qualified investor uh according to the SEC to be able to invest with them and they're very
  36. secretive partially because they're minding their own business running their own portfolio but also because the SEC
  37. requires that they not Market to the public because their strategies are typically riskier and you need a minimum
  38. of about $10 million on average to be able to invest with one now we've heard more in the news recently about private
  39. Equity Funds which are basically funds that for the most part buy companies they develop portfolios of companies and
  40. try to make them better hedge funds are more likely to be investing in Securities stocks bonds derivatives that
  41. sort of thing is that correct correct right now in your title you talk about Alpha uh what is Alpha well Alpha can
  42. mean just the mathematical sense just means excess return over the market Benchmark but I wanted to actually take
  43. it a step further and look at these Alpha Personalities in addition to these Alpha Masters in the hedge fund industry
  44. that were moving the market so I looked for people that had a long history of outperforming uh the SNP and and how
  45. they did that so in Layman turns if you had the S&P 500 returning 10% in a in a decent year right Alpha would be some
  46. return on top of that that they require uh to make this worthwhile and it's not every year too that's one thing that I
  47. noticed that it's it's a general Trend but there are some years where they do underperform I have noticed that the
  48. majority of the managers in the book may have had one or two down years or were minorly under the SNP but then came back
  49. in a really big way and sometimes over 63% over the S&P but if you couldn't beat the market on average there'd be no
  50. point in doing it you just buy an S&P 500 fund and forget about it go play golf and then there's a term beta which
  51. we see in here as well uh you mentioned a number of times in the book what is that about beta is just the actual
  52. Market return so you're always trying to deliver Alpha versus beta so there is a
  53. big debate going on in the hedge fund industry now about what is actually Alpha and what is beta some say that a
  54. lot of these hedge fund managers are just delivering beta yet charging exorbitant fees 2 and 20 and uh and and
  55. it's not making sense for investors so that's a part of the discussion right now and that fee structure is 2% of
  56. assets under management and 20% of profits correct okay and so so the idea is to beat the market and do it with a
  57. minimum amount of risk or volatility while you're doing it that's that's the basic idea which sounds very simple
  58. right but it's quite hard to do in actuality it's a bit tougher now one one of your chapur talks about Paulson and
  59. Company and John Paulson is is one of the most well-known Hedge fund managers especially because he managed to make
  60. $15 billion in 2007 when everyone else was losing their shirts and I wonder if you could sort of take us through that
  61. chapter and describe what it was he did as an example of how a hedge fund operates well I would say that there is
  62. no one example of how a hedge fund is supposed to operate it was interesting to go through uh the 11 different
  63. personalities in the book they all had some similarities but were incredibly different I found what I found to be
  64. inspiring about Paulson's story uh at least in the beginning is that he didn't start his hedge fund until he was you
  65. know looking at 40 he got passed up for promotions he was a good merger Arbitrage analyst and was doing fairly
  66. decent but he was running a pretty small fund until around 2006 2007 where he was
  67. able to identify this trade with a handful of employees that worked for him at Paulson and Co and the big winning bet
  68. on on the subprime morgage market how did that work well basically Paulson uh was able to identify and predict the
  69. housing bubble bursting and so he purchased something called credit default swaps which is kind of like
  70. shorting the housing market so prior to these instruments being available there was no way to do that and it was a
  71. highly contrarian bet to make cuz everyone prior to that time mostly believed that real estate was a fairly
  72. safe asset there were a lot of subprime mortgages being sold and Banks were getting in on many of the trades so
  73. there was a lot of collusion on Wall Street no one really understood who was a counterparty and what the risk could
  74. entail if the entire system fell apart so Paulson was able to identify that through his funds research and made very
  75. heavy bets in in credit default swaps and ended up netting $15 billion on the subprime trade he was also one of the
  76. first interestingly enough to start to go long on housing in about two in 2009 way earlier than the rest of the street
  77. so up until about 2011 pulson was doing extremely well things have obviously changed so subprime mortgages like other
  78. mortgages are bundled into Securities that are kind of like bonds correct and the credit default swaps are sort of an
  79. insurance policy that pays off if the security Falls in value and that's what he was betting on and I guess also using
  80. a lot of Leverage borrowing a lot of money so that his wins were Amplified definitely now his genius seems to have
  81. been that uh he spotted something that other people didn't spot that there was a bubble that was going to burst on the
  82. other hand it wasn't a total secret everybody knew that housing prices had been going up faster than wages which
  83. clearly can't happen forever what do you think it was about his approach that allowed him to take that gamble when
  84. other people were all getting a little bit nervous about what was going on with the housing market so there are always
  85. economists that predict Market activity in the economy and there are a lot of analysts on Wall Street that would agree
  86. with what you said I think the main difference was that he was seeing a high inflow of assets and he was able to
  87. convince a couple of other friend on Wall Street and counterparties to help him get the assets to make the trade in
  88. a very big way he was willing to bet the farm as they say on this one trade and very few people very few others had the
  89. assets and the liquidity to be able to do that at that time or had you know were willing to take that risk it takes
  90. a lot of nerve to do it does yeah and one of the things I I I noticed in reading the book is that Paulson for
  91. example he really started hustling very young I think he was selling candy at school at one point and trading in
  92. stocks when he was still a teenager and uh and you get a lot of little stories like that throughout the Book of people
  93. who were just really uh work very hard uh seem to be very smart ahead of the game usually in school U not all always
  94. though I was wondering what what were there were there individuals you interviewed who really surprised you
  95. that just didn't seem like the sort of master of the universe stereotype that we think of right well I think that
  96. that's a very interesting question and I would say that there were a couple of very key examples uh of situations
  97. across the board that surprised me I was interested to know I we've been I've been covering hedge funds for the past
  98. couple of years and we as an industry talk about the latest trades going on with these managers and that's our job
  99. but going back to their history I was I was fascinated to find out that the majority of the these billionaire money
  100. managers all started out with very humble beginnings and if you're looking for a corollary and I myself started out
  101. with very humble beginnings I know that that's a motivator to succeed so it was interesting to see the stories of them
  102. hustling from a very young age the other interesting thing that I noticed is that
  103. they continued hustling it didn't add one at the point where they were all multi-millionaires they didn't stop I
  104. spoke to one had fund manager Bill Amman and I said what motivates you to continue to outperform year and year
  105. again and he said well every year I start again from zero investors look at every year as on a singular level and it
  106. was interesting to know that you can have 10 15 years of good performance but investors don't care even though they
  107. may be committed for two to three years at a time uh the hedge fund industry is looked at month to month and then on a
  108. year-to-year basis so uh a lot of these managers constantly feel the pressure in
  109. their small community to outdo each other and to continue to outdo themselves so it's really the same
  110. process you see with you know great athletes like Roger feder you could ask well why do you do it you're rich you've
  111. won all these titles why bother they're still just very competitive and they love the game right and I don't think
  112. that it's about the money I think that it's a rewarding experience for them I did notice that their personalities are
  113. they're very they're very strong personalities as you would expect and that wasn't so
  114. much of a surprise but they're willing to take big risks even and and bet large portions of the funds Capital to single
  115. trades including again I would mention Bill Amman just getting a 1% stake in Proctor and Gamble it's a $1. billion
  116. position his fund is only about 10 billion so relative to the size of his fund that's a huge position to take on
  117. one bet so these managers all have a very strong conviction in their analysis and I noticed that they were able to
  118. take the emotion out of the investing process which they all cited as highly highly important and key and that
  119. actually helped them to be able to pair back on positions because they all do have at one point made big mistakes I
  120. also noticed that many of the managers had several scenarios where they almost risk losing the fund on a single bet and
  121. they learned from those mistakes earlier in their career or and some had to just
  122. close their fund and start again and they called on that in the recent financial crisis and because of
  123. that most of them were very profitable during that time so they're very intellectually curious as well one of
  124. the things that comes through and in in a lot of the quotes is that that they really just love detecting some new
  125. truth or what they believe may be some new insight that they don't think anyone else has and that seems to drive them
  126. forward right now um when you look at the kind of educations they've got that seem to also
  127. wander sort of over the lot a lot of them do have have a kind of a na mathematical skill it seems like an
  128. analytical skill but there any common denominators in the kind of education that seem to lead to success or be key
  129. or necessary to success in this industry well I would say I would be about 50/50
  130. there were some people that had the education of actually just investing from a very young age taking bets on
  131. themselves people like David terer who went to Carnegie melon and before that to the University of Pittsburgh and he
  132. never really had really good grades in school he was a crd student he would skip class to go hang out with the nuns
  133. across the street even though he was Jewish because they had free pancakes so I would say that about half of them
  134. really excelled at school and folks like Ray Doo as well never really adjusted to
  135. the school environment didn't really Excel until a bit later in life so once they were able to focus in on what they
  136. like to do and you're motivated by something you enjoy you tend to devote a lot of energy and become really good at
  137. that skill I would say folks like David Einhorn uh did he did go to Cornell but he doesn't have an NBA or a CFA and I
  138. personally asked him if that's something that he thinks that U people who want to
  139. emulate him should try to achieve and he said no the best education is actually just being a very diligent investor and
  140. studying your Investments and the companies and balance sheets and financial statements and learning that
  141. way so I wouldn't necessarily say that getting an MBA from Harvard or Wharton guarantees you to be a great investor
  142. but being intellectually curious and working hard and studying constantly always learning that was another thing
  143. that comes through these guys are always learning and looking for the next Insight they're into their 50s and 60s
  144. and they're constantly looking for ways to do their job better even if it means risking having investors pull out of the
  145. fund people like Ray Doo he was at one point over $160 billion and today he's at 120 he's still the
  146. world's largest hedge fund manager but when he was at $160 billion he figured out a way to manage risk better and many
  147. investors didn't want to conform to that way it was his pure Alpha strategy they
  148. didn't want change and he he basically said that's too bad if you want to stay in the fund we're changing how we do
  149. things he went all the way down to 90 billion lost about 70 billion million dollars of investors money but now
  150. has been a model for the industry and outperformed over the last couple years and has has people dying to get back
  151. into the fund uh well I also noticed that uh almost all of your subjects I think except for one We're Men and I I
  152. think the public has this view that this is sort of a men's club a male dominated
  153. industry is that true and is that changing well I would say that there needs to be more women in senior your
  154. roles across the workforce and in Wall Street I would say that we are seeing a lot more you know successful female
  155. investors but I was looking for the top performers right now who had been managing large sums of money for over 10
  156. years and on that scale Sonia Gardner was definitely in that realm and are there other great female investors will
  157. there in the next five years hopefully be women that are alpha Masters I would hope so I would say definitely I do see
  158. more women entering into the hedge fund industry and Wall Street in general uh but I think overall it's still an uphill
  159. battle for women across the workforce to get into senior positions and in terms of strategy and and and investing Styles
  160. I know they vary radically but I wonder if if from your research you see any Trends over the last decade or so that
  161. they're they're emphasizing different types of things than they used to and and is that just due to the
  162. opportunities that are available or is it due to an advance in their thinking well there's two different things that
  163. I'm noticing right now number one would be that I'm seeing a lot of Pension funds and endowments and uh get
  164. interested in the activist investing space H also Sovereign wealth funds but there's less information publicly
  165. available about them because they choose to stay behind the curtain so to speak Pension funds and endowments too but on
  166. the long term we're trying to find Alpha in this market seeing a lot of Institutions institutional investors get
  167. interested in the activist space number two I'm seeing that a lot of managers and at least the I would say the top 10%
  168. are using credit default swaps not just as a way to get higher returns but to manage risk so I would say that I would
  169. predict that it would it should become a more standard practice across the industry I was actually just in class
  170. yesterday with one Professor that cited that uh that observation as well now the
  171. industry certainly has its critics uh all the alternate investment uh field does including the the the the private
  172. Equity Funds and other forms of funds and and one of the crit criticisms is that a lot of this is
  173. not creating anything or making anything they're not starting a new car company and and hiring thousands of people to do
  174. it they have their own employees but a lot of these bets are sort of Zero Sum games a credit default swaps you make
  175. money but somebody else lost it for society as a whole there's not really any change and I'm wondering whether you
  176. have a sense of of whether their role in society is it a positive role or negative as as some critics claim you
  177. know what is the social benefit of having it what if the Hedge fund industry were to disappear overnight is
  178. there any reason why those of us who are not investors or employees would care sure well I think that that's again a
  179. very interesting question and I would say that hedge funds most retail investors aren't really aware but hedge
  180. funds really do a great part to make the markets way more efficient for the basic
  181. reason that they're willing to take risk that many other investors aren't and so
  182. there are very often the counterparties to banks on transaction actions that have become the norm on Wall Street now
  183. one could argue that Wall Street itself is a zero sum game and part of the problem with the financial crisis was
  184. that the banks were behaving like hedge funds when they had a fiduciary responsibility to their depositors and
  185. investors and clients to behave like a bank so um I would say that when people and institutions and organizations do
  186. what the government wants them to do and has said is legal for them to do then they're doing their part to provide
  187. efficiency to the markets now on a second note retail investors actually do benefit from hedge funds even if they're
  188. not directly invested many hedge fund managers or many of the managers profiled in my book I should correct had
  189. a big part in unveiling frauds these short sellers like Jim chos was the one behind uncovering en Enron Worldcom and
  190. Tao now they choose to speak to journal when the time is appropriate and we follow the normal protocols to be able
  191. to bring this fraud these accounting frauds to the market and I know for a fact that they are trying to have a more
  192. active discussion to work with the SEC so that instead of being more reactive we can be more
  193. proactive number two I do think that um activist investors specifically although it's 50/50 in many cases
  194. there's an up side with when an activist makes a big change in a company like JC
  195. Penney as Bill Amman has committed to doing and all the improvements that are expected to come through in the next
  196. year or two makes the shopping experience a better experience the same can be said to Burger King um and also
  197. companies like Target there are some examples of successes and some examples of failures of course but again to draw
  198. uh back to Bill Amman with General growth partners he saw over a 200% return on that investment and I know for
  199. a fact and I had heard at investment conferences that other retail investors got in on that trade right after it got
  200. back into the market and became millionaires just writing out what these hedge fund managers were doing on the
  201. long side I think the public has a hard time understanding processes like short selling and the sort of things that
  202. sound like a betting on disaster but in they're providing Insight that uh is just as useful as the insight for those
  203. who are betting on the upside right So eventually you know some frauds come to light and some don't but many investors
  204. and stockholders lost their entire net worth by being invested in companies like Enron so it's better to bring that
  205. to the market rather than risk the general public losing their life savings so short sellers you always you know
  206. everyone has a motive for everything that they do and short sellers are no different they're investing on the
  207. market on the downside when a CEO comes on uh a business news channel to talk about their company they're trying to
  208. push the stock up and have a vested interest in doing so on the long side every time anyone speaks publicly about
  209. a company there's an interest for why they're doing so unless you're a journalist like us now before we finish
  210. I want you to take out your crystal ball and say what do you think will happen with this industry in the next say 5 or
  211. 10 years is going to grow has it reached a sort of saturation point or will it shrink what do you think well i' would
  212. say it's a it's a Tipping Point for the hedge fund industry right now you're seeing a lot of uh Legends in the Hedge
  213. fun industry retire like leis bacon Stanley dren Miller Carl icon turning into family offices and basically
  214. shuttering their doors for investors and citing difficult market and environment
  215. so I think investing today is definitely much harder than it was 20 years ago you
  216. can't really be the value investor just the sole value investor that you were back then following the buffet
  217. model because you basically need to have a minor or degree in economics and understand how different economies in
  218. the world are infecting are affecting our markets here in us I'd say things are more interconnected than ever before
  219. and that's making a lot of the older legendary hedge fund managers retire and it's also making a lot of the startup
  220. funds close their doors as well people who thought that they can be like a David Tepper or Dan lobe deciding to go
  221. out on their own raising money and after a year or two very preemptively just shutting their doors so I feel like the
  222. industry is getting more and more competitive and I would say it definitely is and it's it breeds more
  223. competition as we're seeing across Wall Street so I wouldn't say that I see the hedge fund industry expanding but I
  224. would say I would probably see it evolving into uh a better oiled machine and lastly uh you're in a sort of unique
  225. position having having gotten exposed to some of these things at a very young age
  226. and we have certainly students at Wharton and we also have at knowledge at Wharton uh some products for high school
  227. students so I'm wondering what advice you'd give somebody who is just intrigued about this business and would
  228. like to get into it what but still has years of education ahead of them what should they be thinking about doing well
  229. I would say one of the most important things to do is to try to get an internship during your summer break or
  230. if you're based in New York try to get a year round position because that will give you hands-on experience even at a
  231. low level the first few days I was at City Group I was filing papers and by proving your commitment there's no no
  232. there's no shortcut to hard work it's a long process to build up a reputation and I think just knowing that there are
  233. certain steps that you need to take to be patient to be hardworking and to be aggressive in a respectful way about
  234. seeking out those positions is highly important I would contact alumni of you know Wharton alumni are very prominent
  235. on Wall Street as are um from other business schools I would try to get a day where could Shadow them in the
  236. office and I would think about connections as um similar to Google+ or other social networks you have your
  237. friends acquaintances professors family professional Associates and look into your network and see who might be
  238. connected to a manager that you would like to try to emulate that you would just like to try to meet another
  239. important suggestion that I would make is to try to attend industry conferences for students many of those conferences
  240. are free um a and you get higher visibility because you're embraced uh within the finance industry coming from
  241. a prominent school like Wharton I know Wharton is planning to have it's so an investment conference in New York City
  242. in the winter and I would definitely suggest that students try to take advantage of that well that's great
  243. advice and uh you have a long career ahead of you we'll be watching it and congratulations about your book it's a
  244. very good read I can recommend it and we'll hope to see you again thank you so [Music]
  245. much

Brief Summary

Manit Ahuja discusses hedge funds, their strategies, and profiles top managers in his book, "The Alpha Masters."

Key points

  • Unlocking the Genius of Hedge Funds. Jeff Brown discusses his book profiling top hedge fund managers and their strategies.
  • The Risky Business of Hedge Funds. Exploring the tension between risk and reward in hedge fund management.
  • The Relentless Hustle of Hedge Fund Managers. Despite their success, top hedge fund managers continue to strive for excellence.
  • The Role of Hedge Funds. Hedge funds play a crucial role in market efficiency by taking risks others won't.
  • Advice for Aspiring Investors. Internships and networking are key for students interested in finance careers.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes