Barry Schwartz's 'Practical Wisdom'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Swarthmore professor Barry Schwartz says rules and incentives are an "insurance policy against disaster, but [they don't] produce excellence." In his recent book, Practical Wisdom: The Right Way to Do the Right Thing, Schwartz and coauthor Kenneth Sharpe, also a Swarthmore professor, say that what is needed is not more bureaucracy. Instead, society needs the Aristotelian ideal that trumps all others -- practical wisdom. Knowledge@Wharton recently sat down with Schwartz to discuss why individuals fail to do the right thing, what practical wisdom looks like in practice and what organizations can do to regain people's trust. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Barry thank you very much for speaking with knowledge of Wharton today my
  2. pleasure you study the link between economics and psychology and have more recently been focusing on wisdom with
  3. Ken sharp uh your co-author on practical wisdom the issues you are writing about
  4. have really resonated your TED Talks have been watched for by U nearly 5 million people astonishing isn't it it
  5. it's amazing it's amazing you know that there's a collective sense of dissatisfaction with and mistrust of the
  6. institutions and people that surround us why is that and how are we responding so I don't want to be sort of
  7. monomaniacal about this I think that there are probably many reasons not one for this distrust of Institutions but
  8. the one that Ken and I focused on in writing this book uh about wisdom is that we have we have we have come to the
  9. view as a society that when things are broken the way to fix them is either by making more
  10. rules um or by creating smart incentives so that people will do the right thing because it's in their own self-interest
  11. to do the right thing and if you make a lot of rules and you got somebody standing over people's heads watching
  12. them to make sure that they actually obey the rules then it doesn't you don't care what people's motivation is you
  13. have to follow the rules or you or you're out so anytime something is broken schools don't work rigid
  14. curriculum scripts for teachers to follow and then bonuses if your kids do well and stuff like that in in in domain
  15. after domain if the financial system is broken change the incentive structure so
  16. that Bankers stop uh ripping off their clients uh and the point of our book is that you will never get what you need
  17. and want out of any institution That Matters by relying on rules and incentives rules and incentives are the
  18. booby prize uh if you can't count on anything else then you impose rules and incentives but you'll never get what you
  19. want you'll just it's a kind of insurance policy against disaster but it doesn't produce Excellence you need
  20. people of good character who want to do the right thing because it's the right thing who know H who know how to figure
  21. out what the right thing is in this particular situation with this particular person and are willing to
  22. improvise uh take the initiative risk being wrong and all in the service of actually serving the emission of
  23. whatever activity they're in teachers who want their kids to learn and be excited about learning doctors who want
  24. their patients to be healthy lawyers who want their clients interests to be well
  25. served and so on and don't need to be goated either by rules or by incentives into achieving that so we think that
  26. what we are doing as a society instead is um a very very pale substitute for what's needed but you never hear you
  27. don't hear anyone talking about the importance of character to the making of good teachers good doctors good bankers
  28. and uh pretty much good good uh politicians or or pretty much anything else that's right and you say that
  29. practical wisdom is uh is a better path can you tell us uh the source of that idea and and what you mean by that well
  30. the source of the idea embarrassingly enough is Aristotle Aristotle uh who was famous uh for being
  31. what's called a virtue theorist that is the way you create good societies is by creating good people and the way you
  32. create good people is by instilling in them the virtues and he had his own list of what the virtues are and our list
  33. would be different from his but the point is he thought that good societies depend on people of good character and
  34. good character is something that can be trained so he had a big list of Virtues but he thought there was one particular
  35. virtue that was the master and that one he called practical wisdom and the reason was courage is a virtue but you
  36. can be too courageous and then we don't call it Courage anymore we call it recklessness so what's the right amount
  37. of Courage that requires wisdom honesty is a virtue but so is kindness often you
  38. find yourself having to decide whether this is a situation that calls for honesty or one that calls for kindness
  39. what enables you to figure that out wisdom is what enables you to figure that out and so for him uh one one the
  40. way one scholar put it is that these virtues are running running around like unruly school children and wisdom is
  41. what creates order out of this chaos uh and actually helps people to find what he called the mean the right amount
  42. appropriate for this person and this situation so all we did in the book was try to take Aristotle's ideas and
  43. translate them into a language that makes sense in the 21st century and apply them to the kinds of Institutions
  44. and problems that we face in modern developed societies as opposed to ancient Athens and the thing that you do so well
  45. is you really describe um people who are are living that and um uh illustrating that through their lives and the person
  46. who I think a lot about is Luke um the janitor and St I would love to hear you talk a little bit about that and really
  47. what the takeaways are I I can't tell you how surprised I was um by the by the choice that he made in that moment and
  48. it startled me that I was surprised by it so so this is this is work that was actually done by a um a psychologist
  49. named Amy rusi who is visiting Wharton this very year but she's on the faculty at at uh at Yale and was an
  50. undergraduate here at Penn and she started doing this work as an undergraduate at Penn she was interested
  51. in how people craft their jobs and especially people who do what is called Dirty Work the the people who are
  52. invisible the people we don't notice so she did a big study of Hospital janitors
  53. Hospital custodians at a major academic teaching in academic hospital and you know for for a lot of them there was a
  54. long list of job duties I don't know 30 different things that you had to do as a
  55. janitor but when she started interviewing janitors she found there were some who thought their job was just
  56. doing these 30 things emptying trash restocking shelves washing floors and so on but there was a non-trivial number
  57. who thought their job was doing whatever was necessary to provide Aid and comfort
  58. to the professional staff to the patients and to the patients families so the example of Luke involved a a young
  59. man who was in a coma apparently the result of a fight in which he got the tar beaten out of him uh and this Luke
  60. this young boy's father was keeping a vigil all day every day except that he would go out and smoke a cigarette now
  61. and then so Luke cleaned the kids's room and uh washed the floor but the dad was
  62. out smoking and didn't see it and so when the dad came up he said he he angrily accused Luke of not cleaning the
  63. boy's room you know the boy's in a coma how the boy wouldn't know so he was taking advantage and it should also be
  64. said that Luke is African-American the boy had gotten beaten beaten up by African-Americans and so you could
  65. imagine a certain antagonism on the part of the dad toward a black person who was
  66. responsible for his sons getting beaten up so Luke was angry but he immediately suppressed the anger and he said oh okay
  67. I'll take care of it and he went and he cleaned the room again he cleaned it so that the boy's father could see him
  68. clean it and he said in interview that he understood that you know he should have been angry he could have been angry
  69. but he finally decided you know I I can understand what this man is going through why not do something so he can
  70. see that he's actually having an effect uh on that contributes to the welfare of
  71. his son so he clean the room again and it it's really a it's an incredibly touching story because one doesn't
  72. expect that kind of judgment and Humanity from people who are basically invisible these are the people nobody
  73. notices without whom the institutions wouldn't function uh and the reason Luke was able to do that and he has you know
  74. uh colleagues who behave similarly is that they weren't being so closely supervised so they could do their job
  75. the 30 things on on their list and still have time to do what they thought was their real job which was to provide
  76. comfort and care to patients and their families imagine the hospital um having financial difficulties and having to
  77. crack down and you know layoff staff so now they're you know onethird fewer janitors than there used to be well all
  78. of a sudden you have more responsibilities and you have to be working faster and harder and you don't
  79. have time you got somebody breathing down your neck and you don't half time to do what you think is your real job
  80. because there are just too many rooms to get clean and too many trash cans to uh
  81. empty so Luke was blessed to be working in a time and in an environment in which
  82. his supervisors left him alone so he could do both the job that was officially defined as his job and the
  83. job as he had crafted it and get enormous satisfaction out of it and when you asked him and people like him how
  84. how how hard is it to learn to do this job they would say it takes a lot of experience to do this job it doesn't
  85. take a lot of experience to wash floors and empty trash cans it takes a lot of experience to know how to intervene with
  86. patients and their families in a way that actually is comforting and helpful you know you don't want to be a Loose
  87. Cannon and initially you probably are your well-intentioned um efforts to make people feel better don't work but over
  88. time you learn when to intervene how to intervene and how what small things you can do that make a big differen there
  89. another nurse I think we mentioned her in the book who uh there was somebody who' had been in the hospital for months
  90. and months and months and she not did I say nurse janitor who just took it upon herself to change the pictures on the
  91. wall in this patient's room who notices what pictures are on the wall in the hospital room but she figured that maybe
  92. it would be it would it would Inspire this person to get a sense that there was actually progress being made that
  93. things were changing if the environment wasn't exactly the same hour after hour and day after day so I don't know every
  94. couple of weeks she take pictures from another room and put them in this room uh this is not obviously part of her job
  95. description so it's I think people really do come up short when they hear this because they don't they don't
  96. expect it they deeply admire it when they hear about it and they what I hope is they ask themselves well how can I do
  97. something like that in my work right I don't know if they do ask themselves that question but it would be nice if
  98. they did there um that's you know one very interesting or a couple very interesting
  99. examples of one way of sort of um acting um in an ethical way um using the wisdom
  100. that you talk about um on a a very uh personal level you know um but what about the cases where the stakes are
  101. much higher such as in the case of those that surrounded pen State's um jury sanduski many people have uh been
  102. charged with keeping his crimes a secret you know what can businesses do to help
  103. their employees do the right thing in cases like that well I think that's a huge challenge I I I'm much better at
  104. saying what won't do the job than I am saying what will start there what won't do the job is giving lectures to people
  105. about about business ethics or organizational ethics there's no sure way to marginalize ethics than to have a
  106. separate course in it because what people learn is that ethics is something that you learn in a separate course and
  107. U write exam answers to and you try as hard as you can to make sure that it is completely insulated from your actual
  108. day-to-day activities on the job so I think that you need to exemplify the behavior that you want the
  109. people working uh with you and under you to display you need to be a model of what it means to be an ethical
  110. organization and uh you need to be doing it all day every day uh and there are very very few organizations that I'm
  111. aware of that that behave like that there is a um Charter School movement that's become National called Kip
  112. knowledge is power they've had incredible uh uh results with inner city kids um there are a couple of Kip
  113. schools actually in Philadelphia and what and what the the founders of Kip realized though they didn't quite say it
  114. in that way at the time is that the most important thing that kids need to learn
  115. is character if you can teach them character respect for knowledge respect for the educational process respect for
  116. the teacher respect for one another if you can teach them that then teaching them how to add and subtract is Trivial
  117. and if you can't teach them that then teaching them how to add and subtract is impossible so then the question is how
  118. do you teach them that and the answer is you teach them that by showing it to them every minute of every day so that's
  119. what Kip teachers do they are on stage all they are always teaching and they know that they're always teaching it's
  120. incredibly demanding on them and I think it's the secret sauce that produces these extraordinary results that's what
  121. people who run organizations need to do right so it's it's not um the the rule or the policy or the incentive to act in
  122. a certain way it's really over time starting to Foster certain ideals and behaviors um by um through the act of
  123. mentors or teachers or even um uh ways of doing things within an organization is yes you need the power of good
  124. examples you need to show people that you really do value ethical conduct uh rather than just talking the talk and uh
  125. and and then ignoring unethical Behavior I think the reason one reason why the why the bank catastrophe has happened is
  126. that you know you have these CEOs of major Banks who have become public figures and they go off and give
  127. speeches about the bank's ethical commitments and commitments to rebuilding the city and the neighborhood
  128. and this that and the other thing and they know that two levels down in the hierarchy there is a manager whose job
  129. depends on the people he supervises making their margins they don't have to know how that
  130. manager gets that to happen all they need to know is that the manager does get it to happen and if he doesn't out
  131. he goes so there's this it's not just plausible deniability it's just like complete indifference to what it takes
  132. to produce the results that you're insisting that the people who work for you produce and meanwhile you're giving
  133. this these completely sincere speeches about what an ethical uh uh community-minded company you are uh and
  134. that that are in practice um uh betray basically every minute of every day by the people who work under you um so as
  135. long as that kind of dynamic exists you can forget about ethical um uh speeches from corporate leaders because it will
  136. never actually have an impact on the way the people who are making the day-to-day
  137. decisions in the company operate and I guess there's a question here about how institutions can regain our trust um you
  138. know to Circle back back to the sort of the first part of what we were discussing is that possible it's not
  139. easy I think we you know you have to you have to do it again there's the power of the good example you do it by
  140. doing the right thing in in conspicuous ways uh and slowly bit by bit Episode by episode you re you win
  141. back the trust of the community that depends on you um you can't there's nothing you can tell people that will or
  142. should earn uh their trust you have to demonstrate it in the way you behave which means you have to be in it for the
  143. long Hall and be patient uh uh and we you sort of win one victory at a time um and with respect to some institutions it
  144. I'm you know I can't it's hard to be optimistic I don't see how uh um what what uh public educational institutions
  145. can do to regain the trust of the families who are have not been well served by them um I don't know what
  146. financial institutions can do to regain the trust of people who have not been well served by them as far as I'm
  147. concerned the ra the uh the ratings agencies should all be you know everybody in the ratings agency should
  148. simply be thrown in jail and the keys to the jail thrown away they they so betrayed the public Trust
  149. and they're giving AAA ratings to every piece of crap Under the Sun uh it'll take a generation if people are paying
  150. attention it will take a generation to regain the trust that got lost in the space of you know six months and the
  151. adoption of a lot more practical wisdom thank you very much for talking with knowledge at Wharton today thank you
  152. nice talking to you [Music]

Brief Summary

Barry Schwartz discusses practical wisdom, character, and rebuilding trust in institutions with examples from real-life situations.

Key points

  • The Role of Practical Wisdom. Practical wisdom is essential for creating good societies and individuals.
  • Luke the Janitor's Compassion. A touching story of a janitor who chose kindness over anger in a difficult situation.
  • Trust in Institutions. Regaining trust requires consistent ethical behavior over time.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

More from Knowledge at Wharton