Why Employees Will Take a 15% Pay Cut to Work for These Companies

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Would you take a 15% pay cut to work for a company that shares your values? Research suggests many employees would.

J. Daniel Kim, Assistant Professor of Management at the Wharton School, explains how social responsibility influences hiring decisions and why mission oriented startups can attract talent while spending less on compensation. He also explores why that advantage doesn't necessarily lead to better employee retention or job satisfaction.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Companies who are viewed as having a higher level of social responsibility seem to receive more
  2. interest from potential employees when you're talking about a potential hire. But what are the reasons behind that?
  3. And what does that mean for the hiring process overall? Daniel Kim is an assistant professor of management
  4. here at the Wharton School, who is also the Walpole Family Faculty Scholar. He was part of research looking into this
  5. dynamic, and he joins us right now. Daniel, great to catch up with you. It's been a while.
  6. Great to have you back with us. Thank you for having me on. This is interesting.
  7. What was it that drew your attention to looking at these dynamics of how social responsibility
  8. and hiring play a role on one another? Sure. Well, Dan, my research has all been about
  9. scaling entrepreneurial companies, how they grow, and the pitfalls of failure for these companies.
  10. And one thing that just keeps coming back time and time again is this idea that founders really struggle when it comes to getting
  11. their first few hires. So recruitment is a key challenge. And at the same time, what I was
  12. hearing on the ground were people talking about how social mission of a company was a
  13. big motivation of why they joined the company in the first place. And that mission could be our natural environment
  14. and improving it. It can be serving an under-resourced community. But for me, I wanted to see whether
  15. these are, you know, maybe cherry-picked selected examples versus something that really generalizes to a
  16. lot of employers that startups can actually use as a leverage in their recruitment.
  17. That's what really gets me. I'm sorry. It's certainly a topic, I think, that's on
  18. the forefront of obviously a lot of people's minds, but seemingly more and more companies' minds
  19. in recent years. Um, but is it when you're talking about the people that seemingly are more interested, does
  20. it tend to trend towards younger generations who are seemingly looking for this connection through social
  21. responsibility? Sure. I mean, I'll caveat this by saying that my data is really going to be about
  22. the younger community in the sense that these are recent college graduates joining startups, which generally
  23. tend to hire younger people. But I'll also just give you my anecdotal perspective that over time, especially my students, right,
  24. I can see generations of these MBA students. There is a greater identification with the social
  25. mission that people really want to bring their full self to work and, and, you know,
  26. not burning out at work. One of the key motivations is going to be, do you love what you do and
  27. feel that it's rewarding? So I would say it's something that growing in general with our younger.
  28. But obviously, whenever you talk about a hiring process, the salary usually comes into the mix
  29. one way or another. So, so does the level of social responsibility impact what a person will consider to be
  30. a fair salary when they're going to potentially work for a company? Really good questions.
  31. The upshot here is that people are going to be in our data, willing to take a pay cut to join these social mission
  32. oriented companies. And this is really important to caveat here, because if we talk about how people in
  33. general that work for these traditional for-profit companies, you know, earn more, and then, you
  34. know, mission oriented companies, employees earn less, you know, that could be a false comparison here.
  35. The really nice thing was that we had people that had multiple job offers. They had offers both to the for-profit
  36. traditional startups and, you know, mission oriented startups, and they're doing making a trade-off and
  37. a choice, and often as high as 15 % lower compensation to join, right, that mission
  38. oriented startup. So in a way, these companies are saving a lot of money by having people that
  39. are that motivated to even take a pay cut. A lot of times companies and even maybe
  40. the potential employees want to have a good match, you know, in air quotes. Is this kind of another layer of that
  41. component of good match right now, the component of social responsibility? Yeah, great question.
  42. What we saw, Dan, to be really honest with you, is that it really did help getting people into the company.
  43. That recruitment early on, that was a premium. However, when we look at the later stage
  44. outcomes after you take the job, like do you stay longer? Are you more satisfied with your job?
  45. Actually, those outcomes tend to be very similar to those that are taking non-mission oriented
  46. companies. So all that to say, I think what's happening here is that when you're joining a
  47. company, especially startups, there's so much you don't know. You have no idea whether this employer is
  48. going to be a good employer, whether they take care of you. So there is this element of you identifying
  49. with the social mission. Yes, that helps here. But I think what's also in play here
  50. is that social mission in and of itself is becoming a signal of what these employers
  51. represent, how they might treat not only their customers and the stakeholders, but also their employees.
  52. So I think employees are trying to get all the cues of information in the recruitment
  53. stage. But later on, when this information asymmetry is what we call it, when that gets reduced,
  54. because if you work for the employer, you have a direct inference of what that employer
  55. is like. You don't need signals. And this is why I think social mission doesn't seem to matter as much in explaining
  56. the later stage outcomes on turnover and job satisfaction. But if you have that match, though, between
  57. what the company thinks around social responsibility and what the individual thinks about social responsibility, is
  58. there an expectation of the company that because of that match, you're probably going to have
  59. better outcomes, you may get better productivity from that person, and it's going to help the
  60. company develop as you move along? Oh, 100 percent. I mean, that 15 percent saving off the
  61. bat, I think, is a great message for these companies. I mean, that's where we can really provide
  62. you the most compelling evidence that there is a big saving on the labor cost, which
  63. for these companies, by the way, when they're raising venture capital, their initial round of financing,
  64. most of that money goes to wages and people's compensation. So being able to save, you know, 5,
  65. 10, 15 percent and getting great people to join you, that's a real win. Right. So I would say that in itself is
  66. probably the biggest leverage. Your research also looks at attrition. What did you find out in that area?
  67. So there, I just want to caveat here also that in the world of startups, turnover
  68. is a really big problem. This is, I think, one of those facts that we're not talking about enough, which is
  69. that if you look at sort of drift a little bit here, Dan, but if you look at all U.S. VC finance startups,
  70. the average turnover, which is how many people are leaving in a given year, is about
  71. 20 percent. So one in five. Right. And we're not even looking at failures. I mean, we're not looking at those mechanical
  72. 100 percent outcomes when they're alive and doing well. Even then, one out of five people are
  73. leaving. That is much higher than the national average of roughly 45 percent because you have turnover
  74. because people want to take better jobs. There's a mismatch that happens. But in the world of startups, there's a
  75. lot more attrition. So attrition here, really important. But what we found actually, to our surprise,
  76. is that we don't find a big difference between those that are taking mission oriented startups
  77. versus that are joining traditional for-profit startups in terms of their turnover rates.
  78. So they seem to be similar. So we don't really find that advantage playing out. What do you think then is the main
  79. takeaway from doing this research? The main takeaway here is that for startups, that mission orientation is a real benefit when
  80. it comes to the human capital, which is the talent side of the company's prospects here.
  81. So I would say for employers, you have to really lean into this. Obviously, you can't fake this in the sense
  82. that if you say that you have a social mission and it turns out you really don't, it was more like just cheap talk.
  83. Of course, when those employees come in, they will actually then react pretty negatively.
  84. But to the extent that it is a genuine, authentic orientation you have, really lean into
  85. that. And that will draw the people, which then becomes a huge resource for these companies.
  86. So I would say employers play into that. And employees, I would also say, really look
  87. into your internal compass here. What really gives you motivation? What do you align with?
  88. And that is going to reduce burnout and hopefully find what you said, Dan, a better
  89. match. Dan, great to catch up with you. Thanks for your time and great insight on
  90. this. All the best. Thank you. Daniel Kim, who's an assistant professor of management
  91. here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Mission-oriented startups can attract employees willing to accept up to 15% less pay, but the research found no clear retention or job-satisfaction advantage.

Key points

  • A mission can attract talent for less. Candidates with multiple job offers sometimes accept up to 15% lower compensation to join a mission-oriented startup. That can be a meaningful labor-cost saving for companies.
  • The hiring boost doesn’t guarantee retention. Social mission can help bring people into a company, but the research finds similar job satisfaction and turnover outcomes after they join.
  • Startup turnover is a major challenge. Kim says turnover at U.S. venture-capital-financed startups averages about 20% a year—roughly one in five employees—even among companies that are operating.
  • A social mission has to be authentic. Mission can help startups attract talent, but claiming values the company doesn’t genuinely hold can backfire when employees discover the mismatch.

Tension

15/ 100Calm

Related episodes