Apple's Beats Buy...Desperation or Opportunity?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
📂 Technology
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- We're here today with Wharton Marketing Professor Peter Federer to talk a little
- bit about Apple's recent acquisition of Beats. The acquisition came with the purchase of the Beat streaming music
- service, hardware, and talent. Pete, thanks for being with us today. Glad to talk to you. So, our first question is
- is what do you think was Apple's strategy behind this acquisition? It's very interesting. It's a very unusual
- move for Apple to to go out there and work with a a different firm and something that's going to require them
- to to open up and actually accept other people's standards and lose some of the control that they insist upon. Uh more
- than anything, I think it's an acknowledgement that that iTunes just hasn't worked for them. I think the the
- original business model uh that is uh focusing on the those 99 cent downloads was was really an utter failure for for
- the music industry as a whole. They finally waved the white flag. They're moving to the to the streaming
- subscription space, something they said they would never ever do before. Uh and and even their own efforts to do that
- with iTunes radio uh uh weren't working very well. So, not clear that this is going to be any better, but it is a sign
- that they acknowledge some of their failings in this space. And what does this say? I mean, does this represent a
- change in Apple's innovation strategy, i.e. that they're now going to be innovating through acquisition as
- opposed to innovating internally. And what does that mean for the company? It's a huge change in this regard. In
- fact, if we changed the cast of characters a little bit, suppose we said that Microsoft was buying Beats instead,
- everyone would laugh at it. Everyone would say, "Uhoh, here comes another Zoom." They, you know, they're they're
- buying a company because they can't invent things on their own. It's a company that has a very small base when
- it comes to the subscription side. Uh, so you know they they they they'd call it desperation on the part of Microsoft
- and and would kind of declare it dead before it ever got off the ground. So I think a a lot of it we have to take into
- account who's doing the acquiring more than what's being acquired over here. Uh, and because Apple's doing it and
- because it is such an unusual move for them, there's a lot of people who are willing to give them a lot more slack
- than they might if it were a Microsoft or another company on the other side of it.
- Now, Apple is also has its worldwide development conference this developer conference this week. What's at stake
- for them there? I mean, what do they have to do either with their other technology that exists or around the
- Beats acquisition for people to kind of maybe continue to feel optimistic about the company and about this particular
- acquisition? Of course, it's always hard to say. We never know exactly what's going to come out of one of their
- developer conferences. I think that that the news about Beats and the the new iOS, all that stuff is is is nice and
- interesting and and it'll give people something to talk about, but but but all eyes are on the potential iPhone
- announcement. And if they come up with with the big screen, uh that could be a gamecher at least for Apple because we
- know that it's been a gamecher for everyone else. And once again, uh Apple, they they wouldn't admit it to the
- outside, but internally they're probably saying, "Man, we should have come up with those big screens a long time ago."
- One of the reasons why Samsung has caught up and in many ways surpassed them is simply because of the size of
- the screen, forgetting about anything else. Now, if you can take that larger screen and combine it with some of the
- other still unique aspects of the the Apple phone experience, you might have a great device which will make these other
- stories really uh moot, but no one will be paying attention to them uh if they do make an announcement like that. Now,
- be that as it may, how important is it that the Beats acquisition includes their streaming music service? I think
- that's why they made the acquisition. The the the Beats product is is a very nice one. Uh there's no no question
- about it. But but they're they they bought Beats because iTunes Radio wasn't working. No one's downloading music
- anymore. Uh there's just an Beats is is is big enough that it's it's a real brand name. It has some cache. Uh, but
- it's small enough uh that that Apple can supposedly mold it into something that would be more of an an Apple branded
- service than than just Apple being tacked on to an existing brand. But the problem is it's so small they're going
- to have a real hard time competing with Pandora and Spotify and and and some of the other uh bigger players out there.
- It's not clear whether they can take this small service and turn it into a giant one. whether the Apple name is
- enough to do that when the Apple name wasn't enough to make iTunes work. Now, you have been saying for a long time, I
- mean, I think as far back as from our stories from 2002, that streaming was where the industry was eventually going
- to end up. Do you feel like this acquisition is a sign that maybe Apple has realized that the iTunes download
- model was really a transitional technology? In that regard, this is the most wonderful I told you so story that
- I've heard in a long time. I've been calling for this for for truly over a decade. And even went as far as saying
- that that one day when Apple announces that it's getting into a streaming subscription model in a big way. Not
- only will they do well with it, but it's it's it's going to be a rising tide that's going to lift all boats. It's
- going to legitimize streaming in a way that it's it it hasn't been fully legitimized. A lot of people are waiting
- for Apple to give this kind of big blessing. Now again, Apple has made some steps in that direction with iTunes
- Radio, but no one really paid any attention to that. By by doing it with with a brand, by having a more
- established service, I think that's actually going to help Spotify, Pandora, everybody else out there. And it might
- end up actually helping those other services more than it actually helps Apple itself. Why Why do you feel that
- way? Because a lot of people who have been having waiting and seeing, you know, I'm not quite sure I want to jump
- onto Spotify because after all, I I own an iPhone and I want to do whatever the the iPhone offers for me. Fact is that
- that uh that that most iPhone people or more iPhone people are using Pandora or or Spotify than they're using iTunes
- radio. But there's still a lot of folks who are holding out hope that Apple would would have a kind of a worldclass
- uh entry into the streaming music world. uh Beats might be that one. But again, it it's it's it now gives a green light
- to these other ones. And it's also going to encourage the industry to be a little
- bit more accepting, a little bit more progressive. I don't want to say that they've stood in the way of sp of
- Spotify and Pandora, but they haven't made life easy for those other services. I think th this acknowledgment that the
- that the download model is is over and that it's all about streaming, I think it it's going to force the industry as a
- whole to embrace streaming in in in a bigger, more aggressive, proactive way than they ever did before. So, it's
- going to help everybody in the industry, but especially consumers. Consumers are
- just much better off using these services. I don't even care which one. We can nitpick about any of these big
- ones. They're all good. Uh, and they're all a much better consumer experience than than Allakart downloading. Now, so
- Apple had kind of a hoham product in iTunes Radio, at least from consumer response, and now they've acquired
- Beats, so they're going to get whoever those subscribers to Beats or people that were using it. What do you think
- Apple needs to do to kind of take these two services and really stand out in this market because they're entering a
- market that has a lot of established players in Pandora, Spotify, Artio? It's a very good question and a very
- difficult question because usually when whenever Apple announces something, it just turns to gold. There's just enough
- enough people out there whether it's because of of true love for different Apple products and services or maybe out
- of inertia. I I I don't even want to think about it. I'm just going to go with the one that Apple endorses. That's
- usually the way it works. But it didn't work with iTunes radio. Uh, and it's not
- clear that that that just moving to a different horse that they're they're putting, you know, the Apple name on on
- on beats instead or in addition is is going to lead to a dramatic difference, but it does signal that Apple is going
- to be investing a whole lot more in this space than they were before. It could be
- that some of the the disappointments with iTunes Radio wasn't so much the service itself, but that Apple it really
- wasn't a major focus for them. So, maybe this is a sign that they're going to get
- real serious about it. and whether it's it's the the Beats platform itself or just uh Apple's in increased seriousness
- uh that might help them and they're going to have to advertise heavily uh and they're going to have to do all
- kinds of things that that doesn't come naturally for Apple. We'll see how well they do, but it is going to be a much
- tougher challenge for them than other areas where they've been successful to date. Now, is that because they're kind
- of having to instead of being kind of the market creator or the market buster, they're going to kind of have to see
- what everyone else has done and really want to do and really sort of follow on someone's coattails when they haven't
- done that before or that's a big part of it that it's it's a rapidly commoditizing business. Uh, and uh it's
- not clear that they can go in and and and truly shake it up in a disruptive way that they're able to do with the
- iPad and the iPhone. This is just not not something they've been uh very good at. uh that that is to say a service of
- this sort. Uh but Apple's a smart company and they're very resourceful company and if they really do set their
- mind to it, then they're they're they need to be taken seriously. But it's not clear that they're going to be able to
- jump right to the top and and and get people to actually give up on their uh Pandora or Spotify or or unauthorized
- services that they might be using and jumping over to this one here. It is possible, but uh put it this way, I
- wouldn't bet on it. Now, what about the hardware and talent sides of the Beats acquisition? How can Apple deploy those
- effectively? Well, again, be the Beats headphones are a fine product and and in many ways, it's it's a very good fit
- with Apple. It is just a best-in-class. Price is no issue. If if if you want the
- best, this is going to be the thing that you buy. So, so there's there's a good fit in that regard. And just even some
- of the uh some of the design elements are are aligned well with Apple. So I think that they can make beats fit the
- that is again the hardware side fit quite well under their umbrella. It's still unusual for them to to work with
- outsiders but this is about as good an outsider as they can find when it comes to the hardware but how much interplay
- there is between the hardware and the software and and a lot of speculation about how much of the reasons for the
- acquisition is the hardware versus the software that remains to be seen. Now what about the talent side of this? I
- mean do you expect to see them using I guess Dr. Dre or Jimmy Iiovine in a particular way or are they mostly kind
- of figureheads for this to lend sort of street cred to Apple or I think that's that's right. I think that that that
- it's more to show that that that we're cool and that we're endorsed by folks who are respected within the music
- industry, but I don't think that that that those particular folks are going to be game changers in any way. They're
- respected. There's no question about it. But I I don't think that people that consumers are going to say now there's a
- reason to be switching to to the Beats service instead of other services because let let's face it those guys and
- the the whole Beats team have been associated with them all along and that wasn't enough to get them even within an
- order of magnitude of Spotify or Pandora. So it's not clear that attaching those names to Apple is going
- to really change anything. Now, final question. I guess what do you see this acquisition? How do you see that fitting
- into kind of Tim Cook's performance as Apple CEO overall? I mean, what does this say about kind of the direction
- that his leadership is going in? And what do you think are going to be the challenges for him as this goes forward?
- Well, it's an interesting historic moment because on one hand, you could say this is an admission of defeat and
- that Apple can't innovate on its own and can't develop best-in-class products and
- services. On the other hand, you might say the reason why they haven't gone to the outside is a bit of arrogance that
- they've always just felt that they could do it better. But you know what? There are times when it makes sense to partner
- and to acquire. So, so the fact that they're they're open to doing it, does that represent desperation? Does that
- represent opportunity? I'm not really sure. But we're going to look back at it for sure within the next few years and
- and and say, "Oh, it's real clear that it was one or the other." So, it is a pivotal moment. Uh, and I think there's
- a lot writing on it and it might be a precedent that then gets followed in in other unimaginable ways. Uh, but it's
- it's a big step forward for Apple. Right. Pete, thanks so much for being with us today. Always a pleasure.
- [Music]
Brief Summary
Peter Federer discusses Apple's Beats acquisition and its implications for streaming and innovation strategy.
Key points
- Apple's Unusual Move. Apple's acquisition of Beats marks a significant shift in their strategy towards streaming services.
- Streaming vs. Downloads. The discussion highlights the failure of iTunes and the rise of streaming as the future.
- Tim Cook's Leadership Challenge. The acquisition raises questions about Tim Cook's ability to innovate and lead Apple forward.
Episode highlights
- Apple's Unusual MoveApple's acquisition of Beats marks a significant shift in their strategy towards streaming services.“It's a huge change in this regard.”1:22Jun 9, 2014
- Streaming vs. DownloadsThe discussion highlights the failure of iTunes and the rise of streaming as the future.“The download model is over; it's all about streaming.”6:21Jun 9, 2014
- Tim Cook's Leadership ChallengeThe acquisition raises questions about Tim Cook's ability to innovate and lead Apple forward.“This is an admission of defeat or an opportunity?”11:26Jun 9, 2014
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





