Apple's Beats Buy...Desperation or Opportunity?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Technology

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. We're here today with Wharton Marketing Professor Peter Federer to talk a little
  2. bit about Apple's recent acquisition of Beats. The acquisition came with the purchase of the Beat streaming music
  3. service, hardware, and talent. Pete, thanks for being with us today. Glad to talk to you. So, our first question is
  4. is what do you think was Apple's strategy behind this acquisition? It's very interesting. It's a very unusual
  5. move for Apple to to go out there and work with a a different firm and something that's going to require them
  6. to to open up and actually accept other people's standards and lose some of the control that they insist upon. Uh more
  7. than anything, I think it's an acknowledgement that that iTunes just hasn't worked for them. I think the the
  8. original business model uh that is uh focusing on the those 99 cent downloads was was really an utter failure for for
  9. the music industry as a whole. They finally waved the white flag. They're moving to the to the streaming
  10. subscription space, something they said they would never ever do before. Uh and and even their own efforts to do that
  11. with iTunes radio uh uh weren't working very well. So, not clear that this is going to be any better, but it is a sign
  12. that they acknowledge some of their failings in this space. And what does this say? I mean, does this represent a
  13. change in Apple's innovation strategy, i.e. that they're now going to be innovating through acquisition as
  14. opposed to innovating internally. And what does that mean for the company? It's a huge change in this regard. In
  15. fact, if we changed the cast of characters a little bit, suppose we said that Microsoft was buying Beats instead,
  16. everyone would laugh at it. Everyone would say, "Uhoh, here comes another Zoom." They, you know, they're they're
  17. buying a company because they can't invent things on their own. It's a company that has a very small base when
  18. it comes to the subscription side. Uh, so you know they they they they'd call it desperation on the part of Microsoft
  19. and and would kind of declare it dead before it ever got off the ground. So I think a a lot of it we have to take into
  20. account who's doing the acquiring more than what's being acquired over here. Uh, and because Apple's doing it and
  21. because it is such an unusual move for them, there's a lot of people who are willing to give them a lot more slack
  22. than they might if it were a Microsoft or another company on the other side of it.
  23. Now, Apple is also has its worldwide development conference this developer conference this week. What's at stake
  24. for them there? I mean, what do they have to do either with their other technology that exists or around the
  25. Beats acquisition for people to kind of maybe continue to feel optimistic about the company and about this particular
  26. acquisition? Of course, it's always hard to say. We never know exactly what's going to come out of one of their
  27. developer conferences. I think that that the news about Beats and the the new iOS, all that stuff is is is nice and
  28. interesting and and it'll give people something to talk about, but but but all eyes are on the potential iPhone
  29. announcement. And if they come up with with the big screen, uh that could be a gamecher at least for Apple because we
  30. know that it's been a gamecher for everyone else. And once again, uh Apple, they they wouldn't admit it to the
  31. outside, but internally they're probably saying, "Man, we should have come up with those big screens a long time ago."
  32. One of the reasons why Samsung has caught up and in many ways surpassed them is simply because of the size of
  33. the screen, forgetting about anything else. Now, if you can take that larger screen and combine it with some of the
  34. other still unique aspects of the the Apple phone experience, you might have a great device which will make these other
  35. stories really uh moot, but no one will be paying attention to them uh if they do make an announcement like that. Now,
  36. be that as it may, how important is it that the Beats acquisition includes their streaming music service? I think
  37. that's why they made the acquisition. The the the Beats product is is a very nice one. Uh there's no no question
  38. about it. But but they're they they bought Beats because iTunes Radio wasn't working. No one's downloading music
  39. anymore. Uh there's just an Beats is is is big enough that it's it's a real brand name. It has some cache. Uh, but
  40. it's small enough uh that that Apple can supposedly mold it into something that would be more of an an Apple branded
  41. service than than just Apple being tacked on to an existing brand. But the problem is it's so small they're going
  42. to have a real hard time competing with Pandora and Spotify and and and some of the other uh bigger players out there.
  43. It's not clear whether they can take this small service and turn it into a giant one. whether the Apple name is
  44. enough to do that when the Apple name wasn't enough to make iTunes work. Now, you have been saying for a long time, I
  45. mean, I think as far back as from our stories from 2002, that streaming was where the industry was eventually going
  46. to end up. Do you feel like this acquisition is a sign that maybe Apple has realized that the iTunes download
  47. model was really a transitional technology? In that regard, this is the most wonderful I told you so story that
  48. I've heard in a long time. I've been calling for this for for truly over a decade. And even went as far as saying
  49. that that one day when Apple announces that it's getting into a streaming subscription model in a big way. Not
  50. only will they do well with it, but it's it's it's going to be a rising tide that's going to lift all boats. It's
  51. going to legitimize streaming in a way that it's it it hasn't been fully legitimized. A lot of people are waiting
  52. for Apple to give this kind of big blessing. Now again, Apple has made some steps in that direction with iTunes
  53. Radio, but no one really paid any attention to that. By by doing it with with a brand, by having a more
  54. established service, I think that's actually going to help Spotify, Pandora, everybody else out there. And it might
  55. end up actually helping those other services more than it actually helps Apple itself. Why Why do you feel that
  56. way? Because a lot of people who have been having waiting and seeing, you know, I'm not quite sure I want to jump
  57. onto Spotify because after all, I I own an iPhone and I want to do whatever the the iPhone offers for me. Fact is that
  58. that uh that that most iPhone people or more iPhone people are using Pandora or or Spotify than they're using iTunes
  59. radio. But there's still a lot of folks who are holding out hope that Apple would would have a kind of a worldclass
  60. uh entry into the streaming music world. uh Beats might be that one. But again, it it's it's it now gives a green light
  61. to these other ones. And it's also going to encourage the industry to be a little
  62. bit more accepting, a little bit more progressive. I don't want to say that they've stood in the way of sp of
  63. Spotify and Pandora, but they haven't made life easy for those other services. I think th this acknowledgment that the
  64. that the download model is is over and that it's all about streaming, I think it it's going to force the industry as a
  65. whole to embrace streaming in in in a bigger, more aggressive, proactive way than they ever did before. So, it's
  66. going to help everybody in the industry, but especially consumers. Consumers are
  67. just much better off using these services. I don't even care which one. We can nitpick about any of these big
  68. ones. They're all good. Uh, and they're all a much better consumer experience than than Allakart downloading. Now, so
  69. Apple had kind of a hoham product in iTunes Radio, at least from consumer response, and now they've acquired
  70. Beats, so they're going to get whoever those subscribers to Beats or people that were using it. What do you think
  71. Apple needs to do to kind of take these two services and really stand out in this market because they're entering a
  72. market that has a lot of established players in Pandora, Spotify, Artio? It's a very good question and a very
  73. difficult question because usually when whenever Apple announces something, it just turns to gold. There's just enough
  74. enough people out there whether it's because of of true love for different Apple products and services or maybe out
  75. of inertia. I I I don't even want to think about it. I'm just going to go with the one that Apple endorses. That's
  76. usually the way it works. But it didn't work with iTunes radio. Uh, and it's not
  77. clear that that that just moving to a different horse that they're they're putting, you know, the Apple name on on
  78. on beats instead or in addition is is going to lead to a dramatic difference, but it does signal that Apple is going
  79. to be investing a whole lot more in this space than they were before. It could be
  80. that some of the the disappointments with iTunes Radio wasn't so much the service itself, but that Apple it really
  81. wasn't a major focus for them. So, maybe this is a sign that they're going to get
  82. real serious about it. and whether it's it's the the Beats platform itself or just uh Apple's in increased seriousness
  83. uh that might help them and they're going to have to advertise heavily uh and they're going to have to do all
  84. kinds of things that that doesn't come naturally for Apple. We'll see how well they do, but it is going to be a much
  85. tougher challenge for them than other areas where they've been successful to date. Now, is that because they're kind
  86. of having to instead of being kind of the market creator or the market buster, they're going to kind of have to see
  87. what everyone else has done and really want to do and really sort of follow on someone's coattails when they haven't
  88. done that before or that's a big part of it that it's it's a rapidly commoditizing business. Uh, and uh it's
  89. not clear that they can go in and and and truly shake it up in a disruptive way that they're able to do with the
  90. iPad and the iPhone. This is just not not something they've been uh very good at. uh that that is to say a service of
  91. this sort. Uh but Apple's a smart company and they're very resourceful company and if they really do set their
  92. mind to it, then they're they're they need to be taken seriously. But it's not clear that they're going to be able to
  93. jump right to the top and and and get people to actually give up on their uh Pandora or Spotify or or unauthorized
  94. services that they might be using and jumping over to this one here. It is possible, but uh put it this way, I
  95. wouldn't bet on it. Now, what about the hardware and talent sides of the Beats acquisition? How can Apple deploy those
  96. effectively? Well, again, be the Beats headphones are a fine product and and in many ways, it's it's a very good fit
  97. with Apple. It is just a best-in-class. Price is no issue. If if if you want the
  98. best, this is going to be the thing that you buy. So, so there's there's a good fit in that regard. And just even some
  99. of the uh some of the design elements are are aligned well with Apple. So I think that they can make beats fit the
  100. that is again the hardware side fit quite well under their umbrella. It's still unusual for them to to work with
  101. outsiders but this is about as good an outsider as they can find when it comes to the hardware but how much interplay
  102. there is between the hardware and the software and and a lot of speculation about how much of the reasons for the
  103. acquisition is the hardware versus the software that remains to be seen. Now what about the talent side of this? I
  104. mean do you expect to see them using I guess Dr. Dre or Jimmy Iiovine in a particular way or are they mostly kind
  105. of figureheads for this to lend sort of street cred to Apple or I think that's that's right. I think that that that
  106. it's more to show that that that we're cool and that we're endorsed by folks who are respected within the music
  107. industry, but I don't think that that that those particular folks are going to be game changers in any way. They're
  108. respected. There's no question about it. But I I don't think that people that consumers are going to say now there's a
  109. reason to be switching to to the Beats service instead of other services because let let's face it those guys and
  110. the the whole Beats team have been associated with them all along and that wasn't enough to get them even within an
  111. order of magnitude of Spotify or Pandora. So it's not clear that attaching those names to Apple is going
  112. to really change anything. Now, final question. I guess what do you see this acquisition? How do you see that fitting
  113. into kind of Tim Cook's performance as Apple CEO overall? I mean, what does this say about kind of the direction
  114. that his leadership is going in? And what do you think are going to be the challenges for him as this goes forward?
  115. Well, it's an interesting historic moment because on one hand, you could say this is an admission of defeat and
  116. that Apple can't innovate on its own and can't develop best-in-class products and
  117. services. On the other hand, you might say the reason why they haven't gone to the outside is a bit of arrogance that
  118. they've always just felt that they could do it better. But you know what? There are times when it makes sense to partner
  119. and to acquire. So, so the fact that they're they're open to doing it, does that represent desperation? Does that
  120. represent opportunity? I'm not really sure. But we're going to look back at it for sure within the next few years and
  121. and and say, "Oh, it's real clear that it was one or the other." So, it is a pivotal moment. Uh, and I think there's
  122. a lot writing on it and it might be a precedent that then gets followed in in other unimaginable ways. Uh, but it's
  123. it's a big step forward for Apple. Right. Pete, thanks so much for being with us today. Always a pleasure.
  124. [Music]

Brief Summary

Peter Federer discusses Apple's Beats acquisition and its implications for streaming and innovation strategy.

Key points

  • Apple's Unusual Move. Apple's acquisition of Beats marks a significant shift in their strategy towards streaming services.
  • Streaming vs. Downloads. The discussion highlights the failure of iTunes and the rise of streaming as the future.
  • Tim Cook's Leadership Challenge. The acquisition raises questions about Tim Cook's ability to innovate and lead Apple forward.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes