Gamification in Government and Public Policy
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
n a government bureaucracy, any innovation can take years to come to fruition. But that can change, says Tom Kalil, deputy director for policy for the Office of Science and Technology Policy at the White House. Kalil recently participated in a two-day conference at Wharton titled, "For the Win: Serious Gamification," which looked at the application of gaming techniques in business, education, government and other scenarios. Before the conference, Kalil spoke with Kevin Werbach, a conference organizer and a professor of legal studies and business ethics at Wharton, about why gamification has become a hot topic at the White House.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] I'm Kevin wbach professor of legal studies and business ethics and the
- organizer of a conference here called for the win on gamification and I'm talking to to Tom khil who's the deputy
- director for policy at the office of Science and Technology policy at the White House so Tom thanks very much for
- being here a pleasure so tell us a little bit first about uh what ostp is because uh our audience might not
- entirely be familiar with that group in the White House and a little bit about what you do there sure uh so the office
- of Science and Technology policy is part of the White House it's headed by John hren who's the president's science
- adviser and it has two basic missions one is to worry about science and technology for policy that is when the
- president is struggling with an issue about Fukushima and Japan how do we make sure that the president gets the best
- scientific and Technical advice and the second is policy for Science and Technology that is how does public
- policy on things like research uh education Innovation affect long-term economic growth and job creation and the
- ability to harness science technology and Innovation to address major societal challenges so can you give some examples
- of uh how things like R&D and the these more long-term scientific Endeavors actually connect up with the immediate
- concerns about jobs well uh a lot of times there is a long lag between when we start making an investment in
- research and development and when it starts to show up in in the GDP so a classic example is the government
- started invested in the arpanet uh and it took a long back in 1969 and it took a long time be before that started to be
- a driver of economic growth and job creation and productivity so one of osp's mandates is to look out for the
- long term to try to figure out what investments that we need to be making today that are going to lead to economic
- growth and job creation in the long term but there are things that we can do that
- will have a more immediate impact so for example if we're successful in in in working with the Congress to pass
- legislation that will make more Spectrum available for new wireless Services uh that will certainly help Drive economic
- growth and job creation um so this Administration the Obama Administration came in uh with a real commitment to
- renewing the emphasis on on science and technology and and I I had the the fortune of being being part of the the
- team in setting up the administration can you talk a little bit about some of the new initiatives that that this
- Administration has brought in uh and and some of the progress that's been made sure uh so one area of of real Focus has
- been improving Math and Science Education uh and there's been a real focus on on trying to move the United
- States from the middle to the top of the pack in terms of our performance and what's called stem education science
- technology engineering and math so that's been a major area of focus a second has been to try to increase our
- investments in in research and development particularly in the physical sciences and Engineering so th those are
- two examples where we've been able to make some progress and from your sense how do we
- how do we match up with the rest of the world and and what do we need to do to to U achieve better in those kinds of
- comparisons well uh so I think the United States is still an innovation superpower we have a lot going for us we
- have 17 of the top 20 research universities we have an entrepreneurial culture uh we have Capital markets that
- are willing to invest in high growth entrepreneurs but we certainly can't afford to take our lead uh for granted
- and we certainly have to continue to make progress by investing in things like research education and and a
- Century infrastructure what what role can the government play in in entrepreneurship and and startup
- activity well there's a number of things that we're doing so we launched something called uh the startup America
- initiative and it has two components one is things that the government is doing to create the right environment for
- private sector entrepreneurship and the second is a private sector Le activity that that is being spearheaded by Steve
- case who's the uh former co-founder of AOL so the government is doing things things like uh making it easier for
- foreign born entrepreneurs uh to immigrate to the United States we're trying to improve access to capital for
- small and mediumsized Enterprises and we're trying to improve the commercialization of federally funded
- research so that ideas move from the lab to the marketplace what are there things that
- that businesses or startups can do to to get involved or to to help contribute to
- some of these programs yes so if you go to the uh startup America partnership website you'll see a large number of
- companies uh are already getting involved whether it's AMX uh or Intel or Google or Microsoft so uh certainly
- there are a number of large companies uh that are getting involved in trying to encourage entrepreneurship and you also
- have a number of regions that are beginning to organize around this issue so not only do you have this National
- activity called the startup America partnership you also have States beginning to organize around this so you
- have startup Illinois and startup Tennessee and a number of other cities and states are not far behind so I I
- mentioned that that you're here uh at Wharton for a conference on gamification and so can you talk a little bit about
- some of the things that are that are going on in the federal government in terms of using prizes and other kinds of
- game mechanics on public policy challenges yeah well so uh the president in his National Innovation strategy
- asked agencies to increase their use of prizes and challenges as a tool for stimulating Innovation and the reason
- that we're doing that is that uh prizes and challenges have a number of advantages relative traditional grants
- and contracts it allows the government to pay only if someone is successful uh it allows the government to establish a
- goal without picking in advance the the right approach or the best team uh that is in the best position to achieve that
- goal uh and it allows the government to tap into a lot of uh non-traditional performers so NASA has done this and
- they've reported that they're getting a 5 to 10x return on the investment that they're making in prizes when they
- compare that to more uh traditional funding mechanisms can you can you give some specific examples of the the prizes
- that have been done sure so uh one was the uh Dara Grand Challenge uh which is really succeeded in advancing the
- state-of-the-art in robotic cars uh that was really successful uh NASA has been doing a lot of this uh to uh improve the
- state-of-the-art of space technology so uh so right now now a lot of it has been
- the technical agencies another example is uh the department of energy had something called the L prize to advance
- the State ofthe art and efficient lighting technology so as I said a lot of it so far has been limited to the
- Science and Technology agencies but we're also trying to encourage those agencies that have more of a social
- mission to start experimenting with prizes as well do do you have any sense of where this could go and prizes and
- and Beyond what's what's the potential for for the government to employ some of these techniques well I think there's a
- whole Suite uh of Technologies uh and approaches that are going to allow us to stimulate Innovation one that I'm really
- excited about is called an advanced Market commitment which you can think of as a purchase order for a product that
- doesn't exist yet and this has been tried out in the area of uh vaccines for diseases of the poor uh so left to their
- own uh devices pharmaceutical companies May underinvested of the poor because they
- don't have money so they'd rather work on male pattern boldness or or or something like that uh and so some
- economists came up with the idea of an advanced Market commitment and five countries plus the Gates Foundation got
- behind this idea and said to the Pharma industry if you develop a vaccine which is safe and effective we promise that we
- will purchase it uh and this intervention is going to save the lives of 7 million kids in developing
- countries over the next 20 years so uh even the way we change is changing and I think experimentation
- uh with some of these new tools for encouraging and promoting Innovation is really important so I mean on that point
- about experimentation you're you're based in the white house which I think most people don't realize is actually a
- very tiny operation relative to the the scope of the federal government so so how do you push out these kinds of
- changes across a a a very large bureaucracy well uh first of all we try to understand why agencies aren't using
- some of these things so it turned out that there was a fair amount of legal uncertainty about whether uh those
- agencies that haven't been given specific authority to use prizes could actually do it so someone might say well
- I'd like to do a prize and they' talk to their uh general counsel and the general
- counsel would say well we're not sure that you have the authority to do this so we worked uh with the Congress to
- pass legislation that now gives every agency the authority to support prizes and challenges of up to $50 million so
- that's one of the things we're trying to do is to reduce the transaction costs uh
- to remove the legal and Regulatory barriers and then to build a community of practice within the federal
- government of those uh people within the agencies that are interested in experimenting this and then highlighting
- uh some of the prizes and challenges that are successful so if we can demonstrate that many agencies are
- seeing a 5 to 10x return on their investment on prizes uh uh relative to Grants and contracts we think that's
- going to encourage more agencies to to start EXP experimenting with us okay so one one more before we wrap up obviously
- we're in a very challenging economic time and and and a challenging political time so how how does all that play into
- the things that you're working on um is is it more important or or less important and are there any
- opportunities in terms of some of these Innovative techniques and and the the broad area that you're in to help us get
- out of this this kind of mess that we're in well absolutely I mean if I think if
- you look uh at the 1990s uh the the last time I was in government uh we had uh you know 4%
- Unemployment uh not only had we eliminated the debt we were on track to pay down the deficit uh we had double-
- digigit uh increases in private sector investment in in capital um and and Rising wages and the creation of new
- Industries was an important part of the story so it was really in large part uh about this boom in information and
- communic A's Technologies which not only drove economic growth and job creation but also increased productivity so that
- really reminds us that if the United States wants to maintain a a long-term uh e healthy economy that we need to
- make investments in in areas like research and development terrific Tom thanks very much for being us sure
- thanks for being here [Music]
Brief Summary
Tom Khil discusses the government's role in promoting science, technology, and entrepreneurship to drive economic growth and innovation.
Key points
- Government's Role in Innovation. Tom Khil discusses how the government is fostering innovation through prizes and challenges.
- The Importance of R&D Investments. Tom emphasizes the need for long-term investments in research and development for economic growth.
Episode highlights
- Government's Role in InnovationTom Khil discusses how the government is fostering innovation through prizes and challenges.“Prizes and challenges have advantages over traditional grants and contracts.”5:58Aug 16, 2011
- The Importance of R&D InvestmentsTom emphasizes the need for long-term investments in research and development for economic growth.“If the United States wants to maintain a healthy economy, we need to invest in research.”11:15Aug 16, 2011





