Why America Leads the World in Innovation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE What has made the United States a global leader in innovation for more than 250 years?

David Hsu, Wharton Professor of Management, explains why America’s greatest innovation may not be its technologies, but the institutions that transform breakthrough ideas into world-changing industries. From the patent system and Bell Labs to venture capital and AI, he explores the systems that have fueled innovation throughout history and what they mean for the future.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. As the United States gets ready to celebrate its 250th birthday, one of the more interesting areas
  2. to look at is how this country has developed in and around innovation. Certainly we know that the
  3. country has had untold numbers of innovators over the years, but as our next guest recently said in
  4. an article in Fortune, it's not just about innovating technologies, it's the fact that
  5. we're able to reinvent how innovation works. Pleasure to be joined here by Work Management
  6. Professor David Hsu. David, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir? Good, thank you, Dan.
  7. And you start off your article by talking about the fact that it's not always about
  8. the technology, but about the institution to commercialize the technology. They're not out
  9. there, they're not going to be out there, it's just an amazing push forward that we've been seeing
  10. over 250 years. Absolutely. I think there's a very natural tendency to celebrate inventors,
  11. and that's terrific over 250 years. We think about great names like Ben Franklin, Thomas Edison,
  12. Alexander Graham Bell, today's AI entrepreneurs. Obviously they deserve enormous credit,
  13. but if you actually look at the whole history, this other parallel story emerges, which is that
  14. America's greatest innovation may actually be more institutional innovation. That is,
  15. we repeatedly invent better ways to transform discoveries into industries, and those examples
  16. come up time and again. Patent system, the research university, how to organize corporate research,
  17. the whole notion of venture capital, and today's startup ecosystem. So these are all
  18. social inventions, they create the conditions that allow scientific breakthroughs to really
  19. spread and be useful throughout the economy. So my point is that the lesson of American history
  20. isn't simply that we are great at inventing technologies, which we are, but it's that we're
  21. also great at repeatedly reinventing the machinery of how to bring those inventions to market.
  22. Is this then an historical pattern that has occurred over the years where, as you alluded to with Alexander Graham Bell, it was kind of fostered a little bit back in those
  23. days, but as we have moved forward, history has allowed us to kind of open these doors as we move
  24. forward? Yeah, that's absolutely right, and I'd love to start with the example of Alexander Graham
  25. Bell, because it was in Philadelphia in 1876, so 150 years ago, there was a Philadelphia
  26. Centennial Exposition in which he introduced the telephone. Everyone was amazed, but then it became
  27. very obvious, a single telephone has almost no value, you really got to have it in the hands
  28. of millions of people to really make those connections and realize the value. And so
  29. the invention was important, but the system of bringing that invention to the market by forming
  30. the Bell Telephone Company, about adopting a leasing model rather than just simply selling
  31. the telephones, that there's repeated points of contact with the customers and upgrading the
  32. quality of the phones, securing the patents, getting the investment, making partners with
  33. the manufacturing company, in this case it was Western Electric. And then there's legal disputes
  34. in the early days with Western Union and telegraphy, and really just laying the infrastructure for those kind of thousands of miles of communication infrastructure,
  35. that goes way beyond just the simple invention of the telephone, that really to unlock the value,
  36. you need this whole system of commercialization, and that really illustrates well the kind of
  37. phenomenon I'm talking about. So as we see more and more companies and corporations develop over
  38. the years, you talk about the component of research and development, R&D, playing this next
  39. step kind of in the process, correct? Yeah, so if you think about R&D, now we can step forward
  40. into the early 20th century, and if you look at companies like Bell Labs or General Electric or DuPont, that was the era in which we faced a very different
  41. challenge than just the single entrepreneur. We began to develop these complex organizations
  42. and really thinking about just instead of just the flash or genius of one inventor,
  43. you really now wanted to go through and think about systematizing these inventions. And so
  44. Bell Labs is a great example because it brought together lots of different specialists, physicists,
  45. chemists, mathematicians, and the breakthroughs coming out of that lab was incredible.
  46. So just to name a few, the transistor, Claude Shannon's information theory, which actually
  47. Claude Code, a lot of people don't realize that Anthropics Claude is actually named after the
  48. father of information theory, Claude Shannon, who himself was an important person in Bell Labs.
  49. The laser, C programming language, lots of these technologies came out of Bell Labs. So really
  50. the greatest invention out of Bell Labs is really this whole organizational structure of assembling
  51. the lab itself, which is quite important in R&D. How then did the moving forward,
  52. the venture capital component end up factoring in how a lot of this innovation and development
  53. was occurring? So that's actually another really important innovation because it transitioned the
  54. era from big corporate invention to then democratizing it down to individual entrepreneurs.
  55. And that's what we celebrate today. And so the birth of venture capital institution
  56. really helped solve another bottleneck after the end of World War II. And because what these
  57. entrepreneurs really lacked was financing, mentors, industry connections. And so the,
  58. if you could really trace the birth of Silicon Valley and venture capital institution to some of
  59. the issues that were coming out of not only Silicon Valley, but also of the Boston area
  60. in trying to convert great inventions to become organizations that can, again, commercialize by
  61. not just adding money, but also all the value added components that are necessary to bring
  62. great ideas to markets, recruiting executives, connecting founders with customers,
  63. helping shape strategy, preparing companies to scale. All that is just another example of another
  64. chapter in which America reinvented itself for the challenge of the time, which was this
  65. financing of entrepreneurial type of problem. But you also had to have the regulatory process as
  66. part of this to make sure that as all of this development was occurring, we were still adhering to guidelines as we move forward, correct?
  67. Yeah. Regulation is a really important backdrop to this and actually gets to the,
  68. you know, the question of how do we govern good institutions? So we certainly need things like
  69. patent law. We need to get the right incentives so that inventors can feel confident in disclosing
  70. their ideas, having protection. Obviously, financial markets need investors to have
  71. confidence in order to finance very risky ventures. We need corporate law to be established
  72. so that we can build and grow new firms. Good rules really reduce uncertainty without eliminating
  73. experimentation. And so I think the upshot here is that throughout American history,
  74. institutional design supported by a regulatory, a stable regulatory structure really just allows
  75. us to unlock that technological ingenuity and bring to fruition all the pieces of the ecosystem
  76. we need to fully realize the value of these inventions. So now in the landscape of AI,
  77. how does the development and the use of that technology factor into this last 250 years of
  78. history and development that we've seen play out in terms of leading us into the next, I guess,
  79. 250 years? Yeah, and I think this is an incredibly important point because so much of the media and
  80. attention is around the technical specifications of AI models and the companies are constantly
  81. pitting themselves on the technical specifications. And I'm not talking just about American companies,
  82. but if you look at the broader global picture, it's US versus Chinese technical models.
  83. But if we can learn the history here of reinventing institutions, I think we have to
  84. worry even more about the institutional structure, the guardrails, the complementary skills in our
  85. workforce, how people will use and misuse these technologies so that we can earn the public trust
  86. and feel confident about using this technology for the societal good. And so I think the lesson
  87. for me on AI is that we need to think hard about building great institutions to really enable this
  88. breakthrough technology to diffuse and diffuse in a way that's productive. And just because
  89. we've been able to solve that in prior eras with the R&D lab, with venture capital, etc.,
  90. we can't take for given that we'll automatically solve it. And so I'd love to see a lot more
  91. discourse about some of these more institutional structures rather than just focusing on how big
  92. are our models in AI, etc., etc. David, great to talk to you. Thanks for your time and your insight. All the best.
  93. Thank you so much. You got it. Wharton Management Professor David Su.

Brief Summary

David Hsu discusses America's innovation history, emphasizing institutional frameworks over technology alone, and the importance of responsible AI development.

Key points

  • The Role of Institutions in Innovation. David Hsu explains how America's innovation success is tied to institutional advancements, not just technology.
  • AI and Institutional Structures. The discussion shifts to the importance of institutional frameworks for the future of AI.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes