Can AI Improve Financial Literacy? | Wharton's Ripple Effect Podcast
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
EPISODE OVERVIEW Generative AI can help improve financial literacy, but the current models aren’t sophisticated enough to serve as standalone advisers, says Wharton’s Michael Roberts. This episode is part of a series on “Financial Literacy.”
PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use.
#financialliteracy #AI #generativeAI #financialeducation ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I think the trajectory of financial literacy has been positive over time, but positive at a somewhat glacial pace. It's
- not improving quickly enough. And I think recent government policy and actions that we've seen over the last four or five
- years is a positive step forward, but raises perhaps more questions than— concerns that it calms, right? Who's going to teach
- it? - Right. - How's it going to be taught? What's going to be taught? There are a lot of challenges.
- So here we are now. If we're moving at kind of a glacial pace, here comes artificial intelligence, which is certainly
- not moving glacial. It's moving about as fast as you possibly can. And I guess the question is, if AI is having all of these
- impacts in all of these different areas, where does it potentially fit in, in and around financial literacy?
- Welcome to The Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
- Dan Loney. And in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
- Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. Well, in this world
- where seemingly everything is being linked to artificial intelligence, we take a look now at whether or not AI could
- potentially have an impact on something like financial literacy. Pleasure to be joined here in studio by Michael
- Roberts, Finance Professor here at the Wharton School. Great to see you. - You too, Dan. - Before we dig into the AI side of it,
- though, I would like to get your thoughts on where you think kind of financial literacy is in general, in our country, and
- maybe in around the world right now. - Sure. I guess I can start off by saying, I'm not entirely sure
- what financial literacy even means at this point. But if I think about the research on the subject and my engagement with
- practitioners, I would describe it in several ways. So first, in general, it's pretty poor. If you think about financial
- literacy rates, they're about 57% in the US. But that hides a lot of variation in the population across genders,
- across income, across education, across age, where we see rates varying a great deal. I think the trajectory of financial
- literacy has been positive over time, but positive at a somewhat glacial pace. It's not improving quickly enough. And I think
- recent government policy and actions that we've seen over the last four or five years is a positive step forward. But— but
- raises perhaps more questions than concerns that it calms, right? Who's going to teach it? - Right. - How's it going to be
- taught? What's going to be taught? There are a lot of challenges. So here we are now. If we're moving at kind of a— a glacial
- pace, here comes artificial intelligence, which is certainly not moving glacial. It's moving about as fast as you possibly
- can. And I guess the question is, if AI is having all of these impacts in all of these different areas, where does it
- potentially fit in, in and around financial literacy? - Yeah, it's hard to not see it as being central in one way or another to
- financial literacy and financial practice more broadly. And given how quickly it's changing, as you've mentioned, perhaps what
- I'm about to say will be outdated when this is eventually published. Nonetheless, I'll take a stab. Where it's at right
- now is— is simply nowhere near where it needs to be in terms of a standalone, say, investment advisor, or a sort of financial
- guru for individuals. It takes a great deal of understanding of finance, and an ability to prompt or engage with the AI to
- get meaningful answers out of it. I mean, when it does produce answers, they can be impressive, but they can also lead you
- astray. So how long before we get to a point where anyone can just talk to AI and have it solve its— their financial
- problems? I have no idea. But it's not gonna— it's not going to negate the importance of what I call financial proficiency.
- You've taken a little bit of a look at this in terms of how generative AI could potentially have a role here. What have you
- found out? I've been playing with it for about two years, ever since— you know, I had a bunch of students in one of my class use it to
- solve an exam. It was in a different context, admittedly, more programming and data science. Nonetheless, it was a
- quick wake-up call. So I've been feeding it questions, both standard financial literacy questions, as well as questions
- from my exams. And it's interesting. AI is financially literate by any measure, in practice. From that perspective,
- it's impressive. But when you ask questions such as— you know, just broad open-ended questions— you know, "How should I save for
- retirement?" "What should I invest in?" Now I'm sure there's regulations or restrictions on the AI from becoming— you know, an
- unlicensed registered RIA, but it really— it doesn't know where to begin. It provides a very broad overview. And so what I
- mean when I say I don't know when it's going to be ready to be our financial gurus, I don't know how quickly AI technology
- will progress to that point. What has to happen, then, potentially, for it to get to
- that point— because the one thing we do know is that as AI is building up, we have to remember there are human
- components that are kind of behind the scenes on all of this. I think what's critical is that I don't see AI as just a
- panacea. I view it as a complement and an accelerant on our path towards financial literacy, whatever that may be,
- or financial proficiency. In other words, I think it's going to be critical that people recognize that knowledge of
- finance and financial principles are not going to go away. That they're going to be paramount in order to engage successfully
- with AI, wherever it may be in the future. But I think some people would wonder, with the fact that we
- know that financial literacy, education is important, and the fact that it has been a hard thing to truly implement in the
- right manners in schools in different portions of the country, of whether or not at some point AI can be that
- vehicle to be able to help teach along the way. - Oh, I think it can and it probably will be a wonderful aid sooner
- than we think. So Sal Khan has created Khanmigo. - Yeah. - There's no reason we can't have personal AI TAs for our classes now, or very
- soon. But there's a difference between being a TA for a class, and being someone who can answer individual specific personal or
- professional financial questions. - Right. - That's important. It's important to recognize that distinction.
- Everyone's different. Me saving for retirement is different from you saving for retirement, and so on. - Right.
- And the understanding of the dynamics of how each person feels about that, as well, are something that maybe the AI
- cannot fully and truly understand. - Not without the help of the end user. And that's what I mean
- when I say it's critical for individuals to understand how to communicate with AI. But to do so you have to understand
- finance. You have to know what to ask it, and importantly, how to interpret what it's spitting back at you.
- I noticed in the research you had done in around AI there are also instances where you kind of rephrase some of the questions
- that you did to try and see if there would be a better understanding for the generative AI tool, the ChatGPT, as well.
- Yeah, absolutely. I had to learn how to communicate with the AI in some sense in order to give it the opportunity to get the
- right answer. And by the same token, I imagine the AI is learning how I'm communicating with it, in order to give me the
- answer I'm looking for. What you're saying is somewhat of a theme that we've heard from
- other experts, other analysts, other business leaders— that AI in the scope of where financial literacy may be going will be a
- path to help it along the way. But it won't be the be all end all. I think it has the opportunity to accelerate our progress. But
- it won't be a replacement for financial literacy, financial proficiency. You also talk in your work about the ability to properly
- interpret the answers being given by ChatGPT as well. Yeah, 100%. It's not just spitting out a number. It's giving a somewhat
- long-winded explanation of the answer. And so if you don't understand what it's returning, the information is not helpful.
- It's not usable. But is the expectation that, though, there is a level of development that we should expect from ChatGPT in this
- area and a lot of areas as we move forward? - Yeah, I think so. I mean, it's progressing so quickly. It's
- difficult to keep up with. And that's why I say it's hard to see a limitation, at least from my perspective, on what it's
- going to be able to do. Other than I don't see it, at least currently, as a replacement for
- the progress we need to make on the literacy side. What has that research meant to your mindset around teaching
- finance and the component of having ChatGPT as a tool to use in that process? Oh, I'm incredibly excited. I take the view that ChatGPT or
- other Gen AI models are just a fantastic tool in the toolkit that we need for addressing financial challenges. So I
- embrace it. I encourage my students to embrace it. I want them to use it on tests or homework if they choose. But what
- they quickly learn is that if they're going to use it, they can't shirk on understanding the finance. - But because
- we're talking about an area like finance, then I think you also have to bring into the discussion the regulatory side
- of how that industry is managed to begin with, and potentially how AI may have to be managed in and around finance. I mean,
- obviously I think we're talking about a little bit larger-scale discussion. But still, the industry as a whole, there's
- going to be a focus on how AI kind of plays into finance as we move forward. - Absolutely.
- It's a natural progression from robo advisors, right? I mean, just— it's a different algorithm. That's what it is. So
- it's going to have to be subject to similar, though not identical regulations, as we already see in the FinTech space.
- How much do you think, in terms of the education piece, that you've seen it— has it benefited your students?
- So it depends. For data science- related financial applications, when I teach my Data Science for Finance course, it's hugely
- helpful, because it just— it almost— almost completely eliminates the technical burden in terms of programming and
- working with data. It's made things so much more efficient. On the banking and personal finance side, it's a little less
- helpful, again, because it struggles with broad, sort of almost open-ended questions. It varies based on application at
- this point. - Anything that really surprised you about kind of your interaction with
- ChatGPT AI, as you've kind of used it the last couple of years? Yeah. Sometimes it gives impressively insightful
- responses. In fact, it actually— it found an error in one of the financial literacy exams, which I thought was really impressive.
- On the other hand, it also impresses me in terms of some of the silly mistakes it makes. So that sort of volatility, that
- needs to be worked out. And I'm sure it will be as it learns through more interaction and data.
- Michael, great to talk with you. Thanks very much for joining us here today. - Thank you. - You got it. Michael Roberts, Finance
- Professor here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to The Ripple Effect. We hope you found this episode
- informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight
- from the Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Michael Roberts discusses financial literacy and the potential role of AI in enhancing it.
Key points
- The Ripple Effect Podcast Introduction. Join host Dan Loney as he explores the intersection of AI and financial literacy with Wharton faculty.
- AI's Role in Financial Literacy. Michael Roberts discusses how AI could complement financial literacy education, but not replace it.
Episode highlights
- The Ripple Effect Podcast IntroductionJoin host Dan Loney as he explores the intersection of AI and financial literacy with Wharton faculty.“Welcome to The Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty.”0:50Apr 16, 2024
- AI's Role in Financial LiteracyMichael Roberts discusses how AI could complement financial literacy education, but not replace it.“I view it as a complement and an accelerant on our path towards financial literacy.”5:38Apr 16, 2024





