The Rise of Prediction Markets and What Comes Next

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Prediction markets are booming, but are they really different from traditional sports betting?

Wharton Professor Abraham Wyner explains how prediction markets work, why they have become so popular, and how their fee-based model differs from the way sportsbooks make money. He also discusses regulation, professional bettors, the wisdom of crowds, and whether these markets are ultimately just another form of gambling.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Prediction markets have developed quite the strong foothold in American culture recently.
  2. They are allowing people to predict on a wide range of outcomes in sports and culture,
  3. and that word predict is changing the landscape. In many cases, predicting has become a far
  4. more novel approach than betting, but there are some similarities. So, what are prediction markets doing right now?
  5. And a pleasure to be joined by Wharton Professor Adi Weiner. Adi, great to talk to you.
  6. Thanks very much for your time today. Well, it's good to be here with you. Thank you.
  7. I guess let's start with the development of these markets and how they have kind of
  8. come into our culture, especially in the last few years, and the place they have kind
  9. of developed in the gaming realm over the last couple of years. Well, let's take a step back.
  10. So, the idea behind the prediction market begins with basically a theory called the wisdom of
  11. the crowds, which is the observation that large numbers of people, their collected average thoughts are
  12. better than experts. And that has held up in lots of areas, not exclusively, but particularly, say, in sports
  13. and predicting political outcomes. And there was online prediction markets that didn't
  14. involve trading money, but allowed people to kind of put their predictive probability on an event.
  15. They would average them up, and you could track them. And that, for example, I remember in the
  16. 2016 election or 2008 election, you could see these prediction markets track a future event.
  17. And there was no money being waged, but they were thought to be very reliable. So, the next stage of the prediction market
  18. evolution was when it allowed people to actually put money down on their predictions, and that
  19. changed it. And it's not a book, so it's very different from the historical sports betting.
  20. But what kind of impact is it having on traditional betting right now? I mean, how much of the money is
  21. moving from the online gambling component over to prediction markets? Well, that's hard to say because everybody's growing,
  22. right? So, nobody is losing. I mean, market share is kind of hard to figure out because everyone's going like gangbusters.
  23. You know, the fan duels and the online sports betting industry is growing like crazy.
  24. And so, yeah, they're probably losing some business, but they're also getting others in other ways.
  25. They make money differently, but I'm not sure. I don't know the exact data on whether
  26. people are moving. I mean, basically, you move because you feel you get better odds in one location versus
  27. another. And you move because you might think you'd get better fees or you might get better
  28. service. I know that the fan duels and the gaming companies are very big on promotions trying
  29. to get you to come in with attractive offers. The betting markets don't do that.
  30. Well, and I think to a degree, at least from the outside looking in, that the prediction markets are viewed as maybe more attractive
  31. just in general, more of a niche connecting with the public right now than, say, the
  32. traditional betting markets. Those are still doing very well, but there's something that's connecting with the consumer, it feels
  33. like. Sure, you can bet on anything, right? And you can even propose a bet that's
  34. not even there and see if someone will take it. So you can bet on, oddly enough, you
  35. can bet on whether the second coming of Jesus Christ happens by January 1st. You can actually bet on that.
  36. So you can bet on anything you want. Lots of things are being offered, and you can see what they are and the prices
  37. that are being offered, and you can propose new ones. And that has an attractiveness that goes way,
  38. way beyond sports. So it brings the consumer in at a level that maybe they never were at before,
  39. correct? Yeah, exactly. I mean, you could stand back, and this is not something that I have expertise in
  40. psychologically. What do betting markets do to people that get them to be interested in?
  41. And I would just speculate that I think it has to do with feeling deeply involved,
  42. right? So it takes something that you might have a casual interest and sharpens that interest and
  43. focuses it and makes you much more interested in it because you have proverbial skin in
  44. the game, right? So you care more, right? I was walking out of a Yankee game where the Yankees had lost, and someone ahead
  45. of me was just screaming about the Yankees' bad play. And I'm thinking, wow, I haven't seen anyone
  46. get that excited about a Yankee game, and the Yankee lost in a long time after 162 games in a season.
  47. A loss is just another day. And then he turned around and said to me, I don't care about the Yankees.
  48. I put money on it. Well, and so there's the other component of this is how sports have kind of adapted
  49. to having that gaming component more of a normal part of the day-to-day operation.
  50. And this is every sport kind of across the board. It used to be verboten for the longest
  51. time. There were no pro teams in Las Vegas. And now look how things have changed over
  52. the last 15 to 20 years. Well, certainly, internationally, the other countries have taken
  53. the lead on that. So Europe and Asia has long and had much more rigorous and robust betting markets.
  54. And those, of course, have been exploited. There have been scandals where players and fans
  55. have colluded. And there's deep, dark underbelly to having such a large betting market.
  56. And we've, in the United States, have always tried to avoid that. That may have been because of our different
  57. moral values, you could say, or just history. And we've really dropped those obstacles.
  58. And they have caused problems. There are already lawsuits. There are examples of players and people involved
  59. in the game who have been accused of using their positions to influence betting markets.
  60. How does an entity, and I read yesterday about the connection that obviously the prediction markets
  61. have to have with an agency like the CFTC, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, and the
  62. fact that these contracts are being kind of reviewed and looked at by that agency, which
  63. I think is a unique component to it, it feels so much different than traditional gambling
  64. because of there's this oversight. Okay, let's just be 100% clear. It's gambling.
  65. Yeah. It is gambling. Now, you could step back and say, what's the stock market if it's not gambling?
  66. Well, the stock market serves a lot of functions that aren't gambling for businesses, for individuals,
  67. and also the stock market goes up, right? So when you buy into the stock market,
  68. you're betting, essentially making a bet on the economy, if you'd like, on individual companies.
  69. And we consider those things good because they have upside utility, right? But if you stand back and think about
  70. it, if I'm going to be betting on whether the S&P 500 goes up or down tomorrow, which I can do with an
  71. option, and in many ways, how is that different from betting on the Yankees? The answer is it's really not in any
  72. structural way. So now that you take these prediction markets and expand the betting event pool to something
  73. much, much larger, you're essentially getting involved in gambling. I don't know how to say it that
  74. way, but it is gambling. If you define gambling as essentially making a wager on an outcome for which you have
  75. no say or no party involved, and it's not a hedge. I mean, you could use it as a
  76. hedge if you're in certain ways. So it's not that you don't have economic utility, and they certainly have entertainment value, but
  77. it is gambling. So when you ask the question, does it feel better because there's a government agency involved?
  78. Well, that helps because a lot of these events are hard to define, like the coming
  79. of Jesus Christ. What is that going to mean, right? How do you know when that's over, right?
  80. And so there's a lot of... That has to be regulated so that there aren't conflicts and people saying that this happened
  81. or it didn't happen. And that's really what kind of makes this a little bit more official, because imagine making
  82. a bet with a friend over something wild and then disagreeing on whether the event actually
  83. took place or didn't take place. So that sort of helps settle these contracts. They are business contracts.
  84. They have economic force. They are legal, binding contracts. And then to make the whole thing work
  85. better, you do need regulation. So then when you think about the future of how prediction markets are going to look
  86. to continue to grow, just the fact that there are so many potential questions or ideas
  87. that can be put into a contract as we move forward, I mean, basically anything is
  88. out there available, that that just kind of leaves us with the potential for continuous growth
  89. year after year after year. I suppose so. I mean, obviously there should be some sort
  90. of saturation. There are certain people who will just never do this, right? I mean, my wife had no idea that
  91. such a thing as a prediction market and is never going to find out and would never be interested.
  92. Obviously, lots of other people have been in this game for a while. So then you're not starting to fight for
  93. the middle ground where you're going to go on that. I typically have almost never done a couple
  94. bets on it, mostly out of curiosity individually, not out of desire. There is a fee, right?
  95. So you do pay money. I mean, you think that it's a fee -less transaction, but no, there is a fee.
  96. It's not a huge fee, but it is a fee and there's money to be made by the providers and that money has to
  97. be paid by the bettors. And I have no special insight, right? So I mean, obviously, if I put my
  98. statistical talents potentially to work, I could gain an edge. But as I'd like to say, I mean,
  99. years and years and years ago when I was a grad student and I became some of an expert in card counting and blackjack,
  100. and I would go to Vegas and other places and make a little bit of money and then I realized a job is more
  101. profitable, right? So yes, there are people who will do this and will enjoy it, but I'm not
  102. going to spend my time, my available time trying to beat the market when I have other ways of doing this.
  103. Other groups can really put together their books, their energy, their intellectual power and do it,
  104. and they are. Looking at it from a statistical perspective then, longer term, does one or the other prediction
  105. markets or traditional gambling have a better kind of long-term view in terms of the
  106. success that they are looking to have? You know, predicting the future is hard, right?
  107. So I don't know, so I don't, I think the books, the traditional sports books are
  108. just a lot easier. You know, you don't have to settle. The books make the prices, right?
  109. And so I can't say whether or not one will do better than the other. I think there's plenty of room for everybody
  110. to get involved. You know, it's really marketing, right? So I think the sports books know how
  111. to get you to become their customer and stay as your customer. And I don't know whether the prediction markets
  112. are working as hard on that. They don't offer the promotions and plans to get you hooked.
  113. They also, on the other hand, don't try to keep you out. One of the things that a sharp, a
  114. excellent better, they call that, will generally be denied a service at the sports books if
  115. they prove to be too good a better. And certainly they will be denied all those promotions, which makes sense.
  116. You don't want to be giving all these promotions to the excellent betters. But they have historically, and this is something
  117. that I haven't researched, but I've certainly read about and talked to some of my friends
  118. who are professional gamblers. They'll say that the sports books do their best to keep them out.
  119. And the prediction markets, at least as far as I can tell, don't care about that
  120. because there's a counterpart, right? So when you make a bet, there's someone on the other side.
  121. In the sports book, the person on the other side, the entity on the other side is the book, not an individual.
  122. So they have skin in the game as well. They don't want to see their lines saturated
  123. with professionals because they actually make money, not just on what they call the vig, which
  124. is the advantage that they have because the bets don't sum to one, they sum to something greater than one.
  125. And that advantage is traditionally earned by the book. But they can take lopsided books, which means
  126. that they're actually taking a position. And they like to take positions because the
  127. public likes to take bad bets. It's hard to know unless you saw their inside information, but articles have been written and
  128. published historically that show that about half their money is made on the vig and about
  129. half is made on bad bets. The prediction markets don't make money on bad bets. That's not how it works.
  130. They make money on their fees. That's it. Otty, always great to talk with you. Thanks very much for your time today.
  131. All the best. Terrific. Thank you. Always glad to join. Bring me on to talk about something else
  132. at any time. Absolutely. Otty Weiner, Wharton professor joining us, and we should mention as well, co-host of the
  133. Moneyball podcast each and every week right here on the Wharton Podcast Network.

Brief Summary

Adi Weiner discusses prediction markets' rise, their appeal, and their impact on traditional betting in American culture.

Key points

  • The Rise of Prediction Markets. Prediction markets are gaining traction in American culture, allowing predictions on various outcomes.
  • The Wisdom of Crowds. The theory that collective predictions can outperform expert opinions is central to prediction markets.
  • Gambling or Not?. The debate continues on whether prediction markets should be classified as gambling.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes