Dean Oliver on Whether Sixers Can Fit LeBron with Other Stars

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Can the Philadelphia 76ers turn one of the NBA’s most star-studded rosters into a championship team?

Basketball analytics pioneer and ESPN data scientist Dean Oliver joins Wharton Moneyball to break down how LeBron James, Joel Embiid, Tyrese Maxey, Jaylen Brown, and VJ Edgecombe might share the ball and adjust their roles.

The conversation covers player chemistry, usage, late-game decision-making, three-point shooting, defense, and why predicting whether stars will fit together remains one of basketball analytics’ hardest challenges.

Plus, the hosts discuss the Baseball Hall of Fame and the growing commercialization of college sports.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Money Ball, welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on
  2. the Wharton Podcast Network, Cade Massey hosting this week, along with the whole team.
  3. Delighted to have everybody in here, Eric Bradlow's in here from Points Northeast, Shane, Center City,
  4. Philadelphia, Ottie Weiner, Wharton Campus West, Wharton, San Francisco. If you can just see over Ottie's left
  5. shoulder, the Bay Bridge, spectacular real estate. We've had the privilege of leasing for a
  6. few years now. Ottie's out there doing some teaching on behalf of Wharton, managing to find time for us.
  7. We're going to run our regular format this week. We're going to have a guest here in
  8. the first half hour. You might, if you're on video, guess who that guest is. We'll have open lines in the second half
  9. of the show. Got a few topics queued up. We have as our guest, a frequent guest,
  10. a multi-time guest over many years now. Dean Oliver is with us. Dean is a data scientist with ESPN.
  11. He has had a role like that off and on over the years. He is one of the real pioneers.
  12. I would say one of the, I don't know, two or three top pioneers of basketball analytics.
  13. It wasn't that long ago we had a guest on here making the case for Dean in the Basketball Hall of Fame.
  14. Maybe we will take up that. We are happy to take up that cause. Maybe we will see that cause succeed over
  15. the years. Dean has worked for basketball organizations. He was actually a bench coach for the
  16. Wizards at one point. He's kind of done it all. He's, for those of you who've listened over
  17. the years know, he actually is involved across a lot of ESPN's metrics, including the creation
  18. of FPI, which is one of the best public numbers out there, has been from the beginning.
  19. But he mainly focuses on basketball. Most recent book, Basketball Beyond Paper, is a
  20. sequel of sorts to his path-breaking basketball on paper. So it's a great way to dive into
  21. more of Dean's work if you'd like. Dean, always glad to see you. Thanks for coming in.
  22. Good to be here. I listen to you guys pretty much weekly. So it's actually interesting to see you all
  23. in person. I listen. I don't usually watch it. Wow. Okay. Well, you've been, we've been at conferences together.
  24. You've taught for Audi. You've been around. We really appreciate your contributions in multiple forms.
  25. But, you know, we had you scheduled this week and we thought we were going to talk, well, here's some Jalen Brown business to
  26. talk about. That'll be fun. But we got even bigger news in the meantime. So let's just jump straight to it.
  27. LeBron James made his decision and he chose our Philadelphia 76ers. They're a little bit less ours than they
  28. used to be. They're still owned by Wharton alumni, but our friend Daryl Morey's not running them anymore.
  29. LeBron to the Sixers. Let me just note that your tweet, did this tweet, did it stick in our rundown?
  30. Your tweet shortly after the decision was merely usages last year. And then you run down five current Philadelphia
  31. 76ers. They played for different teams last year. Usages last year. LeBron, 27%.
  32. Maxie, 29%. Edgecombe, 19%. Brown, 35%. Embiid, 32%. And because you're an analytics guy, you sum
  33. those up to the total of 142. So what is your perspective, Dean Oliver? This is going to be a big experiment.
  34. There is there to put so many guys together who have used, but had the ball, taken a lot of shots, made, committed the
  35. turnovers, made the passes, putting them all on the floor at the same time is, there
  36. have been times it's been done, but it's not a common thing. That's for sure. Of course, they're not going to be on
  37. the floor the whole time. And so at the end of the season, you're not going to see each of that
  38. add up to 142, but it's also not going to add up to 100 either. It's going to add up to probably in
  39. the 110 range or so, because you'll stagger who's on the floor and they'll pick up
  40. more usage when they're out there on the floor with the bench. So you'll see it, but the tweet was
  41. very simple because it's conveying this question to the coaching staff. How are you going to distribute the shots
  42. and the ball handling and all of that that's out there? It's not saying that they're going to maintain
  43. it. In fact, obviously they're constrained to not maintain it. So yeah, hopefully that message got conveyed.
  44. At a high level, is it a bigger challenge managing egos or is it a bigger challenge managing the way the guys play the
  45. game? Like guys who are customing on ball are going to spend more time off ball.
  46. Are those equal? Is one of those more important? What's your thinking? They kind of feed back into each other
  47. at times. What you hope is that the egos for the players that are out there, they're confident
  48. enough in who they are that they don't mind kind of taking a backseat at times. I don't know these players personally myself, so
  49. I don't know how those egos are going to be. But managing the play style is going to
  50. be a blend of Nick Nurse, and he has his own style, and these guys. And I think what they say about a
  51. lot of coaches when you have a lot of talent is you kind of want to rule the balls out there and just let
  52. them see how they're going to do it on their own. And then the coach kind of tweaks it
  53. because you want them to like each other. You want them to kind of evolve a natural way.
  54. That's super, super interesting. Yeah, I hadn't thought about it in quite that way.
  55. Figure out what's natural for them, and you might not be able to predict it. I mean, guys do play with each other
  56. all the time, pick up at higher levels. They figure out how to defer and when not to defer.
  57. Shane, I think, was going to jump in. Well, I just want to kind of point out, I mean, I don't follow basketball nearly
  58. as closely as the rest of you, but I kind of feel like a previous time that the same kind of discussion of sharing
  59. ego and also like just sharing the rock came up in our show was when Durant went to Golden State.
  60. I think there was kind of there was a situation, too, where I remember discussing how
  61. are we going to actually, you know, who's actually going to be able to hold the ball type of thing.
  62. So that, I guess, one can look back on as a success story. I'm sure there's a lot of other ones.
  63. Do you kind of feel like that is actually a good analog to this situation? Or is each one of these cases so
  64. idiosyncratic, you can't really learn much from something like that? By the way, just note, Bob Meyer is
  65. involved with both of those. Yes, yeah. That one was a little bit different. In Golden State's case, it was pretty clear
  66. that Steph was the man. Draymond Green is not a big possession user. He's a big part of their defense, but
  67. he's not going to be a big part of their offense. He's going to facilitate. That was very clear.
  68. He could facilitate without taking a whole lot of shots. Klay Thompson was someone who played off the
  69. ball. Golden State was a little bit different. I think some of these other potential super
  70. teams that people have talked about. So you had Kevin Durant. You had Kyrie Irving.
  71. You had James Harden. You had that team. You had the Phoenix team when they got Bradley Beal and Devin Booker and Kevin Durant.
  72. Kevin Durant's involved in a lot of these. Crazy, you know. And they don't necessarily work.
  73. And Kevin Durant is pretty moldable. It's interesting. I think that was one of the reasons
  74. that they did it, is Kevin Durant's willing to take the right shot. He was a hero on Team America, Team
  75. USA, and the Olympics and everything, because he could play with great players really well.
  76. That doesn't mean it's going to work for the teams that he did join, those super
  77. teams. And I think you're looking at this Philadelphia team. I think they're hopefully looking.
  78. They're looking at it, hopefully, from this perspective that maybe it'll be like Team USA.
  79. Then all of these guys can just play together like they do on Team USA. And it takes a few weeks for sure.
  80. What are the odds saying right now? Are they genuinely thought to be a contending
  81. title tender? Title contender? If I recall, they're third behind the two teams in the West, OKC and San Antonio.
  82. But they're, yeah, it's like plus 900, if I recall. So they're not like heavy people.
  83. Plus 900. Yeah, so they're not. Nick's not in the top three. Very interesting. I think they may be tied.
  84. I think they may be plus 900, 950 or something like that. It's really close. Oh, sorry.
  85. Go ahead. Eric, go ahead, please. I was going to ask you, Dean, so a couple things.
  86. One is people have said for the last 20 years that the real LeBron is a pass-first guy.
  87. So we're going to find that out, right? I mean, we're going to find out if point guard LeBron, because by the way, the
  88. article that I read today, statement by LeBron says he plans on playing point forward.
  89. He wants the ball in his hands. They're going to have Maxie off the ball. They're going to have Jalen Brown off the
  90. ball. So number one, do you believe that point guard LeBron is the true LeBron? And number two, my major concern, because I've
  91. seen the Sixers disastrous at this over the last 10 years, which of these guys is
  92. getting the ball at the end of the game? Yeah, you're getting at something that is very
  93. important. So how are these guys going to handle the ball? I tend to agree that LeBron is the
  94. best decision maker of the whole group. He doesn't have tunnel vision. He does know how to create for other
  95. people. But part of what his mechanism was for creating shots for other players was that he
  96. himself was a shooting rat. And he's not as quick as he used to be. He's not as able to finish around the
  97. rim. He was maybe the best finisher at the rim of anybody who didn't just play center
  98. and had dunks every time. He's not going to have that anymore. But he is still, I think, young enough
  99. at 41, crazy enough, to be able to create some advantages. I don't know if he, I doubt he's
  100. going to be sitting in the post very much and creating from there. But they could experiment that if that's what
  101. they will find out. So I can see some of those kind of things happening, for sure.
  102. I think Maxey probably can make some decisions. What's interesting is, you talked about end of
  103. the game, who has the ball in their hand. Well, it's also who can make the shot if it's passed to him, too.
  104. Because if you look at the catch and shoot numbers, catch and shoot numbers are pretty
  105. good for Maxey. They're pretty good for LeBron, actually. But he's not going to be passing and
  106. catching and shooting to himself. Someone else has to pass it to him. Someone else has to make that pass.
  107. Edgecombe is pretty good. But actually, Jalen Brown is not that great at catch and shoot.
  108. Joel Embiid is not that great at catch and shoot. So there's some complex dynamics about how that
  109. ball is going to move in critical times and, I think, regular times. So, Dean, let me follow up real quickly
  110. on behalf of you, Eric, real quick. Eric has a big man theory in basketball, which I think goes back to Patrick Ewing
  111. and the Knicks. My version of the theory is, if your best player is your big man, you're going
  112. to lose at critical moments. You're disadvantaged at the end of game, critical moments, end of game.
  113. Do I have that right, Eric? Yeah. I mean, Dean, my theory is very simple. If your best man is, let's say it's
  114. Joel Embiid, if you want to claim that. You trap the ball in the backcourt. So now by the time they get over
  115. the line, it's 17 seconds. You front them big man in the post. By the time you weave it around to
  116. him, it's five seconds, six seconds. Now you've got a one-dimensional big man who can only do one or two things.
  117. There really aren't many options. So I've always said that having a big man as your best offensive choice at the
  118. end of the game is not good. That's always been my theory. So two questions for you, Dean.
  119. You know more about basketball than all the rest of us combined and more. So your take on the theory as a
  120. standalone, and then to what extent does it apply to the Sixers? Does it differently apply to the Sixers now
  121. with currently constituted? In general versus the Sixers. OK, in general, I think basketball is a
  122. dynamic game. Things have changed a lot. I think, of course, if you go back to the 80s when you had Kareem Abdul
  123. -Jabbar scoring on the low post, he was the primary option. They won championships with him doing that.
  124. That's going back a ways. I think what happens with basketball, things do kind of come and go.
  125. And what we have right now is we have a very well-spaced game. You can't just collapse in the post.
  126. Like a guy who does that, you have to stay attached to shooters. So it's very hard to kind of double
  127. team him. You can front, but it gets risky to do that now because there is so much
  128. spacing. You can't leave that weak side shooter. So it's difficult. Going through Embiid, so Embiid has kind of
  129. gravitated a little bit, at least, from kind of the low post a little bit more to the high post, too, which is, frankly,
  130. easier to get the ball to him there in a lot of situations, too. You're not going to be slowing yourself down.
  131. The double team options there get a little bit tricky for a defense. So I would imagine they will do some
  132. stuff with him, and they'll do handoffs stuff from him. They'll have pick and rolls at the top.
  133. And he'll catch and shoot, and he'll probably hand it off and have some fakes, handoffs,
  134. and go to the rim, that kind of thing. I think that's, the middle of the floor is very powerful right now.
  135. So you can have a post who is that for Philly. I think they just, I don't think it's
  136. going to be a traditional right on the box. Eric, you began your question. I'll cut you off from here.
  137. You've got another question, at least. No, I was going to ask Dean whether he thinks the Sixers are a good enough
  138. three-point shooting team to contend in the NBA. I don't consider Jalen Brown a great three
  139. -point shooter. He's adequate. Maxie is slightly above average. Edgecombe, we only have one year of data.
  140. He seems reasonable, but he's no Steph Curry. No one's Steph Curry, but he's not a
  141. great three-point shooter. Embiid is definitely, I mean, he's good enough for a big man that he can, he
  142. creates a threat. And, you know, so I don't see the Sixers as a great three-point shooting team.
  143. So does that put them at a major disadvantage? I think it's going to put them at
  144. a minor disadvantage, not a major disadvantage, because they're not terrible. And it is one of those skills.
  145. A couple of years ago when I was at Sloan and with Ben Alomar, we actually did a paper kind of looking at how
  146. long it takes for players to get familiar with each other. In terms of that catch and shoot shot,
  147. a lot of those are three-point shots. And teams do get better. Players get used to where that pass is
  148. coming from, speed at which it's coming, whether they should be like right, like in line
  149. with the box at the three-point line in the corner or a little bit higher, all of these kinds of things.
  150. There is this familiarity process that improves shooting by quite a bit, several percentage points.
  151. So it's not trivial. Over the course of a season? Over the course of a season. What happens, it definitely starts off low when
  152. guys haven't played much together, and then it grows over the course of months. And it's an important feature.
  153. Well, let me ask you a related question about concerns. I don't consider LeBron a great defensive player
  154. anymore. Jalen Brown can be a good defensive player if that's the part of the game he
  155. decides to focus on. Maxie and Edgecombe are undersized guards now in the NBA. Certainly no one thinks of Tyrese Maxie as
  156. the Michael Jordan of defense. And B has no lift whatsoever anymore. Basically can't get off the ground.
  157. Maybe he'll show up healthy this year. Won't this team give up 115 points a game?
  158. I think there is a risk on the defensive side. This is where I can see Nick Nurse
  159. pulling his hair out a bit. There's usually an assignment where you have to defend the opponent's best player.
  160. And a lot of times you have a wing who's assigned to that point guard who can initiate those actions and make the passes
  161. out of that. I don't know who that's exactly going to be. I think Brown can do that for a
  162. while. He has done that in the past. Last year he got away from it because he was the scoring threat for sure.
  163. But he's not that guy who that is his personality. He's going into trying this major extension.
  164. He's trying to get a major extension. You think he's going to get it just by being that guy?
  165. All right. Adi's got one. Yeah, so I mean actually that's my— just to follow up on that.
  166. You have a guy like Jalen Brown. I mean if you want to push people to give up offense for defense, isn't that
  167. something that has to happen? I mean they get exhausted if they work too hard on defense and therefore they have
  168. to pull back on offense. You can't—it's not—those two things are free lunch. So you have all these stars who's going
  169. to play hard on defense and you wonder whether that's going to be any of these guys.
  170. And I don't—I mean Jalen Brown, yeah exactly. Who might be the person who's willing to
  171. give up? Is it LeBron? I don't think physically LeBron can do it. Like no. I think he tries.
  172. I think when he's motivated, when he gets to the playoffs, he's going to try. But he's not—he was one of the best
  173. defenders we ever did see too. So he's coming down from that peak. I don't—when he cares, I think he's still
  174. average. But there are significant times when you're watching him and he's not really caring.
  175. He is leaking out in hopes of transition and have a bunch of transition guys there.
  176. But that's not helping the defense. Well it's probably hard to discern not caring
  177. from preserving energy, right? At 41, he's got to like—it's like running a long distance race where you can only
  178. set that pace so high if you plan on finishing the race. By the way, Adi, my thoughts have been
  179. to your point, and Dean can comment on this too, it may not be any of the starters.
  180. Might be Anthony Simons, might be Dean Wade, might be Kentavious Caldwell-Pope. So actually some of the players that they've
  181. signed this year, forget about LeBron and Jalen Brown for a second, are more known for—not
  182. Anthony Simons, but more Dean Wade. He's no good at defense. But Dean Wade and certainly Kentavious Caldwell-Pope,
  183. that you might have a better defensive team in the second five unit than you will
  184. with the starting five unit. I always find it very interesting that people don't realize that points saved on defense matter
  185. as much as points earned on offense. I mean, it's symmetric, right? So I had Pope—Kentavious Caldwell-Pope when he
  186. was in D.C. Good guy, definitely. I enjoyed having him around a lot. He does work.
  187. He is a bit older now, though, too. And it's been a few years since he was able to, like, put all his skills
  188. to use on that side of the floor. I hope he still has it because he's someone I can root for.
  189. But yeah, okay. So you got Dean Wade, and then some question marks. Dean, let's use Jalen Brown, the trade, the
  190. discussion around the trade to get a window into analytics these days. What was your position?
  191. There was this big brouhaha over whether Brown was overvalued, undervalued by the Celtics when they
  192. moved him. And there was all this analytics. Analytics say this, analytics say that.
  193. That he's not the big player that you'd think based on his MVPs. Where were you on that debate?
  194. And what do we learn about analytics, like the cutting edge of analytics in basketball these
  195. days from that debate? So let me step back from the question a little bit and just kind of, let
  196. me say it's the metrics as opposed to analytics. Because analytics is this whole process of asking
  197. questions, the data and testing it, which can go well beyond how good a player is.
  198. And effectively, player metrics are what are being tested here. How good is he? How good will he be?
  199. That's a great refinement, Dean. Thank you. Yeah, it's relevant because I don't want anybody
  200. to look at analytics as only being about player metrics. There is so much more than it does.
  201. So with Brown, we had people at ESPN who came out and said this was a terrible trade for the Celtics.
  202. I definitely disagreed. I thought Jaylen Brown is a good player, not a great player.
  203. He was getting paid like a great, he is getting paid like a great player. And I think that's always a challenge.
  204. If you're getting paid like a great player and you only perform at a good player
  205. level, that's very risky. And if there is a market out there where you can get a couple first round
  206. picks in return, that's not a bad thing. People didn't like the trade because they thought
  207. he could be, he could get more than those first round picks that they got. That's not what the market said.
  208. Okay. So that's kind of the general perspective. Analytically, there are a number of things that
  209. Brown didn't do as well as Stars. And I always have to couch this argument that way because it sometimes comes out and
  210. says, implies that he's bad. He's not bad. He's not bad. He's just, he tends to turn the ball
  211. over a lot. He tends to, he's not a great shooter. He's an okay shooter. He shot below the league average this year.
  212. Even when you account for threes and these sorts. I did a comparison of him to 33
  213. other high usage guys who basically averaged 33 % of the team's possessions or more over
  214. the last five, six years, I think it was. And among those 33 players, he was one
  215. of the worst shooters. He was one of the worst turnover guys. Yeah, he certainly produced a lot of points.
  216. He was actually below average in assists too. So some of the major stats that you
  217. would look at that you would hope be somewhat efficient while he's using all the possessions,
  218. he was below average. Now you're comparing it to a lot of great players, but not all those great players
  219. made the all-star game. Not all of those players. Yeah, a lot of them actually didn't make
  220. all NBA. So there's all these metrics that you can dive into. The player metrics try to capture a lot
  221. of those things. And you try to explain what's in there. And in the end, it said, there's just
  222. not a lot of components. The major component is he scored a lot of points because he used a lot of
  223. possessions. So Dean, the Sixers know this. It's not like Bob Myers and they don't
  224. have analytics people there. So there's a couple of theories, and just tell me. One could be that they don't use metrics
  225. in that way. The second could be, well, that was when he was on the team, maybe without Jason
  226. Tatum because of injury. Or maybe he'll be better with the group of players the Sixers have.
  227. Or it could be that's the old Jalen Brown, but there's going to be, you know, we'll use statistical terms.
  228. There's some change point and there'll be the new Jalen Brown. What do you think?
  229. I mean, you don't know, I don't know. But what do you think they could have been thinking?
  230. Because they can do, I'm sure they did that same type of analysis. Yeah, what you're doing when you have trades
  231. is you're trying also to kind of maximize a window that you may have for winning.
  232. And there is definitely a window that's going on here right now in Philadelphia.
  233. Joel Embiid is aging. He's aged badly since he was 18, effectively. But you have that.
  234. Tyrese Maxey is very, very good right now. I think they were looking for a way, like, can we go all in about now?
  235. I think that's part of it. Plus they had, when they made the trade, they were also trading away Paul George, who
  236. does get paid a lot too. Not as much, I think it's a little bit less. And also for shorter time.
  237. But, like, they are, so they're making that decision too, that Paul George can't help them
  238. as much as Jalen Brown in this chase to maximize the window that they have, for sure.
  239. And they were looking at these two first round picks, and they have a lot of protection with at least one of them, that,
  240. like, okay, that's down the road. We want to win during, they're probably beyond
  241. the window that we are aiming at. So there's a timing aspect to this also. Dean, the other thing it seems to me
  242. that's in here is the all-elusive chemistry and fit. And from a modeling perspective, we're talking about
  243. interactions. So it's one thing to value Jalen from, you know, his personal metrics, but then there's
  244. always the question, it's like, what's his impact on other players? And this is elusive across all of our
  245. sports, but I feel like basketball has made more progress than, say, football. You've got fewer free variables to play with.
  246. So where is analytics on fit and chemistry and these kinds of interactions that are so
  247. hard to get? We think are there, and people talk about all the time, but they're hard to model.
  248. We know it's real, and you can measure it in extreme situations. Obviously, you're not putting five centers on the
  249. floor because they don't, like they don't, none of them can handle the ball. So you find these occasional situations where, okay,
  250. we put the wrong guy that they don't really fit. Sure out there. So you can see it in the extreme
  251. cases. When you're actually looking for it in data, it gets much more tricky because it basically
  252. you're looking at this interaction term between two players. And is it positive?
  253. But is it negative? What's your sense of whether executives, how often is an executive able to suss that out
  254. intuitively? Because that's their job. Historically, that was like what they did.
  255. Judging horse flesh, but also this horse, effect on this horse. And this is how you justify, this is
  256. the rhetoric, and this is actually some of the thinking on how you justify, like the
  257. Ravens paying Roquan Smith to play middle linebacker at a full free agent price at a
  258. not a very high value position because he's supposed to make everybody else better.
  259. And he probably does. But I'm guessing executives get that wrong about as often as they get it right.
  260. Have you been around some folks who you think, yeah, they're pretty good at sussing that
  261. out. They're better than my model at sussing that out. I can't say I've seen a situation where
  262. they're better at it than models. And I can't say models are very good at it either.
  263. What I would say is people are pretty good at observing what is happening, but not
  264. necessarily predicting what will happen in this kind of situation too. In the case where you're trying to make
  265. a trade for a Jalen Brown, maybe you think he is going to fit. Making that prediction is quite hard.
  266. You can look at the data, and we have data. I looked at some of the Jalen Brown fit slash synergy, however you want to call
  267. it, label it, with the Boston Celtics. And there was a couple of cases where he was negative.
  268. I think he hurt Peyton Pritchard's performance, for instance. But there wasn't anything standing out as positive.
  269. When he and Jason Tatum played together, there might have been a little bit of negative
  270. aspect there too. There's this negative side too. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that can happen for sure.
  271. Yeah, it's hard to see, and it's easier to see than it is to predict. So let me ask you a question, Dean.
  272. Maybe it's obvious to everybody else on this podcast but me. So am I correct that Jalen Brown has
  273. never played with Tyrese Maxey, or Fiji Edgecombe, or LeBron James, or Joel Embiid, right?
  274. So normally to measure interaction effects, it might be helpful to have observations of the people
  275. actually together. So is this like a characteristics-based approach? Like we describe each player by a set
  276. of characteristics, and we see what combination of characteristics tend to work well?
  277. I just want to make sure we're all talking about how you might actually model interactions
  278. like this. Yes, that is one way to do it. Basically, you have a set of skills, and
  279. do they complement each other? We have a decent enough model of basketball where you can put that together.
  280. That is one approach that is quite hard. Another approach that is quite hard is basically
  281. looking for this interaction term between players, looking for how well they complement each other.
  282. Do they play? The classic example, I mean, frankly, was Steph, Klay, and Draymond.
  283. Those guys, when they were on the floor together, their individual performance numbers all went up.
  284. When any one of them was off, it went down. When two of the other guys were off,
  285. it went down even more. So, you can look at it those kind of ways. So, Dean, this ties into your saying that
  286. you can see it and describe it better than you can predict it, because the prediction
  287. is probably going to be based on some feature-based model. The actual thing is going to be an
  288. individual thing, and you have to do that. Are they going to have the same features
  289. in this system as they did in that system? Real quickly, last one, just to educate us
  290. on basketball, we're always looking to learn a little bit more. You just gave a classic example of a
  291. three-player interaction. Tell us what that means in basketball terms. Why were Steph, Klay, and Draymond creating positive
  292. synergies for each other on the court? Give us some of the reasons for that. Yeah, so the reasons, there was one aspect
  293. is the fact that they came together at the right time, when the league was not quite ready for the way the Warriors played.
  294. Steve Kerr came in in 2015, I believe it was, and he let those guys play the way they wanted to play, kind of
  295. what we're talking about for the Sixers to experiment with. And they played on the perimeter.
  296. In a time where defenses were still protecting the paint first, and some of them really
  297. still are, these were guys where you have to take care of the perimeter first. And they ran a ton of stuff, and
  298. Draymond Green was totally unselfish for that. He's actually much better at making that pass
  299. to the perimeter than he is to making the pass to the interior. And so they had a matchup advantage due
  300. to the timing of the era of basketball, but they also had this advantage that their
  301. two best scorers scored from the perimeter. It was just, that's part of it. The other aspect, there was a defensive side
  302. too, which is that Draymond Green knew how to, he is one of the best communicators.
  303. You will see on the defensive side of the floor, he tells guys where to go. He makes it easier for them.
  304. And frankly, the Warriors bought into another aspect that was not totally innovative, but they were
  305. ahead of the game on, they would switch. So anybody can guard anybody else. And Draymond was particularly good at calling out
  306. switches and helping those guys go where they needed to go. Dean, let me just build one last question
  307. on what Shane's earlier comment was when you were talking about the odds, plus 900.
  308. How plausible is it? I'm not asking you to predict necessarily what's going to happen, but how plausible is it
  309. that the Sixers, who have now a bunch of players, certainly LeBron, Jalen Brown coming in,
  310. who have never played together, that they're going to be better than the Spurs, OKC, or
  311. possibly even the Knicks? Like I understand people want to say, well, they have a great starting five.
  312. I don't know. OKC has more depth and talent than any team. They've got more first round draft picks coming
  313. in. The Knicks just won the title, beat the Spurs. So I'm saying, let me ask it in
  314. a very specific way. Let's imagine Eric Bradlow builds a probability model that says the 76ers are the favorites.
  315. What would you say is the face validity of that model, given your experience? I would be highly dubious.
  316. Highly dubious. I, it's, you use the word better, and we do have to be careful with the
  317. word better here too, because I think if I recall correctly, the Vegas odds actually have
  318. the Sixers as the favorite in the East to get to the finals, but actually I think third or fourth best record in the
  319. East. So what is better is relevant here. What are they, everybody's looking at them and
  320. saying, they're trying to maximize the playoffs. They are, they're willing to, they just want
  321. to make an easy regular season run to get their 50 wins, get the top four seed, that kind of thing.
  322. But they're going to save it for the playoffs. And that is very tricky to model.
  323. Frankly, it's one of the things I'm thinking about on my end a lot. How do we model that one better?
  324. All right, Adi, last word. Got to be quick here. I'll be very quick here. But my understanding is that NBA teams do
  325. not even devote that much time to practicing together. They just play, which would mean that it's
  326. compounded, unless I'm kind of wrong on that score. When do they have time for this?
  327. These guys are superstars. Do they get together and practice all winter? So I can tell you what's going to
  328. happen right now in August. So beginning in August, you're going to have all of these guys show up without being
  329. required to in Philadelphia, and they're going to play some pickup. There's not going to be any active coaching
  330. going on. And they're going to start feeling each other out at that point for who they are.
  331. And then through training camp, you'll get a lot of that time in. And then, yeah, once the regular season goes,
  332. those games are going to end up acting as a lot of practice. All right. That's exciting.
  333. Eric, please call your buddies, Josh and David. Round us up some tickets for those preseason
  334. scrimmages. We'd enjoy that. And we'll report back on how that goes, Dean. Thanks for pointing that out to us.
  335. Dean Oliver, always a pleasure. You guys track his work down. Most recent book just out, I think last
  336. fall, Basketball Beyond Paper, a sequel of sorts to his path-breaking Basketball on Paper.
  337. Dean, doing the good work at ESPN. Always a pleasure. Good luck to you, Dean. Great seeing you guys.
  338. Great to see you. All right. That has been the first half of this week's Wharton Money Ball.
  339. Come back and join us after the break. Welcome to the second half of this week's
  340. show. After a full discussion with Dean Oliver, our longtime friend about basketball, come away smarter about
  341. basketball. Dean's always a pleasure to talk to. We're going to dive right in to a
  342. little bit of baseball. We have some other topics to cover, but we're going to lose Adi momentarily because he's
  343. teaching out on the West Coast. And Adi wanted to talk Hall of Fame. Eric made his annual family pilgrimage to the
  344. Baseball Hall of Fame ceremonies this past weekend, I believe. We got a few texts about it.
  345. And Ad, why don't you start us off with whatever you want to know from Eric and his pilgrimage?
  346. Well, I mean, what's interesting, of course, is the hoopla around the Hall of Fame.
  347. And do you get any sense when you're there why Baseball Hall of Fame is just so much more of a thing than the
  348. other Hall of Fames? That you have people like you doing this. I mean, maybe you have people like you
  349. in other sports, but it just doesn't feel like it's the same. Yeah, I mean, to me, it's just about,
  350. it's the history of baseball. And, you know, when you're at the Hall of Fame building itself, that's where Babe Ruth
  351. gave his speech. And that's where Ted Williams gave his speech. And that's where Mickey Mantle gave his speech.
  352. And that's where Ty Cobb gave his speech. And so the amazing thing is that, you know, you can watch video of each of
  353. them giving their speech and you can stand right where they stand. And then now they've moved it about a
  354. mile away to the Clark Sports Center. But, you know, I don't know another Hall of Fame.
  355. Maybe they do. I'm sure they, obviously, they're returning Hall of Famers in other sports.
  356. But, you know, when you have Sandy Koufax returning to the Hall of Fame and you're
  357. thinking, this guy has been in the Hall of Fame for 54 years. And I'm going to tell you, looking at
  358. him, I'm predicting at least another 10. This man looks fantastic. I'm going to tell you, if there's something
  359. wrong with Sandy Koufax, he's hiding it extraordinarily well. The other interesting stat, Adi, I know you
  360. have to run. So Raleigh Fingers has just came to his 34th consecutive ceremony, which is only second to
  361. Bob Feller, who came to 38 consecutive. And Raleigh Fingers is not that old. So, I mean, and he looks damn good.
  362. So, you know, I think it's those kind of stories. And the wonderful thing about the Hall of
  363. Fame is they do such a wonderful job telling the stories of the Hall of Fame. And the woman that's the chairperson of the
  364. Hall of Fame, Jane Forbes Clark, grandfather, started the Hall of Fame. So she always gives like a 10-minute
  365. speech talking about her grandfather and who started the Hall of Fame and was in the
  366. first class and was inviting them back. It's these stories are just incredible. To me, I think people that lived baseball
  367. like you and I do, Adi, look, I love the NFL. I love the NBA, love tennis, golf.
  368. Baseball's just different. It's just different. It's different, especially when you're there with your
  369. kids. Because, you know, someday, Adi, I assume, you know, I'll be gone. And I hope my kids continue to go
  370. to Cougar Town every year. Well, I'm going to just summarize by saying I think that baseball has a connection to
  371. the history, has historical connections much deeper and longer than the sports. It was invented in the mid-19th century.
  372. And it's also very deeply tied up to American history. One of the things that I talk about,
  373. and when we had Professor Henkinen from Berkeley talking about baseball, you know, sport was only
  374. a thing of the upper crust because they're the only ones who had time. Everyone else worked and there was no time
  375. for games. And baseball was brought to the United States as well as soccer to England right around
  376. the time where people were starting to have free time. Yes, Adi, let me just add one other
  377. thing. One other thing they did that was really neat at this year, I know you have
  378. to run and go teach. You may remember this. This is the 50th anniversary. Since this is the 250th anniversary of America,
  379. they celebrated a very interesting thing at the Hall of Fame this year. You probably remember this, Adi.
  380. Do you remember when Rick Monday prevented two people that had jumped out of the stands
  381. during a Dodger game? They were going to burn a flag on the field. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
  382. And so Rick Monday, who was there, he was there at Cooperstown, celebrated all the Hall
  383. of Famers, stood up and cheered him. They showed a video of him grabbing the flag that had been doused in oil or
  384. lighter fluid. And they made a special deal. It was the 50th anniversary. And Rick Monday, by the way, you may
  385. not know, he was the number one pick in the draft. Didn't play for six years because he was
  386. in the Air Force. So he talked about it. He came up to the podium and said, you think I was going to let them
  387. burn the American flag? So they even did that right. And also our buddy who had been on
  388. the show, Josh Trowick, the president of the Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, gives a
  389. great speech about the importance of the Hall of Fame. And it's a museum too. It's the history of the game.
  390. So they just do everything. My cousin, my first cousin who came to us had never been to the Hall of
  391. Fame, never. He said, of all the ceremonies he's ever been to, they did this one right.
  392. Great. All right, Odd. Odd, he's slipping back to the classroom out in San Francisco in the shadow of the
  393. Bay Bridge. Eric, anything else from your notebook about your family trip, your annual family pilgrimage to the
  394. Hall of Fame? I just think what's funny is it's clear to the fans who the first tier, you
  395. know, we always talk about this first tier, second tier, third tier. So when players, when they announced the returning
  396. Hall of Famers, and by the way, I was so happy that it was the largest returning class in the history of the Hall
  397. of Fame. So 60 Hall of Famers were there, six zero. That's a big number given there's only been
  398. 270 players that have ever been there, and 60 were there. All the way from, you know, Sandy Koufax,
  399. the oldest, to if you'd like the newest being the three new members, but even last
  400. year, Ichiro. Like people literally stand, like when Ken Griffey's announced, people stand and cheer.
  401. When, I hate to say it, when Big Poppy was announced, people stand and cheer. Sorry, Shane.
  402. You hate to say it, I mean, you know. Well, I'm saying Derek Jeter, you know, you
  403. know, that these are the, you know, Greg Maddox. These are the immortals, 355, and the beautiful
  404. thing they did. Are you putting Big Poppy in this upper tier of the Hall of Fame?
  405. No, not that tier, but. You have to norm, you have to norm the applause for the recency.
  406. Yeah, but I'm saying. If you norm for recency, then you'd get it. They literally stand.
  407. I don't know if you've seen that with Jeter, but okay. They also have a great announcer.
  408. The guy, Brian Kenney, who's the lead announcer on the MLB network, is the MC. And so as each Hall of Famer comes
  409. out, besides video on the screen, he gives a 30 second like, now coming out as Sandy Koufax, inducted in 1970, blah, blah, blah,
  410. blah. And then the whole crowd just rises. And you know, I hate to say it, but when Alan Trammell's announced, you know, there's
  411. nice applause. I mean, you know, Alan Trammell's not getting the same thing as like.
  412. But then you got, you know, when Rod Carew comes out, George Brett, you know, the
  413. Ironman, Cal Ripken. I mean, it's just an incredible experience. And of course, for me, you know, it
  414. reminds me of my dad when we used to go to games. You know, my dad grew up in Philadelphia.
  415. My dad used to tell a story. My dad was born in 1920. He said one of the first games he
  416. went to saw the Yankees play the A's. Lou Gehrig, Babe Ruth, and Jimmy Fox were on the field.
  417. So I mean, it doesn't get better than that. I like that you've kind of created this
  418. nascent field of Hall of Fame ceremony analytics where we look at the, how predictive or
  419. how correlated is Hall of Fame kind of tier with applause at the Hall of Fame. Yes, it's entirely possible.
  420. We could record. We've already talked about some outliers. We've got, you know, I mean, at least
  421. in your mind, Big Papi, disproportionate applause. We could, you could have. He was a fan.
  422. He was always a fan favorite, right? He was a fan favorite. You can find out affection is different from
  423. performance on the field. Some guys stand out in that way. But clearly there's no doubt.
  424. Sandy Koufax, like they literally just let the applause go for like five minutes.
  425. It was just, that was just incredible. That's great. Good fun. You know, these, we should know what is
  426. different about different sports and baseball has the corner on history. There's no, no question about it.
  427. The other thing is also, it makes you reflect on this year's class, which I consider
  428. a particularly weak class. But, you know, you did have Jeff Kent. He's got something going for him.
  429. He's got the most home runs ever by a second baseman. That's something, you know, you have Andrew Jones
  430. is there's only three players in major league history that have 10 golden gloves in center
  431. field and a 400 home runs. So he's one of them along with Willie Mays and Ken Griffey.
  432. That's worth something. And, you know, um, you know, so, you know, Both of those are, those are both
  433. big things. You just said. I'm just saying as the hall of fame grows, it can only get harder and harder
  434. to stand out versus the hall of fame, you know, right. Just so you know, next year we're looking,
  435. maybe people are saying if he's a first ballot, Buster Posey, and then maybe Chase Utley
  436. in his like eighth year, but let me just say it ain't murderers row going into the hall of fame next year.
  437. Okay. Let's, let's not, let's not move this conversation into next year. I know we're going to have time for
  438. forecasting that. I want to go one of two directions and they're both connected in a way.
  439. Let's go, let's go in the snarky direction. Did y'all notice today was a day, a notable day in college football.
  440. This was like the beginning of jersey patches in college football. It's happened.
  441. They've had the ability to put jersey patches in college football. I think the requirement, the restriction is they
  442. can have up to two sponsors, no more than four square inches each. I believe the big 12 announced a deal
  443. earlier this summer. The big 12 got something like $20 million from an outfit called Monster Energy to sponsor
  444. every team, all 16 of them in the big 12. And then, oh my goodness. I mean, we live in a tacky world.
  445. That's all right. That's tacky. That's tacky. That's July. Now we're still in July, aren't we?
  446. Just two weeks later, big announcement this morning. Ohio State has a deal with, get this
  447. guys, JP Morgan, JP Morgan Chase. Chase is the patch, has a deal for 16 million, all 36 varsity sports at Ohio
  448. State with the possible add-ons like NIL, internships, all that kind of stuff. So it's one team, $16 million, all programs.
  449. Hey, can I be, just for a second, let me be a quantitative marketing scholar, which
  450. is what I do in my daytime job. Is this an opportunity to start measuring the effectiveness of sponsorship?
  451. Because in theory, we will have, like, JP Morgan Chase is at Ohio State. We could measure the DMA in the area.
  452. We could see if there's local effects of having those patches. We could try to see if distance from
  453. Ohio State matters. We could start to see, you know, I'll make it up. Texas has, I'm making this up entirely, has
  454. American Express, but this team has Ohio, the Ohio State has this. I think there will be a large number
  455. of academic quantitative marketing scholars studying patches and their impact on awareness, sales, and all kinds
  456. of- Precisely because you get this, but hold on, Shane, because you get this geographic
  457. and time-varying introduction. So it's like exactly what you want. Look, we've talked about this a lot.
  458. You need variation. This is exactly the kind of, now let me just comment. It's probably not random variation because JP Morgan
  459. Chase isn't randomly selecting teams, but at least it's variation. Yeah, Shane, I'm sorry, go ahead.
  460. Well, I was just saying, I was just kind of going, upon glibly that as the amount of marketing we're exposed to is increasing
  461. geometrically, the amount of marketing scholars we need is also increasing geometrically.
  462. So I guess there's some good news in all that there. So scholar per exposure? I was interested in like, I've watched like
  463. a lot of soccer out with people over the last, you know, a couple months. And it's always fascinating to me that the
  464. jerseys that when you buy like a jersey for a soccer team, like it comes with like the ad, like whatever ad the athletes
  465. has to wear. Like the jerseys that you're buying is also like, so you're purchasing this $100 jersey that
  466. is also an ad for some random company. Like, you know, like an airline or something
  467. like that. It's just so odd to me. So we are squarely, that's what I mean, college football, just, you know, every corner is
  468. being monetized. But so just to add a little flavor to this story, Ohio State now announces this
  469. sometime this morning. Notre Dame announced it like two hours later. Notre Dame, patch, SoFi, I think it's $20
  470. billion. $20 billion, 18 to 20, something like that. So they topped Ohio State. Ohio State had the top number for like
  471. 90 minutes. And then Notre Dame comes in, SoFi. And pricelessly and predictably, there was somebody on
  472. Twitter as soon as Ohio State announced that said, oh, frigging Buckeye's selling out.
  473. Notre Dame would never do that. And it didn't take an hour for that to be proven.
  474. Anyways, it's notable. You know, it is, I mean, it's college athletics, but it's also business.
  475. And when he started throwing in JP Morgan, you're talking about, you know, they hire a
  476. bunch of our students and that's squarely our world. And it's like, that's an interesting intersection.
  477. It's just continuing to drive these things together. Okay, that was one possible connection to Hall
  478. of Fame in that it's the opposite of cherishing your history and keeping it pristine like
  479. baseball does. But in the direction of Hall of Fame, this is not a novel topic now.
  480. Two days after Jackson Coven won the PGA, the three-in tournament this weekend in his
  481. third start ever, he's just blown up in the last few days. I've named this guy to y'all a
  482. couple of times over the last couple of years because- Oh, and who came in second again, Cade?
  483. Yeah, Scotty Shuffler came in second again. So this is Eric's hypothesis that Scotty's now
  484. a number two guy, a runner-up guy. So Jackson Coven- Every week on Scotty Shuffler.
  485. That's not the last time we hear that one. I can assure you. Exactly second, Shane.
  486. Not win case or show, exactly second. That's where you've got- You're a precise guy.
  487. Shane, Shane, everybody's getting the big story wrong. People think it's Jackson Coven.
  488. No, it's Scotty Shuffler coming in second again. That's the big story. Five seconds this year.
  489. Let's see you do that. So just a couple of things. We're 48 hours late on this, but Coven
  490. was one of the biggest amateurs we've ever had. He helped Auburn win, I think, two titles.
  491. And certainly this past year, he won a bunch of tournament titles himself. He earned enough points.
  492. The PGA has this system where if you win enough, do well enough as an amateur, you can earn points and qualify.
  493. And it usually takes a lot of years to do that. He earned them by the end of his
  494. sophomore year. He could have turned pro after a sophomore year. He declined. He didn't think he was mature enough yet
  495. in whatever way. Went back to Auburn his junior year, won the national championship.
  496. He qualified again. I think he would have qualified based on just those 12 months worth of points.
  497. Just his junior year, he qualified to go to- So now he has twice as many points as he needed.
  498. He came on third start. Wins this thing going away. Won it going away. Strong field, multiple major winners.
  499. Apparently, according to DataGolf, DataGolf has been keeping amateur rankings since 2010.
  500. So whatever that is, 16, 17 years worth of amateur rankings. And he has the highest ranking ever among
  501. amateurs. He's no longer an amateur. But when he left amateur-ness, and the next two guys were Jordan Spieth and Jon
  502. Rahm. They've done okay. So coming out of, with the history they had at that point in their career, this
  503. guy is in that territory and even slightly ahead of that territory. So big name to keep track of.
  504. So if one, I mean, like I assume though we all agree, like if we were going to put a confidence interval on this
  505. guy on any reasonable thing you might want to predict, like total PGA wins or majors,
  506. you just have to put even, I mean, you would put it, obviously, maybe considerably higher
  507. than the average person that joins the PGA tour. But it would have to be extraordinarily wide,
  508. right? I mean, this guy may never win a major. It's just hard to know. That's a great point.
  509. I mean, who foolishly would try to forecast the majors of any individual? Who would do that?
  510. Who would take up that exercise? That's the kind of thing we do all the time. Eric is saying the following.
  511. Eric's saying, yeah, yeah, this guy's got a higher mean than the typical amateur that goes
  512. pro, but you still don't know. Even with the higher mean, you're just like wildly uncertain what he's going to actually do.
  513. And that's a very fair point. Yep. This kind of makes me wonder whether the, like what the correlation is between kind of
  514. amateur rankings in golf and how people actually do in their career. I mean, we obviously ruminate on this like
  515. every week in football, right? And, you know, like how predictive the draft is from actual NFL performance.
  516. There you've got the additional confounded factor of the person drafted goes to a team, which
  517. can be like that's essentially added randomness, essentially. In golf, maybe you don't have that added
  518. randomness. It stays an individual thing. That's right. So maybe the correlation is tighter.
  519. And even the competition in some cases is identical. Like you see amateurs play in professional fields.
  520. I had a bit of this conversation with Rufus, our friend and my collaborator, former student,
  521. Rufus Peabody, a golf analyst and better with the British Open this year. I was asking him, this was just kind
  522. of text and then on the passing, so I didn't get details. We're like, how much trouble do you have
  523. forecasting amateurs when they haven't played a lot? Like you're going to, he's going to run
  524. numbers on everybody in the field. He's got to run numbers on an amateur. He was like not, he was not fussed
  525. about at all. I got data on those guys. Yeah, I have some numbers here. So here we go.
  526. So according to Golf Week, there's a correlation of about 0.45 between amateur rankings and
  527. professional earnings and wins. According to the World Amateur Golf Ranking, WAGR,
  528. the correlation is about 0.35. And according to Strokes Game Data, it's about 0.25.
  529. So people have done this analysis where they've taken amateur rankings and measured in certain ways
  530. and correlated it with certain outcomes, wins, strokes, gain, earnings. Eric, what was that?
  531. The first one you said was 0.45. What exactly was being correlated with the 0 .45?
  532. I'm guessing that's higher than Shane would have thought. It's higher than I would have thought.
  533. 0.45 is a serious correlation. I think it was amateur rankings and like earnings and wins.
  534. Like when they end their amateur, their peak, when they leave amateur status, what was their
  535. ranking? And then let's look at their career. Okay, Shane, how does 0.45 sound to
  536. you? I mean, that sounds high. I mean, certainly NFL would be way lower, right? I mean, you know, so yeah.
  537. No, I mean, that, you know, that, you know, I mean, you really wanted to kind of like go down this rabbit hole.
  538. You just want to start looking at that top end and all this type of stuff. But I think, you know, that's super interesting.
  539. And that is kind of, that's certainly high relative to me. Let's say it was a third just for
  540. a second. That would imply that if you just did a simple regression, you'd have an R squared
  541. of, you know, 0.1. And it probably means also, you know, if you included a bunch of other variables in there, its partial
  542. correlation is going to be considerably lower because there's all kinds of other things in there.
  543. But I agree with you. There's, that number's way high. No way. I'm not saying no way.
  544. I'm not saying no way. I mean, whether or not it's like the real number or whatever like that, it's a
  545. suitably high number that like, you know, I consider they're now empirical support to my hypothesis
  546. that the correlation is higher in like- Yeah, I mean, it's a different exercise than
  547. college football. It's individual play and they actually see them play on the exact same field sometimes.
  548. No interaction, no stacks of team, all that type of stuff. Yeah, all that stuff.
  549. That's right. That's right. Okay, guys, let's hit a little bit of baseball before we go.
  550. I see that someone's talking about Misoreski for Cy Young, we had a text thread a
  551. couple days ago where someone, what he else told me, I think what he all told me that Misoreski had like 12 Ks in
  552. five innings or something. He did, yeah. And what happened with that? That's ridiculous.
  553. Yeah, I mean, his strikeout rate is insane. Like, you know, he's kind of, in my mind, it's the Cy Youngs right now, kind
  554. of a two-horse race between Misorowski and Sanchez. Sanchez has actually, you know, pitched more innings,
  555. but Misorowski is like this, just an insanely high strikeout rate for, you know, what he's
  556. doing right now. Yeah, he's super impressive. Tell me something about Sanchez. Well, I mean, he had that scoreless innings
  557. streak. No, no, I need more basics than that. Where does he play? Where did he come from?
  558. What's going on? Well, Chris, he's a Phillies pitcher. So sorry, guys. No, no, I mean, he...
  559. Oh, Sanchez is that kid who, he had all those scoreless innings. He did. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that guy.
  560. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I will say, he then got rocked in the All-Star game and his first start
  561. after the All-Star game has not been particularly good. Let me just comment. But he had a tremendous first half of
  562. the season. But that's one or two starts. I'm just saying, let's hope he has a good second half of the season.
  563. Yeah, no, I mean, both of them, I would be surprised. You'd have to expect a lot of regression
  564. to the mean for both of them because an entire... Multiplying up either of their two first-half
  565. performances over a whole season would, I think, come close to historical, not just be kind
  566. of a Cy Young-type season. This is an Oddie question that he could answer off the top of his head, I
  567. suspect. But how much station, how much persistence do we see across starts for pitchers?
  568. Within a season, persistence. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And that's like, it's a version of Eric's
  569. momentum. Eric's always interested in momentum. This is related. We talk about golf having quite a bit
  570. of, you know, medium-term momentum. What do we see in baseball? Pitching. I don't want to speak for my Oddie,
  571. but my recollection of what he would say, I think, is that there's a lot of variation.
  572. Like, you know, that even the great pitchers bounce around quite a bit, you know, and
  573. every great pitcher has starts in a year like the one Sanchez just had. I mean, if you start stacking up those
  574. bad starts or less excellent starts, then we'll start kind of moving, I think, our image
  575. of his actual mean. But like, you know, I think it's, you know, well, there is a lot of variation
  576. start to start. Yeah, guys, I have to run, but I remember the context by which Oddie brought this
  577. up. You remember, Kay, the discussion was this idea of the second and third time through the
  578. lineup. And what Oddie pointed out was, yeah— Hold on. Make that observation. The claim was that pitchers are worse on
  579. the third time through. Once a batter has seen a pitcher three times, they are more effective against them.
  580. And Oddie kind of pooh-poohed that. He not only pooh-poohed that, but what he said is this high level of inter
  581. -game variation, which Shane correctly points it out. He said, yeah, but by the time someone's
  582. pitched a couple innings, you could tell whether this is the good hump or the bad
  583. hump. That's right. So, you know, it's not like— Yeah. So once you've observed somebody for a small
  584. number of innings, why are you—you know, you probably have a high chance that this is
  585. one of their good days. That was his point. You know, one of the great things about
  586. that from a behavioral perspective, unless you appreciate the inter— the intra-player, inter-game variation,
  587. you're going to underreact to those early draws. Exactly. You carry in your head this— there is
  588. this inter-game variation, intra-player, inter-game variation, then you're much more quick to react
  589. when you get that sample. But people don't carry around a lot of variants in their priors.
  590. And so they're not going to update appropriately. Okay. Eric's going to step away.
  591. So why don't we just wrap here? We had a long session with Dean. We'll let this one go.
  592. That is the whole show for Eric Bradlow, for Oddie Weiner, who was here for the most— most of the show, but not all
  593. the way. For Shane Jensen. For our boss lady, Dee Patel. Our producer, Jacob Grodnick.
  594. For all of you guys, the listeners, thanks for being here. Come back and join us next time.
  595. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Dean Oliver discusses LeBron James' impact on the 76ers, player dynamics, and basketball analytics.

Key points

  • LeBron Chooses the 76ers. LeBron James makes a surprising decision to join the Philadelphia 76ers, shaking up the NBA landscape.
  • Dean Oliver's Insights on Team Dynamics. Dean Oliver shares his thoughts on managing egos and shot distribution in a star-studded lineup.
  • Defensive Concerns for the 76ers. Dean Oliver highlights potential defensive challenges for the newly formed 76ers team.
  • The Analytics Debate on Jalen Brown. A discussion on whether Jalen Brown was overvalued or undervalued by the Celtics.
  • The Importance of Chemistry in Basketball. Exploring how player interactions impact team performance and analytics.
  • The Unique Experience of the Baseball Hall of Fame. Eric shares his insights on why the Baseball Hall of Fame stands out among others.

Episode highlights

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes