Banco Santander Leverages Mexican Subsidiary for a $4.3 Billion Stock Offer

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Last week, Spanish bank Banco Santander announced plans to use the recent strong financial performance of its Mexican unit as leverage to raise $4.3 billion in a stock offering -- the largest ever in Mexico's history. Part of a longer-term expansion plan in Latin America, the move is also designed to signal financial markets that the bank has high growth potential outside of its troubled home markets in Spain and the eurozone. In an interview, Wharton management professor Mauro Guillen and Adrian Tschoegl, a Wharton management lecturer, discuss how the deal fits in with Santander's master plan. The professors are authors of a book titled, Building a Global Bank: The Transformation of Banco Santander. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] we're speaking today with Wharton management Professor Maro Gan and Adrien
  2. chgo A Wharton lecture about Bano santand which has put out an offer for $25 % of the stock of its Mexican
  3. subsidiary a deal that's valued at about 4.3 billion the professors are authors of a book called building a Global Bank
  4. the transformation of Banos Sant so they're in a good position to talk about this Bank uh this is the largest stock
  5. offering ever in Mexico would you comment on just how significant this is for Banos Sant and also for Mexico
  6. itself Maro maybe we'll start with you well this is uh one uh additional step in terms of uh fully utilizing their
  7. Capital base um so they have uh either plans or they have already floated part of their equity in their Brazilian
  8. subsidiary in the UK and now in Mexico those are the three most important markets right now in which they have a
  9. presence outside of the home country of uh of Spain uh so this is essentially part of a you know long-standing policy
  10. to try to uh you know fully utilize their Capital base and uh I mean let's remember that there's other banks that
  11. have done this and there's a a lot of companies especially for emerging markets that have um essentially used um
  12. you know Partners in uh local markets and Float part of the stock as a way to you know leverage their you know
  13. resources uh more broadly and be able to accomplish more in a shorter period of time um uh so this is a you know it's a
  14. smart move uh but it is a uh part of a longstanding strategy for on the on the part of the bank does it say uh more for
  15. Mex perhaps then than it does for bco Sant at this moment well keep in mind well if they were going to float
  16. anything Mexico is the one to float because of the the major uh markets they're in it's the Mexican operations
  17. doing best uh last year it accounted for about 10% of uh Sand's Global profits which is just a little bit under
  18. Spain uh but it's the growing it's the one where the profits are growing versus Brazil's little off Spain is a little
  19. off so in terms of what's easiest to sell it's going to be the Mexican operation
  20. now keep in mind this 24.9% they actually sold that that amount back around 2006 to Bank of
  21. America then about two years ago Bank of America sold it back to them so in effect all they're really doing is
  22. putting the same 24.9% back back into play in a way as Maro said it's part of um a long-standing
  23. plan it's a little right now part of the motivation is a they just made the 9% Capital base uh that the European uh
  24. banking Authority wanted they want to get to 10% so this will be will they'll use the proceeds to up their Capital
  25. base second at a time when Spain is let's say a little bit in the dogghouse globally there's a problem of valuing
  26. santand if they can get market valuations for the main components that puts a flaw under the valuation of the
  27. whole Corporation so uh in other words if if you sort of add up Brazil and Mexico and
  28. the UK and some other bits and pieces then the total thing has to be worth at least that plus at least a
  29. little bit for Spain that's interesting it sort of plays into another question I
  30. was thinking about which is that here you are in Europe all the banks are having trouble raising money all the
  31. banks are being asked to raise money under bosel 3 and other new regulations that they've got to beef up the reserve
  32. so they're kind of caught between Iraq and a hard place and of course the economies are tanking but here's s
  33. sandare uh at least outside of Europe uh able to to raise money but also they had
  34. a successful Bond offering um just uh I think it was a month ago uh of about2 billion EUR which which did pretty well
  35. especially considering what some of the Sovereign bonds how they were tanking at
  36. the time so there I mean that that's another sign that that that the Market's viewing a Bonos santand there
  37. differently than some other banks in Europe is it would you say well it's a it is a very um unique bank I mean
  38. there's very few banks in the world that have a uh a franchise you know that have
  39. operations in the retail Market in so many different uh countries you know hhbc perhaps is the uh you know
  40. everybody's uh you know favorite example when it comes to uh Global retail Banks
  41. uh but after HSBC maybe there's a couple more and santand there is you know up there among the top five banks in terms
  42. of having operations in multipal markets and of course the European crisis and in
  43. particular the problems in Spain uh have resulted in a situation in which the stock of Spanish Banks is or some
  44. Spanish banks at least is undervalued right um because again that stock is being heavily penalized by the fact that
  45. uh Spain they are associated with uh with a market that is now in trouble uh but you know Sant generates more than
  46. half of its profits and has more than half of its assets outside of the Home Country right way more than half of
  47. their of their profits and so uh uh the markets are not seen through that so this kind of a flotation in Mexico helps
  48. clarify as Adrian was mentioning that you know there's a minimum that this bank is worth and no matter how um
  49. skidish investors are about Spain or about the Euro Zone uh this is a bank that has major operations outside of the
  50. Euro zone so they shouldn't be penalizing the stock as much so the benefit to the brand in the market is
  51. maybe even greater than than the proceeds from from the stock if if it draws attention to the fact that in
  52. santand is about 550 mature markets Emerging Markets within the mature markets look
  53. in total I'd say Spain is a probably last year's profits under 30% um so if it draws attention to the
  54. fact that santande is really a world play not a Spain play that can only help in terms of
  55. perception of the bank now if addition additionally they use the These funds and they Gathering some other funds you
  56. mentioned the bond offering they've just decided to sell they've just sold their
  57. uh uh Colombian operation they decided it wasn't growing to where they wanted it to be 10% market share or better so
  58. they sold that that's going into Capital if they now have a better Capital ratio
  59. than is mandated one of the best Capital ratios in Europe that too pulls them out of
  60. the out of the league of troubled entities in general how has the European financial crisis affected sand we've
  61. talked about it a little bit but maybe we could elaborate and and how will it affect it in the future it's affecting
  62. its strategies as as we just heard but well certainly I mean for the starters the uh the price of the uh the stock is
  63. uh you know at historical you know lows obviously uh it has hit earnings right because even though Spain is far less
  64. than half it still is an important uh market for them uh and other than that in the Euro Zone itself uh they have uh
  65. um you know Consumer Finance operations throughout Europe uh Western and Northern Europe and a little bit in
  66. Eastern Europe um they uh uh these these operations of course have suffered because of course uh consumption and
  67. Consumer Credit has uh you know decreased as a result of the uh recession and the crisis uh so they are
  68. being hit both as a bank and uh as a market you know uh player in the sense that uh you know whatever happens with
  69. aggregate demand also affects them right if the economy doesn't go well uh but other than that as Adrian was mentioning
  70. then they they have a presence very strong presence in other uh developed or mature markets that are not Euro zone so
  71. that's the UK and the US primarily right well in Brazil and and then they have Emerging Markets right they have
  72. Emerging Markets such as Mexico or Brazil and couple of others uh of importance in Latin America um so they
  73. are well positioned uh you know in terms of the the portfolio of businesses in different currency areas in different
  74. types of markets to whether a storm such as this as as long as of course not all
  75. economies you know uh go south at the same time well I was going to ask about that you mentioned Brazil and of course
  76. Brazil's economy has been contracting of late um they've got a lot of loans out there there's been talk about
  77. possibility of some you know bad loans uh coming out of the woodwork there um any possibility that those bad loans
  78. could be large enough to you know give them a big dent or or is this is something that would be considered
  79. manageable probable I mean look you always be surprised UBS is currently uh the the
  80. trader who cost UBS 2.5 billion in bad trading is just went on trial today I think in London you can always be
  81. surprised but in Brazil sand had a um okayish bank which and then with the when the bid for when they took part
  82. in the breakup of Aban amrel they got one of the crown jewels which was the Brazilian operation which was very well
  83. run and the president of the Brazilian or the CEO of the Brazilian operation is very highly respected he ran a good bank
  84. ABN it was ABN U Amro real um he's now in charge of the total thing and still trying to put the
  85. various pieces together but you have you have essentially a good and a very good
  86. operation being put together so it's not likely that you're going to have some major uh surprise there and even in
  87. Spain uh thinking about it they've they've been they're pretty good on risk control they're a bit below average for
  88. their market share in their exposure to the real estate sector in particular to uh Residential Mortgages so sound
  89. they've been cautious there too so I'm not again always be surprised but I wouldn't
  90. expect anything there uh does the uh Mexican issue because it's the largest in Mexican history and
  91. so forth does it uh I mean is it's part of a pattern where there's more and more
  92. successful IPOs I realize this isn't an IPO but it's it has some parallels to an
  93. IPO but more and more IPOs and big IPOs coming out of Emerging Markets we've seen it in Malaysia now even Indonesia I
  94. think one needs to put in perspective the the fact which is of course a fact that this is the largest IPO in Mexican
  95. history for two reasons the first reason is that Mexico stands out as a market in
  96. which there's been very few privatizations right uh so we've only really had one big privatization which
  97. was the telephone company and that's now controlled by by Carlos Slim Right I mean the the company that came out of
  98. that that was many years ago right uh but Mexico hasn't really privatized anything else you see when you go to a
  99. lot of countries in Latin America where you go to uh even countries in in Continental Europe like France or Spain
  100. the biggest IPOs have always been stay on companies that went public right but Mexico you know because of limitations
  101. in terms of how much the state can can privatize uh written into the Constitution um you know they haven't
  102. privatized The Old Company for instance right uh so has had very very small IPOs
  103. that's the first reason the second reason is that uh Mexico there are large firms but most of them are controlled by
  104. families and not all of them are listed and if they're listed they're listed they're listing very small percentages
  105. right so here I'm talking about semx I'm talking about bimbo I'm talking about uh
  106. vitro I'm talking about about um you know Modelo all of these large Mexican firms most of them with a global
  107. presence right in cement in in beer uh in um uh bread uh you know baking baking and so on and so forth um so so you know
  108. it looks big in Mexico but uh it is in part because it is a big flotation but uh even more importantly
  109. it looks big because up until now not that much has been going on in Mexico right because of these two reasons
  110. Limited privatizations and very strong presence of family ownership in the largest firms so a bit of a special case
  111. there Mexico is a special case in many respects uh you know in many respects the other reason of course is that it's
  112. so close to the United States and in general uh would you after having literally written the book on S D
  113. would you comment on how their Global strategy is going uh you you talk about it in your book you made some
  114. predictions there some of which turned out quite nicely um well the big one is still open let's talk about that and the
  115. big one is is the succession mhm uh when uh botin steps down and I'd say that's still what clouded in
  116. shadowed in mystery because the obvious era parent is his daughter anap prum but
  117. that doesn't that's not I wouldn't say it's a for it's not a foregone conclusion at all so um he's
  118. he's been at the helm since what 86 87 and the bank has done well um he took a okay what number six or number seven
  119. Spanish bank and made it one of the the largest bank in the Euro Zone and so there's issue when will he
  120. step down what who will be a successor and what effect will that have on the bank and that's just open that's an open
  121. question but in terms of global strategy they've you you mentioned I mean think following
  122. essentially the the template I mean their template has been since they started to um uh internationalizing ear
  123. in the 1980s it has been to um uh you know grow by entering new markets um for the most part to continue focusing
  124. themselves on retail banking Commercial Banking and not you know branching out into other things and uh they've been
  125. entering a number of markets more more than 25 exiting some of those markets Bolivia more recently Colombia um you
  126. know just responding to uh circumstances uh so they've been very um I think pragmatic about uh you know
  127. Market entry and Market exit um they've also tried to diversify by as I mentioned earlier by monetary area and
  128. in terms of the characteristics of the economy mature markets emerging markets and so on and so forth um so I think
  129. pretty much you know in my view um the decisions that they're making that they've been making over the last uh you
  130. know two years let's say you know expanding the UK uh consolidate Brazil uh uh expanding to Poland expanding to
  131. Turkey and so on and so forth all of those decisions are really consistent with the last 20 years right so they are
  132. not shy about entering new markets even when other Banks were retrenching in the
  133. midst of the um financial crisis and they're not shy about exiting markets if they think that uh they shouldn't be
  134. there right so they are I think continuing to uh you know um implement the principles that they established
  135. couple of decades ago as to how they should go about growing internationally yeah um they don't have they don't get
  136. uh locked into a market in the sense that uh developing a Sentimental attachment try it out if it works if
  137. they can get the market share and they do work by mostly by acquisition if they can build build up a good position fine
  138. if it's a dead end they leave um Colombia being the most recent example of that and then they've got sort of 10
  139. priority markets that hasn't changed and a lot of small ones and then they'll see how those go but it's again
  140. it's it's the same it's continuation of the same overall strategy of the last 20
  141. plus years it's sort of interesting cuz it sounds like they have a certain nimbleness that that a lot of uh Bank
  142. analysts say Banks need but Banks typically lack so that might set them apart a little bit what about Asia which
  143. everyone talks about as being for many the future of banking since it's seem to be the strong growth area how are they
  144. set up they were in in the Philippines they did buy some stuff and then they exited because they couldn't
  145. figure out how to make that work they have they have clearly have an interest in China
  146. but they can't figure out a way to do that in particular they can't find people that can bridge between China and
  147. Spain where they have where the with top management has a has confidence in them
  148. they do not I could be dead wrong on this but I don't believe they've taken minority positions in any major Chinese
  149. uh financial institutions or Asian market for that matter I mean the thing is that you know there's really only a
  150. you know two or three banks that uh have historically had a presence in in strong
  151. presence in in maybe one or two at at most three markets in Asia I mean these markets I mean let's say you know India
  152. Thailand Indonesia know the Philippines South Korea Japan China they're all very
  153. different I mean they happen to be in Asia but you know they couldn't be more different from one another they differ
  154. in terms of the structure of competition the regulations whether they are strong
  155. local players or not and so on and so forth so uh you know it is it's certainly a something that they're
  156. watching uh I think every European Bank wants to keep on watching you know what's going on over there but you see
  157. we're talking here about a bank that wants to play in retail banking opening branches and uh running you know uh
  158. taking deposit extending loans maybe that's not a part of the world where you know they should be you know they're
  159. they're exploring they're trying to see if it makes sense or not um but you know
  160. they have a lot of uh you know Room to Grow uh in Latin America in Europe uh and also here in the United States we
  161. haven't even talked about United States in the United States they have a major presence uh in one uh small part of the
  162. country right the northeastern Corridor uh but that's about it and this is a big
  163. Market that is right for consolidation right because there's a lot of uh small Banks and uh so they don't need to grow
  164. in China in order to keep on growing and China perhaps is a difficult market and
  165. you know it seems as if China is following Brazil right now in terms of um you know a deterioration of
  166. microeconomic indicators especially growth um so it's not clear to me that China would be and of course India is
  167. very difficult you have very sophisticated entrenched local banks uh and I AR sophisticated but very
  168. entrenched local entrenched and uh so so you know it's not clear why they would want at least let's say in the next five
  169. or 10 years to allocate resources to that part of the world when they have growth opportunities in Europe in Latin
  170. America and in North America uh one last question talked about growth opportunities in Europe um a lot of Bank
  171. analysts say Europe has too many banks there's going to be a consolidation maybe a major
  172. consolidation um where does Banos sand there fit into that should that occur as many see as likely they've
  173. been Sid stepping a little by F focusing on consumer credit rather than Banks and so if you look at um the
  174. scandies or Germany or so forth they haven't really built up a banking presence there's a bit of they've got a
  175. bit of a banking presence in Germany and so on but it's been more of a consumer credit
  176. presence uh they made one for many years they they targeted uh Italy they were interested in Italy they finally got an
  177. Italian operation again in the breakup of Aban Amro and within a month they sold it to uh Mont pasy Sienna mostly
  178. again this is the no uh um psychological uh attachment even though they've been trying to get
  179. into Italy for a long time Monte deasi came up with an offer that was ridiculously high So within a month they
  180. turned they they got rid of it uh I think one problem with Europe is it's still a country of it's still a
  181. continent of Nations and it's very hard for a foreign Bank to make a major acquisition without there being a
  182. certain amount of concern uh if you think again think about ab and amra when that finally fell apart the
  183. Dutch the Dutch nationalized the Dutch bit the belgians took over the Belgian bid and only BOS sad came out because
  184. they they had none of those pieces yeah I mean Europe is is complex Continental Europe and uh will there be
  185. consolidation well I guess first we need to know what happens to the euro right and then next we need to know um whether
  186. um in the wake of uh a potential reorganization of Europe's um treasuries right or maybe in the form of some
  187. fiscal Union uh whether uh then as a result of that governments become less concerned about foreign takeovers of
  188. local banks it is inconceivable of course that in the context of a uh currency Union uh that you still have uh
  189. you know in every of these in each of these markets uh the the the first the second and the third largest Banks is a
  190. local bank right so there's been no uh you know incursions no invasions right of One Bank into another at one's Turf
  191. right after 12 years of a 13 years of a monetary Union right this is really really strange uh so I think it depends
  192. on what happens to the EUR depends on the kind of fiscal if the Euro survives it's obviously going to be with some
  193. kind of a uh fiscal Union yeah so what shape is that going to take uh our governments then going to uh you know
  194. essentially you know be more open uh to take overs in the financial sector it is
  195. a politically sensitive sector it is a strategic sector it is you know A peculiar sector that's what we love
  196. talking about Banks right and uh and in Europe of course many of these institutions uh are 100 years old and
  197. you know it's it's very difficult to move away from that right but even here in the United States I mean it's it's
  198. sometimes hard to um you know to see how you know there could be further consolidation well we all know that
  199. perhaps there should be more consolidation right so so the problems are you know uh pretty much in this
  200. sector you know present around the world but Europe is I think a very clear case
  201. right of compartmentalization or fragmentation right in the face of you know a uh you know monetary Union which
  202. is kind of weird [Music]

Brief Summary

Banos Santand's $4.3 billion stock offering highlights its strategy and significance for Mexico amid European banking challenges.

Key points

  • Largest Stock Offering in Mexico. Banos Sant's recent stock offering marks a significant milestone for the bank and the country.
  • Succession Uncertainty. The future leadership of Banos Sant remains uncertain as discussions about succession continue.
  • Banos Sant's Global Strategy. The bank continues to expand internationally while maintaining a focus on retail banking.
  • The Complexity of European Banking. The discussion highlights the challenges foreign banks face in acquiring local institutions in Europe.
  • Future of the Euro. The fate of the Euro may hinge on the establishment of a fiscal Union.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes