Jeremy Siegel: A 2016 Outlook for Stocks

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're speaking today with Jeremy seagull A Wharton Finance Professor about the outlook for markets in 2016 welcome
  2. Jeremy thank you for joining us happy to be here and happy New Year Happy New Year to you although not not so happy in
  3. the stock market today well let's talk about uh a couple of things one is that 2015 was the worst for stock markets in
  4. since 2008 uh the Dow Jones and S&P 500 indexes basically were flat they they lost a little bit but basically we flat
  5. so that is a Lis performance in in quite a while uh so I wanted to ask where you
  6. see them going in 2016 but then as we get up this morning we have these issues in China a suspension of trading a drop
  7. of 7% in the stock market there so uh the these are all connected so let's talk about the short term and then we
  8. can talk about the long term one thing I think is pretty interesting you know the
  9. worst in what six seven years and it's a flat Market that's not bad bad right I mean it shows how many up markets we
  10. have had over the last seven years that the worst is uh slight negative on the index and if you add the dividend return
  11. actually a very slight Pro positive one um and the the major reason for that and
  12. we touched on this you know in uh you know August last year that we had a tremendous drop in earnings uh
  13. unexpected uh both on the rise in the do and the collapse of uh Energy prices and
  14. uh so the earnings were way way below estimates and and actually not a bad stock market performance uh given the
  15. decline uh in earnings that we had and so um I think that the projections are that earnings the upcoming reports
  16. aren't going to be great either and now we have this wrinkle large or small with
  17. China at the moment um so what do you see it's a tough it's a tough call for 2016 yeah well let's get to the real
  18. short run I mean the China thing uh a circuit breaker at 5% for a volatile Market is way too small uh and
  19. there's also fears that there's the there's the big lockup they prevented insiders from selling stocks for six
  20. months that's going to end on Friday and there's a you know whenever something bad happens oh my God there's going to
  21. be millions of shares sold on Friday and then it just does I get out now before the circuit breakers come in it's a mess
  22. they've just not you know we all know that they've handled the market really bad
  23. um and um you know it's it's it's an important Market of the world and uh I think that that certainly uh contributed
  24. to the declines we saw today do you think that that that the situation in China is not quite as bad as the market
  25. suggest today and that it's sort of technical things that are making it overshoot on the downside well you know
  26. the the market always overreacts I mean how will how much will GDP go up I mean uh you know I I heard you know on CNBC
  27. some forecasters saying as low as two or 3% for this year which would really be a
  28. shock but most of the people that I talk to that have used it said maybe it's five um and yeah that's a come down
  29. still not a disaster we wish we could get uh anywhere near that figure right okay um so then let's look forward let's
  30. look into the first quarter first half and and the whole year the whole year what are you seeing well I you know
  31. there's a lot pessimism now I mean if you take a look at bulls and bears and how it is wow there's a lot of downbeat
  32. on the market I don't think it's going to be as downbeat um first of all I don't think the FED is going to tighten
  33. as much as many observers fear right now I mean a lot of people calling for four
  34. tightenings some even think more I don't think so I really think it's going to be
  35. two tightenings um on around that level uh so I I I think that that's going to be a positive in the market once they
  36. realize oh my goodness you know the FED is not going to tighten that much uh Hey
  37. at that particular point you look at the valuation of stocks and they're very even though they're high from a
  38. historical basis they are not high relative to current and prospective interest rates and I think that that
  39. realization will bring some money back into equities this year so where would you see the indexes at the end of the
  40. year I I think we can do 10% this year um you know uh again we were flat last year I think earnings are going to rise
  41. about 10% uh a little bounce back from about 7% drop that we had this year and with the earnings increase and the fear
  42. fears being allayed on how aggressive the FED is I can see you know we would be at the same price earnings ratio then
  43. uh for a 10% move uh in the market this year what do you see as the uh major positives and the major threats to the
  44. US economy for 206 16 well I mean the the positives is I think as I mentioned I don't think interest rates are going
  45. to be a threat in fact they're going to be less of a threat than many people think so that's going to turn out on the
  46. positive side uh I also think that earnings are going to recover we had a tremendous decline in particularly
  47. energy earning sectors and they're going to recover the threats are my goodness there are people still calling for $20
  48. oil and although again you know we've talked about this issue a drop oil prices is good net for the US economy
  49. although not as good as it used to be because we're almost balanced in terms of imports and exports with our
  50. tremendous increase in Shell production over the last five years but uh nonetheless the S&P 500 is not just a US
  51. index it's way more heavily weighted towards energy the manufacturing companies that Supply the energy
  52. companies like Caterpillar and others in Slumber with all the drilling equipment
  53. and all that and they are definitely hurt and marking down also the fact that the strong dollar although it helps us
  54. in terms of imports is is very challenging for those companies that sell abroad and bring back uh euros and
  55. Yen that are worth less than dollars and that's another reason for the hit uh in
  56. earnings so again oil prices down is not going to be good for the earnings of the
  57. S&P 500 even though it's not going to have uh you know a big negative effect on on the us consumers how about places
  58. like Europe and China they would benefit of course from low these lower oil prices China is a net importer India is
  59. a that importer by the way India is you know growing 78% uh now really faster than China it's
  60. the oil producers in the emerging markets that have been hit the most so if we uh uh you know again what happens
  61. uh on on on you know what's going to going to happen on oil and China is a big story about by the way what happens
  62. on oil uh uh unquestionably if we get a big slowdown in China oil will continue to be under pressure in
  63. 2016 what are the chances um that the relatively positive picture for job growth in the US in
  64. 2015 will finally lead to some real wage growth in the US which has been lacking
  65. for some would say for decades uh when you account for inflation and also uh connected to that a real investment by
  66. corporations in in into increasing production expanding in some way well one thing we should realize is that one
  67. of the biggest disappointments over the last four or five years we've had a really good increase in the number of
  68. jobs but productivity growth GDP growth has been very poor and I say you know people say well it's two and two and a
  69. half percent but that's the trend rate uh We've that's if you had no increase in jobs and we of course had have had a
  70. net increase in number of workers over 2 million a year over the last three years
  71. we should be producing 4 and a half 5% growth rates in Real GDP we don't completely understand the reasons for
  72. the productivity collapse um uh part of it is more regulations um part of it is maybe a
  73. mismeasurement of uh prices so many things are now free because of our cell phones and our apps and everything and
  74. and if they're free they're not in GDP because GDP is price times quantity so uh there's there's some people and I'm
  75. one of these included that think that there's there's actually more deflation going on than people think when you
  76. actually take into account all the things that have sort of gotten free over time which means we're understating
  77. real GDP and understating the growth of of real wages uh so there's some measurement problem uh there may be some
  78. compliance problem and and and regulation problem it's it's not completely understood we get if we get a
  79. bounceback in that productivity you will see a bounce back in the real wages is this connected in any way to the labor
  80. participation rate because it's great when you see jobs increasing and so forth but when you compare it
  81. historically to you know the percentage of workers in the US that are employed which is which is in a way a more
  82. long-term measure um we're still I mean we're still kind of struggling back to where we were before the financial crash
  83. and and I think we're at actually we're at record low I mean the participant participation
  84. rate has continued to fall and you're absolutely right Fallen much more than we would expect it now we do know the
  85. participation rate will be falling because the baby boomers are going into the retirement period now but it is
  86. falling about twice as fast as most economists say it should be falling why people are quitting the
  87. labor force uh there's a lot of speculation but that's one of the things that has put pressure on the
  88. unemployment rate actually one of the things that I want to see we're going to have a jobs report Friday and of course
  89. every month uh we we have that jobs report if we could get the participation rate to stabilize or even move up in
  90. 2016 that would take a lot of pressure off the FED moderate any sort of increases they would have and that would
  91. be a very positive uh development for the US economy what do you think the odds of are of that happening I I'm I'm
  92. not sure um it keeps on surprising us again on how poor is I mean with a good labor market un appointment rate of 5%
  93. one of the lowest in the developed world I mean we should see more people saying
  94. hey you know what there are job openings out there why aren't they coming back you know uh into the job market and it's
  95. not just low wage jobs Etc and so on we don't understand all the reason people change an attitude about workers and
  96. double income families and uh comp there's a very complicated Dynamic that's going on also the idea that this
  97. unemployment rate at 5% or whatever it is doesn't really capture the number of people that are outside the U6 which
  98. includes those disc but that's gone down a lot too I mean that's gone down for that fell below
  99. 10% uh again so we've really reduced even the discouraged workers of marginally attached workers the workers
  100. are working part-time instead of full-time all those have also seen a dramatic decline we've done a really
  101. great job there still have not been able to coax people back into the labor force
  102. and just to note that um as bad as you say things are with that number in the US it's I think it's even worse in
  103. Europe so they're suffering from the same thing yeah well they they have the I mean the participation rates first
  104. they have you know many of them have much earlier retirement age and much more generous pension
  105. promises and uh unemployment insurance is automatic for them while for us it isn't automatic uh there's a lot of
  106. differences that make ours a much more flexible uh labor market than in Europe what
  107. should what signals should we take from the big dip that's happened in high yield yeah bonds the I think almost all
  108. of that is the energy sector uh if you take high yield off the energy sector it is only a very modest weakening so
  109. basically you know the collapse in oil prices and there was a lot of debt associated with that uh you know the
  110. master limited Partnerships at DES faster that that occurred last year people thought that they had a safe
  111. income vehicle and uh you know those PES have been crushed 70% or more that I mean that that has hurted I do not think
  112. that you know we're going to you know see a weakening of the high yield Market this year in fact there's probably some
  113. good values right now in that market so you would disagree with those who say this could be the canary in the Coline
  114. that's suggesting there's some underlying weakness in financial markets that this is this is yeah and it's good
  115. to do that because those credits are I mean you know we take a look at what you know the financial crisis 20078
  116. financial crisis we saw the deterioration of those but that was much more endemic I mean high yield were
  117. owned by you know everybody this is just the energy credits which by the way the
  118. banks are not in at all this is very very important in contrast to 2007 and8 uh uh the banks you know basically were
  119. were not going to any of this financing of these uh uh oils there was so much money on the sidelines that went in
  120. directly they didn't have to go to the banks the banks are very very sound at this uh at this juncture uh we touched
  121. on this earlier but I'd like to get a little bit more of your thoughts on how big of a threat is deflation we know
  122. that with China's slowdown commodity prices have plummeted it's not just oil it's copper it's everything almost
  123. everything almost everything um and I know that there's also we're at the end of a major cycle pricing cycle inise but
  124. now with China doing this uh pullback um it's it's causing a tremendous effect so
  125. where are we with deflation Europe seems very vulnerable China seems vulnerable and if they were to devalue again for
  126. example which what they are there I mean we saw tremendous weakening today in the
  127. value and it it looks like it wants to be weaker and yes that does export deflation and yes I think Janet Yellen
  128. is going to have difficulty meeting her 2% Target and yes that's one of the reasons why I think we're going to have
  129. very moderate uh increases in the rate this year but not something that's going to spin out of control it's not I I
  130. don't see most of the experts actually Point again what happens to oil I mean oil goes down to 20 that's another leg
  131. down but if we get stability in oil if you look at the core rates of inflation they're they're they're not quite at two
  132. but they're much closer to two and they don't really show a sign of substantial weakening so uh I still don't think
  133. deflation per se but hitting the 2% Target might still be a challenge and if the economy in the US performs or the
  134. stock market performs the way that you're suggesting it will uh that's going to help the world economy in
  135. general but there are people out there that are saying the world economy could already be in a recession or or
  136. certainly that one is ahead what's your feeling on that well the Emerging Markets are the most challenged and of
  137. course those that are producers of of these Commodities under more actually Europe is looking better than it did a
  138. year ago um and the US is no is is not really looking weaker I mean looking into this year I still see two to two
  139. and a half% uh and we'll see what happens it's you know we see the labor force and and
  140. the productivity again not great for uh a good labor market growth because of that productivity features and Japan has
  141. not you know abish shinzo's plan for Revival has been very slow and coming off but uh I don't see a recession there
  142. uh the Emerging Markets are the most challenged of of the group and since their in internal growth rate is so much
  143. higher again a recession in China is 3 to 4% GDP growth so um and as I say India still looks very very strong so I
  144. I I I don't see World recession 2016 thanks very much for joining us happy to be
  145. [Music] here

Brief Summary

Jeremy Seagull discusses the 2016 market outlook, focusing on stock performance, earnings recovery, and global economic challenges.

Key points

  • China's Market Turmoil. Discussion on the impact of China's market issues on global stocks.
  • Market Outlook for 2016. Jeremy Seagull discusses the stock market's performance and projections for the upcoming year.
  • Labor Market Challenges. Exploration of the U.S. labor market and participation rates.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes