How Will Real Estate Be Shaped By Natural Disasters Like the L.A. Wildfires?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Ben Keys, professor of real estate at the Wharton School, analyzes the impact of the L.A. wildfires on home insurance markets, housing policy, and rebuilding efforts. He explains how climate change/natural disasters, rising premiums, and regulatory challenges affect homeowners and businesses in high-risk areas. The interview also highlights strategies for wildfire prevention and the need for collaboration to build safer, more resilient communities.

Wharton Business Daily airs Monday-Friday from 10 AM - 12 PM ET on SiriusXM Channel 132, featuring emerging trends, top business leaders & Wharton’s renowned professors.

Learn more: http://whr.tn/businessdaily

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, as the battle against the California wildfires continues, the question of rebuilding all of those lost homes and
  2. buildings will become a very important one. And part of that issue ahead involves the insurance industry. Some
  3. companies had canceled policies due to the threat of natural disaster, and there's also a greater concern about further
  4. pull outs in the state. Now it won't happen, at least in the short term, because the state's Insurance Commissioner put in
  5. place a one year moratorium from pulling out of the state. Nonetheless, still lots of questions involving the
  6. insurance industry in the state of California. Ben Keys is a Professor of Real Estate here at the Wharton School, and he joins
  7. me right now. Ben, great to talk to you again. How are you? Ben Keys: I'm doing well. Dan, thank you so much for having me. And I
  8. want to say right at the outset, my thoughts and condolences are with everyone in Southern California dealing with the
  9. incredible challenges from these wildfires. And obviously the component of what's been going on in and around
  10. the insurance industry becomes very, very much a huge talking point, especially when you think about what could potentially be
  11. the rebuild of this area in the future. Well, that's right. The backdrop for these wildfires is an insurance
  12. market that was already in turmoil. This is a market that has seen an enormous amount of distress over the last few
  13. years, with— with climate change inducing ever more frequent and severe disasters. Dealing with issues around inflation, rising
  14. cost of materials and labor. And then rising cost of capital. Going from a low interest rate world to a not low interest rate
  15. world has shaken up these types of insurance and reinsurance companies. And so we've seen insurers sharply increase their
  16. premiums in risky areas, and my research has been focused on that. And now the question becomes, okay, after a sizable
  17. disaster like this one, what is the path of recovery going to look like? All right, so let me ask you that question. What is the
  18. potential path of recovery at this point? Well, I think there are a lot of incentives that drive local
  19. policymakers to attempt to rebuild in the same location. There's a desire among local municipal governments to rebuild
  20. their tax base. And there's sort of the— the warm and fuzzy feelings that we get in saying that we've rebuilt bigger—
  21. bigger and better in the same location. But we know that that's not often the right strategy, and it's likely that
  22. we'll rebuild with higher quality materials and more durable materials. But, you know, I think in terms of wildfires,
  23. there's a playbook in terms of wildfire prevention. And one of the key elements of that playbook is keeping a buffer
  24. zone between that wild land- urban interface. And so, you know, I think there are going to be a lot of local pressures to
  25. want to rebuild in the exact same locations. But I think we can learn some lessons from it and rebuild in a smarter way
  26. that increases density in some of the safer locations and create some buffer zones elsewhere.
  27. I guess it's interesting, because when you think about the state of California, I guess we saw this a little bit with the
  28. wildfires in the northern part of the state the last couple of years— is that it just has been a sprawl. It's been a spread out
  29. of how builders have thought about and where they have thought about putting homes in the state of California.
  30. That's right, it's all connected. When we think about land use policies over the last few decades, those policies have
  31. encouraged building in the suburbs and in the exurbs. We've seen cities blocking increased densification. We've seen inner
  32. ring suburbs deciding, "Hey, we're all full up." We've imposed strict lot size requirements and things like
  33. that. And what that does is, it pushes developers further and further away from the city centers and into the areas that
  34. are most wildfire prone. And so this is— a big challenge going forward is, you know, in an environment where we're going to
  35. see more frequent fires, how can we encourage development in those denser, safer locations, and try to steer clear of some
  36. of the riskiest spots? So you also, I guess, when you're thinking about policy, and you
  37. think about housing policy, don't you also have to look at the types of homes that may be built or how they are
  38. constructed as you move forward? Obviously, some of the homes, especially the ones along the water, are basically one level.
  39. You know, do you— you know, from what I understand, the policy has been to build out and not up. And so maybe that changes in
  40. the mindset of how you think about building as well. Yeah. And it's hard, sort of in the— in the immediacy of
  41. these fires, to just kind of think through what some of these neighborhoods could look like going forward. But what I think
  42. part of this is— again, being strategic about, you know, where should we build in a way that's more dense, and that allows people
  43. to return to their communities, broadly defined, and where can we avoid some of the riskiest things? But there's
  44. also another layer of wildfire prevention that I think is that sort of last mile of prevention that it is hard to do when it
  45. comes to removing all the landscaping around properties. People need to give up their yard. Roads and shrubbery need
  46. to be, you know, cleared in a way that's just not very appealing to the eye. And so there is a sense in which there
  47. is something we're going to have to give up going forward if we want to really harden communities against wildfires.
  48. So let's look at this from from first the consumers' perspective, the homeowners' perspective. How, then, should they think about the
  49. idea of insurance, especially if they are in an area that is susceptible to these types of events?
  50. Yeah, I think this is the tension that— that these markets are facing right now, which is that insurance
  51. companies are recognizing the risks. They've been very clear- eyed about climate change for a long time, and the effect that
  52. that has on their balance sheet. And so that is going to lead to higher premiums in risky areas. And that's what my research has
  53. borne out. Over these last few years, insurers have sharply increased the ways in which they price disaster risk, and so
  54. living in a risky area has gotten much more expensive. We should expect that it will continue to get more expensive
  55. as the path of climate change continues. And so I think this is going to be the challenge for households. It's going to be one
  56. of affordability struggles. Is it affordable to purchase insurance to live in these areas? Now, on the flip side, we
  57. should anticipate that insurance premiums will be capitalized into house prices. So ultimately, the value of the
  58. asset should decline, to sort of, quote, unquote, "compensate" for— for those rising costs. But regardless, the position that
  59. homeowners are going to be in is one of substantially higher premium. What needs to be done then from the regulatory side to kind of
  60. bring both the homeowner and the insurance industry to a point where both sides can feel it to be palatable?
  61. And this is the tension for state regulators. Insurance is regulated at the state level, and so we have 50 different
  62. regulatory entities that regulate this market across this country. And they're all grappling with this issue at the
  63. moment, this tension between access and affordability. For the states where they've been more tightly regulated in the
  64. past, giving insurers less discretion in setting premiums, insurers have simply left. They've said, "We don't want to
  65. operate in these locations." And insurers are extremely mobile and— and they write annual contracts. And so they can
  66. readjust their risk profile quite quickly. But we should recognize that homeowners and and policymakers are operating
  67. on a very different time scale. They're thinking about living in their house for the rest of their lives, essentially. - Yeah.
  68. So there's a real tension there, and I think this is going to be where policymakers will— will have to collaborate with the
  69. industry and with researchers to think about both considering ways to both keep sending price signals to markets saying, "This
  70. is a risky place to live and a risky place to develop," but also find ways to support the lowest income homeowners in our
  71. communities who might not have that flexibility if the premiums rise. When you have a disaster this size— and obviously we've had a
  72. couple very large ones in the— in the last several months, when you think about the hurricanes that came through and obviously
  73. impacted portions of North Carolina, what does that mean for insurance prices in general? Because these— you're talking
  74. about companies that are obviously in so many of these states that I would assume there has to be a downstream impact on
  75. insurance prices in general, as well as the region where the disaster occurred. It's especially hard because 2025 was anticipated to be a
  76. year where insurance markets were going to normalize a bit, where we weren't going to see the sharp increases that we've
  77. seen in the last few years. And instead, these waves of disasters, hurricanes Helene and Milton and now these awful
  78. wildfires, are driving up the costs for the insurance and reinsurance industries, and they're going to have to take
  79. that into consideration as they go forward. To your point, there's an open question as to how much of these costs are
  80. being spread more broadly across the country. So imagine a national insurer who operates across a lot of different
  81. states. They might see these losses in California. Can they pass those costs on to the rest of the country? I think it's a
  82. little bit unclear. We know that more regulated states are generally more affordable than than less regulated states, but
  83. in terms of, you know, a direct mechanism across those states, it's challenging. You do have local providers in most states
  84. who potentially can— can undercut in terms of the pricing. So if a national insurer said, "Hey. You know,
  85. we know that you're in Iowa, but these wildfires in California have— have increased our costs. So we want to drive up your
  86. premium," you could go find a local operator who doesn't have that exposure and shop around. So I think you know, teasing—
  87. teasing out exactly that mechanism is challenging. How does this also potentially impact the business side? I
  88. mean, so many businesses in this region as well, who have their businesses insured,
  89. obviously will feel an impact from this as well. The business side is— is, I think, the under-studied and
  90. underappreciated aspect of this. Insuring commercial property, the market is— is quite a bit less liquid. There are fewer players
  91. in that space, and there's been less regulatory support. There's been less effort among policymakers to make, you know,
  92. the lives of the business community easier when it comes to finding affordable insurance. Whereas, you know, for
  93. homeowners, these state insurers of last resort have been more— more generous and more accessible. So I think on the
  94. business side, there's a real challenge there. And certainly we're hearing about this in the context of housing
  95. affordability, because this is going to drive up the cost of developing new apartment buildings, for instance. And
  96. we've heard stories of multifamily developers saying, "We couldn't get this project going because we couldn't find
  97. affordable insurance for it." And so all of these— these issues become interconnected in the same way. We have the climate
  98. crisis interactive with an affordability crisis. What do you take from this unfortunate instance, in terms of
  99. where we are, but where we need to go in terms of our thought process around insurance?
  100. I think it's a great question. There's no doubt that— that policymakers and— and homeowners more generally, are— are way
  101. behind relative to how quickly the climate is changing, how rapidly we're seeing more severe disasters, and just how
  102. seriously we need to take these changes going forward, if they continue on the trajectory that's forecast. I think of
  103. insurance as being very— very clear-eyed when it comes to these risks. And we should be all taking signals from the
  104. market, that they're telling us that these are riskier places to live in. And that means that we should— we should react
  105. accordingly. That means that we should invest in being more resilient, home hardening efforts and community hardening
  106. efforts, whether that's for floods or wildfires or otherwise. It means we should rethink where we're developing,
  107. to your point earlier. Where are we putting the new buildings that are going to be there for 50 or— or 75 years? And we should
  108. be thinking about the most vulnerable communities and thinking about ways to bring together, I would say,
  109. policymakers and the industry and researchers to shed more light on these risks and give people some sort of toolkit in
  110. order to defray some of these challenges and help them re-optimize. Ben, great to talk to you, and thanks again for your insight.
  111. All the best. - Yeah, thanks so much for having me, Dan. - Thank you. Ben Keys, who's a Professor of Real Estate here at
  112. the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

California wildfires raise insurance costs and rebuilding challenges, urging strategic development and regulatory support for homeowners.

Related episodes