Getting Out of Line: How to Shorten ER Wait Times

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research examines a new approach to assigning patients to doctors in the ER. More: http://knlg.net/2fk98wd πŸ“‚ Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton operation information and decisions professor huh me song to talk to her about some of her
  2. latest research how many thanks for being with us oh thanks for having me so first can you give us a short summary of
  3. this research so so my work is in healthcare operations and what I'm focusing on is thinking about how we can
  4. design systems and processes that will enable physicians to work more productively this particular paper I'm
  5. focusing on queue management systems thinking about how can we better design this queue management system to enable
  6. physicians to be more productive so first what do I mean by queue management so this is thinking about the kinds of
  7. you know think about a line that you waited in this morning let's say we encounter these things all over the
  8. place and we're trying to think about different ways of structuring them so in this particular case it's a queue
  9. structure thinking about what kinds of implications that has for productivity outcomes that were interested in in this
  10. kind of a healthcare setting we're thinking about the length of stay of the patients the waiting times of the
  11. patients and as we'll get to talk about this particular paper we're thinking about in an emergency department setting
  12. so these are patients in the waiting room of an emergency department thinking about how you should design those cues
  13. as they wait to be seen by a physician so you can naturally think of two different ways of structuring these
  14. queues one is what we'll call a pooled Q so this is a case where you have essentially a single line where the
  15. patients are waiting to be seen by one of the many physicians who are working there they're not pre assigned to
  16. particular physicians Q the other kind of cue structure that we consider is a dedicated queue and this dedicated Q is
  17. essentially as soon as they arrive and get registered they're getting assigned to a specific physicians dedicated queue
  18. right so from the beginning you're waiting in the line that belongs to a particular physician so ultimately we're
  19. asking given these type type two types of Q structures which one of these might lead to more efficient or productive
  20. outcomes which is a good question for any of us who've ever been ill I at the ER you know it can be a very frustrating
  21. experience so when you look at these two types of queues what it what were your key takeaways what did you find sure so
  22. what we find is surprisingly because this is actually counter to what tradition queuing theory would predict we find
  23. that having the dedicated queues actually led to faster throughput time so in this case shorter lengths of stays
  24. and shorter waiting times for the patients we found this to be interesting because like i said it's
  25. counterintuitive in a way and what we're finding is that it's it's not just that
  26. you know with pooled cues you are able to buffer against the variability that you might see in these kinds of cues but
  27. in this case with the dedicated cues given that the physicians are people who they're people first of all and they
  28. have a lot of discretion in terms of how they organize their work when they have
  29. these dedicated cues they start feeling a greater sense of ownership and responsibility over those queues of
  30. patients in this case and they're trying to actively think of ways to get people
  31. into the beds quicker which means that they have to think about how can i get the patients who are in the beds out
  32. faster so they're doing things differently like pulling for the test results if they ordered tests they're
  33. proactively you know calling up to see what kinds you know what are the results rather than just waiting for those
  34. results to be pushed to them and we can validate a lot of these hypotheses that we generated from our interviews and
  35. observations with the physicians through the data that we collect from the electronic medical records of the
  36. particular emergency department that we worked with for this project so looking at some of the practical implications of
  37. this research I guess with I'm an emergency department how could I I mean it seems like this is indicating that I
  38. would want to implement this sort of Q and I guess first of all is that in fact the case and if it is I guess how would
  39. I go about doing that I mean are there things you would say how do hospitals take this and really apply it sure so
  40. that's a great question and since this paper we've actually spoken with different emergency departments that
  41. have started implementing this because let me just backtrack just a little bit and say a little more about our findings
  42. and why it was so significant we find that you know this change that I told you about the reduction in the length of
  43. stay in the reduction in the waiting times they're actually quite significant so we're finding a seventeen percent
  44. decrease in the length of stay of the patients and a nine percent decrease in the waiting times when you translate
  45. that into numbers minutes for an average patient who's coming to this particular ed
  46. that's about 40 45 minute reduction in that total time so that's huge and if you think about given the fact that
  47. they're about 200 patients who are showing up to this emergency department per day that's a large amount of time if
  48. you add that up for all 200 such that they're able to see about 30 more patients per day with the same amount of
  49. resources that's exactly why practically speaking these other emergency departments that tend to have pooled
  50. queuing systems most EDS or emergency departments in the US still have pooled queuing systems that's why they're so
  51. interested in thinking about oh how can we make this transition to a dedicated queuing system given that that might
  52. mean that we're able to see much more in terms of kind of a patient load per day
  53. without adding more resources so the kinds of things that they're doing differently so a lot of times so this
  54. will defer by emergency department so each place we speak with is slightly different but in this case you can think
  55. of you know if there's a computer assignment system in terms of how you assign patients to physicians you can
  56. make that assignment happen just essentially at the beginning of when they get registered rather than when
  57. they get into a bed typically what is done with these pooled queuing systems is that they wait until the patient has
  58. an available bed to get into to assign the physician so in the again in the waiting room they're really waiting in
  59. this cold queue and when we think even beyond emergency departments thinking about how might we apply these kinds of
  60. things it's very much a case-by-case basis but what I would say is the key thing to think about is you know are
  61. these workers in this case it was physicians but in other cases it could be all sorts of other service sector
  62. workers are they people who have lots of discretion over how they work if they don't I i would say pooled queues are
  63. still probably more efficient but if they have that capacity to really change the way they structure their workflow
  64. and use their discretion to make those real-time decisions you might start thinking about these dedicated cues as a
  65. way to try to improve productivity and efficiency in ways you wouldn't have thought of before because it sounds like
  66. one of the keys here is that not only are you switching the way you do the queue but you're also the
  67. doctors know is that they have their given ownership over this list of people and so instead of just waiting what
  68. comes next they see what's next and how do what they can think about what they can do about it that's a really
  69. interesting point you mentioned about seeing it there's actually a separate study not mine that's recently come out
  70. and I've seen it in the press actually even just yesterday in the New York Times we're having visibility into the
  71. length of your queue is really important so if you design this queue where the physicians in this case might not
  72. actually be able to see how many patients are waiting in their queue it might not actually make much of a
  73. difference because what's important is you know you can actually see oh wow I've got 12 patients waiting for me like
  74. I should really get to them they belong to me if you don't have that kind of information maybe it won't change your
  75. behavior now what's next for this research or what are you going to what are you studying next yeah sure so most
  76. directly related to this project so with any kind of operations management question it's really important to think
  77. about trade-offs and thinking about the boundary condition so with this particular paper we looked at things
  78. like quality of care and look what it means for utilization those kinds of things but I want to take it a step
  79. further and think about less so in an empirical setting like this paper was but more so in kind of a jet more
  80. generalizable modeling setting so I'm working with some other colleagues writing a modeling paper trying to see
  81. what are the conditions under which this might be the case we're dedicated queues
  82. outperformed pulled queues given different types of work a version that you know servers might have so we
  83. consider things like whether they're averse to having high levels of workload or just have it or just being busy at
  84. all and then they would prefer idle time so we're trying to understand what is the threshold or what are the conditions
  85. under which this would be the case so that's most directly related to this particular queuing paper but more
  86. broadly I'm very interested in thinking about different levers that we might be able to use to try to think about ways
  87. to improve efficiency and productivity in these healthcare settings not just the emergency department but also
  88. thinking about impatient settings or outpatient settings more broadly so I've been looking into things like different
  89. ways of leveraging performance feedback that you might provide to physicians different ways we might thinking about
  90. matching the supply and demand of hospital beds because there are all sorts of different patients who show up
  91. in different types of beds that are available at different times and especially given the enormous amount of
  92. data that are being collected these days electronically in hospital settings how
  93. can we better leverage that to make predictions that we can act on in real time so those are the kinds of things
  94. I've been really interested in great thank you so much for being here thank you you

Brief Summary

Professor Huh Me Song discusses her research on queue management systems that improve efficiency in emergency departments.

Key points

  • Revolutionizing Emergency Care. Dedicated queues can significantly reduce patient wait times and improve throughput in emergency departments.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes