Can Ben & Jerry’s Keep Its Social Voice?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Who gets the final say when a company’s values clash with its corporate owner? The Ben and Jerry’s legal battle reveals the challenges of protecting a brand’s social mission after a sale.

Maurice Schweitzer, Wharton Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions, explains the dispute and what it reveals about corporate governance.

From independent boards to the limits of founder control, Schweitzer explores why ownership deals can lead to unexpected conflicts and why it is so difficult to predict what the future will bring.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. When is a board of directors not necessarily a board of directors? That might have been the question in the
  2. case involving ice cream giant Ben and Jerry's and its then parent company Unilever and its
  3. now immediate parent Magnum. As Ben and Jerry's became part of Unilever several years ago, an independent board was still
  4. in place at Ben and Jerry's to allow that ice cream giant the opportunity to still
  5. oversee many of the issues that its company was involved with, especially its social voice.
  6. But that started to wane over time and that led to this court case. So what lessons do we learn from this
  7. about the importance of an independent board even with a parent company above it?
  8. Maurice Schweitzer is a professor of operations information and decisions here at the Wharton School.
  9. Maurice, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir? Great to see you. How unique is it, this kind of structure
  10. that developed where Ben and Jerry's gets bought by Unilever, but there is still this independent
  11. board that allows it to take on these social issues? Yeah, it isn't very common.
  12. Typically, when entrepreneurs sell their business, they typically move on either to another venture or to
  13. retire. The issue in this case is that Ben and Jerry wanted to remain active in the
  14. social work connected to the ice cream business and they negotiated some say. I mean, they wanted to retain some level
  15. of control. And I think that becomes tricky. So first of all, to answer your question,
  16. it's not very common. And typically, most entrepreneurs are focused on the business, not in this case or sort of
  17. a secondary goal. But that's been such an important component of Ben and Jerry's.
  18. That's for to a degree outside of the ice cream itself. That's what they've been known for is taking
  19. these stands on these issues. And obviously, in this case, what's been going on with Israel and Gaza in the last
  20. few years has really drawn the attention of Ben and Jerry's. Yeah. So Ben and Jerry's have been drawn to
  21. a lot of social issues. And yeah, in this one, it became complicated in a way that Ben and Jerry's and
  22. the parent company disagreed and they ended up not able to resolve those disagreements in an
  23. amicable way, which is unusual. That is, it's rare for cases to come to this point where typically organizations have a
  24. hierarchy and they speak with one voice and they have one consistent message and employees are
  25. free to leave. But in this case, yeah, you had this inner turmoil that became something of a mess.
  26. And the original component of the legal case was a concern of censorship of speech by
  27. Ben and Jerry's, was it? You know, I'm not a legal expert, so I want to be careful not to opine
  28. sort of outside of my lane. I don't think so. I mean, like, I don't think it's I
  29. think everybody can say what they want to say. But but I think in this case, it's
  30. really an issue of control. So so what happens when you sell your company? What control do you retain?
  31. And I think that's I think that's an interesting issue. I mean, sort of these legacy issues, you
  32. know, when you give up control, it's very difficult, I think, to retain the influence that
  33. you used to retain. I think I think I think we we feel the losses painfully. Well, doesn't that then go to the deal
  34. and how it was set up and the process of setting up that deal? And Unilever at that time saying, OK, we'll
  35. do the deal and we will allow you to continue to have the independent board. Obviously, Ben and Jerry's felt like in order
  36. to make the deal, they needed to still have that independent board in place. Yeah, so they wanted I mean, so so
  37. for them, they wanted to sell the business and then do what was sort of fun and meaningful to them.
  38. Sort of, you know, play this role. I I think I think, you know, when that deal was done, it was difficult to
  39. anticipate that they would have differing opinions that that, you know, there's a huge brand and
  40. they have so many different products, but they felt this one was a special case sort
  41. of off to the side. And most of the social justice issues are pretty uncontroversial.
  42. You know, this this particular issue has people on different sides seeing things, you know, sort
  43. of weighing weighing these issues differently. And and I think this, you know, this
  44. sort of created the opportunity for a conflict where I really think both parties didn't anticipate
  45. they would end up here. And I think they both felt entitled to more control in a way that surprised.
  46. I think they were both surprised that they ended up in this conflict. So the most recent decision by a judge
  47. in this case involved the fact that many of the concerns were stripped out and that
  48. Magnum, which now owns Ben and Jerry's, is the defendant in this case. For Magnum, it's an interesting component of purchasing
  49. Ben and Jerry's from Unilever, but doing it at a time where this legal case is playing out and kind of walking right into
  50. the all of this. Yeah. And sometimes those are real opportunities. That is, sometimes in the middle of uncertainty,
  51. there are some players that want to take the risk and other players are happy to
  52. sell the risk at some discount. Yeah. So here, Magnum, you know, they could have
  53. read the legal issues. They probably had a legal team that was advising them that this was a reasonable opportunity.
  54. And, you know, it's, I mean, there's always risk and some, some players are happy to
  55. take that risk and sometimes do great weighing into it. And other people are really happy to leave
  56. the headache to somebody else. What do you think this case then tells us about that component of social voice and
  57. corporate ownership? And obviously it's been, you know, very much talked about topic over the last, you know,
  58. couple of decades. Yeah. Well, you know, it sort of reminds me a lot of the Barnes Foundation.
  59. And here in Philadelphia, there was this famous museum left by this guy named Barnes.
  60. He was a huge collector and in his will, he was very specific that the collection
  61. should not be moved out of his very large house, his mansion where it was housed.
  62. And years later, they, they ended up moving it, I think in a very tasteful way down into the center city where many more
  63. people could access it. And the pieces could, I mean, the museum could be in a much better financial position
  64. and the collection could be better cared for, but it was really at cross purposes with
  65. what the, the, the previous owner had sort of stated in their will. And I think, I think partly it's hard
  66. to forecast that is we're, we're forecasting things in the future and we're constantly surprised somebody
  67. has to make decisions and the best decisions as somebody sees them may be at odds
  68. with what a previous owner or founder envisioned. And so I think, I think there's sort
  69. of a few key lessons here. One is it's difficult to sell pieces of a business and try to maintain a sort
  70. of a key or central role in governorship when you don't really have the reins anymore.
  71. Right. The second is the thing about the forecasting challenge. That is, we were trying to forest cast
  72. things in the future, but life is uncertain things. We're constantly surprised more often than we should
  73. be because we failed to anticipate how uncertain, how chaotic, how diverse the possible set of
  74. outcomes could be. Maurice, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much for your time.
  75. All the best. Oh, thank you. Maurice Schweitzer, who's a professor of operations information
  76. and decisions here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Ben and Jerry's legal case highlights challenges of independent boards post-acquisition and the complexities of corporate social responsibility.

Key points

  • The Ben and Jerry's Dilemma. The case highlights the complexities of maintaining an independent board after a sale.
  • Social Issues and Corporate Control. Ben and Jerry's struggle with Unilever reveals tensions between social activism and corporate governance.

Tension

55/ 100Some tension

Related episodes