Unlocking Green Tech at Home
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
EPISODE OVERVIEW Real-time electricity pricing, which fluctuates based on peak usage hours, can cut costs for both consumers and utilities, according to research from Wharton’s Arthur van Benthem. This episode is part of a series on “Innovation” that was produced in cooperation with Mack Institute for Innovation Management.
PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.
Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.
#electricity #electricityprices #energycosts #energyindustry ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Arthur van Benthem: So that would suddenly tell me that it's five p.m. in Philadelphia, and on August 21, it's extremely hot outside. But
- now my power is very expensive. So maybe instead of setting my thermostat to, you know, 70, I might set it to 74, and that's a
- big difference. The issue is that people don't like unpredictable bills. If you don't pay attention, all of a
- sudden, you hadn't really looked at your thermostat settings, and you get a bill the end of the month, and it turned out you
- consumed power during really, really high price hours. Dan Loney: Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a
- journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
- inspiration behind the ground breaking research that Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings
- resonate with the world today. Dan Loney: Well, another area of innovation to be looked at involves that in and around the energy sector,
- more specifically, electricity. Research takes a deeper dive into the new ways to potentially charge consumers for the
- electricity they consume. Pleasure to be joined by Arthur van Benthem, who is an Associate Professor of Business, Economics
- and Public Policy here at the Wharton School. He's been part of research looking into this. Arthur, great to talk to you.
- How are you today? - I'm doing fine. Thanks for asking. - Thank you. I guess, let's start with what was the driver to take a
- look at this component of how consumers deal with the costs around the electricity they use.
- - Righ, yeah. I heard so many stories and energy podcasts about how great it would be if people charged their cars and maybe
- put their clothes in a dryer during hours when there's lots of clean, cheap, renewable electricity. But then I thought
- to myself, right? I mean, I always pay the same price per kilowatt hour of electricity. What's in it for
- me? Like, what incentive do I have to actually use electricity at the right time?
- - So you talk about a mispricing component that's out there in this industry, meaning what specifically? - Yeah,
- let me start by saying that electricity is kind of a special product. It's priced in a so called wholesale market, where
- generators sell their power to large customers. You can think of a utility. And the price in the market changes every few
- minutes, right? When demand is very low, then electricity is cheap. But all of a sudden, a couple hours later, perhaps when
- air conditioning demand is very high, because the temperature has risen, prices can suddenly skyrocket, as we need expensive
- power plants to supply that power, but we as end consumers don't see any of that action. We just pay the same constant price
- of electricity. And that's kind of the source of the mispricing. You always pay the same price for your power, but in reality,
- the power is sometimes very cheap to generate, and sometimes it's actually very, very expensive.
- - How much of a component are we talking about here in terms of the annual costs associated with this pricing?
- - Yeah, that was one of the things that we tried to get a handle on in this study. And sort of our estimates suggest that it is
- several billion dollars a year across the US, probably much higher. I can get to that. But the main reason for the $2
- billion is that, you know, the flat pricing for end consumers, it leads to inefficient energy use. We use it at the wrong time
- of the day, right? So there's sort of two things that are costly. One is, you know, during peak hours and hot
- weather, the wholesale prices are very high for electricity, but consumers don't have much of an incentive to increase their
- thermostat settings and help the power system, so to speak. So they consume way too much power exactly when it's very expensive
- to generate. And then the flip side is, is that there's also hours of the day where electricity is very cheap. It
- would be perfect to charge your electric vehicle, say, but you still pay that same flat price, or you're not seeing that very
- low price in the wholesale market. So we're also inefficiently not charging our cars and doing our clothes
- washing when it would be great to do so. And that altogether is sort of a total loss of several billions a year.
- - For the utilities, is this price fluctuation probably their biggest element that they have to deal with because of these
- conditions? - Yes, yes, indeed. I mean, we as end consumers are shielded from all those fluctuations in the wholesale market, right? The
- prices for electricity can be 10 times as high late afternoon compared to, you know, two a.m., but the utility, of course, you
- know, faces that variation. So they can handle that in various ways. They can sign long term power contracts with
- generators to hedge that price risk. But still, they need to buy some of their power on that wholesale market. And
- what's happening, has happened actually many times before, is that during extreme peak hours, when prices that are
- normally in, say, the $40 per megawatt hour, are suddenly 1,000, utilities might find themselves buying at very high prices in
- that real time market, but still only selling it to consumers at that fixed, much lower rate. So it's a real issue
- for utility. - So what are some of the type of ideas that need to be considered in terms of trying to find a solution that both sides
- see the benefit from this relationship? - Yeah, well, there's an idea that a lot of
- economists have proposed, which hasn't gotten much traction yet, but it's sort of useful to start out with. It's called real time
- pricing, which is essentially letting consumers face that price that changes every five minutes, right? So that would
- suddenly tell me that it's it's five p.m. in Philadelphia, and on August 21, it's extremely hot outside, but now my power is
- very expensive. So maybe instead of setting my thermostat to, you know, 70, I might set it to 74, and that's a big
- difference. The issue is that people don't like unpredictable bills. If you don't pay attention, all the sudden you
- hadn't really looked at your thermostat settings, and you get a bill the end of the month, and it turned out you consume power
- during really, really high price hours. And the extreme example was Texas a couple years ago when there was this big winter
- storm. Texas doesn't regulate prices very much. So some consumers who were unlucky enough to have signed up for one
- of those programs ended up paying a monthly power bill in excess of $10,000, because the wholesale price had spiked to
- $9,000 per megawatt hour. The other sort of big issue with why this is so difficult to do in practice is that there's
- vested interest, right? Generators love those high prices, and you know, real time pricing would probably make
- people a little bit more sensitive to them, and might actually soften those peaks. So there's
- pushback from all kinds of sides. - Are we close, though, to being able to do that in the first
- place, that idea of real time pricing? - Yeah, so it's not about technological barriers. I mean, you need
- an electricity meter that can sort of, you know, handle that. That's not the biggest obstruction. What's really hard
- is that people would need to pay active attention all the time to, you know, what is happening to the power press. How am I
- going to move my activities around during the day? And that's where, I think, you know, innovation in home automation
- software and smart EV charging is going to help, right? If an app could basically receive the real time electricity price and
- program for you when your car will be charged if you don't need it to happen straight away, for example, that will take away
- a lot of that risk that people would be paying very high prices, not being aware they're using that power. So it should
- actually become quite a bit easier over time. But nevertheless, utilities have used very different pricing
- systems so far to try to approach it, which our study finds have not been very effective.
- - But for the consumer, it sounds like it would be a little bit of a challenge for them to kind of deal with real time pricing and
- understanding how, you know, the dynamics play here. And it almost feels like it's like you'd have to be watching your
- thermostat over the course of 24 hours to make sure you're maximizing the benefits. - Yeah, your
- software, you would essentially have to, in the beginning, be very careful and add -- you know, tell your software what you're
- willing to pay and how it should sort of -- you know, what kind of rules it should it use to handle it. But
- it's especially for like -- if you own an electric vehicle, that's a huge percentage of your electricity
- bill. That's typically something that can, in fact, be charged at very low prices if you were in a real time pricing plan, as long
- as you're a little bit patient and are happy to charge it overnight, which most people would do anyway. So people
- always worry about the high prices, but those plans also allow you to take advantage of very low prices exactly because
- you have some electricity demand that you can schedule during those off peak hours. So I think it's a real opportunity for a
- lot of people to also save money. - In terms of doing this research, we're able to determine that
- with some of these off peak hours, there's enough of a pattern that plays out so that people can understand that this
- would be a time, two a.m., three a.m., whatever it might be, that this would be the time that I can take advantage of this on a
- frequent basis. Not just on maybe one day a month, but maybe all week or five days out of a month, that they can
- develop a pattern with this. - Yeah, so that's the way utilities have tried to tackle it so far,
- because the move to real time pricing has been so hard. The most common approximations of real time pricing, although they
- don't get very close, the first one is called time of use pricing. It's something along the lines of what you suggest,
- right? There might be sort of a lower off peak tariff that you have during the night. You have a peak tariff, could be late
- afternoon, for example. And then, because it's only two tariffs, it's not that hard to remember that you should
- charge your car outside of the peak hours. Now, you can make those more sophisticated. Some utilities have actually
- introduced something like 20 different tiers. It varies by season. It varies by day of week, time of day. Thinking that,
- as long as you keep adding more and more of those tiers, you will approximate more and more closely what would happen if you
- put people on real time pricing. And what we find in this research, which is kind of surprising to us, and you know,
- we got some generous help here and research and support from Wharton's Mack Institute for Innovation, is that those
- pricing systems really only capture maybe 10 percent of the benefits that real time pricing could achieve. It turns out you
- can estimate that, last year, it happened to be that Tuesday afternoons had high prices, but then out of sample, projecting
- it into next year, you're very often going to miss what's happening to next year. So in fact, the more categories you
- use, the more you over fit the data, and the worse these, systems perform. So the current trend that the
- utilities are trying doesn't seem to solve the issue, really, as much as real time pricing could. - That's
- what I was going to say next, because it feels like, with all of these dynamics at play, that trying to fight -- find, excuse
- me, what the right formula is for both sides to benefit here, it's still got a lot in the mix to truly understand what that
- path is going to be. - Yeah, and that's -- it's very difficult, and especially if you
- need to forecast it based on past data, it makes it very difficult, right? It's actually -- it's going to -- you're going to
- get more alignment between the price that the consumer pays, and the cost that it takes for generators to generate the
- power, if you can set the price close to the actual event. And that's the second system that utilities have been playing
- with. It's called critical peak pricing, where they say something like, you know, "You pay this flat price most
- of the year, but we are allowed to call, say, 20 events every year." So a day in advance, you get a text message saying, "We
- anticipate prices to be very high tomorrow because it's soaring temperatures." You give people some advanced warning so
- they know that tomorrow they have to be careful during a certain time window, and they need to adjust their thermostat
- settings, otherwise they would pay a high price. Or you can subsidize them for reducing consumption. That's sort of the
- more carrots version. The first one was the sticks version. So that system has been used throughout the US. It's, you
- know, the vast majority of people don't have it, but some people do. And again, it seems like that can cover about -- it can
- close about 10 percent of the gap between flat pricing and real time pricing. But again, it doesn't come close to something
- that directly connects the wholesale market with what consumers pay. - So what do you think are the ways that maybe need to be
- considered in order to try and increase that percentage of seeing benefit on real time pricing as we move forward? And
- I'm guessing maybe technology is going to play a role in this. You know, innovation, obviously, but technology will play a
- role in this. - Yeah, to me what was really interesting about the results that we found is that you could do -- you could take the
- sharpest edges off of real time pricing and say, "Let's just have the price vary, you know, minute by minute or as frequently as
- you want to. But let's avoid these Texas stories, where people get totally caught by surprise, and that leads to
- really serious problems for the customers." So let's just say that the price can only vary but up to some price cap. And
- the price cap doesn't even have to be that high. You could say, if a typical wholesale market price is 40, you could set the
- price cap at 80 or 100, which is far removed from the craziness that we've seen in some of these markets. Turns out
- that most of the time the price still tracks the wholesale markets correctly, and that actually recovers about two
- thirds of that gap. So you would -- of the two billion a year, you would get two thirds back. When you
- run simulations with that, monthly bills are, you know, certainly not higher. If anything, they're going
- to be lower. And the variation in those bills isn't all that spectacular, either. So what,
- we find in this research is actually that all this emphasis on extending time of use and critical peak
- pricing might, in fact, be pushing really hard on levers that aren't doing all that much, whereas we could do a much more
- modest version of real time pricing, which would lead to much bigger benefits. I think that's what I would propose.
- - Arthur, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much for your time. All the best. - Thanks for having me. - Thank you. Arthur van
- Benthem from here at the Wharton School. - Thank you for listening to the Ripple Effect. We hope you found this episode
- informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight
- from the Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Arthur van Benthem discusses electricity pricing inefficiencies and the potential benefits of real-time pricing for consumers.
Key points
- The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join Dan Loney as he explores innovative research from Wharton faculty, focusing on energy pricing.
- Real-Time Pricing Challenges. Arthur van Benthem discusses the complexities and consumer resistance to real-time electricity pricing.
- Potential Savings with Smart Charging. Consumers can save money by charging electric vehicles during off-peak hours under real-time pricing.
Episode highlights
- The Ripple Effect PodcastJoin Dan Loney as he explores innovative research from Wharton faculty, focusing on energy pricing.“Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty.”0:33Feb 18, 2025
- Real-Time Pricing ChallengesArthur van Benthem discusses the complexities and consumer resistance to real-time electricity pricing.“People don’t like unpredictable bills.”6:15Feb 18, 2025
- Potential Savings with Smart ChargingConsumers can save money by charging electric vehicles during off-peak hours under real-time pricing.“That’s a huge percentage of your electricity bill.”9:10Feb 18, 2025





