Cognitive Neighborhoods and the Valuation of Innovation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The value of a patent is determined largely by the worth of the underlying invention. But how it is classified also affects its valuation, according to Wharton research. More: http://knlg.net/1RLW668 📂 Innovation 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. i'm here with Wharton management professor Tyler rye and doctoral student Adam caster who are here to talk about
  2. their paper cognitive neighborhoods in the valuation of innovation across national analysis welcome thank you
  3. thanks so tell us about your paper yeah so in a nutshell this paper is trying to
  4. understand exactly how classification systems which differ across countries how that affects outcomes animation in
  5. particular trying to understand how the classification system affects how patent
  6. examiner's search for prior art and how they find sort of what might be relevant
  7. or not relevant so what are some of the key takeaways of your paper so the key takeaways are that it's really important
  8. to understand how the classification system affects the way that an innovators innovation is going to be is
  9. going to be viewed and seen so if it's a sign to a certain class it's a class that is much more central and much more
  10. related to other technology classes it's going to be much more likely to be picked up by others when they're doing
  11. future examination search by not only patent examiner's but also inventors so it's going to much more likely we cited
  12. and probably much more likely to be more highly valued so that's an important key
  13. takeaway yeah absolutely you know something that's interesting to keep in mind when we're looking at patents and
  14. classification and the valuation of intellectual property is there's an assumption that the number of citations
  15. that a patent gets in future innovation is a reflection of its value and what Adams done really nicely in this paper
  16. is show that it's not just a reflection of the quality of the patent that's driving its valuation but it really is
  17. where it gets slotted into the classification system so examiner's like all of us use heuristics and shortcuts
  18. to think about what's related in what isn't and what we've done in the paper is actually modeled this out and shown
  19. the structural characteristics of the different patent classes in terms of how they relate to each other based on how
  20. examiners are searching and the big takeaway is that the same piece of intellectual property if it's in a class
  21. a patent class that is in the neighborhood of many examiners are more likely to then cite
  22. it in future patent searches and this is going to affect its valuation so irrespective of quality its examiner's
  23. it's their cognition and it's the properties of the categorization system that really seemed to be driving
  24. valuation in an important way as well as perceptions of what is a breakthrough technology versus what isn't and in to
  25. add on to that another important aspect that we find is that we're looking at cross different patent systems so we're
  26. looking at the US Japan and Germany and you can see that there is structural differences in the classification
  27. systems across these different patenting jurisdictions and that this itself you know just even looking at the exact same
  28. innovation being applied for in these different systems kind of very different outcomes purely based off of or at least
  29. in a strong part due to the fact that the way that the technology is classified is different and so this
  30. isn't really important for for practitioners to sort of be aware of and also just in terms of better
  31. understanding exactly not only evaluation itself but is how I was mentioning what might be breakthrough
  32. what might not be breakthrough what's the best way to ensure that something might be a breakthrough is going to be
  33. seen by the most people going forward so what conclusions have any surprised you
  34. so I think for me personally I expected that for technology classes that were very central so we're very related other
  35. technology classes I thought there'd be a downside in the sense that if it's highly related it might distract it
  36. might detract attention away from that focal class so if you think about a patent examiner inventor who has a
  37. technology and they're looking back if it's if the technology class itself that they're originally searching it is very
  38. broad they might leave as much time to search directly in that in that primary class so I was really expecting there to
  39. be sort of a negative effect as well at least in terms of saying that while it's
  40. going to it's going to say it's going to basically push attention further outwards and I thought there might be a
  41. negative effect what was rising to us is that we didn't find that at all in fact
  42. what we do find that most of the you know the difference in terms of what technologies get cited more often than
  43. not comes from citations from outside the class there was actually no negative effect within the class itself which I
  44. think for me was was surprising I thought there'd be some some negative associated with with sort
  45. of being more central yeah and for me my my big takeaway is uh you know a little
  46. less complicated in your uh which I agree absolutely everything you've just said but it surprised me that the same
  47. piece of intellectual property applied for in different systems is valued so differently you know you'd expect that
  48. there is some sort of underlying quality that's reflected in the valuation of intellectual property and the degree to
  49. which it's picked up and built on and what we found is that I mean this is true to a certain extent but depending
  50. on the properties of the classification system this changes in really quite dramatic ways and it you know it really
  51. speaks to the cultural creation of innovation and innovation outcomes what are some of the practical implications
  52. of your findings yeah so I think that the first important thing to note especially is is sort of practitioners
  53. to understand the differences across these systems now I think admittedly some the research might be one step away
  54. from you know really being able to explain exactly how should patent applicants really proceed in terms of
  55. trying to maximize value so first I think a first step in an area for future researchers to understand exactly how
  56. much agency they have in terms of what classes are assigned certainly there is at least indicators that the USPTO for
  57. instance has a very strong hand and sort of affecting what the eventual primary classification is going to be which is
  58. what we're looking at but also when applicants file for a patent application there they're required to include a
  59. class when in their first application so i think it's it's clear that the you know the class is important what the
  60. next step is to understand exactly how much agency and what can Apple can't do in order to ensure that their
  61. application their applications are going to be funneled into the classes that they want it and be seen by the the
  62. proper examiner's so what sets your research apart I think you kind of touched on that could you explain a
  63. little bit more yeah absolutely so theoretically there is a large difference in terms of the way that
  64. classification understanding its use as a heuristic has been used and so this context is very different because we're
  65. trying to understand search and particularly sir for innovation so generally generally
  66. the research is focused on consumers looking for specific products which is a slightly different context one where
  67. they already have in their mind a certain type of product they're going to look for and so the dynamics are very
  68. different when you're thinking about technology on the other hand especially in this paper we're looking at
  69. nanotechnology which for a large part of the period that we're studying is a very
  70. nascent area is to understand exactly how do people make sense of these new technologies and in particular when
  71. they're when they're searching trying to understand that it's related where where
  72. might this new you know piece of this new innovation or adventure and fit into the sort of broader sense and where my
  73. in have might one frame it in order to best take advantage of of the you know the institution in terms of its
  74. classification or aspects or become really important I think this is something that's that sort of missed and
  75. more broadly we have a much more fluid view of the way that these classification systems work so
  76. theoretically most of the research is sort of focused on how these classifications are sort of fixed in
  77. time and all individuals really have this sort of the same premonition or the same sort of cognitive schema of what
  78. these classification systems look like whereas whereas we're taking much more fluid look and trying to look at how a
  79. new technology class know technology is starting to become you know sort of more
  80. mainstream and sort of how that affects the innovations over time yeah and I the
  81. only thing I'd add to that is I think that one of the unique things about this work that we're doing is instead of
  82. looking at individual categories or individual classifications which is the traditional approach in the academic
  83. literature we're really highlighting the influence of the properties of the classification system and so we're
  84. taking a level of analysis from here and expanding it out to the broader topography of categories and how they
  85. relate to each other now this leads to some different questions and this is part of you know the basis for you know
  86. want to undertake this research in the first place because the traditional prediction is that if you want to be
  87. understood and you want to be valued you have to fit neatly within a particular category and so this applies very
  88. generally to technologies to people to organizations and there's a large literature that's looked at this
  89. but what hasn't really been looked at is how the embeddedness of the category that you're in in a broader system of
  90. classification effects outcomes for you as a technology a person and organization whatever it is and that's
  91. really the piece that we're bringing to bear in this research showing that yes it's important what category you're in
  92. but really what's driving the effects especially when valuation is based on being on the radar of lots of other
  93. things is where this class sits in the broader system what lessons are in your research applicable to venture
  94. capitalists inventors and businesses are there any yeah I think so just as Tyler
  95. was mentioning oftentimes we think of it being necessary to sort of fit into a single category have a very very salient
  96. identity that fits into a single category and that that is important to degree but especially for I think in
  97. particular new innovations new technologies is in order to get garner widespread attention you actually want
  98. to sort of sometimes appear more broad so in particular it might not be a bad thing I think we're showing that's not a
  99. bad thing to actually fall into multiple different classes because that's going to garner more intention so I think
  100. fundamentally speaking it's important of a sealing identity at the same time I think our research is really going the
  101. direction of showing that actually there's a lot of benefits to sort of spanning multiple different classes
  102. product headers etc because that might garner more attention which ultimately my benefit producers themselves and
  103. venture capitalist in terms of thinking about who they should invest in and the other thing that I'd add to that is to
  104. the extent that venture capitalists or other audiences are looking at patent citations as a way to value startups IP
  105. or even an established company's intellectual property you know they might be picking up some misleading
  106. stuff here so doing close to diligence is probably still very important especially when you're thinking about
  107. something like nanotechnology that really is global in its scope and revolutionary and its potential unless
  108. you're actually getting under the hood and understanding the nuts and bolts of what this technology is doing what its
  109. potential is in the real world you might be missing stuff if you're just looking
  110. at things like you know the traditional measures of forward citations it's picked up by a lot of other
  111. innovations this must be important or it's picked up by lots of diverse innovations so this must be a
  112. breakthrough so what we're showing is you know there's a piece to that that's true but if you're relying just on that
  113. you're probably missing a big chunk of what's actually driving quality in this field
  114. you

Brief Summary

Classification systems across countries affect patent valuation and innovation visibility, emphasizing the importance of understanding these differences.

Key points

  • Understanding Patent Valuation. The classification system significantly affects how patents are valued and perceived.
  • Surprising Findings on Technology Classes. Contrary to expectations, being central in technology classes does not detract attention.
  • Implications for Innovators. Innovators might benefit from spanning multiple categories to attract more attention.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes