Cognitive Neighborhoods and the Valuation of Innovation
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
The value of a patent is determined largely by the worth of the underlying invention. But how it is classified also affects its valuation, according to Wharton research. More: http://knlg.net/1RLW668 📂 Innovation 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- i'm here with Wharton management professor Tyler rye and doctoral student Adam caster who are here to talk about
- their paper cognitive neighborhoods in the valuation of innovation across national analysis welcome thank you
- thanks so tell us about your paper yeah so in a nutshell this paper is trying to
- understand exactly how classification systems which differ across countries how that affects outcomes animation in
- particular trying to understand how the classification system affects how patent
- examiner's search for prior art and how they find sort of what might be relevant
- or not relevant so what are some of the key takeaways of your paper so the key takeaways are that it's really important
- to understand how the classification system affects the way that an innovators innovation is going to be is
- going to be viewed and seen so if it's a sign to a certain class it's a class that is much more central and much more
- related to other technology classes it's going to be much more likely to be picked up by others when they're doing
- future examination search by not only patent examiner's but also inventors so it's going to much more likely we cited
- and probably much more likely to be more highly valued so that's an important key
- takeaway yeah absolutely you know something that's interesting to keep in mind when we're looking at patents and
- classification and the valuation of intellectual property is there's an assumption that the number of citations
- that a patent gets in future innovation is a reflection of its value and what Adams done really nicely in this paper
- is show that it's not just a reflection of the quality of the patent that's driving its valuation but it really is
- where it gets slotted into the classification system so examiner's like all of us use heuristics and shortcuts
- to think about what's related in what isn't and what we've done in the paper is actually modeled this out and shown
- the structural characteristics of the different patent classes in terms of how they relate to each other based on how
- examiners are searching and the big takeaway is that the same piece of intellectual property if it's in a class
- a patent class that is in the neighborhood of many examiners are more likely to then cite
- it in future patent searches and this is going to affect its valuation so irrespective of quality its examiner's
- it's their cognition and it's the properties of the categorization system that really seemed to be driving
- valuation in an important way as well as perceptions of what is a breakthrough technology versus what isn't and in to
- add on to that another important aspect that we find is that we're looking at cross different patent systems so we're
- looking at the US Japan and Germany and you can see that there is structural differences in the classification
- systems across these different patenting jurisdictions and that this itself you know just even looking at the exact same
- innovation being applied for in these different systems kind of very different outcomes purely based off of or at least
- in a strong part due to the fact that the way that the technology is classified is different and so this
- isn't really important for for practitioners to sort of be aware of and also just in terms of better
- understanding exactly not only evaluation itself but is how I was mentioning what might be breakthrough
- what might not be breakthrough what's the best way to ensure that something might be a breakthrough is going to be
- seen by the most people going forward so what conclusions have any surprised you
- so I think for me personally I expected that for technology classes that were very central so we're very related other
- technology classes I thought there'd be a downside in the sense that if it's highly related it might distract it
- might detract attention away from that focal class so if you think about a patent examiner inventor who has a
- technology and they're looking back if it's if the technology class itself that they're originally searching it is very
- broad they might leave as much time to search directly in that in that primary class so I was really expecting there to
- be sort of a negative effect as well at least in terms of saying that while it's
- going to it's going to say it's going to basically push attention further outwards and I thought there might be a
- negative effect what was rising to us is that we didn't find that at all in fact
- what we do find that most of the you know the difference in terms of what technologies get cited more often than
- not comes from citations from outside the class there was actually no negative effect within the class itself which I
- think for me was was surprising I thought there'd be some some negative associated with with sort
- of being more central yeah and for me my my big takeaway is uh you know a little
- less complicated in your uh which I agree absolutely everything you've just said but it surprised me that the same
- piece of intellectual property applied for in different systems is valued so differently you know you'd expect that
- there is some sort of underlying quality that's reflected in the valuation of intellectual property and the degree to
- which it's picked up and built on and what we found is that I mean this is true to a certain extent but depending
- on the properties of the classification system this changes in really quite dramatic ways and it you know it really
- speaks to the cultural creation of innovation and innovation outcomes what are some of the practical implications
- of your findings yeah so I think that the first important thing to note especially is is sort of practitioners
- to understand the differences across these systems now I think admittedly some the research might be one step away
- from you know really being able to explain exactly how should patent applicants really proceed in terms of
- trying to maximize value so first I think a first step in an area for future researchers to understand exactly how
- much agency they have in terms of what classes are assigned certainly there is at least indicators that the USPTO for
- instance has a very strong hand and sort of affecting what the eventual primary classification is going to be which is
- what we're looking at but also when applicants file for a patent application there they're required to include a
- class when in their first application so i think it's it's clear that the you know the class is important what the
- next step is to understand exactly how much agency and what can Apple can't do in order to ensure that their
- application their applications are going to be funneled into the classes that they want it and be seen by the the
- proper examiner's so what sets your research apart I think you kind of touched on that could you explain a
- little bit more yeah absolutely so theoretically there is a large difference in terms of the way that
- classification understanding its use as a heuristic has been used and so this context is very different because we're
- trying to understand search and particularly sir for innovation so generally generally
- the research is focused on consumers looking for specific products which is a slightly different context one where
- they already have in their mind a certain type of product they're going to look for and so the dynamics are very
- different when you're thinking about technology on the other hand especially in this paper we're looking at
- nanotechnology which for a large part of the period that we're studying is a very
- nascent area is to understand exactly how do people make sense of these new technologies and in particular when
- they're when they're searching trying to understand that it's related where where
- might this new you know piece of this new innovation or adventure and fit into the sort of broader sense and where my
- in have might one frame it in order to best take advantage of of the you know the institution in terms of its
- classification or aspects or become really important I think this is something that's that sort of missed and
- more broadly we have a much more fluid view of the way that these classification systems work so
- theoretically most of the research is sort of focused on how these classifications are sort of fixed in
- time and all individuals really have this sort of the same premonition or the same sort of cognitive schema of what
- these classification systems look like whereas whereas we're taking much more fluid look and trying to look at how a
- new technology class know technology is starting to become you know sort of more
- mainstream and sort of how that affects the innovations over time yeah and I the
- only thing I'd add to that is I think that one of the unique things about this work that we're doing is instead of
- looking at individual categories or individual classifications which is the traditional approach in the academic
- literature we're really highlighting the influence of the properties of the classification system and so we're
- taking a level of analysis from here and expanding it out to the broader topography of categories and how they
- relate to each other now this leads to some different questions and this is part of you know the basis for you know
- want to undertake this research in the first place because the traditional prediction is that if you want to be
- understood and you want to be valued you have to fit neatly within a particular category and so this applies very
- generally to technologies to people to organizations and there's a large literature that's looked at this
- but what hasn't really been looked at is how the embeddedness of the category that you're in in a broader system of
- classification effects outcomes for you as a technology a person and organization whatever it is and that's
- really the piece that we're bringing to bear in this research showing that yes it's important what category you're in
- but really what's driving the effects especially when valuation is based on being on the radar of lots of other
- things is where this class sits in the broader system what lessons are in your research applicable to venture
- capitalists inventors and businesses are there any yeah I think so just as Tyler
- was mentioning oftentimes we think of it being necessary to sort of fit into a single category have a very very salient
- identity that fits into a single category and that that is important to degree but especially for I think in
- particular new innovations new technologies is in order to get garner widespread attention you actually want
- to sort of sometimes appear more broad so in particular it might not be a bad thing I think we're showing that's not a
- bad thing to actually fall into multiple different classes because that's going to garner more intention so I think
- fundamentally speaking it's important of a sealing identity at the same time I think our research is really going the
- direction of showing that actually there's a lot of benefits to sort of spanning multiple different classes
- product headers etc because that might garner more attention which ultimately my benefit producers themselves and
- venture capitalist in terms of thinking about who they should invest in and the other thing that I'd add to that is to
- the extent that venture capitalists or other audiences are looking at patent citations as a way to value startups IP
- or even an established company's intellectual property you know they might be picking up some misleading
- stuff here so doing close to diligence is probably still very important especially when you're thinking about
- something like nanotechnology that really is global in its scope and revolutionary and its potential unless
- you're actually getting under the hood and understanding the nuts and bolts of what this technology is doing what its
- potential is in the real world you might be missing stuff if you're just looking
- at things like you know the traditional measures of forward citations it's picked up by a lot of other
- innovations this must be important or it's picked up by lots of diverse innovations so this must be a
- breakthrough so what we're showing is you know there's a piece to that that's true but if you're relying just on that
- you're probably missing a big chunk of what's actually driving quality in this field
- you
Brief Summary
Classification systems across countries affect patent valuation and innovation visibility, emphasizing the importance of understanding these differences.
Key points
- Understanding Patent Valuation. The classification system significantly affects how patents are valued and perceived.
- Surprising Findings on Technology Classes. Contrary to expectations, being central in technology classes does not detract attention.
- Implications for Innovators. Innovators might benefit from spanning multiple categories to attract more attention.
Episode highlights
- Understanding Patent ValuationThe classification system significantly affects how patents are valued and perceived.“It's really important to understand how the classification system affects innovation valuation.”0:44Apr 7, 2016
- Surprising Findings on Technology ClassesContrary to expectations, being central in technology classes does not detract attention.“We didn't find any negative effect within the class itself.”4:17Apr 7, 2016
- Implications for InnovatorsInnovators might benefit from spanning multiple categories to attract more attention.“It's not a bad thing to actually fall into multiple different classes.”10:05Apr 7, 2016
Tension
30/ 100Low tension





