Feel the Pain: How Conflict Influences Decision-making

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

New Wharton research looks at how the pain of others struggling with the agony of decision-making can influence our own process. More: http://knlg.net/1PKwnhe 📂 Human Resources;Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. okay so so when we think about many decisions that we make throughout our lives uh often a central component of
  2. the decision- making process is the emotional conflict that we experience while making the the the choice now when
  3. we think about emotional conflict there there are a lot of different symptoms for emotional conflicts like increased
  4. heart rate body language facial expressions and so on now when we think about it these are observables so it's
  5. very easy for us to spot others it could be strangers at a store family members managers very easy for us to spot that
  6. someone is experiencing a certain amount of choice conflict the question we ask in this research is a very
  7. straightforward yet important and understudied question is how does observing someone else going through
  8. this emotional conflict while making a decision impact our own prefer preferences will we be more or less
  9. likely to choose a similar option chosen by a conflicted versus a non-conflicted
  10. person so what we found is that when I observe someone else going through this emotional conflict in Choice I'll be
  11. more likely to actually choose a similar option the question is why what we find
  12. is very interesting we find that our immediate instinctive reaction towards someone else's pain and an Agony if you
  13. will over over a decision is to empathize with this individual we'll start taking this person
  14. perspective sharing his emotional states which leads to what is called greater connectedness or merging so so in a
  15. sense I'll start seeing this person in a more self-like manner okay which and this process will essentially lead me to
  16. choose a similar option okay um what's interesting is that we find that this tendency is much stronger for people who
  17. have a greater innate tendency to empathize with others so so for example in one in one experiment in one study uh
  18. people observed someone making a certain decision which to which of two Charities
  19. to donate money to what they didn't know is that this person was actually a paid
  20. actor one time this person acted as if the decision is extremely conflicted and difficult and in another condition uh it
  21. wasn't very difficult and what we find is that whenever we observe people observe this conflicted actor they were
  22. much more likely to donate to the charity chosen by this conflicted person so so I think there are several
  23. intriguing results uh uh the first one is that this response to to emotional conflict experienced by others is is
  24. extremely innate it's spontaneous it it will happen even if we observe a complete stranger that we that we do not
  25. know another interesting uh finding is that we find that this happens also when we know that the choice made by this
  26. person is completely random so let me give you an example so so imagine I'm playing a certain game and You observe
  27. me and the game is pretty simple I have two doors behind one door there's a huge
  28. monetary reward let's say a million dollars okay behind another door there's nothing now the game is very simple I
  29. need to open one of the doors and whatever is behind this door I get to keep I'll be conflicted I mean I have a
  30. chance here to win million dollars I don't know what to do I'll probably think about it and you'll see this
  31. conflict now this conflict that you observe uh would not inform you about how thoughtful I am right there is no
  32. right decision it's a completely random decision yet what we find is even in these situations where you know it's
  33. completely random you'll be more likely to choose the same door that I chose when I uh when I uh was experienced
  34. conflict in Choice the Third intriguing result is that this effect will happen only if you believe that the conflict
  35. that I experience and exhibit is warranted to the decision at hand if you see me conflicted about something you
  36. think is Trivial the effect would completely go away and sometimes even reverse so going back to the doors
  37. example let's say that behind one door there's million but now behind the the second door there's $900,000 so in both
  38. cases say no matter what I choose I'm going to make a lot of money now if you see me conflicted about this decision
  39. you'll actually gravitate away from it so first at the the most higher level abstract level we find that pain and
  40. conflict bring us brings us closer now we can think about many situations managers politicians and and other
  41. situations where there are certain group dynamics voting jury duty for example where one wishes to form or build a
  42. certain consensus around a certain decision he's about to make or already made now the common wisdom will be to be
  43. decisive right as a manager as a politician I need to show decisiveness This research act actually suggest that
  44. in some situations sharing the emotional conflict that you're experiencing while
  45. making a certain decision would actually be very helpful to build consensus uh as
  46. group members or or the team that I'm leading would have a greater tendency to choose uh like I did for example in one
  47. study we asked group members to cast a vote about a certain decision real decision that involved U monetary uh
  48. outcomes what we found is that the voting of the group converged to the voting of the first group member if this
  49. first group member showed conflict while making the choice so we see a very interesting group dynamics where one
  50. person is very conflicted how other others in the group would converge to the same
  51. choice so I think that the first of all this research suggests that when we think about social influence how others
  52. people's behaviors and choices impacts our own This research suggests that our preferences are shaped not only by the
  53. ultimate choice that others are making but also by the process leading to this choice if I see an emotional conflict
  54. then I'll I'll converge more so so next steps uh in terms of this re research is
  55. first of all to look at other decision cues other things that happens during the decisional process that might
  56. influence the observer's preferences we also started looking at how process cues
  57. such as conflict would impact not only my preferences but also my own decision process will I be more likely to be
  58. conflicted when I see others conflicted or less likely and so on and the third part the third uh uh in kind of uh uh
  59. investigation that that that we're looking at or research is H we're looking at from the other opposite side
  60. how does it make us feel when someone else sees that we're experiencing conflict in choice
  61. [Music]

Brief Summary

Observing emotional conflict in others influences our decision-making and can foster group consensus.

Key points

  • The Impact of Emotional Conflict. Observing someone in emotional conflict can influence our own decision-making. 'When I observe someone else going through this emotional conflict, I’ll be more likely to choose a similar option.'
  • Empathy and Decision-Making. Empathy towards others' pain can lead us to make similar choices. 'Our immediate instinctive reaction towards someone else’s pain is to empathize.'

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes