How Ben & Jerry’s Got Bought Out Without Selling Out

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Despite being bought out by Unilever in 2000, Ben & Jerry's has managed to keep intact the commitment to social justice that was baked into the firm by its founders. More: http://knlg.net/1NY65Tr 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Katherine kleene I'm delighted to be speaking at knowledge of Orton today with yosin solheim CEO of Ben and
  2. Jerry's the iconic delicious ice cream company and we're really here to talk about not only your ice cream we must
  3. talk a little about your ice cream but really the social mission of the company uh and how you have maintained that
  4. social Mission even as Ben and Jerry's has become part of Unilever uh and has continued for many years well yeah I
  5. know great to be here thank you for I uh you know I think it's like all companies
  6. with a long history Ben Jers is now 36 years as a mission Le company I think the the key thing in the whole
  7. transition to one shareholder from multiple shareholders was the Govern structure that was put in place and I
  8. think Unity was very Visionary in recognizing that you know it says Ben and Jerry on the packaging yes if Ben
  9. and Jerry go out and say well this is all you know it's not really true anymore this is not a mission Le company
  10. anymore that would really undermine the value of that acquisition so unever acquired uh Benes in
  11. 2000 and uh this was a company that where the brand where the social mission was part of was baked into the brand
  12. it's an integral part of how we do business and and Unilever saw that and its investors saw this from the
  13. beginning and saw value and and even at that time saw value in this so that's why they set up and together with the
  14. then sitting board agreed to set up an independent board of directors and that act basically like our benefit uh
  15. Corporation director they are responsible for the social mission for the Integrity of the Ben andary's brand
  16. our policies they even get involved in basic things like wage setting in the factories where we have a livable wage
  17. policy uh that is overseen by by the board of governor of directors and and the directors are self- selecting so un
  18. has two seats of 11 board members fascinating and so so unusual very and had a career in ice cream at unever
  19. before coming on five years ago as CEO of Ben jer's how how was that transition to go from the larger entity of unever
  20. to this interesting different uh Mission driven company yeah I don't know whether
  21. that transition was tougher for them or for me uh but no I I you know unver as a
  22. company is very aligned in its values it actually has a lot of diversity in it in
  23. terms of management styles personalities it has a history of quite a lot of autonomy in its in its senior leaders so
  24. it wasn't like a a super stark contrast you know I worked in Italy I worked in Sweden the culture of Ben and Jerry's is
  25. actually similar right to uh to typical Scandinavian company it's a flat non-h hierarchical sort of approach to
  26. business so uh no so the biggest thing for me was I felt a big sense of responsibility sure uh and uh but with a
  27. really exciting group of people to work with and have stayed involved in some in
  28. yeah you know they're they're not they are involved uh but they do more of their own things they have the best jobs
  29. in the world their job is to be Ben and to be Jerry and they basically just have
  30. to deliver on that uh so day today is really the management team and the board of directors interesting so Ben jer's
  31. describes itself as a as a values-driven company um you celebrate the your social
  32. environmental governance uh values on the website can you talk with us about how that plays out in action you know
  33. how how do we move from words to to deeds and actions well I think that's the key point a lot of companies would
  34. say they're consumer Le yes you know whether that's in product development or in ad Mission similarly when companies
  35. that come to the world of CSR or whatever they look at what do people really care about and then how can we be
  36. part of that as Ben and J we come out it the other way we actually start with what do we truly believe in us and then
  37. we execute really well because we truly believe in it and hence convince others to join us so that's what we really mean
  38. by values that it starts with our values and then we apply it enjoying movements
  39. and other partners to make change so talk to us about some of those specific values and and how they are enacted
  40. through your products through your Employment Practices and we one yeah take one with just just one uh let's
  41. take samesex marriage yeah uh so that came uh on the agenda in the 80s at Ben and Jerry's Ben and Jerry was one of the
  42. first companies to offer samex Partners the same rights yeah Health Care Etc so when that started to come into uh the
  43. public domain and and become a debate it's very clear for the company we can't just say well you're okay if you're a
  44. Ben and jerus but if you're not you're not so it was very natural for the employees to join in and campaign for
  45. same-sex marriage and then as we grew bigger and bigger we scale that campaign up whereby now we have you know we we
  46. finished in the US with a supreme court uh decision this year but we also won in
  47. Ireland we put it on the map in Australia in France uh in multiple countries where this comes up uh it's
  48. something that we believe in we don't do an assessment if this is popular or unpopular when we started a same-sex uh
  49. marriage uh campaign in Australia not a single political party supported samex marriage and everybody came to us what
  50. are you doing you shouldn't do well sorry this is something we really believe in right and as you do that so
  51. you've had employee individual employees engaged in these campaigns um B Jerry's
  52. as a company as a major uh donor or leading a campaign yeah no I mean we run this you know it's it's the amazing
  53. thing is that selling ice cream and uh running campaigns is the same set of skills you want to get people's
  54. attention you need social media H you need events and and the one great thing that we have of course is ice
  55. cream right it's very hard to be angry and eat ice cream at the same time it's very tempting to stop and and sign a
  56. petition if there's free ice cream so ice cream plays a really important role in how we connect with our fans but no
  57. we we we we treat those campaigns in exactly the same way as we would treat a new product launch and sometimes they
  58. actually appear on the on on your products right I saw this but I I I do I do or I I I do I do was the celebration
  59. of of the same sex marriage act right now we've just launched a product uh save our swir where which is in support
  60. of a binding climate uh uh agreement in Paris the cop in five weeks time and we launched that with uh Tesla out on the
  61. west coast and then we actually launched the European version in Bon during the climate negotiation
  62. inside the climate negotiations at the UN so we had the opportunity to to feed all those people trying to work this out
  63. for us right and and and you actually use ice cream as a as a metaphor for global warming right we show what ice
  64. cream looks like if it's just two degrees warmer and it's a bit of a mess it's a bit of a mess yeah it's a
  65. fabulous a fabulous metaphor like this is what happens to your ice cream cones in two degrees what happens to the world
  66. if it's warmer in two degrees um are there instances where you uh as a CEO you as a company have said yeah we care
  67. about that issue we can't go there that we're that's too that's too hot that's too
  68. controversial there are many issues where we've had to say we can't go there not necessarily because they're too hot
  69. or too controversial more because we don't judge our that we have a real ability to
  70. make an impact or that we are really prepared pred you know we really believe we got to walk the talk not just talk so
  71. we want to really align our internal programs with the external campaigning so there are issues that come up that
  72. are important and legitimate issues and we we haven't you know built an internal
  73. program and we'll start that and then join in uh but controversy is not something that that scares us maybe it
  74. should but it doesn't you know we we were the only Corporation to support Occupy Wall Street uh at sone Park which
  75. was a surprise to them yeah as well and uh you know and as I say nothing bad really happened to our business as a
  76. result of that yeah so what so what are the as um you know we like to uh hope in
  77. the social impact space that that one that companies can actually achieve a positive Financial return and a social
  78. return uh on investment and on their on social impact strategies what's your sense of uh you know how this pays off
  79. or doesn't pay off for for Ben and Jerry's is there is there I mean it sounds terribly craft
  80. but is there money to be made through Corporate social responsibility through this kind of values driven
  81. company there is there is because people want to make a difference with all the things that they can actions and
  82. activities that they can can do so what you buy and how you buy it is a big part
  83. of your everyday life and increasingly uh consumers are saying I don't want to waste my money on on
  84. products I don't try to make a difference now there's a lot of greenwash out there
  85. and I would uh you know so people are are rightly so skeptical and demand you know real evidence and and and and some
  86. other uh authorities and just what a company say but uh it's the fastest growing area of fast moving consumer
  87. goods by far socially responsible companies are making up 60% of the growth in fast moving consumer goods in
  88. developed markets and if you look at like a neelson statistic that just came out now which was across 14 countries
  89. what you're seeing is the rate of change is really picking up uh in 2013 50% of respondents said that they would pay
  90. more for a socially responsible product today that's already at 66% and accelerating and obviously a Big
  91. Driver of that is our wonderful Millennials yeah yeah and and do you see this as something that any company can
  92. do I mean there Ben and Jerry's what could be criticized on some you know is this a healthy product I'm thinking of
  93. other products that we may look at and say that's not a that's not a healthy product that's not a product that's good
  94. for the environment and yet can any company um find ways to AB absolutely to to live this Mission absolutely uh I
  95. think you know not every company will become a a you know an activist company or a campaigning company uh like Ben and
  96. jares I wouldn't I wouldn't think that's that's appropriate for every company but
  97. every company can make uh those decisions that optimize their social impact and their business impact in any
  98. industry anywhere that benefits their employees their communities the environment um whichever
  99. constituents that they they address so I don't think this is something unique to
  100. specific companies uh on the on the healthy or non-healthy products and good products and bad products again you know
  101. for us it's all about transparency and I always say you know when you're tucking
  102. into a Ben and& jer's and you're on a diet you you know you know there's no hidden calories here they're right there
  103. right for you to enjoy and the world needs all sorts of different things uh to function so now I think transparency
  104. is critical MH uh in any offer people should really understand what they're getting into and we shouldn't try to
  105. fool people we shouldn't have hidden sugars and hidden fats Etc it's got to be transparent and open and open choices
  106. uh and and it goes the same for all other Industries so again I think it's very hard to say oh I'm in this business
  107. and this product hence I can't get a social impact right strategy right interesting um and as you think about
  108. the social impact that that Ben and Jerry's has had in the places where you've tried to make a difference um and
  109. I'm particularly interested in your own operations whether this is your supply chain uh your HR practices um can you
  110. talk to us about something that you're particularly proud of perhaps something relatively recent and then areas where
  111. you say we haven't cracked this nut we still have work to do in this area I think actually we could could be the
  112. same example actually in a sense you know when when we uh we did a sort of a assessment around what are the really
  113. big and important issues and what are the really urgent issues uh that are important to us I mean we did a lot of
  114. internal discussion and it was very clear to us that there were two big big topics that we need to address over the
  115. next 5 to 10 years and that's climate and climate Justice right and it's urgent and that's Equity as we're seeing
  116. Equity both racial and income uh the inequities that we're seeing is creating such a tension in society it's hard even
  117. to operate businesses neither in that environment of climate change and the environment or inequity so we've really
  118. embraced these two topics and what I'm the most proud of is to just see how our teams our partners really embrace it and
  119. scale it and and really throw themselves into making a difference that's probably
  120. what makes me the most proud right uh what we have in crack is how do you reduce your carbon footprint by 80% true
  121. when you you know there's a lot of again noise out there or we going to be carbon
  122. neutral or this or that well the carbon footprint of a business goes end to end it starts on a farm and finishes with a
  123. you know the waste product sure and you need to take responsibility for the whole thing and we need to reduce that
  124. by 80% 50% of our carbon fopr is in ingredients wow so so it originates on a farm and and we really believe that
  125. carbon neutrality is a real opportunity for Farmers to generate another income stream in carbon in setting so it's one
  126. of those things we haven't cracked it because we're not there but what we did was we put a price on carbon so we said
  127. we put arbitrarily $10 end to end per ton yeah and then we allocate that money to a carbon insetting program where we
  128. inherently are investing in Farmers to inset Carbon on their Farms fascinating and and on the the inequity inequality
  129. front uh I maybe two questions um making clear so what what is the I mean it sometimes intuitively we can see
  130. this but what is the connection you're between business success and inequality what is that negative relationship
  131. you're seeing uh and and how might you take action in this space so you know that's typically the first question you
  132. get when you're getting involved in in structural racism H and and other of these really
  133. Dee rooted social issues and what's in it for a business if you actually look at the correlation of success of
  134. economic success and inequality uh is highly correl ated so so we have an inherent value and
  135. belief that a society where everybody's treated justly and equally it's just a better Community to be in uh but
  136. actually if you look at the econometrics of it it Maps out very nicely as well in
  137. terms of economic uh opportunity and success so it's not a direct correlation it
  138. comes from our human values it comes from the values we have in our company uh but we also really see those
  139. communities thriving and doing better and being better for our business so that's a that's a sort of a link now
  140. climate Justice is about climate change but it's also about the fact that it's the poor people right disadvantaged
  141. people they get hurt first the wealthy can move the you know and can shift around the poor cannot so that has an
  142. equity component in it but as we're moving now into the next phase for us you know we have to recognize that we're
  143. a terribly white company you know we we come from Vermont Vermont's 96% white so
  144. we've had to do a lot of work in our company to really really really understand it and we've partnered with a
  145. whole host of different amazing Partners we've had a lot of Nos and activists has
  146. have taken their time and invested in us right uh to to make it get a better understanding of this and and I think
  147. 2016 will be exciting it's a it's election year it's a great opportunity as I like to see to say to rearrange the
  148. lighting to get a disproportionate impact on certain key issues like voter rights and and and
  149. minority participation and our democracy great fabulous talking with with you and
  150. uh you know just a extraordinary impact through ice cream and starting with ice cream so thank you much for thank you so
  151. much for being with us thank you C great thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Yosin Solheim discusses Ben and Jerry's social mission and activism under Unilever's ownership, emphasizing corporate responsibility and community impact.

Key points

  • Ben & Jerry's Social Mission. Ben & Jerry's maintains its social mission even after being acquired by Unilever.
  • Campaign for Same-Sex Marriage. Ben & Jerry's was one of the first companies to support same-sex marriage rights.
  • Corporate Social Responsibility Success. Ben & Jerry's sees financial success through its commitment to social responsibility.
  • Transparency in Business Practices. Ben & Jerry's emphasizes transparency in its product offerings and practices.
  • Climate Justice Commitment. The company is focused on addressing climate change and social equity.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes