How 9/11 Changed the FDNY Forever
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE The FDNY was forced to rethink almost everything after 9/11.
Gregory P. Shea, Wharton Adjunct Professor of Management and author of Rising from Ground Zero, explains how the department transformed its approach to mental health, leadership, training, and disaster response.
The conversation explores how firefighters overcame cultural barriers to psychological support, why the FDNY turned to the U.S. Forest Service for help, and how the department became an all-hazards organization better prepared for future catastrophes.
ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Well, as we approach the 25th anniversary of 9-11, a new book looks at the transformation made by the FDNY, the Fire Department
- of New York, in the wake of that horrific day where 343 of their firefighters were
- among the over 2,700 people who lost their lives that day. The book is titled Rising from Ground Zero,
- and Greg Shea, who's a senior fellow at the Wharton Center for Leadership and Change Management,
- is one of the authors of the book, and he joins us right now to discuss it. Greg, great to catch up with you again.
- How are you, sir? Good, good to see you and be with you again. Obviously, this is a very, it's a very
- emotional time, but when you think about the transformation, what was it that made you want
- to look at this aspect of this whole incident around 9-11? Well, the project really evolved.
- It started with Andre Klotze, one of the other authors, plopping down in front of me
- at Executive Ed. He works, does work in different programs as a facilitator and saying, would you like to
- do a few interviews? Well, nine years later and 90 hours of interviews, we wrote a book.
- But the, so to answer the question in terms of how we ended up looking at this, it came out of the interviews.
- We got access largely due to Paul Brown, who was the other co-author, who's a retired captain of the FDNY and a third
- -generation firefighter, which is not that unusual inside the FDNY. We had a street cred that let us
- in. I think the way that we did what we did and then the ways we wrote the articles we did showed that we were
- trustworthy partners in bringing the story out. And a lot of people talked to us
- who didn't talk to us, didn't talk to other people before outside, certainly not as a
- collective. And so out of that, we followed our noses and the day needs reporting.
- And we've got all that and a lot of oral history in there. But I think part of the story that's
- not told is, and we discovered it as we went through it, was how long the tail was to how the FDNY handled this.
- So the short answer is it evolved, Dan. Yeah. So there were many aspects to this transformation,
- which you go through each of these different components. I'll start with one of them, which caught
- my attention, is just the healing process that not only the FDNY, but the firefighters had
- to go through after this horrific event where so many of their brothers and sisters were
- killed. It was fundamental. And these are tough human beings. I mean, you start with the fact of
- New Yorkers, which moves you down the toughness scale right there. And then it's FDNY, so they're fighting fires.
- They came out of the war years, which is the 80s, 70s, 80s, which was New York City, had all kinds of problems, including
- lots of arson and lots of fires. They referred to them as the war years. So these people were particularly tough individuals coming
- into this time. So as one of the people we interviewed, who's Paul Brown's author brother, said, reflecting what
- many people said was, prior to 9-11, we took our therapy out of a bottle. And that he said, but then with the
- comment that other people made was, this was just too big. This was too big, too broad, too deep.
- We were going to do something different this time. And they had a small support services largely
- around addiction and substance abuse. And they rapidly expanded that. So that was an institutional piece.
- But Dan, I think one of the really interesting things was these seasoned people, the leaders,
- knew what I just said. I learned it from them in terms of the depth of the hurt, both individually and
- collectively. And it's not that the department hadn't lost people, but never at this scale.
- And so they put psychological resources into the firehouses almost immediately. The firehouses are the basic unit there.
- But they weren't getting utilized. The psychologists were basically sitting in a firehouse
- and people weren't going to break the norms and they didn't know who these people were.
- But the leadership didn't give up, Dan. They said, this is a problem. We just haven't found the right solution.
- So what they did the next wave was they brought in veterans, retirees of the FDNY
- and trained more to basically provide an opportunity in the firehouses and also triage, provide an
- entry point into psychological and emotional services. And that made a big difference.
- And so Dan, that maintained itself over time. They have a much bigger resource now.
- And as some folks in the interview said, then what you don't need, you know, therapy
- out of a bottle. Now, if you have a problem, you even talk to somebody, the question in the firehouse
- is why aren't you talking to somebody? That's a huge change. Well, and something you brought up a moment
- ago is the fact that the FDNY is trying to do this reorganization and work with their firefighters.
- At the same time, they're also still trying to protect millions and millions of people in
- New York City, which is an incredible challenge in itself. Yes, absolutely. And so they had to run in the
- short term. Well, they believe that they were up to response time. Sometime, in other words, the quickness of response,
- sometime midday, plus or minus on September 11th. Right. Yeah. So while they were doing all this other
- stuff and then they had to, they were still tending to what they needed to tend to, because as you said, this is the
- busiest fire department in the world. Yeah. And they had to still do that. And the, I think one of the remarkable
- things about them was that they quickly adjusted in the short term to doing 24 hour
- shifts on site, off site. And then they moved to allocation within a week or two of how to have adequate,
- but skeleton crews out there, as well as people on the site. So they continued to evolve the way that
- they handled both dealing with the site, which was both physical and emotional, as well as
- dealing with their ongoing responsibilities. So you talk about the fact of the response was somewhat traditional up until the towers
- came down. How did that dynamic get incorporated now in the processes of the FDNY?
- Because there's nothing that would ever say that we couldn't see that happen again.
- And you want those firefighters as prepared as possible for something well beyond what the normal
- response might be. Well, I think multiple things, I'll give a couple. One would be that they have done a
- tremendous amount of opening of themselves to training from outside. So as one of the commissioners that we
- interviewed, former commissioners, said, he said, the FDNY is 150 years of service uninterrupted by progress.
- So when you've got somebody who's the commissioner, who says that, and that's what he's doing,
- he's going to change this. We're moving on here. So I think that includes things like they
- established a terrorism center. I've been there. I taught there. They really increased the openness to outside training,
- including places like Wharton and the center that I'm affiliated with, Mike Yusim Center.
- At the military academies, they've expanded their training facilities. They expanded the leadership training that people get.
- They've increased and improved the connection with other agencies inside of the city, including the police,
- and they do more joint training together. So that type of collaboration, as well as
- down to something that's a knit, is they, although they did attend to this in 9 -11, it's part of the formal process of
- not leading from the front as much as they did. They still lead from the front, but you
- got to leave somebody back in HQ, which they did, but now it's official. You got to make sure we got some
- of the leaders secure away from the site. And I noticed that there, I guess, was
- a partnership that was developed with the Forest Service out of all of this. Tell us a little bit about that.
- Yeah. As one of the senior leaders said, if somebody had told me before 9-11 that
- one of our key resources would be from the Forestry Department, he said, I would have
- had them committed. But as I told them, I thank God you people show it up. So, and what they, what these people do
- or did brought to this is there's a tremendous federal capacity to handle massive, massive catastrophes.
- We think about in our lifetime, like Hurricane Katrina, a lot of the wildfires are of
- a scale that's unbelievable in the West, Superstorm Sandy. Well, the people who deal with that are
- incident management teams out of forestry, out of wildland fires. And so when these people showed up and
- this part of one of the chapters is the skill with which they approach this particular
- situation is normally they show up, they take over. As they said, we knew that wasn't going
- to happen this time. So we have to develop, they had to develop a relationship with the FDNY that was
- valued and supportive. And the process that they went through to do that was so effective that not only
- were they an integral part, the FDNY fought to keep them there longer and the FDNY
- made a major part of their training incident management, which is basically the logistics, the unbelievable
- complication of doing something like this kind of project for fire departments there for eight months
- on site and just getting people fed, paying medical care, all the rest. And they not only took it on to
- do it, become good at it in the moment, they've made a part of themselves and then they've made themselves available to the feds.
- And you will see, if you look at film from Hurricane Katrina, the Superstorm Sandy in
- Portland today, you will see if you look at enough tape, FDNY capped. That's because they are FDNY people who've been
- called in to help. They're not fighting the fire, they're helping in the very thing that they had to learn
- from the forestry department. So then how do you say that the FDNY has come out the other side with
- all of this change? It seems like, obviously, this is all for the good. And as the book talks about, this has
- transformed how the FDNY does its work every day. Well, it changes definition to being an all
- hazards department, which is a very different definition. It includes and principally is firefighting.
- But they came on the other side with, as I mentioned, incident management, that ability.
- They came out with a much stronger family and psychological support in a formal sense.
- As one of the people we interviewed said, I knew when we started that, that we were stronger than we were before the 11th.
- And they've come out with a much broader and deeper kind of training, which they've sustained
- in terms of the way that they think about their training, particularly of their leaders at
- different stages as they move up. Those are very significant changes in an organization,
- and they've sustained them. Greg, I greatly appreciate your time to discuss this and all the best with the book.
- And obviously, I think it's going to be an important read for a lot of people. Thank you, sir.
- Thank you. Thanks for having me, Dan. Be well. Thank you. Wharton's Greg Shea. The title of the book is Rising from
- Ground Zero, and it is out and available now.
Brief Summary
Greg Shea discusses the FDNY's transformation post-9/11, focusing on healing, training, and new support systems for firefighters.
Key points
- Rising from Ground Zero. A new book explores the FDNY's transformation after 9-11, highlighting resilience and change.
- The Healing Process. Firefighters had to undergo a significant healing process after losing many colleagues on 9-11.
Episode highlights
- Rising from Ground ZeroA new book explores the FDNY's transformation after 9-11, highlighting resilience and change.“This was too big, too broad, too deep.”3:36Sep 11, 2026
- The Healing ProcessFirefighters had to undergo a significant healing process after losing many colleagues on 9-11.“Now, if you have a problem, you even talk to somebody.”5:19Sep 11, 2026
