Joseph Pfeifer (Former FDNY Chief) on Leadership Through 9/11 & Emergency Preparedness

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

KNOWLEDGE@WHARTON ARCHIVES: On September 11, 2001, New York City Fire Department Battalion Chief Joseph Pfeifer saw the first aircraft hit the North Tower and radioed the alarm, the first FDNY fire chief to take command. Today, Pfeifer is the New York City Fire Department's Chief of Counterterrorism and Emergency Preparedness and a Citywide Command Chief. Wharton management professor Michael Useem talked with Pfeifer recently about his leadership during the 9/11 rescue efforts, what firefighters in NYC and beyond do to prepare for the unexpected, and lessons learned in leadership and crisis management.

More on this interview: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/leading-on-911-and-beyond-new-york-city-fire-departments-joseph-pfeifer/ 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] this is Mike us and today we have Joseph feifer from the New York fire department
  2. he is the chief of counterterrorism and emergency preparedness for the City of New York and he's a city Citywide
  3. command chief for the City of New York responsible for commanding major incidents uh in the city Joe great to
  4. have you here and I'm going to begin Joe by asking you about basically your career with the the department you
  5. joined in 1981 and during especially your early years what have been some of the most
  6. informative experiences that helped you learn how to lead people into uh sometimes in the Harm's Way many days
  7. are routine but some days are not in the life of a firefighter so your your formative moments if you would well when
  8. I first came into the fire department as a probationary firefighter I was told the most important thing is to know the
  9. job know what you need to do so I started reading reading a lot of the fire manuals and procedures um but
  10. that's only half of it the other is actually experiencing um firefighting there a tcid knowledge of of of how to
  11. force a door how to climb an aerial ladder 100t in the air um but to be a good firefighter to be good at anything
  12. is is really having the competency and and knowing uh what to do um as I became an officer it was it was more than just
  13. knowing what to do is being responsible for firefighters and that point was made
  14. um actually after 9/11 I was uh in command of a third alarm fire up in the Bronx so we have about 100 firefighters
  15. at the scene uh about three dozen pieces of apparatus and the fire goes out and I'm leaving and I have this firefighter
  16. running down the block after me and says chief chief chief and I stop and he turns and I turn around and he says
  17. Chief I just want to let you know that I'll follow you down any hallway now for firefighting for
  18. firefighting the most dangerous part is is a hallway becomes like a uh like a chimney and all the smoke and and heat
  19. fills into the hallway and I thought wow this is this is a very nice compliment and then when
  20. I got back to my car I realized he was saying just more than I'll follow you he was saying that I'll follow I'll be with
  21. you I'll follow you and I want you to keep us safe see leadership is about um not giving orders but it's about sharing
  22. the sharing the danger and that firefighter was saying that that that that because of what I've done in the
  23. past that he'll follow he'll be with me uh during the next uh major event uh an awesome responsibility I could actually
  24. feel that pressure of of the responsibility for others and uh and um he meant what he said a formative moment
  25. very much so Joe let me ask about a set of documents that I know you help prepare a set of checklists of the New
  26. York fire department reference particular incidents if you will so you have a checklist if there's a
  27. radioactivity release you have a checklist in case of a building collapse you have a checklist that has the title
  28. the MayDay checklist talk if you would about why you develop these checklists and then how they're used in practice by
  29. members of the New York fire department we use a checklist as shortcuts um and and for a radiological
  30. incident there's a we don't do that a lot of times so we need a a list to follow what procedures but as a shortcut
  31. is it's it's how do we deal with the stress of a situation so during a fire as the fire becomes more and more
  32. complex and and uh and we have to make decisions the stress level increases one of the most um difficult
  33. times as as a commanding Chief would be a mayday Mayday is a message from the firefighter that the firefighter is in
  34. trouble that the firefighter is um trapped doesn't know his or her way out of the building that something's
  35. seriously wrong a life and death situation immediately the stress level goes up and and you have to deal with
  36. that and at the same time fight the fire so we use a a checklist and and an acronym um the word we use is lunar what
  37. what we want to know is the me M's location his or her unit the assignment um and what resources do we
  38. have available um in the person's name um that is critical critical information so we can make sure that firefighter
  39. gets out of the building alive um it it helps to to to uh know what to do right away and it and it's very
  40. focused another thing we're we're dealing with now is how do we use technology as a checklist and instead of
  41. of writing words where there's a checkbox we look at at visual cues so for example we're developing
  42. electronic command board or or what I like to call a command pad very similar to the iPad we're able to see where our
  43. units are deployed uh they're within a a a building uh um structure and one one of the important things for for safety
  44. is to do searches of of every floor that there's there's fire and even floors that there's not fire um we're required
  45. to do that within 15 minutes so as a checklist we use visual cues if the search isn't is not completed the
  46. primary search is not completed within 15 minutes on that command pad they it'll the floor will turn red and
  47. instantly that's a cue to The Incident Commander to check on the status of the Searchers if we do a primary search it
  48. turns yellow and if we do another search afterward a secondary it turns green so
  49. we use the intuitive knowledge of a stoplight red yellow green to give the instent commander the same cues or a
  50. checklist but now we're doing it in in a visual format you know looking at the mday
  51. checklist there looked to me my outside eye that you've got a good number of items they all look pretty Mission
  52. critical and you probably want your officers to get through all of those and one in particular that caught my
  53. attention having gone actually through your training program with seven of my colleagues a few months ago on the
  54. MayDay command we learned I think it's part of the checklist protocol that when you say Mayday if you're a trap
  55. firefighter uh you have to repeat that three times so tell us why is that important it's important because we're
  56. dealing with Wireless Communications we're dealing with radios um and what we wanted we want to make sure that message
  57. comes across so for firefighters in trouble the firefighter will go mayday mayday mayday and then give a message it
  58. it it um makes sure the message gets through and it's also tells the other firefighters to stop talking on the
  59. radio and listen um so in just three words there's a lot of communication being done speaking of Mayday uh as fate
  60. would have it on the morning of 911 you were down near the World Trade Center checking on a a gas leak it was a
  61. pretty routine day uh you did look up uh a few minutes before 9:00 8:46 a.m. to be very precise
  62. and you saw the first flight hit the uh the North Tower uh you were the ranking Commander that close to the World Trade
  63. Center you played a very important role uh in bringing firefighters and emergency service people in there and
  64. then you were The Incident Commander in the North Tower just take us from that 8:30 or so moment the morning to 911
  65. just talk us through the next couple hours if you would on the morning of 911 we were at a
  66. a gas leak in the street and it was pretty much a routine emergency for us and then at 8:46 in the morning we heard
  67. this loud roar of a plane and you never hear um a plane going overhead in Manhattan because of the
  68. height of the building and um we saw the plane actually aim and crash into the North
  69. Tower and at that moment we knew we were going to the biggest fires of Our Lives
  70. um I got on the radio and I gave a message um to transmit a second alarm for a plane into the building and I told
  71. the people that I was with the firefighters to respond in with me about a minute later um I had it I had
  72. just a little bit time to think and I gave another message and very clear I asked them to transmit a third alarm
  73. more resources coming and then I said to the dispatcher that the plane was aiming
  74. for the building um I knew at that moment that this was not an accident that this was a
  75. terrorist event and then I I uh proceeded to give further orders where I wanted firefighters to stay and where I
  76. wanted them to to go in and I can remember stepping into the World Trade Center um into the lobby um it looked
  77. like the plane actually hit the lobby um there was debris all over the place Glass Broken people injured some people
  78. were burnt um and I went up to the fire safety director and I was told that the fire was somewhere above the SE the 78th
  79. floor so as firefighters came in uh they came in and I um I gave an order and the order was to go
  80. up to evacuate the people from the building and to rescue those that couldn't get out by
  81. themselves and I told them to go up to the 70 70th floor I figured at the time eight floors was a good measure of
  82. safety we would regroup and then try to get people out that were above the fire and then
  83. um as we were doing that a little bit before 9:00 we gave the order to evacuate the South
  84. Tower but a few minutes later at 9:03 that morning we heard another loud roar and this was um the second plane
  85. crashing into the South Tower at that point we um we uh divided our Command there was one command in the
  86. North Tower one in the South Tower and and our chief of Department was across the street over over all um the person
  87. in charge um firefighters came in and they started to climb and they started to encourage people to to come down don't
  88. stop keep goinging down keep keep moving down um get out of the building and then at at 9:59 that
  89. morning we heard we heard the crashing sound um and we moved oh about about 20 M from
  90. where we were standing um in the lobby to a passageway uh that that led across West
  91. Street and um that the the lobby that was um was covered with dust and with uh and went
  92. completely black um now for firefighters being in darkness is not a big deal we operate in
  93. that all the time um but at that moment some of the other chiefs were saying we had to get out of the building something
  94. very important to do we had to we had to move out we couldn't command in the lobby we had to
  95. leave but I knew how to get out of the building see this was my building um I was there hundreds of times so that
  96. brought me some time to think and that few seconds to think I knew that if we couldn't
  97. command that we need to get the firefighters also out so I picked up my handy talkie radio um and I said command
  98. to all units in Tower one evacuate the building and the firefighters started to come
  99. down but being many floors above it took a long time to come down what we didn't
  100. realize at the time was that we were running out of time um and as firefighters came
  101. down um they didn't think of just themselves one Lieutenant I could remember stopping and around the the ninth floor
  102. and directed other firefighters to another stairs because the stair they were coming down would have led to the
  103. uh the courtyard where the debris was um another unit lad 6 stopped and and noticed a woman that couldn't um
  104. couldn't continue any longer so they picked her up and started the carrier down we made our way out into the
  105. street and standing in front of the the World Trade Center um we couldn't tell what happened
  106. it was covered with dust and debris um and we were never told that an entire 110 story building just collapsed
  107. to the ground and then at at uh 10:28 that morning we heard the uh the crashing and
  108. the Roar of the North Tower collapsing and we be began to run but with bunker gear you can't run that fast
  109. or that far um so we crouched down behind a behind a truck and and this beautiful summer morning
  110. that was full of of sunshine to turned completely black where you couldn't see the hand in front
  111. of your face and you could hear the the steel crashing all around us and we were just
  112. waiting for really um to be crushed because we knew we were too close to the Trade
  113. Center and then the steel stopped and it became silent there was no more talk on
  114. the radio there was just this Eerie sound of total silence it was like a new snowfall you just heard nothing it was
  115. just this muffled sound when we got up and we walked back to the Trade Center or where the Trade
  116. Center was we saw this Rubble uh um and couldn't believe that the buildings The Two Towers just
  117. crashed to the ground I heard um on my radio I heard a call from L 6 L 6 to command were
  118. trapped in the be stairs on the fourth floor while I looked out on the pile and I knew the building well and I had no
  119. idea where the captain was see that was the captain carrying the woman down and by slowing that
  120. descent they were able to to survive in a little pocket um that Captain got his unit out
  121. and and the woman out alive miraculous story um but other stories that Lieutenant from engine 33 and and 343
  122. firefighters that day died um in total we lost uh 2750 people in New York but amongst the rebel and amongst the
  123. the uh the uh the pain we we saw glimmers of Hope um see terrorism tries to take away
  124. um people's hope but we what we saw that day is people helping each other what we
  125. saw in the days and the months that follow was the silhouette of a firefighter on on the pile at Ground
  126. Zero searching for to to to make rescues initially and then to recover those that
  127. are that were lost um it's it's important that we uh we don't Focus just on the on the
  128. sadness of the of that day because we did save 20,000 people and 911 is is something different
  129. it's not just an event for New York City or just an event for the United States is it an International Event because no
  130. matter where you were in the world you experienced it through the through the media a type of global
  131. trauma but 9/11 10 years after it gives the International Community a voice that small roadside
  132. bombing that that uh um um Hotel bombing um it gives people a voice against terrorism it's a United voice a
  133. world voice that terrorism is wrong so as we look at at at the anniversaries um the 10th and other
  134. anniversaries is really an international event that gives all victims a terrorism
  135. of voice and Joe I know in the 10 years since 911 you have spent a lot of time thinking about that event its
  136. implications for leadership for getting through a crisis of that kind you work with 911 Commission you've written about
  137. what happened and some of the Lessons Learned talk if you would about a a couple of the
  138. leading call them lessons that you have now worked with uh since the the events of that terrible
  139. day I think the 911 Commission captured it well um by saying that there was a lack of information sharing certainly
  140. there was a lack of information sharing before the the events of 9/11 with the the the intelligence Community but there
  141. was also a lack of information sharing among emergency responders police and and fire department so I I think one of
  142. the the important Lessons Learned is that during a catastrophic event during a disaster uh we need to share
  143. information and there's a sense of of uh interdependency we we need to work together uh one of the things that
  144. um that that that I wrote about is that during any major event they'll always be
  145. organizational bias so as the stress of an incident increases groups turn into their own firefighters go to
  146. Firefighters police go to police emergency medical form their own groups but during a disaster we need
  147. just the opposite we need for those groups to collabor collaborate um so as as we look at other major disasters
  148. around the world a an earthquake a tsunami another terrorist event it is really um groups coming together and and
  149. communicating and and working with it with with each other to deal with the the disaster at hand and I know you've
  150. spent a lot of time building that integration and ability to communicate since then as you've taken on additional
  151. duties now as chief of counterterrorism for the City of New York what keeps you up at night these days 10
  152. years after 911 with my uh my job there's a lot of things that keep me up at night but one
  153. of the things that I do worry about the most um is the type of an attack that we
  154. saw occur a few years ago in Mumbai well matter of fact this refer to a Mumbai style attack where there's multiple um
  155. active Shooters uh in different locations using um improvised explosive devices and using fire is those three
  156. weapons of of of of guns explosives and fire is the thing that keeps me up at night um because in
  157. combination they are the most deadly um the World Trade Center was brought down not by the planes it was brought down by
  158. fire and we see that terrorists are starting to learn from their own activity and um and it points to to that
  159. we also must learn so if for us to battle a a um a an event that uses multiple means of of weapons multiple
  160. means of attack we need to to work with each other and and to deal with a an event like that um but certainly it's
  161. something that worries Us in New York I'm in contact with uh London and it worries them um but I think by sharing
  162. information um within the city of New York and with other cities um we'll be better prepared to deal with that type
  163. of event if it would occur Joe a final question here you've been with the New York fire department for 30 years you
  164. were at Ground Zero and 911 for the last decade you've thought a lot about how to
  165. build out of that to prepare for whatever may happen in the future catastrophic events we all worry
  166. about they've been sort of brought more to home as we watch what happened to BP in the Gulf the Fukushima power plants
  167. in Japan the disaster in Haiti with that earthquake on the basis of your experience with the New York Fire
  168. Department 911 and the decade since then what advice would you have for people who are responsible in the private
  169. sector public sector maybe a nonprofit organization for thinking about how to get through a catastrophic
  170. event I think when we look at those events we want to we want to think of just how to manage it or um the military
  171. refers to command and control we want one person to to run the whole thing and I I think what we've learned since 911
  172. and and looking at those major events that is not the leadership um that that's not what leaders do leadership
  173. during a catastrophic event does more than just manage the event they they did they do three other things they connect
  174. collaborate and coordinate connect when an event occurs the first thing that needs to be done is
  175. to hastily form networks at the scene of the incident among um firefighters Rescuers law enforcement medical
  176. personnel and and for them to start to communicate and work together away from the incident we have to connect to those
  177. Emergency Operations centers that we've created and have information passed from
  178. for example New York City to the state to the National Operation Center down in Washington
  179. DC once we we form these networks the incident commanders the people that are responsible for for
  180. dealing with the event need to get together and collaborate so there's this flattening of command not just one
  181. person but now we have the major decision makers getting together and figuring out what to do and what they do
  182. is is coordinate the resource that that that that we need to get a job done we take
  183. that resource but I think what we're seeing now is that it's not just one resource it's multiple resources so for
  184. example during the Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans we had the Coast Guard spot fires the Fire Department New Orleans
  185. fire department with the assistance of the New York City Fire Department went out and extinguish the fires but they
  186. also went out with law enforcement for protection so it was that combination coordination of of resources
  187. so when when we look at at leadership whether it's in the in a uh emergency response or in business or in uh in in
  188. nonprofits when there's a disaster it's the combination of what we call uh C5 command and control connect collaborate
  189. and coordinate Joe thank you very much let me on that note bring it to a close uh
  190. let me thank you for 30 years a service to the city of New York let me thank you
  191. for uh putting uh your leadership and your life on the line on that very fateful morning on 911 and thank you for
  192. your insights that have come with a decade of thinking now and reflecting on 911 and all the threats that we face so
  193. that the rest of us can be more prepared to face those I ities that maybe are out
  194. there one day and we need to be ready to do what we have to do if heaven forbid we do face another disaster so Joe
  195. feifer thank you very much thank you [Music] Mike

Brief Summary

Joseph Feifer discusses his firefighting career and leadership lessons from 9/11, emphasizing collaboration and preparedness for emergencies.

Key points

  • Leadership in Crisis. Joe shares his insights on effective leadership during emergencies, emphasizing shared responsibility.
  • The Day of 9/11. Joe recounts his experiences during the 9/11 attacks, highlighting the chaos and urgency.
  • Lessons from 9/11. Joe discusses the importance of information sharing among emergency responders post-9/11.
  • The Importance of Coordination. Effective emergency response requires collaboration among multiple agencies and resources.
  • A Tribute to Leadership. Acknowledging Joe Feifer's 30 years of service and leadership during crises.

Tension

75/ 100High tension

Related episodes