Is Cyprus a Game Changer?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. well Cypress is the fourth uh economy in the Euro Zone that has uh received a formal bailout after Ireland and uh
  2. Portugal and Greece and it is Tiny uh even smaller than the other three economies and the problem with uh Cyprus
  3. is that it has an oversized Financial system uh the Assets in the banking system are six or seven or eight times
  4. the size of the economy and there's a lot of uh foreign money there and uh including Russian money but also
  5. British money and the Europeans especially the Germans have been pushing for a solution that is very different
  6. from the one implemented in the other three countries in the sense that they wanted uh Savers uh so people with money
  7. in cpress to pay for you know part of the bailout about half of it and this is why they've imposed a tax on depositors
  8. a tax on wealth essentially but of course the controversy has been around the fact that U they didn't exclude
  9. small depositors they could have gone after just the big depositors those with uh you know several million dollars in
  10. in Cyprus but what they've done is essentially uh you know go after the uh the small depositors so so this is a
  11. very different kind of bailout uh it is as uh the media have reported a uh you know there's a before and an after with
  12. this kind of a bailout because not even small depositors now are safe yeah the bailout of Cyprus uh is qualitatively
  13. different and if uh you remember the uh bailout of uh certain banks in the United States was unimplemented under
  14. the premise that depositors would be guaranteed and in fact uh the FDIC here in the United States extended uh made
  15. its guarantees of depositors even bigger and so did the Europeans because they made Mutual guarantees uh at the
  16. beginning of the financial crisis 5 years ago that depositors money wouldn't be touched uh so this is a uh a creates
  17. a very different dynamic uh it reminds one of Argentina in 2002 where depositors actually U you know
  18. lost quite a bit of the money so in Cyprus right now what they've done is they they're saying that they're going
  19. to you know take away you know six 7% from small deposits and up to 10% or 11% from larger deposits but not only that
  20. uh they've also um decreed a bank holiday so right now what we have is that people cannot access their money of
  21. course why are they doing that well the reason is very simple which is that otherwise there would be a run on the
  22. banks so they're trying to create some stability now this week uh and try to sell the idea that uh it makes sense to
  23. uh you know uh Implement a haircut on depositors uh but remember again this was uh imposed by Europe because they
  24. didn't want to give Cyprus the entire amount of money that they needed for the bailout of the uh of the country well
  25. the the danger intrinsic to this kind of a bailout in Cyprus um raises the uh you
  26. know the question of whether there could be contagion into other economies in the
  27. Euro Zone uh also with banks that are in trouble and uh you know the uh the problem May spread first to places like
  28. uh Italy and Spain which so far have avoided a formal bailout the issue here is of course whether people with money
  29. and Italian or Spanish Banks start thinking that something like what happened or what is going on in Cypress
  30. right now could happen in Spain and Italy and of course you know there's nothing rational about Bank runs but if
  31. a bank run starts then it is rational for you to go to the bank and try to uh you know get out your money um so this
  32. is the the real danger is that people will extrapolate from what's going on in Cypress now and see the writing in the
  33. wall and just uh think well my money is also at risk let me take it out and of course you know banks on average keep
  34. you know four 5% of the deposits in cash right because they have the rest of the
  35. money they have it invested uh so it's very easy actually to bring down an entire banking system if depositors uh
  36. start to believe that uh their money is not safe so this is a what is going on in Cypress is actually pretty serious
  37. well what we've seen is that when the deal was announced over the weekend yes on Monday the markets the equity markets
  38. uh responded badly not just in Europe but around the world now that's Equity markets that's not you know driven by
  39. depositors depositors include pretty much everybody in these economies everybody has a bank account everybody
  40. has at least a small balance in the bank uh I think as a result of this bailout which again is very different from the
  41. one implemented in Greece or Portugal or Ireland uh I think the the risk of um other banking systems in Europe
  42. suffering from some kind of pressure from depositors has increased considerably now that doesn't mean that
  43. people are going to run to the bank in Spain or in Italy or or even in Portugal or in Greece right that doesn't mean
  44. that but it but it does mean that the risk has gone up significantly and it means that you know I think it's a
  45. warning signal for policy makers that something like this you know the uh the bailout of Cyprus perhaps is not the way
  46. to go uh because look at all the Uproar that he has created uh you know I think it is unnecessary to uh punish uh small
  47. Savers small depositors [Music]

Brief Summary

The Cyprus bailout imposes taxes on depositors, raising concerns about contagion to other Euro Zone economies.

Key points

  • Cyprus Bailout Controversy. The bailout in Cyprus imposes taxes on all depositors, sparking widespread concern.
  • Potential Contagion Risk. The Cyprus situation raises fears of bank runs in Italy and Spain.

Related episodes